Aces High Bulletin Board

General Forums => Aces High General Discussion => Topic started by: Shane on September 04, 2026, 06:29:13 PM

Title: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: Shane on September 04, 2026, 06:29:13 PM
Ok, the new AFK not counting towards ENY update has been producing unintended (?) consequences with the incentives being stay logged on instead of logging out.

I think it can be attributed to the 5 minute timer being too short.  It should consider being increased 30 minutes to an hour, so the effects aren't as immediately manipulatable.

1. Instead of hurting their own side, AFK players now actively penalize the other side.  People can simply walk away leaving game open (for 5 minutes or even hours) and keeping ENY up (or down.)   The below screenshot - why are Rooks under ENY? Because for 5 minutes someone went to check their emails?

(https://i.postimg.cc/sDHHbkCS/whyeny.jpg) (https://postimages.org/)


2.  AFK still benefit from war win perks - why?



Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: The Fugitive on September 04, 2026, 07:16:51 PM
1. I dont understand the issue. The Rooks have ENY because the have 14% non-afk players than the Bish If the two afk players come back, the ENY would go up. From what I understand as soon as an afk player makes any input they are no longer afk and couunt toward the percentage for ENY.

2. perk points while afk has always been a thing. It is most likely how the tower sitting started back in the day when we all sucked and it was much harder to get perk points.
Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: Shane on September 04, 2026, 07:49:11 PM
1. I dont understand the issue. The Rooks have ENY because the have 14% non-afk players than the Bish If the two afk players come back, the ENY would go up. From what I understand as soon as an afk player makes any input they are no longer afk and couunt toward the percentage for ENY.

2. perk points while afk has always been a thing. It is most likely how the tower sitting started back in the day when we all sucked and it was much harder to get perk points.


1. 5 minutes is all it takes to be considered AFK - so for a short window their AFK impacts another side.  Checking your email, or whatever = eny effect on active players. IIRC it also applies to in-flight, say a bomber on long climb out is not counted for eny as long as they don't input anything. 

2. It's easily manipulated with a such a short window. Case in point, instead of some morning Jokers having to eat it and go sit on knit/rooks to lower bish eny to get access to better planes for the reset (and no win perks), now all they have to do is go AFK a short time and still benefit from the win perks.

https://bbs.hitechcreations.com/smf/index.php/topic,412833.msg5474896.html#msg5474896

Let's take a look at that example I posted above.  Total player and in-flight numbers are pretty balanced, yet ENY.  What are you struggling to grasp about this situation being  :headscratch: in that 2-3 players being "AFK" has such an impact?   Wait til people learn how to fine tune this tactically.
Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: -gg- on September 04, 2026, 08:24:13 PM
It would be cool if ENY was specific to the plane type or vehicle type. In other words bombers, fighters, gvs, attack, etc.  all separately calculated..

For instance, if one side has way more bombers than both sides up, ENY kicks in for bombers only.

Maybe have autopilot disengage after 5 minutes so people have to actively monitor their flying. I'm not sure what the equivalent would be in GVs.

A lot of these problems, in my opinion, arise from the numbers being so low and the system kicking in. It makes the system easily manipulated by just a few players.

Before I was saying that maybe it shouldn't be even kicking in until at least 100 players were online. But I'm thinking it would be close to that number or a little bit higher. Maybe 120 players online before the system even kicks in at all.

And ultimately, I just don't like it at all any of it.... But at the very least it needs to be looked at because it's just damaging too many people's game experience. Whether people come here and talk about it or admit it or not, it really does piss people off when they can't fly the planes they want to fly and being placed at a disadvantage against players who are very skilled and just end up tearing you apart because you can't compete against the plane that they are in.. And doubly so when it's possibly being manipulated.
Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: -gg- on September 04, 2026, 08:38:05 PM
Or like somebody mentioned before. ENY by sector.

Some guy AFK with bombers 20 sectirs away from anything probably shouldn't be affecting ENY at all .... Or getting the benefit of it



Say for instance there's like 15 people online. At one bomber is hitting the strat
 10 sectore away from anything. Somebody should be able to take up a 163 to intercept them. Or any plane .

Maybe the only time it should take effect is not only when the numbers are at least 100 players online, but also when the numbers are a certain amount in any given quadrant or sector or whatever okay
Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: Shane on September 04, 2026, 08:39:58 PM

Before I was saying that maybe it shouldn't be even kicking in until at least 100 players were online. But I'm thinking it would be close to that number or a little bit higher. Maybe 120 players online before the system even kicks in at all.



