Aces High Bulletin Board

General Forums => Aces High General Discussion => Topic started by: Yarbles on June 18, 2009, 10:50:37 AM

Title: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Yarbles on June 18, 2009, 10:50:37 AM
When I am on typically its 0 in that arena and in many ways its my favourite but not wih just a few others.

Appart from Historical accuracy it progresses you through a number of planes.

I understand people wnat to fly the same plane or a particular plane but are their other reasons people dont like AVA.

My only objection to it iappart from the lack of numbers is some people treat it like a persoanl duelling arena which is very boring and for me goes against the whole concept. I wsih they would go to the DA where they belong but then there would be even lesss people :cry I suspect though if they did go to the DA a much greater no. would replace them :pray
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Captfish on June 18, 2009, 11:00:11 AM
Our squad used to fly in it but there was too much drama. Basically a few bad eggs ruined it for the rest of us. :cry
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Lusche on June 18, 2009, 11:06:29 AM
Can't speak for other players, only for me

In descending order:

Icon settings
Player behaviour
Low numbers
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: A8TOOL on June 18, 2009, 11:09:47 AM
It's just not that popular (popultaed) or organized (no Squads set up).

Heres an Idea from another thread.

Quote
If a couple of interested AVA players tried to organize 2-4 strong player based  squads that could be made up from any MA country, I'd probably be interested in something like that.


There are plenty of guys who might be willing to try and set something like that up but for now it's just an idea.

A good all around AVA Squad Name to join might be

Axis of Evil vs The Allied Alliance or The Allied Aviators. It'd be nice to see 2- 4 Large squads made up of enthusiasts playing in there on a set days.

EDIT: In other words, you wouldn't be joining JG54 for instance, you'd be joining an axis side made up of many different players from many different squads and countries. The same for an allied squad if allied planes were your preference.

 Joining an an all AVA squad is totally separate from the MAINS which means you can be in more than one squad at a time just like in FSO.

I think if the squads could get large enough while staying fairly even, AVA could succeed. If I joined a squad there and they had two set days during the week to fly and enough interested people...I'd show.
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: A8TOOL on June 18, 2009, 11:11:53 AM
Can't speak for other players, only for me

In descending order:

Icon settings
Player behaviour
Low numbers

Place needs a baby sitter with boot privs just like in the TA.
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: DrDea on June 18, 2009, 11:28:40 AM
Place needs a baby sitter with boot privs just like in the TA.
Cant see that happening till theres enough numbers regularly to justify it. Catch 22. The place just has the equivalent of AIDS to games.
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: B4Buster on June 18, 2009, 11:29:44 AM
Place needs a baby sitter with boot privs just like in the TA.

It does! I have never seen any action in that arena that a boot would be justified. The AvA is a player's arena. Us staffers work hard to get people in the arena, but all of you have just as much power on that subject. You all can talk to squaddies and friends and say "hey, let's go to the AvA". Also - anyone can go on the AvA forum and request a setup. If yo do, it's almost guaranteed to be set in a week or two.
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: shreck on June 18, 2009, 11:32:50 AM
Cause there is very little difference tween it and the LW arenas  :aok
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Yarbles on June 18, 2009, 11:34:02 AM
Can anyone suggest an active AvA squad that flies allied planes. My own squad of which I am currently CO shows little interest.

I would like to fly with an active AVA squad and see what is possible.

Then maybe see if I can enthuse my squad.
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: JB11 on June 18, 2009, 11:41:05 AM
Cause there is very little difference tween it and the LW arenas  :aok
Well sure there is! If i'm strolling along in a 109G-2, it's guaranteed that i will not be fighting against other 109's.  :aok
That is the #1 difference, a substantial one i might add, that i like about AvA.

 :salute 11
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: waystin2 on June 18, 2009, 11:48:23 AM
The Pigs tried it as a squad for a few weeks, but it is just not our kind of mud to waller in.
(http://pumapac.org/wp-content/uploads/2009/05/liddy-pig.jpg)
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Shuffler on June 18, 2009, 12:06:45 PM
The Pigs tried it as a squad for a few weeks, but it is just not our kind of mud to waller in.
(http://pumapac.org/wp-content/uploads/2009/05/liddy-pig.jpg)

Hey looks like you been workin' out since you last pic.
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: whiteman on June 18, 2009, 12:14:26 PM
Numbers, tried it when they ran the war setups and it was fun but I get bored with just furballing after awhile. The AVA "Rules of Engagement" were another turn off since no one followed them.
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Dinan on June 18, 2009, 12:14:57 PM
Did you forget about this one already?  

http://bbs.hitechcreations.com/smf/index.php/topic,264661.0.html (http://bbs.hitechcreations.com/smf/index.php/topic,264661.0.html)

you got 8 pages out of the last one and now you're out trolling again.

<yawn>





Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: james on June 18, 2009, 12:20:01 PM
When you go in there the only things to pick from are what someone else wants you to use. It's like a glorified SEA. Numbers are low in there. Would like to see a way where i can pick all allied or all axis vehicles or planes maybe? If i wanted to have a certain setup i'll go to FSO.
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Bear76 on June 18, 2009, 12:31:52 PM
Place needs a baby sitter with boot privs just like in the TA.
There is. Arena CM's are there often.
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Yarbles on June 18, 2009, 12:40:51 PM
Did you forget about this one already?  

http://bbs.hitechcreations.com/smf/index.php/topic,264661.0.html (http://bbs.hitechcreations.com/smf/index.php/topic,264661.0.html)

you got 8 pages out of the last one and now you're out trolling again.

<yawn>


All these people have contributed and my post was a bit more weighty this time. Strangely though I had forgotten. :noid

Anyway AvA I realise is where I want to be but with lots of like minded people and so this is my campaign now. Wish me Luck ;)

 
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Dinan on June 18, 2009, 12:41:32 PM
Quote
When you go in there the only things to pick from are what someone else wants you to use. It's like a glorified SEA. Numbers are low in there. Would like to see a way where i can pick all allied or all axis vehicles or planes maybe? If i wanted to have a certain setup i'll go to FSO.


"Hey! what is with this 190 vs P-47 setup?  Were is the spit16!"   :rolleyes:

I've never seen anything more glorified in this game than the FSO and that's only one night a week where you can go watch the paint dry.  Yet the AvA is open 24/7.

Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Yarbles on June 18, 2009, 12:41:58 PM
When you go in there the only things to pick from are what someone else wants you to use. It's like a glorified SEA. Numbers are low in there. Would like to see a way where i can pick all allied or all axis vehicles or planes maybe? If i wanted to have a certain setup i'll go to FSO.

What if its not Friday :rolleyes:
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Dinan on June 18, 2009, 12:45:26 PM


Anyway AvA I realise is where I want to be but with lots of like minded people and so this is my campaign now. Wish me Luck ;)

 

Come by around 9pm EST.  The place usually stays empty until then.

Also Larry does missions on wendsday nights that draw a good crowd.
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: B4Buster on June 18, 2009, 12:49:46 PM
Did you forget about this one already?  

http://bbs.hitechcreations.com/smf/index.php/topic,264661.0.html (http://bbs.hitechcreations.com/smf/index.php/topic,264661.0.html)

you got 8 pages out of the last one and now you're out trolling again.

<yawn>

Quite right N7. Most people aren't mature enough for this type of thread.


The AvA is not right for everyone. It is most active between 6-9 On the west coast. Me being on the East Coast, I can usually catch some action before i go to bed.
AvA is also not for everyone because it really is about the fights, no about base taking or porking (which is probably why the Pigs On the Wing didn't like it). What's great about it though is the setup gets changed weekly , so if you ARE into that, then some weeks you'd enjoy it.

Nobody has ever claimed the AvA is like a mini - SEA...not really sure where that's coming from. It's an arena used and run by players who fancy historic matchups. Not the outrageous Spit v Spit or 51 v other American planes you find in the MAs.

Let the bashing begin unfortunately  :rolleyes:
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: james on June 18, 2009, 12:57:30 PM
I consider it a mini sea because it has a setup like in the sea arenas. My idea of ava is simply different than others. I would like to see more players in there but id also like to pick my side and fly or drive what that side did. Some of the setups are really good but not what keeps my attention really.
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Krusty on June 18, 2009, 01:04:26 PM
No comparison of any kind to the SEA stuff. I wish folks would stop attempting that comparison.

Also, as Dinan pointed out, this is a transparent troll (and a duplicate, no less).
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Yarbles on June 18, 2009, 01:12:45 PM
Come by around 9pm EST.  The place usually stays empty until then.

Also Larry does missions on wendsday nights that draw a good crowd.

2am Uk time :cry
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Yarbles on June 18, 2009, 01:13:41 PM
Also, as Dinan pointed out, this is a transparent troll (and a duplicate, no less).

I told you I really did forget. If anything its pre senile dementia :uhoh
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: james on June 18, 2009, 01:15:03 PM
Ok, the SEA has to be set up with a CM, the ava has to be set  up by someone as well. The ava lets the setup run maybe a bit longer but hey theres nothing in common with the arenas huh? What exactly is the attempt im trying to make by seeing things this way?
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: detch01 on June 18, 2009, 01:22:02 PM
Up until fairly recently I had a very low opinion of the AvA. That opinion has changed. When there are 20 or so players in the arena it's very nearly as good as the old CT was in its heyday. Last night's mission (by Larry) was a perfect example of that - some great fights, a civil atmosphere and a great time.
Those who've been put off of the AvA by the less than stellar behaviour that was the norm in the last couple of years but would like to play a 2-sided game should at the very least show up for the next mission night and see for themselves. It isn't perfect by any means but it's one hell of a lot better than it was.


Cheers,
asw
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: waystin2 on June 18, 2009, 01:42:39 PM
Hey looks like you been workin' out since you last pic.

