This is a very complex matter, not only in Alabama, but in several other states. I looked up in my search engine the ten commandments, ten commandments in the courtroom. There are many diverse opions, even among scholars. It would take a lot of reading time to truly delve into the legal aspects concerning Moore's courthouse stand. I admire him for his tenacity, albeit whether he is politicizing the issue or not. I have read mostly assumptions from his opponents, calling him a hypocrite. I don't know whether he is or not. I would like to believe he is not.
Also, I saw a couple web sites that seemed to indicate that having the ten commandments in the courtroom, was a step up from medieval law...which was oppressive. Christian Revisionist Movement seemed to go into some detail.
What do I think:
It is a political issue. Seems like the one thing I found in common, was the ACLU files these suits, (and loses about half of them.) Most people in Alabama think of the ACLU as communist in nature, and fight it whenever they can. So it's not about religion, or even the ten commandments. It's about standing up to the ACLU.
The same ACLU that filed a lawsuit against a high school, three days after the terrorist attack 9-11. Reason for the lawsuit? The high school had "God Bless America" on their sign out front.
Les