Wolf-
What is that Banana doing to the lemon in you Avatar?
Errr...nevermind.
Slap-
I can see your point. Getting into a knife-fight teachs alot about SA and what you can do in a plane. However, like I said originally, I don't see it being a great idea in a pony. Like I said, my experience in this plane is limited.
If he was in a Spit, or an FM2, and was not outnumbered, extending, or running would be cowardice. He could use those planes to knifefight with the NIkI. Extending, then boom and zoom seems to me to be the right way to approach this situation based on the plane he was in and situation he was facing.
I have little doubt you would have approached it differently, seeing how you are always landing kills. But we are talking about a guy who's somewhat new to this, and whose skills are probably on par with mine, so I can see his point of view.
Now, for everyone's benefit, what would you do, step by step, to win the engagement? Remember, your in a Pony, let's say 1/2 tank, 5K alt advantage over 2 Nikis. No bases or CVs nearby.
If you have time, I'd like to see how you'd approach the same engagement flying an F6F...this is info I can really use.
Thanks.