Hey thanks!  I tightened the tension on my throttle to make it a bit more of a workout while playing! :rofl
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: B4Buster on June 18, 2009, 01:48:12 PM
Up until fairly recently I had a very low opinion of the AvA. That opinion has changed. When there are 20 or so players in the arena it's very nearly as good as the old CT was in its heyday. Last night's mission (by Larry) was a perfect example of that - some great fights, a civil atmosphere and a great time.
Those who've been put off of the AvA by the less than stellar behaviour that was the norm in the last couple of years but would like to play a 2-sided game should at the very least show up for the next mission night and see for themselves. It isn't perfect by any means but it's one hell of a lot better than it was.

Cheers,
asw

Was a pleasure to have you in the arena last night asw, you definately seem like a good guy. Hope to see you in there more.
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Sunka on June 18, 2009, 01:49:06 PM
Well if i look at it tonight and see 20 or more i will go have look at what kind of fight i can find.I just want a good fight!!!!I don't care where i get it.
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: waystin2 on June 18, 2009, 01:50:32 PM
(which is probably why the Pigs On the Wing didn't like it, although I do not really know so I put my totally uneducated guess here). 

I touched up your remark B4Buster as it seems it was missing something.  We are not the Squad you think we are B4Buster.  I sincerely ask you to come visit on vox sometime Sir.  See for yourself.  Base capture entails maybe 20-30 percent of the Pigs squad time, the rest is spent in total Pig anarchy with no real aim or goal other than getting into a good fight on land, sea or air.  As far as porking (which you think would come naturally to a Pig) it is only done to slow an advancing enemy when needed.
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Sunka on June 18, 2009, 01:53:41 PM
Do they have short range icons and no radar bleeps on AvA?I like that about FSO.



"Hey! what is with this 190 vs P-47 setup?  Were is the spit16!"   :rolleyes:

I've never seen anything more glorified in this game than the FSO and that's only one night a week where you can go watch the paint dry.  Yet the AvA is open 24/7.


Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: whiteman on June 18, 2009, 01:54:50 PM
Do they have short range icons and radar bleeps on AvA?I like that about FSO.



yes short range icons, as for bleeps just the standard MA style radar when I have been in there.
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Sunka on June 18, 2009, 02:04:22 PM
Yea,I would be more into it if no radar,I like having to keep my wits about me all the time.
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: whiteman on June 18, 2009, 02:13:17 PM
I've seen it like that in there a few times, only problem was we were running across the sector looking for each other without luck. Then there's been times with no Dar Bar so you could fly above bad guys and never know it, kept it interesting but hard to find a fight if you were looking for it
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Sunka on June 18, 2009, 02:18:39 PM
I imagine it would need people in the number of MA or FSO to be able to do that and find a fight then.But i imagine AvA is more like taking a certain base so you know where the fight is? As opposed to just random fighting?
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: whiteman on June 18, 2009, 02:23:38 PM
Depends who is on, seems like most look down upon base taking in the AVA and most the time it's turned off. So your basically looking for a furball if larry isn't running his wednesday mission.
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Oldman731 on June 18, 2009, 03:18:33 PM
Depends who is on, seems like most look down upon base taking in the AVA and most the time it's turned off. So your basically looking for a furball if larry isn't running his wednesday mission.

...er...um....base taking is almost never "turned off" in AvA.  Battle of Britain setups, perhaps, because the Battle of Britain was pre-invasion kind of stuff (ask any Englishman).  If a map can be porked too easily, or if for some reason we are discouraging milk running during off hours, we will often increase the number of troops required to take a base.  Otherwise base capture is usually the same as in the MAs.  Look at the bottom of the MOTD, the number of troops required to take the base usually appears there.

Best way to find a fight:  Announce yourself on Channel 200 and say "Hey, where's the fight?"  You'll almost always get an accurate answer within seconds.  Alternatively, do what I've occasionally done when I visit one of the other low-attendance arenas, and announce (again on 200) "Just took off from [base name] in a [aircraft type], headed for [opposition base], come stop me!"  This won't work for people like Larry and N7, but when I try it it draws enemy a/c like flies to...er...honey.

- oldman
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: TwinBoom on June 18, 2009, 03:19:11 PM
it suks......................sor ry
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: A8TOOL on June 18, 2009, 03:46:33 PM


Anyway AvA I realise is where I want to be but with lots of like minded people and so this is my campaign now. Wish me Luck ;)

 



Well heres a man that knows what he wants and might even have a pretty good idea of how to get it.  If you can gather up a few other like minded individuals from both sides, I think ya got a chance.  Don't count on the nay say'ers though as they will only bring you down. Once it gets rolling though I think you'll find that there always was an interest in AVA but it's just having a hard time trying to find it's way off the ground.

  WTFG Yarbles!!

Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: B4Buster on June 18, 2009, 03:49:53 PM
I touched up your remark B4Buster as it seems it was missing something.  We are not the Squad you think we are B4Buster.  I sincerely ask you to come visit on vox sometime Sir.  See for yourself.  Base capture entails maybe 20-30 percent of the Pigs squad time, the rest is spent in total Pig anarchy with no real aim or goal other than getting into a good fight on land, sea or air.  As far as porking (which you think would come naturally to a Pig) it is only done to slow an advancing enemy when needed.

Have visited you guys many times, and nothing against you all. I think most of you are great guys. Whenever I have flown with the Pigs, they were rolling bases. A game style that isn't the norm in the AvA.  Rolling bases is nothing to be ashamed of though
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Shuffler on June 18, 2009, 04:22:50 PM
Hey thanks!  I tightened the tension on my throttle to make it a bit more of a workout while playing! :rofl

 :rofl
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: waystin2 on June 18, 2009, 04:38:10 PM
Have visited you guys many times, and nothing against you all. I think most of you are great guys.

CC that.  Well you are certainly welcome anytime Sir.

Have a great day,

Way
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Larry on June 18, 2009, 05:07:22 PM
Here we go again. :rolleyes:


The AvA isn't the MA or SEA. Its the AvA. The people who say 'its just like the MA' are the ones that come in there ganging or HOing people then expect not to have it happen to them. A few weeks ago shreck and his squad came into the arena. There first sortie I ran into them I was already fighing a spit in my 110 when three or four came into gang. The next sortie I was in another 110 fighting a F4U. The second the F4U lost the advantage he ran for his buddies. Soon after that they were vulching our field. The next day he was complaining that we were HOing them while all this was happening.

Simple fact is if you come in there flying like that you will get the same attitude right back, but if you come in there and respect how other people fly then you wont have a problem.


As for Yarbles, BS you forgot a thread YOU started a month ago that got 100+ replies. You just want to stir the AvA pot some more and I hope skuzzy deals with you.
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: AKKaz on June 18, 2009, 05:08:02 PM
Have been lookin at using it for squad night type ops, but usually from zero to only a few in there.

Things have changed alot over the years, and long gone are the days of freindly squadron rivalry type fights.  Have been lookin for a squad or 2 to have an evening with some good fights and wingman type stuff and always considered the AVA as a good place for an evening.  But the few times I have check it out, only a few in there.

Also, I would think that alot of people are somewhat put off by having to be cornered into a certain plane set.  If 10 or 15 ever feel like doin just some back and forth rolling furballs, let us know.  Doesnt really matter on the set or side, just looking for some fun for a night.
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: antivortex on June 18, 2009, 05:55:58 PM
it suks......................sor ry

 Yeah, the repeated buttwoopin you got had nothing to do with it...
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: A8TOOL on June 18, 2009, 05:57:11 PM



As for Yarbles, BS you forgot a thread YOU started a month ago that got 100+ replies. You just want to stir the AvA pot some more and I hope skuzzy deals with you.

WOW,  what a

(http://tbn3.google.com/images?q=tbn:LDQ39YaOQ__fsM:http://blog.seedgiveslife.com/wp-content/uploads/2008/02/dickhead.jpg)


The guys just trying to get something good going. Shame you don't like that sort a thing and would rather see him fail. Kind of petty of ya don't ya think?

Why don't you get off the  :furious  :furious :furious and try some of the  ;)  :)  :cool: once in awhile. Might do you some good  :aok

 
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: moot on June 18, 2009, 06:17:24 PM
No one's in there. 
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Larry on June 18, 2009, 06:22:12 PM
Tool, read what I said. He started this same thread a month ago and got over a hundred replies. That one went right where this one is going. There is no way that someone 'forgets' a thread they made then starts the same one. So there is no doubt he is trolling with this one to get the anti AvA people here and only clueless people cant see that. So can you not see what he is doing?



No one's in there. 

And there wont be until the AvA regulars go in tonight. The people that bash the AvA are the ones that never go there. They would rather sit here crying about how the people who actually play there are doing things instead of going in there and trying to change the place into something they like.
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: fudgums on June 18, 2009, 06:24:32 PM
Some people don't see the big picturé
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Dinan on June 18, 2009, 06:39:57 PM
They should take a break...   :noid
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: moot on June 18, 2009, 07:07:09 PM
Larry, all I'm saying is everytime I consider it, I don't bother because there's something like 5-10 people in there.
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: whiteman on June 18, 2009, 07:11:57 PM
I liked it there was just to much player bickering over how the arena use to be and how it should be, plus I love the PTO setups and not many seem to fly AXIS when those do apear. I'll show up if a PTO setup is in there.
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: uptown on June 18, 2009, 07:25:06 PM
the plane sets suck. I peeked in there the other day and my allied choices was a spit or a mossie. Wtf are the 38s,47s and 51s? Why can't we have all the planes in AH2 and split them up into axies and allies?! Everytime I look into the AvA arena it's always some crap ride no one flys.
It makes me wonder if the guys running the AvA even have a clue about what the majority of players want.
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Larry on June 18, 2009, 07:27:19 PM
Larry, all I'm saying is everytime I consider it, I don't bother because there's something like 5-10 people in there.

Well you should. Its not like the MAs where everyone is spread out over the map. Most of the time those 5-10 people are fighting in the middle of just two bases.


the plane sets suck. I peeked in there the other day and my allied choices was a spit or a mossie. Wtf are the 38s,47s and 51s? Why can't we have all the planes in AH2 and split them up into axies and allies?! Everytime I look into the AvA arena it's always some crap ride no one flys.
It makes me wonder if the guys running the AvA even have a clue about what the majority of players want.

Then you were to lazy or dumb to look at the MOTD to see that F4Us F6Fs FM2s and Seafires where enabled off the CVs. It seems people like you have no clue how the AvA works. Maybe you should have thought before posting crap like that. :rolleyes:
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: uptown on June 18, 2009, 07:33:20 PM
Lazy or dumb? Buddy I work 55 hours a week and have other things to do besides look at the MOTD. When I have time to log on I want to fly what I want. Not what you want me to fly! I just went to the AvA and low and behold a good plane set but only 3 people in there.
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Larry on June 18, 2009, 07:45:54 PM
You work 55 hours a week and don't have two whole minutes to read something that pops up every time you log into the arena? So which is it lazy or dumb? Really it takes you just as long to look what is enabled in the hanger then it does to look at the damn MOTD. Stop crying like the only thing the allies had was a goon. There were more planes enabled but you where just way to busy look to the left of the clipboard when you logged on. :rolleyes:
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: B4Buster on June 18, 2009, 08:09:59 PM
Lazy or dumb? Buddy I work 55 hours a week and have other things to do besides look at the MOTD. When I have time to log on I want to fly what I want. Not what you want me to fly! I just went to the AvA and low and behold a good plane set but only 3 people in there.

Uptown. That was a setup I had put up at the request of the AvA regulars. As I said earlier in this thread, setups get changed weekly. Stop by and request a setup Uptown, would love to have you in the arena  :salute


These threads bashing the AvA really doesn't help matters. Yes, you may die just like you do in the MAs, but the fights are a heck of alot better. I can play in the MA for months and not lose an honest 1v1, whereas I'll be lucky to two sorties in the AvA. 
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: uptown on June 18, 2009, 08:38:25 PM
Larry is about to piss me off :mad:
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: E25280 on June 18, 2009, 08:45:53 PM
Larry is about to piss me off :mad:

Yeah, I get mad too when I do or say something stupid and someone else points it out.
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Sunka on June 18, 2009, 08:48:32 PM
(http://i198.photobucket.com/albums/aa252/Husky3D/jerry.gif)
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: uptown on June 18, 2009, 08:49:07 PM
Uptown. That was a setup I had put up at the request of the AvA regulars. As I said earlier in this thread, setups get changed weekly. Stop by and request a setup Uptown, would love to have you in the arena  :salute


 

I just may do that. Trukill is going down!  :devil
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: uptown on June 18, 2009, 08:51:33 PM
Yeah, I get mad too when I do or say something stupid and someone else points it out.
You're on the "going down" list too pal!  :furious
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: DrDea on June 18, 2009, 08:59:05 PM
You work 55 hours a week and don't have two whole minutes to read something that pops up every time you log into the arena? So which is it lazy or dumb? Really it takes you just as long to look what is enabled in the hanger then it does to look at the damn MOTD. Stop crying like the only thing the allies had was a goon. There were more planes enabled but you where just way to busy look to the left of the clipboard when you logged on. :rolleyes:
  And this folks right here is why the AVA has no pilots.The attitude.Same attitude that got you thrown out of FSO,DFC one would think you would learn something by it.
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: fudgums on June 18, 2009, 09:12:30 PM
<shakes head>
<Looks up at God>

Asks why this thread should've started

<looks at his fingers>
<shakes head more>
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: uptown on June 18, 2009, 09:21:03 PM
Larry advertised a big bombing mission several months ago in the AvA and I decided to try something different and take part in it. When the event started I joined his mission only to be pretty much left out of it. I found Larry to be argorant and rude. I haven't spent any time in there since. Although I would love to shoot this guy down. I know he's a good stick, but I can whip him.

Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: fudgums on June 18, 2009, 09:26:36 PM
Larry advertised a big bombing mission several months ago in the AvA and I decided to try something different and take part in it. When the event started I joined his mission only to be pretty much left out of it. I found Larry to be argorant and rude. I haven't spent any time in there since. Although I would love to shoot this guy down. I know he's a good stick, but I can whip him.



tell us how you really feel
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: uptown on June 18, 2009, 09:32:51 PM
ahh just trying to get a fight started :) it might be fun in there with some good planes
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Larry on June 18, 2009, 09:57:59 PM
  And this folks right here is why the AVA has no pilots.The attitude.Same attitude that got you thrown out of FSO,DFC one would think you would learn something by it.


Wasn't thrown out of DFC, I quit. Wasn't booted outta the FSO for my attitude eather.

If you would have actually read some posts instead of jumping to conclusions you would see the whole story, but instead you are only seeing what you want to see.

Uptown logged onto the AvA didn't read the MOTD and thought only two planes were enabled. He then came here posting crap about the arena and the people who volunteer their time to run it because HE didn't have the time to read the setup for that week.

When I showed him he was mistaken he posted more crap.

So try again ''Dr'', and get the full story before posting like you know whats going on eh.
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Larry on June 18, 2009, 10:01:34 PM
Larry advertised a big bombing mission several months ago in the AvA and I decided to try something different and take part in it. When the event started I joined his mission only to be pretty much left out of it. I found Larry to be argorant and rude. I haven't spent any time in there since. Although I would love to shoot this guy down. I know he's a good stick, but I can whip him.



Some might not see the sarcasm in your post and be turned away from the Wednesday missions because of what you just posted.


ahh just trying to get a fight started :) it might be fun in there with some good planes

15+ people in there tonight with both ponys enabled. Why wernt you in there?
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: stodd on June 18, 2009, 10:20:52 PM
AvA is also not for everyone because it really is about the fights, no about base taking or porking (which is probably why the Pigs On the Wing didn't like it).
I was in the pigs squad when they were active in the AVA for a bit, at the time their was a "war" setup thing. The objective, if I remeber correctly was actually to capture specific bases.
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Oldman731 on June 18, 2009, 10:21:28 PM
Larry, all I'm saying is everytime I consider it, I don't bother because there's something like 5-10 people in there.

Actually, Moot, some of the best fights can be had in just that situation.  The MA-style furball, where getting shot down is more a matter of lacking SA than getting beat in ACM, is fairly rare in AvA.  You don't need a lot of numbers to have a lot of good fights.  Come try!

- oldman
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Oldman731 on June 18, 2009, 10:25:03 PM
the plane sets suck. I peeked in there the other day and my allied choices was a spit or a mossie. Wtf are the 38s,47s and 51s? Why can't we have all the planes in AH2 and split them up into axies and allies?! Everytime I look into the AvA arena it's always some crap ride no one flys.
It makes me wonder if the guys running the AvA even have a clue about what the majority of players want.

We've actually tried enabling All Axis v All Allied several times.  It turns out to be about what you'd expect:  the Axis flyers pick the 1945 planes, as do the Allied pilots.  That's fine, we run a fair amount of 1945 setups, but we also like to see early and mid war matches.

Your greater point is accurate:  The principal reason people flock to the MAs is that they want to fly a particular plane, which might not be enabled in the AvA at that moment.  AvA is, and always will be, a self-limited arena.

- oldman
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: moot on June 18, 2009, 11:10:20 PM
Actually, Moot, some of the best fights can be had in just that situation.  The MA-style furball, where getting shot down is more a matter of lacking SA than getting beat in ACM, is fairly rare in AvA.  You don't need a lot of numbers to have a lot of good fights.  Come try!

- oldman
It's not often that the setup has the 152 enabled and that I don't have squaddies in the other arenas, both at the same time.. Otherwise I'd definitely be in there as often as the other arenas.
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: DrDea on June 18, 2009, 11:22:12 PM
 Larry.Your squad was thrown out of FSO  and you were thrown out of DFC.Twist it any way you want. AVA COULD be a great addition but your name keeps it from being so. Most see anything related to JG 54 in an arena as a killer.Sorry.Thats just the facts.Youve told people that if they dont follow YOUR rules they will be run out of the arena.Want me to dig for that nugget? YOU kill this arena.YOU. Deal with it and show some honor and get out of it. You never should have been involved in something to draw players.Just do the right frigging thing and get away from the AVA arena. Your banning of jg 54 from FSO wasnt a fluke.

Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: PhantomBarron on June 18, 2009, 11:24:42 PM
I will tell you it gets really old why folks keep trying to point out reasons not to fly in the AvA. It is not what the overall AH population wants as it would obviously be another MA.
My personal reasons for flying there is the clean fights. This is where I learn from my mistakes while still feeling like im fighting for a purpose. You can't get that from the Training Arena or from the DA.
Yes there are times when it seems like the MA with vulching, hoeing, base taking etc. as a few bad apples set off a chain reaction but normally this is not the case.
I get pissed as everyone else does occassionally but I get over it and move on with no grudges.
Buck up and either fly in there once in awhile where your input is valued due to participation or focus your negativity to the arena you frequent.

Tyrant
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: DrDea on June 18, 2009, 11:26:24 PM
Oldman.....JG54 is your issue. As long as ANYone from that squad is thought as being in control AVA will suffer.It would take more than a HT announcement on every page to get this across.JG54 IS your cancer.
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: PhantomBarron on June 18, 2009, 11:30:21 PM
DrDea
I for one am glad you never fly in there. You are nothing but negative.
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: uptown on June 18, 2009, 11:39:16 PM
When are the busiest times in the AvA? When and how often are the plane sets changed?
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: DrDea on June 18, 2009, 11:41:11 PM
 Negative my eye..You take a squad that has nothing but bad reputation and put them,even in a perceived way in charge of an arena and what do you think will happen? AVA is dead.I wonder why?
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: DrDea on June 18, 2009, 11:42:56 PM
See Rule #4
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: uptown on June 18, 2009, 11:51:52 PM
JG54 is a axis squad. I perfer the axis to be a little naughty  :D
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: DrDea on June 18, 2009, 11:58:05 PM
So do I.Im an axis flyer,but when the people in question act like they do,AVA has no chance,and it will take months of them not being there to fix that.Ask around.
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Larry on June 19, 2009, 12:05:09 AM
Larry.Your squad was thrown out of FSO  and you were thrown out of DFC.


We weren't thrown out of FSO because of my attitude and I wasn't thrown out of DFC. I posted on the Muppet's boards to remove me from it. Those are the facts take it or leave it.


You saying JG54 is the problem is a lie. JG54 has quit playing the arena many time to prove people like you wrong and that's exactly what we did. Any time JG54 leaves the arena it dies. I'm not talking about some people in there I'm talking about week long periods were its 0 during prime time every day.

In the AvA to bring numbers you need numbers. And that's what we bring to the arena. If you don't like what we say then detune 200 or squelch us. If you choose not to that then your problem

All you do is cry. Maybe you should go to the Obama forums and post another poll about us.

You don't fly the AvA so you don't get any more replies from me. Cry all you want JG54 and other squads who fly there keep the arena alive. That's more then I can say about you and your negative Nancy attitude. Good day to you sir  :salute


Oh P.S. My name and JG54 is written all over the Wednesday Missions. Please tell me if we ruin everything why do wee see 20-50 people in there when they are run?

When are the busiest times in the AvA? When and how often are the plane sets changed?

Between 6-10PM CST is when most people start showing up. If you get on early and no one is there sit in the tower and go make yourself a drink and usually someone will show up before you get back. As for setups every Friday is the normal. If the staff are busy it may run a little longer.
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Larry on June 19, 2009, 12:24:33 AM
JG54 is a axis squad. I perfer the axis to be a little naughty  :D

JG54 isn't an axis squad. We fly whatever side needs the numbers. Like tonight there were less allies on so I switched over and fought against my squaddies for a few hours. By far some of the best PJ,P51b vs 109 fights Iv ever had. Some the non stop turn and burning went on for almost five minutes. Each time I had to wipe my hands and joystick off. If you'd like I can post some of the everyday normal fights that go on in there.

Some people cry its a bad arena just like the MAs, but Iv gone days without being HOed or picked in the AvA while on the deck almost the whole time. When I go into the LWs Ill be lucky to go one or two sorties before someone pulls one of those.


As I said in another thread ''there are no 'rules' that you HAVE to follow just some guidelines that some ask you to take in to consideration so you don't ruin other peoples fun.''

If you go in there respecting people and their fights then you will end the day with a smile on your face and some good fights. On the other hand if you go in there HOing and picking everyone with the 'its my $15 ill do what i want' attitude then you will get that attitude right back.


Just remember you're in there to have fun, but so is everyone else. Treating people the way you'd want to be treated goes a long way.
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Dinan on June 19, 2009, 01:23:26 AM
Drdee-da-dee is JG54's #1 fan!    :aok
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Delirium on June 19, 2009, 01:40:18 AM
I've tried AvA in the past but it struck me repeatedly as a 'small pond, big fish' attitude arena in addition to the 38 not always enabled.

I haven't tried it in the past 6-9 months but if a 38 enabled planeset came up again, I would give it another go.
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: A8TOOL on June 19, 2009, 01:44:25 AM
I've tried AvA in the past but it struck me repeatedly as a 'small pond, big fish' attitude arena in addition to the 38 not always enabled.

I haven't tried it in the past 6-9 months but if a 38 enabled planeset came up again, I would give it another go.

38 is enabled on this map.
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Delirium on June 19, 2009, 01:47:12 AM
38 is enabled on this map.

Too bad my time is disabled... I still need to finish my AAR on the squad I was part of last month.
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Larry on June 19, 2009, 01:53:52 AM
SAPP is not allowed in the AVA!! The arena has a limited number of planes for each setup and when SAPP members come in the arena's supply if B-38s are used up in hours. Stick to the MA you bomber tards!!!



Next time one of the Wednesday missions include a B-38 Ill send you and the 80th a PM so you guys can join in on the fun. We are always looking for more bomber pilots to escort in our B17s
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Yarbles on June 19, 2009, 05:30:05 AM
I wish I could get involved in all this squeaking and name calling but sadly when I am on no one is even in AvA :cry

It appears the reason more people arn't in there is because they want to fly a specific palne. I see the measure of any plane as what it is up against. A spit 5 is a different plane in this sense against a 109E or F as compared to a 262 or especially another Spit.

I like flying Spits and Brit planes generally but want to fly them against their historical adversaries as this best explores the strengths and weakneses  and how they developed.

This to me seems to be the obvious purpose or AvA.

I think the other turn off for people apart from this limited plane set thing is that many people in there treat it as their private DA. I wish the DA served them better and people would come to AVA for the historical context because that is OBVIOUSLY what it is for.         
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: fudgums on June 19, 2009, 07:00:14 AM
Yawn...there's a reason HTC made 90 plus planes. Don't stick with one try many
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Yarbles on June 19, 2009, 07:04:58 AM
AND

Having read quite allot about various air battle its interesting to see how much of this can be reflected in AVA.

Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Larry on June 19, 2009, 12:47:58 PM
People don't treat it as a private DA. Most people that go to the AvA are looking for clean fights. A historical 1v1 and a duel are two different things. With the low number 1v1s or just even fights are what make the arena fun. When there are 15+ people in there is will turn into a big furball which is also fun but usually ends up a HO or vulch fest. Anyways the arena is the way it is because people went in there and in the long run made it into something they enjoy. If you really want to change it to something you enjoy then get some buddies and go in there and do it. Posting here in the BBS does nothing.
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Larry on June 19, 2009, 12:58:58 PM
This weeks setup for you guys.







BOCAGE

The Western Allies at last have linked their
D-Day beaches, but their attempts to break out of
the bridgehead have been stymied by fierce German
resistance and by the Norman terrain which makes
every pasture a fortress.  Both sides have poured
air assets into the area.  Low-level combat is
an everyday occurrence.

Map:  Ardennes 08 (for lack of a better alternative
  and to encourage low-altitude combat).

The P-51D is available at limited bases because it
was just coming into service during this period.  The
Spit 9 is available at limited bases for balance.


ALLIES (BISHOPS)

B-26
C-47
P-47D25
P-51B
P-51D (at A6,33,49,52,56,70,87,98,104)
Spit 9 (at A6,33,49,52,56,70,87,98,104)
Typhoon
Jeep
The Ms
Firefly Sherman


AXIS (KNIGHTS)

Me-109G6
Me-109G14
C-47
Fw-190A8
Ju-88
Jeep
Osti
Pz Mk IV
SdKfz 251
Tiger I
Wirbelwind


SETTINGS:

Killshooter is on.
Perk points are disabled.  Fly or drive anything.
Friendly collisions are off.
Fuel burn is 1.0.
Visibility is 12.0.
Radar settings historical, as follows:
Tower 237,600
Sector 369,600
Traditional AvA bombsight (must be calibrated).
Ack is .25 (considerably less effective than MA)
Strat is disabled.
Ten troops required for base capture (map room setting
 is .0015)
There is no radio channel one.  By convention,
 people use channel 200 for cross-country
 communications.

AND PLEASE REMEMBER:  Civil behavior is valued,
and required, in this arena.
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Sunka on June 19, 2009, 01:07:44 PM
Turn Killshooter  off and i will be there.
(http://i198.photobucket.com/albums/aa252/Husky3D/sparta.gif)
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Larry on June 19, 2009, 01:12:04 PM
That will never happen.


We used to have it off and it worked great for a very long time. Then one day the MAs were fubared and people flooded into the AvA. Not shortly after people discovered this and some started sitting in maned acks killing friendlies as they took off. After that Skuzzy himself told the AvA staff to turn it on and keep it that way.
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Sunka on June 19, 2009, 01:18:07 PM
As i remember in Air Worrier,kill shooter was off,if you shoot friendlies like three times or something you could not up for some time.It teaches people not to zoom in front of me when I'm shooting someone.But.....i know killshooter is not going anywhere.Just a pipe dream.
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Dadsguns on June 19, 2009, 01:18:24 PM
It got old fast when we were in there doing a bomber mission at um-teen "K" feet and after shooting down all the fighters that intercepted the bomber mission then shooting them down again, and again, on the return trip, why go there to conduct missions when you can do the same thing in the MA.  
The historacle value only pertains to the arena your flying in I will give it that, but shooting down the same pilot multiple times does not even come close to the reality.  

If it had a way of having a one life sortie, it would make it fun and exciting.  

Other than that, you can get hoed, rammed, horded, picked, ganged, etc just like in the MA, except there are more people.   :lol
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: JimmyC on June 19, 2009, 01:19:04 PM
Yarbles , 71 RAF will go up against (+)Presicion in AvA at any given time
should be fun if we can muster some numbers  :D
Heres to fun & Games
Cheers
Jimmy
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Larry on June 19, 2009, 01:26:47 PM
It got old fast when we were in there doing a bomber mission at um-teen "K" feet and after shooting down all the fighters that intercepted the bomber mission then shooting them down again, and again, on the return trip, why go there to conduct missions when you can do the same thing in the MA.  
The historacle value only pertains to the arena your flying in I will give it that, but shooting down the same pilot multiple times does not even come close to the reality.  

If it had a way of having a one life sortie, it would make it fun and exciting.  

Other than that, you can get hoed, rammed, horded, picked, ganged, etc just like in the MA, except there are more people.   :lol

 :rolleyes:
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: hitech on June 19, 2009, 01:43:40 PM
I have a very different question, why would anyone want to go to the AVA. I am not being facetious, try come up with real reasons.

HiTech
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Dadsguns on June 19, 2009, 01:49:46 PM
When the MA is full.
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: B4Buster on June 19, 2009, 01:52:05 PM
I have a very different question, why would anyone want to go to the AVA. I am not being facetious, try come up with real reasons.

HiTech

Player's arena. Anyone can muster up friends to bring in there and have historical matchups 24/7.
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Larry on June 19, 2009, 01:53:16 PM
I have a very different question, why would anyone want to go to the AVA. I am not being facetious, try come up with real reasons.

HiTech

Real reasons have been posted before, but the nay sayers always have something bad to say about those to.
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: fudgums on June 19, 2009, 01:57:54 PM
I have a very different question, why would anyone want to go to the AVA. I am not being facetious, try come up with real reasons.

HiTech

1. The fights- The best fights in the game are here. The best pilots in the game fight here. You would learn ACM faster and look at the way of Air Combat in a totally different way.

2.Historical matchups- Not everyone likes P51 Vs P51 in the MA, the history in the arena is what brings me there. To fight in the same terrain and the same environment like the original great ones did.

3. Set ups- If you want a set up, the CM's will run it. It might not be right away but if you request it, it will be there.

4. Gangs/picks/HOs- The reason they are looked down upon are to make the fights the best they can be. and in respect of that, you treat players how you want to be treated. If your going to Ho every pass, Im going to kick my rudder a little then shoot ya right in the cockpit. Simple

Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: A8TOOL on June 19, 2009, 01:58:45 PM
I have a very different question, why would anyone want to go to the AVA. I am not being facetious, try come up with real reasons.

HiTech

That's a tough one.

Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Larry on June 19, 2009, 02:00:26 PM
1. The fights- The best fights in the game are here. The best pilots in the game fight here. You would learn ACM faster and look at the way of Air Combat in a totally different way.

2.Historical matchups- Not everyone likes P51 Vs P51 in the MA, the history in the arena is what brings me there. To fight in the same terrain and the same environment like the original great ones did.

3. Set ups- If you want a set up, the CM's will run it. It might not be right away but if you request it, it will be there.

4. Gangs/picks/HOs- The reason they are looked down upon are to make the fights the best they can be. and in respect of that, you treat players how you want to be treated. If your going to Ho every pass, Im going to kick my rudder a little then shoot ya right in the cockpit. Simple



Now wait for the people that never fly there tell you you're wrong. I mean you're an AvA ragular what do you know.
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Oldman731 on June 19, 2009, 02:13:51 PM
1. The fights- The best fights in the game are here. The best pilots in the game fight here. You would learn ACM faster and look at the way of Air Combat in a totally different way.

2.Historical matchups- Not everyone likes P51 Vs P51 in the MA, the history in the arena is what brings me there. To fight in the same terrain and the same environment like the original great ones did.

3. Set ups- If you want a set up, the CM's will run it. It might not be right away but if you request it, it will be there.

4. Gangs/picks/HOs- The reason they are looked down upon are to make the fights the best they can be. and in respect of that, you treat players how you want to be treated. If your going to Ho every pass, Im going to kick my rudder a little then shoot ya right in the cockpit. Simple


From my perspective - and I'm perhaps the most dedicated Axis v. Allied player I know - Fudgums' Reason No. 2 is the primary reason people should want to fly in the AvA.  If a person wants to have some sense of what WWII combat was like, he's not going to get it as well flying a Corsair against a P-51D as if he's flying a Corsair against a Zero.  As many have remarked before, there is something surreal about attacking a B-17 formation with a Spitfire.  So I put the historical connection first among reasons.

I'd place Fudgums' Reason No 3 next - and for mostly the same reasons.  You have a better understanding of Johnnie Johnson's account of his Spit V squadron meeting FW 190s over Dieppe when you can play out a 1942 Channel setup.  You won't get this in the MAs.

People may argue with Fudgums' Reasons 1 and 4, although I personally agree with them.  I think the fights tend to be better in any lower-number arena than in the 150+ beehives.  There were times, back in the heyday of the Combat Theater, when the high numbers produced the same kind of conduct that, later, resulted in the splitting of the MAs.

- oldman
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Sunka on June 19, 2009, 02:16:08 PM
I have a very different question, why would anyone want to go to the AVA. I am not being facetious, try come up with real reasons.

HiTech
That's why i say,turn off kill shoother and turn off radar bleeps.Then its someting truly diffrent from Main arena.And i for one would always be there. :pray
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: iTunes on June 19, 2009, 03:04:48 PM
I like the historical match ups and that you get a fight, like to win them of course, but I'm just glad I get the cance for a good old fight! If we are all honest for a momement then I think the majority would agree that the MA is mostly arcade in nature, base capturing and winning the war mostly. A lot of the fights in the MA are usually ended by folks taking off to the ack or running or get a face full of lead from someone on the pick. The mentality in the MA seems to be "must not die at all costs" nothing wrong with that if that's what you lile to do and there's nothing wrong with base capture, running etc as it's your money and you have the choice to play as you wish.
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: DrDea on June 19, 2009, 03:15:43 PM
 Their are a ton of the old school AW pilots that would like this whole idea.So ask yourself.Why dont they go IN there? Seriously.FSO gets great numbers,this isnt FSO but its the closest thing to it. So why are all these people who OBVIOUSLY like that kind of set up not flocking to this utopia? :huh
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: soda72 on June 19, 2009, 03:20:45 PM
I have a very different question, why would anyone want to go to the AVA. I am not being facetious, try come up with real reasons.

HiTech

What fudgums and oldman listed are the real reasons for showing up in the AvA.  Personally I think #4 would be nice but it has a tendency to cause more headaches than attracting players.  

I think you could drop EW MA and have an AvA MA with a mid war setup that would be attractive to some players.  Base taking and the AvA haven't mixed to well without causing a lot drama.

Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: hitech on June 19, 2009, 03:27:38 PM

2.Historical matchups- Not everyone likes P51 Vs P51 in the MA, the history in the arena is what brings me there. To fight in the same terrain and the same environment like the original great ones did.


First I would say all your reasons except # 2 are conclusions and not reasons. 2. Can not be debated, it is your preference, all your other "reasons" are big stretches.  But does not matter, #2 is a very valid reason for your choice.

Only 1 more question.

What things do you give up so that you can have historical match ups.

HiTech

Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Lazerr on June 19, 2009, 03:39:57 PM

I never flew AvA because the guys I fly with usually tend to clear a sector pretty quick.  I like to kill things, not fly on a cool terrain.  Preference I guess.
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Oldman731 on June 19, 2009, 03:40:19 PM
First I would say all your reasons except # 2 are conclusions and not reasons. 2. Can not be debated, it is your preference, all your other "reasons" are big stretches.  But does not matter, #2 is a very valid reason for your choice.

Only 1 more question.

What things do you give up so that you can have historical match ups.

HiTech



(knits brow)

...er...um.....plane choice....?

- oldman (and very small pebbles)
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Larry on June 19, 2009, 03:40:21 PM
Their are a ton of the old school AW pilots that would like this whole idea.So ask yourself.Why don't they go IN there? Seriously.FSO gets great numbers,this isn't FSO but its the closest thing to it. So why are all these people who OBVIOUSLY like that kind of set up not flocking to this utopia? :huh

Because AvA isn't FSO. FSO and AvA have almost nothing in common. FSO is once a week for two hours, they give you orders for each frame, and there is always a CM there. The AvA is 24/7/365, and there are no orders given out. It is a free for all, and because its an open arena there cant always be a CM on to fix something or stop it if people get out of hand.



When the whole wars were going on it did bring numbers, but because they revolved around base capture it also brought the worst of the MAs. FSO has numbers because its a closed event that only lasts a few hours. If it was open like the AvA and a squad had to go in there two or three times a day and complete their orders you would see people leave.

We I run WNMs and there are orders we see numbers in the arena. They may not be 500 but number are numbers. And almost everyone that fly them only have good things to say.

At the end of the day AvA isn't the MA, SEA or FSO.

Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: soda72 on June 19, 2009, 03:41:46 PM


(knits brow)

...er...um.....plane choice....?

- oldman (and very small pebbles)

lol  I was thinking more of what happens when you fly a zeke vs F4f kind of thing...



Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Larry on June 19, 2009, 03:45:16 PM
I never flew AvA because the guys I fly with usually tend to clear a sector pretty quick.  I like to kill things, not fly on a cool terrain.  Preference I guess.

But that's in the MA. I think you guys would have your hands full going up against some of the AvA guys.


You say you like to kills things, well that's where some of the cool terrains come into play. For the most part bases aren't so far away in the AvA so getting to a fight only takes a few minutes.
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Ardy123 on June 19, 2009, 03:47:42 PM
Have visited you guys many times, and nothing against you all. I think most of you are great guys. Whenever I have flown with the Pigs, they were rolling bases. A game style that isn't the norm in the AvA.  Rolling bases is nothing to be ashamed of though

I've never taken a base, never tried either, I am a POTW member too.
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Larry on June 19, 2009, 03:53:31 PM
First I would say all your reasons except # 2 are conclusions and not reasons. 2. Can not be debated, it is your preference, all your other "reasons" are big stretches.  But does not matter, #2 is a very valid reason for your choice.

Only 1 more question.

What things do you give up so that you can have historical match ups.

HiTech




HT I'm sorry to say but the only real reason people don't fly the AvA is because they cant always get their uber '45 plane. People who try to say they don't go in there because of trash talk don't really want to go in there in the first place. If they did they would use the squelch option and go on with their day. People that say that its just like the MA say that because they don't fly in there or come in there fighting like they are in the MA and don't like it when others fly the way they do. AvA fighting is absolutely nothing like the MA. Sure there are some gangs, HOs, etc. but it is very rare compared to the MAs.


Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: fudgums on June 19, 2009, 04:11:36 PM


What things do you give up so that you can have historical match ups.


Not sure if I understand this correctly but here's my answer.

1. I give up flying with friends and squadies- Not many people in the AvA, so not as many of my friends in the game are there either. Then when I attempt to bring them into the arena. I always get "The arena is empty", not "the attitudes of people"

2. I don't fly in a target rich environment most of the time in the AvA- nearly the same answer as 1. but we had a Blitzekrieg(Guadalcanal-my design w00t) few months back. And it felt like the real thing for a while. It was a raging furball in "the slot" and it was fun. Also Larrys mission with the Okinawa map few weeks back. Not nearly as realistic but it felt like it could've happen. So flying in the AvA with 4 people, just so I can get some sense of "man, wonder how the original guys felt with only 1 life and they couldn't start over again.

I think I answered your question. If I didn't, tell me, and I'll do my best next time. 
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: waystin2 on June 19, 2009, 04:27:00 PM
I've never taken a base, never tried either, I am a POTW member too.


Welcome to the boards you Swine! :D
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: waystin2 on June 19, 2009, 04:29:58 PM


What things do you give up so that you can have historical match ups?

HiTech



You give up choices in favor of historical accuracy. 
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: DrDea on June 19, 2009, 04:35:46 PM

HT I'm sorry to say but the only real reason people don't fly the AvA is because they cant always get their uber '45 plane. People who try to say they don't go in there because of trash talk don't really want to go in there in the first place.
  Heres where your wrong. AVA has a wreched reputation.If HT ran a poll upon going into the arena that asked " What keeps you from going into the AVA?" I think you would be shocked.That or claim it was all rigged. People LIKE historical matchups. Its the community that has the issues.
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: iTunes on June 19, 2009, 04:44:33 PM
Hi Drea
Could you clarify for me your statement "it's the community that hs the issues" for me?
Cheers
Tunes
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Larry on June 19, 2009, 05:19:56 PM
The community doesn't have issues they have excuses.

Here is an example just like what you say you face in the AvA.

I love going into the MW. When I'm in there I always go to the low side and DO NOT let people just milk undefended bases. This means most of the milking comunity in the MW hates me. I can post films of people calling me a cheat and even cussing me out on VOX. Now, I could be like you and leave because they 'ran me out', but you know what I do? I squelch them then kill them with a smile on my face. When I don't squelch them I record what they say and send the films into HTC. I don't let other people ruin my fun and how I like to play.


The ONLY person keeping you from flying there is yourself plain and simple. Say whatever you want but that's a fact.
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: uptown on June 19, 2009, 06:17:10 PM
I think this thread will do alot of good for the arena. I hope it does anyway. Think I'll check it out again.
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Krusty on June 19, 2009, 06:35:15 PM
The community doesn't have issues they have excuses.

So so so many of us all with different backgrounds, experience levels, and personal opinions, have tried time and time again to tell you YOU are part of the problem for the AvA and you ignore us every time.

And then when somebody says you're wrong when you post your biased opinion as to why nobody else wants to fly with you, you turn around and tell them they're wrong and ignorant, and unqualified to give any answer on the matter that isn't quoting you.

Frankly, that's one of the biggest problems with the AvA: The attitude you and a large number of other regulars keep spouting off on.



To answer HT's second question, my mind went to "You give up finding a quick fight" -- because in the MAs you can find a large fight and dogpile on, whereas in the lower numbers arena you have to go looking sometimes.
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: DrDea on June 19, 2009, 06:43:19 PM
Hi Drea
Could you clarify for me your statement "it's the community that hs the issues" for me?
Cheers
Tunes
Well where to start. The prevailing impression that JV 54 thinks the ava is their own personal sand box that berate those that dont 'Play their way"  The "bad ass" attitude backing that impression up on the ava forums.Cant count the times Ive seen the "were the best" line in there. Ive heard from way to many people respected in the AH community that AVA is a cesspool that after reading the forums some,I had not the slightest reason to think otherwise.
  Like I said.If HT ran a poll that allowed a single reason that the community could say why they wouldnt piss on the AVA if it was on fire,These would top if not dominate the list. Deny it all you guys want,but that is the general consensus in all the people Ive heard opinions from.
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: fudgums on June 19, 2009, 06:56:20 PM
I have to disagree with you there dea. Most people don't fly there becuase there isn't anyone there. Only few people(spouting off on the BBS) actually say that
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Delirium on June 19, 2009, 07:07:13 PM
HT I'm sorry to say but the only real reason people don't fly the AvA is because they cant always get their uber '45 plane.

So that is the only real reason I don't fly in the AvA too?

-1
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Larry on June 19, 2009, 07:25:41 PM
So are you guys going to fly in the arena or just sit here crying?







Ill be in there in a few I hope you all do the same, but I wont hold my breath.
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: detch01 on June 19, 2009, 07:47:05 PM
Deny it all you guys want,but that is the general consensus in all the people Ive heard opinions from.
Granted, there was a time when the AvA was a sewer and I was one of the ones spouting off about it. Then it seemed as if 3 out of 4 posts in the text chat were accusations, whines or insults. I didn't particularly enjoy the atmosphere so I left. But times and attitudes change and so did the AvA. I recently took another look and it isn't the cesspool it had become. And my experience with JG54 since I started flying the AvA again has been nothing but good. Maybe it's time for another look at the AvA. The general consensus in this case seems to be running at least a couple of months behind the reality of the AvA.


my 0.02
asw
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Kazaa on June 19, 2009, 07:59:18 PM
1. The fights- The best fights in the game are here. The best pilots in the game fight here. You would learn ACM faster and look at the way of Air Combat in a totally different way.

2.Historical matchups- Not everyone likes P51 Vs P51 in the MA, the history in the arena is what brings me there. To fight in the same terrain and the same environment like the original great ones did.

3. Set ups- If you want a set up, the CM's will run it. It might not be right away but if you request it, it will be there.

4. Gangs/picks/HOs- The reason they are looked down upon are to make the fights the best they can be. and in respect of that, you treat players how you want to be treated. If your going to Ho every pass, Im going to kick my rudder a little then shoot ya right in the cockpit. Simple



You must be delusional, all but No.2 are true imo.
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: DrDea on June 19, 2009, 08:04:08 PM
I have to disagree with you there dea. Most people don't fly there becuase there isn't anyone there. Only few people(spouting off on the BBS) actually say that
Theres no one there because they dont WANT to be there.This catch 22 you guys feel is the reason is just wishful thinking on your part. Ya just dont get that. Maybe the crappy attitudes have changed,maybe they havent,but as long as the same people are perceived to be leading the way its gonna end up with the same results.
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Ack-Ack on June 19, 2009, 08:16:42 PM
So that is the only real reason I don't fly in the AvA too?

-1

Must be mine as well.  Silly me, all this time I thought it was because by the time I get home from work and fly, there is no one in the AvA arena.  I'm glad Larry was here to set me straight.


ack-ack
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: shreck on June 19, 2009, 08:18:34 PM
When the AvA was new I would go in there once in awhile, Then it slowly became a PIKHOVULCHFEST just like the MAs! I stayed out for awhile then returned when the muppets and the UF were chalenged by jg54! The second I arrived squadies were complainin that they were being HOed relentlessly, in fact my 1st sortie I was "straight up" dirty HOed  :aok
The set up was as follows WE were US iron vs German iron! Navy rides were all that was worth upping to avoid a prolonged flight to target! The CVs were about 2 clicks off shore and the LUFTWABBLE was in the predictale and very "MA ARENA" position to punk any plane to gain even a small amount of alt! When I did get a little alt and got past the pikhorde just outside CV ack range I found luftwabble hugging ack and some coming back from climbing to the moon in opposite direction after launch!
As far as I can see the challenge was a set up and pretty sad, muppets were actually flying with jg54 (although m00t may have been the only one)
It looks to me like a set-up arena and really not for a good fair historical match-up! I was very suprised just how MA like it was, the only diff being plane choice being limited in the AvA.

So far as your statement about 45' rides goes larry, well-------> BAH! I fly 38G most of the time  :aok

A slight attitude change and a little humility may go a long way to help promote your desire in the AvA! Also being "above board" on the generally accepted tardish gameplay wouldn't hurt you guys either  :aok

Why don't you guys set up missions at specific dates and times? spend your BBs energy promoting these instead of ranting against everyone who doesn't see it your way :aok  I would bet your success rate in attracting participation would go up immeasurably :aok :aok   :salute
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: fudgums on June 19, 2009, 08:22:12 PM
My momma told me if you don't have anything to say don't say anything at all.                And this isn't coming from 10 year olds. Its coming from grown adults. all I can say now is wow
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Dawger on June 19, 2009, 08:35:19 PM
The quest for an historical arena is about half the reason I've been flying online for well over a decade. Many, many moons ago a different game had an excellent historical arena and it was quite popular for a brief moment in time and then it became drearily similar to the AvA. Since then I have hoped for a return engagement. It has been a rather quixotic journey.

The AvA is a pale shadow of that ideal with no real hope of ever changing.

Hitech makes it quite clear that he doesn't believe in the concept. It is antithetical to his business model (And he is right, most folks don't really want historical re-creation even if they say they do)

Thus he allows the AvA to fester in its current malignant iteration because it validates his conclusions.

The primary market is Late War, All planes for all sides. That is where the money is. Always has been and always will be.

I believe there is a niche market for those interested in historical re-creation in a 24/7 arena, maybe 5 percent of the player base, but it requires HTC finding and supporting a player staff that is focused on providing a vibrant, attractive arena.

What the AvA is now is a small pond with a few big fish that like it that way and some folks that genuinely want to grow the arena. The two groups are in constant tension. Without direct guidance from HTC it will remain this way.

The AVA is BETTER than it used to be but it still isn't an attractive arena. It will not be attractive until the problems are addressed that make it unattractive.

There is a simple list of items that could be done that would start to reverse the trend but I won't bother.

This ain't my first rodeo. It is quite amusing how this particular situation remains unchanged across years and different games.
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: DrDea on June 19, 2009, 08:42:19 PM
My momma told me if you don't have anything to say don't say anything at all.                And this isn't coming from 10 year olds. Its coming from grown adults. all I can say now is wow
Yea and My mom told me to always tell it like ya see it. Bury your head in the sand.The problems still wont go away till the AVA is flushed.
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Larry on June 19, 2009, 08:44:06 PM
More full fights tonight. Sad to say none of the people bashing in this thread were in there. I wonder if they will ever fly there.




Shreck you are just sad. YOUR squad was vulching and ganging us and you dare whine that we HOed you while you were doing it? Hell yes I'm going to HO when I'm getting ganged by 4 people no matter what arena I'm in. Same goes for vulching. For most of the night LW was out numbered 2:1 by F4Us and spits. You really need to get real and stop making it out like you did nothing wrong.
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: APDrone on June 19, 2009, 08:47:05 PM

HT I'm sorry to say but the only real reason people don't fly the AvA is because they cant always get their uber '45 plane.  

Wrong.


Occasionally I'll pop in to the AvA arena and my thought process is thus:

I know enough about history to realize, generally, what planes are going to do what to whom.  The question remains, then, would my adversary be skilled enough to use them or could they possibly suck as bad as I.  

Case in point:  yesterday I entered the arena.. noticed the plane choices-late war American vs. LW., noted that there was a single axis flyer in the air,  I chose the 47D-11 and took off from an airfield that was closest to the only opponent ( as indicated by the red dar bar ).  I promptly had my butt handed to me by a 109 something.. G, maybe.. I did manage to get him to collide with me, but only after losing the turn fight miserably.    So I upped the next logical ( for me, anyway ) plane.. the P38J.. and got my butt handed to me again by the same guy.  I looked at the menu for his next meal and saw no other plane that stood a chance against him. Fortunately, I had a church meeting so I could quietly log out and go about my RL business shortly afterwards.. secure in the reafirmation of my complete suckage.  

In a case like this, it boils down to the same reason I don't play cards.  I suck at cards because of the chance factor.  If I roll a plane that is good for killing bombers ( 190 A-8, in particular ) I will only encounter LAs, Spits and Ponys.  If I up a good plane for dogfighting ( A6M5 ) I will encounter bombers.  If I launch an uber plane, I will encounter an uber adversary.  Luck of the draw.

So.. I'll wander in when I'm feeling comfortable enough in my suckage to handle the disappointment.  Otherwise, I'll just go bomb something or defend a fleet in the puffy ack guns.



  


Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Larry on June 19, 2009, 08:50:24 PM
Wrong.


Occasionally I'll pop in to the AvA arena and my thought process is thus:

I know enough about history to realize, generally, what planes are going to do what to whom.  The question remains, then, would my adversary be skilled enough to use them or could they possibly suck as bad as I.  

Case in point:  yesterday I entered the arena.. noticed the plane choices-late war American vs. LW., noted that there was a single axis flyer in the air,  I chose the 47D-11 and took off from an airfield that was closest to the only opponent ( as indicated by the red dar bar ).  I promptly had my butt handed to me by a 109 something.. G, maybe.. I did manage to get him to collide with me, but only after losing the turn fight miserably.    So I upped the next logical ( for me, anyway ) plane.. the P38J.. and got my butt handed to me again by the same guy.  I looked at the menu for his next meal and saw no other plane that stood a chance against him. Fortunately, I had a church meeting so I could quietly log out and go about my RL business shortly afterwards.. secure in the reafirmation of my complete suckage.  

In a case like this, it boils down to the same reason I don't play cards.  I suck at cards because of the chance factor.  If I roll a plane that is good for killing bombers ( 190 A-8, in particular ) I will only encounter LAs, Spits and Ponys.  If I up a good plane for dogfighting ( A6M5 ) I will encounter bombers.  If I launch an uber plane, I will encounter an uber adversary.  Luck of the draw.

So.. I'll wander in when I'm feeling comfortable enough in my suckage to handle the disappointment.  Otherwise, I'll just go bomb something or defend a fleet in the puffy ack guns.


So are you saying that you dont like it because you get killed to much?
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: APDrone on June 19, 2009, 08:56:16 PM
So are you saying that you dont like it because you get killed to much?

No, I can't say that.. because the response would be 'then get better, silly'.. to which I would have to reply how I know I'll never get good because I don't have the time, talent, nor most importantly, the desire, to get any better.

I think the lack of options in how I'm going to die might better describe it. Or maybe the odds of having different executioners.

I really find no thrill fighting the same guy over and over.  Even if I were victorious. 
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Larry on June 19, 2009, 09:06:09 PM
No, I can't say that.. because the response would be 'then get better, silly'..


No not really. There have been many times where Iv seen people help others out in the AvA. Iv even done it a few times myself. Most of the time if you ask 'what did I do wrong' or ' what could I have done to survive longer' the other person will help you out. The arena is filled with blood thirsty savages like these people would like you to think. Just normal people looking for a good fight.
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: B4Buster on June 19, 2009, 09:51:47 PM
It has been my opinion that you don't give up anythinf flying in the AvA. It's a fun experience.

Wednesday night Larry launched a B-17 mission. We were cruising up at 15K when 2 or 3 Fws made a head on pass at our bomber bow. It was really cool to see them coming at us and weaving through the formation on their pass.

I'm not going to lie. Not all AvA matchups are even. Perhaps that is what you mean when you ask what you give up (really not sure exactly what you meant). If someone is the type of person who feels the need to have the plane advantage everytime they up, then no the AvA probably isn't for them. I for one love being at a disadvantage. No different than in the MAs. 9 times out of 10 I'm fighting someone higher, with a superior plane, with more numbers, and on many occasions all three advantages combined! Now not every plane set is lop sided. Belive me alot of thought and consideration goes into the setups every week. We do what we can to make it so they're as even as possible with the limited plane set (and as even as they can be)

I played Janes before I decided to go online with my WW2 flight sim experience. The prospect of flying my favorite American planes versus German iron, or Japanese fire starter was appealing to me. I quickly found out it can be difficult to find that. I was drawn to the AvA and got hooked. I don't care if the matchup is even (heck I fly a B-38 around in the MA). I just want to have fun. The AvA is fun to me.

Sorry for the novel, was trying to cover some of the "AvA downfalls" so many speak about  :lol
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: moot on June 19, 2009, 11:10:06 PM
I have a very different question, why would anyone want to go to the AVA. I am not being facetious, try come up with real reasons.

HiTech
Historical match ups not restricted to events' schedule.  That's a huge draw.. Correct me if I'm wrong but that's what the promise of CT was.
What things do you give up so that you can have historical match ups.
Just about anything.. E.G. No or limited cross country comms, a kill message system that worked not in real time but only confirmed the in-flight "possible kills" on a kill board once you were back on the ground would be ok.  Flying only per scheduled sortie system could be tolerable too.
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Mister Fork on June 19, 2009, 11:29:59 PM
Only 1 more question.

What things do you give up so that you can have historical match ups.

HiTech


I give up:
1. The ability to fly any aircraft to immerse myself in a historical situation to simulate what a real WWII fighter pilot faced.
2. Tactical advantage of flying the easy aircraft from a list, vs what the historical situation was at the time.
3. Main Arena style engagements of 20 vs 30 around an airfield to 3 Spit V's vs 3 Bf-109F-4 over the English Channel or flying my Ju-88 formation into a horde of Spit I's and Hurri I's.
4. MA style engagements of being slammed by a La-7, Spits, and Mustangs to fly a Zeke or Frank against P-38's, Corsairs, or Thunderbolts in historical PTO.
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: antivortex on June 19, 2009, 11:30:38 PM


What things do you give up so that you can have historical match ups.

HiTech


You give up the ability to choose flying any plane you want.

Your also going to give up numbers, I believe only the 'hard core' AHers really care about the historical matchups.

Your also going to have to make comprimises on aircraft choice seeing as we have limits there too in terms of matchups.













Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: TEShaw on June 20, 2009, 04:32:53 PM
If I thought A v A was fun, I'd play Warbirds in the year 2003.
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Dawger on June 20, 2009, 05:06:17 PM
If I thought A v A was fun, I'd play Warbirds in the year 2003.

When Warbirds first introduced WBIII in spring 2002 (if memory serves), the  Historical Arena had No Icons and a steady population of 70+ folks (which was a large number for Warbirds at the time). That was the peak of online historical matchup type flying in the history of MMOG. For me anyway. There is nothing more intense than no icon fights (yes, I have heard every argument under the sun regarding icons so don't bother). I miss that but I know it will never occur again. The few folks that enjoyed that sort of thing have moved on to other things and I don't think you could get more than five people in the world who would fly no icons on a regular basis.

But it was the heyday. And it only lasted about 6 weeks. Warbirds introduced AI scripts into its Main Arena.The HA emptied within an hour of that and never recovered. It straggled on for a while longer and then was finally scrapped because Warbirds put up the World War II Arena (basically the AvA except it had all planes enabled, just not on the same side). Warbirds never recovered from that mistake. It split an already small player base into even smaller piles and folks left in droves. Most eventually came here. Some stayed with WB way too long, myself included.

The AvA is like the Warbirds Historical Arena with Main Arena style settings. For me, it is better than nothing but far short of the mark for the type of historical re-creation I enjoy. Mainly, the neon icons detract from the immersion of the fight. There is nothing more visually stunning than a no icon fight for several reasons. And the tactical differences make for fights that more closely match historical descriptions (so don't tell i should just turn off my own icons). It is a different experience altogether. Not necessarily more fun. More intense is the best description.

Enough nostalgia for the good ole days. Aces High is a much better game by far but the players have changed and the excitement and enthusiasm for such silliness is gone with them.
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: DrDea on June 20, 2009, 06:54:07 PM
Quote
Mainly, the neon icons detract from the immersion of the fight. There is nothing more visually stunning than a no icon fight for several reasons. And the tactical differences make for fights that more closely match historical descriptions (so don't tell i should just turn off my own icons). It is a different experience altogether. Not necessarily more fun. More intense is the best description.
i know theres been times on some maps with some planes that I was shooting just below the icon due to it just hideing the plane. This would make for some interesting fights if you ask me.
 Of course it wouldnt work in a mixed arena.
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: SpiveyCH on June 20, 2009, 07:16:58 PM
     Took my squad into the AvA.  We had 20 guys and split them even.  We started at a few bases that were not busy.  I did not want to inject 20 guys into the smaller fights, thought it might ruin any good fights going on.  Figured they would work their way down to us.  Things were going good.  After about 40 mins, I notice that the numbers were a bit out of whack.  By this time, all that were in the arena, were in our area.  The Numbers were something like 17  to 11.  Another squad had joined in and were all working together, on one side.  There were about 5 or 6 of them.  One of my guys says over range that the numbers are getting a bit uneven.  The response from one of them in that squad, "Why don't you send a few of your guys over to even it out."  So, we left and went back to the MA.

    

    
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: fudgums on June 20, 2009, 07:37:07 PM
 The response from one of them in that squad, "Why don't you send a few of your guys over to even it out."  So, we left and went back to the MA.

    

    

Squadies like to fly with squadies. I think they ment, "Hey, our squad is here , if you want to fly with your squadies, the numbers will be even"

Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Slash27 on June 20, 2009, 07:40:10 PM
This one time, in the AvA, this guy was like, "why you acting so messed up towards me?" and I was like "why are you acting so messed up towards me?", and he was like " you saying all that stuff about me" and I was like," lots people were saying stuff."





Then I ho'd him and ejected him for letting me ho him. Its against the code you know.
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: SpiveyCH on June 20, 2009, 07:53:38 PM
     They had all their guys on one side, my guys were already split 50/50.  Just thought is would make more sense for them to split and help keep the sides even. 
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Larry on June 20, 2009, 07:55:19 PM
    Took my squad into the AvA.  We had 20 guys and split them even.  We started at a few bases that were not busy.  I did not want to inject 20 guys into the smaller fights, thought it might ruin any good fights going on.  Figured they would work their way down to us.  Things were going good.  After about 40 mins, I notice that the numbers were a bit out of whack.  By this time, all that were in the arena, were in our area.  The Numbers were something like 17  to 11.  Another squad had joined in and were all working together, on one side.  There were about 5 or 6 of them.  One of my guys says over range that the numbers are getting a bit uneven.  The response from one of them in that squad, "Why don't you send a few of your guys over to even it out."  So, we left and went back to the MA.
    


Would that be the same day you guys went in there fighting between two bases and when other people started to join in one of your guys PMed my squaddie telling him to leave that area because you guys were doing a squad thing? Then a few minutes later I heard the same thing on range.

It seemed you guys wanted a private place to fight each other without anyone else joining in. Then when they did you guys got mad and ran out.
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: mensa180 on June 20, 2009, 07:59:15 PM
The only reason I am not in there more is because of numbers, or lack there of.  I know, evil circle, blah blah blah.
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: SpiveyCH on June 20, 2009, 08:08:49 PM
I did not know of any pm's to you or hear it on range.   They did not come from me.  I did not expect to go into the AvA and be left alone.  I apologize to you and your squaddie.  My intent going in there was to keep my guys even on both sides and hope the rest would help to even it out.  From my POV and what I heard, I thought that the numbers would stay uneven.  
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Larry on June 20, 2009, 08:20:57 PM
 The comments didn't come from you but they did come from a CH. No need to apologize we just ignored them and went on with the night. There were some of my squad on each side because I remember shooting one down then getting beat up bad by N7. I for one would love to see the CH's come back in there. Its rare for a MA squad to come in there and try to keep numbers even. Most of the time they come in and gang everyone else 3:1 then cry it was just like the MA. And for that I salute you and your squad. :salute
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: dstrip2 on June 20, 2009, 08:44:46 PM
i know i personally would love to play ava more often. i always check the numbers, its usually 1 guy if that. if i saw people in there id play it lol. catch 22 i know.

i think one thing that would attract more people would be to have the plane sets divided up like the MA by year, played on a generic battlefield. you know,
ava early,
mid and
late war.

it would still be nice to see the specific scenarios run in there, i think those would be awesome if more people were on.



a more diverse plane set (as mentioned above) and a bit of exposure/advertising if you will would in my opinion significantly help the numbers issue. after that is solved other things can be worked on.

i will say that the few times i have found other people on, they have been of a better caliber than the typical MA stuff. id like to see it stay that way
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: PFactorDave on June 20, 2009, 08:51:27 PM
Quote
Why dont more people play axis v allies

(http://i177.photobucket.com/albums/w220/Davis_Andrews/AxisAndAlliesBox.jpg)

Great game, back in the day...  The biggest reason I don't play is, most of the guys I used to go up against have moved to other cities, have families of their own now...  Just nobody to play the game with...

Tried to get my kids interested in it once, but having two daughters isn't helpful when looking for a strategy game opponent.

 :D

In all honesty, I gave my reasons in another thread once and was lambasted by the chosen few.
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Sunka on June 20, 2009, 08:52:42 PM
 :rolleyes:
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: fudgums on June 20, 2009, 09:11:55 PM
(http://i177.photobucket.com/albums/w220/Davis_Andrews/AxisAndAlliesBox.jpg)

Great game, back in the day...  The biggest reason I don't play is, most of the guys I used to go up against have moved to other cities, have families of their own now...  Just nobody to play the game with...


I have that game under my bed right now  :lol ,I bought it when I was 8 years old  :cool:
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Larry on June 20, 2009, 10:34:22 PM
I have that game under my bed right now  :lol ,I bought it when I was 8 years old  :cool:


So you got it last week?  OHHH BURN!!! :devil
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: james on June 21, 2009, 12:38:49 AM
Playing the anniversary edition right now. It kills the first edition I have like yours. I recommend it if you ever find another group of people to play the game with.
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: OOZ662 on July 10, 2009, 05:51:03 PM
I don't find it strange that the people that are bashing on the AvA aren't in there. I find it more strange that Larry expects us to be.

I flew a few times in the AvA. I was bored. Then, when my squad started telling horror stories of dweebs and JG54, I decided to never go back. Some of my good friends still say no to flying there because of the attitudes and JG54.
I don't even know if JG54 exists any more. Point being, if I had a miserable time in there, why am I expected to come back?
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Ardy123 on July 10, 2009, 06:15:21 PM
Bad behavior? more like no behavior. I've gone several times but never have I ever seen anyone in there. Another thing that would make it cool would be if every day of the week was a different year of WWII in the AVA. That way....
1) On Sunday I could kill you in my 109E
2) On Monday I could kill you in my 109E
3) On Tuesday I could kill you in my 109F4
4) On Wednesday I could kill you in my 109 G2
5) On Thursday I could kill you in my 109 G6
6) On Friday I could kill you in my 109 G14
7) And on Saturday just as I wake from a whole night of drinking, you up in a Runstang... and I'll kill you again in my 109 k4.

 :D
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Masherbrum on July 10, 2009, 06:22:19 PM
I still have my

(http://www.mondocollecto.com/files/images/axis-and-allies.jpg)

but I also have the Mod:

(http://www.mnemo.dk/axis-worldatwarexp1.jpg)

It adds more countries and more ships.  Had a 28 hour marathon game with my oldest brother back in 1995.   
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: DrDea on July 10, 2009, 06:48:37 PM
I flew a few times in the AvA. I was bored. Then, when my squad started telling horror stories of dweebs and JG54, I decided to never go back. Some of my good friends still say no to flying there because of the attitudes and JG54.
I don't even know if JG54 exists any more. Point being, if I had a miserable time in there, why am I expected to come back?

  Your gonna love this. They are called the "Class acts" now :rofl :x
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Larry on July 10, 2009, 07:54:23 PM
  Your gonna love this. They are called the "Class acts" now :rofl :x

Your ankle humping is getting pathetic. You must be to slow to realize that our name 'the class acts' was a joke. Kinda like you are every day. :rolleyes:
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: DrDea on July 10, 2009, 09:22:54 PM
Your ankle humping is getting pathetic. You must be to slow to realize that our name 'the class acts' was a joke. Kinda like you are every day. :rolleyes:
No I understood it was a joke.We all did. It was just a very funny one.
Title: Re: Why dont more people play axis v allies
Post by: Dinan on July 11, 2009, 01:52:40 PM
It's really hard for me to believe you're actually able to understand anything.