The times when in-game number of players is more than 100 is a very short prime-time window, and 120 even shorter when it occurs.  In your scenario, ENY is practically removed and would reward off-prime time swarmboi skawds like morning Jokers or overnight Tropic Thunder.

I actually gave thought that maybe ordnance can be ENY'd or perhaps autoswitchers go to the low base number side, regardless of overall numbers, but... unintended consequences, aka, players.

[edit: ENY by sector would be problematic as how would you factor it? Not seeing how that could be calculated?10 players who upped under no present eny affecting the next 5 people upping behind them?]

Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: Kruel on September 04, 2026, 08:40:33 PM
Or like somebody mentioned before. ENY by sector.

That seems logical.
Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: -gg- on September 04, 2026, 08:57:31 PM
The times when in-game number of players is more than 100 is a very short prime-time window, and 120 even shorter when it occurs.  In your scenario, ENY is practically removed and would reward off-prime time swarmboi skawds like morning Jokers or overnight Tropic Thunder.

I actually gave thought that maybe ordnance can be ENY'd or perhaps autoswitchers go to the low base number side, regardless of overall numbers, but... unintended consequences, aka, players.

[edit: ENY by sector would be problematic as how would you factor it? Not seeing how that could be calculated?10 players who upped under no present eny affecting the next 5 people upping behind them?]


Regarding ENY by sector.... I mean yeah if you take off and there's no current penalty but then you push the numbers in that sector to the point where the other side has the disadvantage, then yeah anybody upping behind the original players would have the penalty. And maybe make it so that the one sector where the action is happening that's triggering it also affects the next sectors all around it so people can't just up from the next base over and avoid the penalty. And maybe if the numbers get too far out of whack it can affect two sectors over.

But at least that way it would be affecting the local fight.

I find it kind of rare when we are under the penalty that I am actually in a fight where I am in an area where I'm outnumbering anybody. Usually it's the other way around even though I'm getting the penalty.


But yeah, the low numbers do affect everything and are easily a manipulated. So if the eny didn't kick in until 100 players and there's rarely 100 players, that's not a bad thing in my opinion. Because the numbers are so low anyway that there really isn't a possibility of somebody getting totally gangbanged for very long or at all.

I personally don't want any advantage when it's the other way around either. Like when the other side is under the penalty I don't want to have an advantage over them either.



Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: Shane on September 04, 2026, 09:18:03 PM

But yeah, the low numbers do affect everything and are easily a manipulated. So if the eny didn't kick in until 100 players and there's rarely 100 players, that's not a bad thing in my opinion. Because the numbers are so low anyway that there really isn't a possibility of somebody getting totally gangbanged for very long or at all.


Oh sweet child of summer... I suggest you log on between 8-12am est any morning of the week. It's like this every day. And it's generally both bish and knits hitting rooks.  It's not quite as bad between 2-8am est when the swarm belongs to Tropic Thunder vs those few opposing night owls, but still a rough experience.  It's why I get .rpt abused, calling the weebzery out.

See, any changes need to take in the overall experience, not just yours or mine, altho' I play at all hours of the day. I think changing the timer would be the easier fix since it's already implemented and is an adjustable arena setting (currently at 5 mins.)

A longer timer removes a lot of potential immediate manipulation. And without additional changes, this *will* occur; it already is.


(https://i.postimg.cc/rsvPDHC6/swarmboisa.jpg) (https://postimg.cc/PvQ4c2RK)


Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: haggerty on September 04, 2026, 09:23:45 PM
first image shows the intent, not unintended consequence. 
Its 13-17-20, Rooks have 5 ENY because of the 20 to 13, just like they would if those AFK guys logged off.
Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: Shane on September 04, 2026, 09:37:18 PM
first image shows the intent, not unintended consequence. 
Its 13-17-20, Rooks have 5 ENY because of the 20 to 13, just like they would if those AFK guys logged off.

But they're not logging off, they're just maybe doing some trivial thing like me sitting here responding while sitting in the tower. It is effecting ENY.  Let me go un-AFK to grab current data. While I (and maybe others) was AFK that ENY may have crept up to 10 for bish, as an example.

(https://i.postimg.cc/8PzRv4ng/enyone.jpg) (https://postimg.cc/G96TwFCX)


Take mornings for example. I used you relating Jokers switching sides to lessen eny for reset (no perks for them; took it for the team!) Now there's no need to do that, just go AFK and come back to a win obtained under less eny.  Nice reward for gaming a "fairness" mechanism.

I think increasing the timer 30 min to an hr is less susceptible to manipulation while still performing its intended function.
Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: -gg- on September 04, 2026, 09:51:55 PM
I'll be honest and say that I don't have the brains to figure out how the AFK players are negatively affecting the new eny system.


Seems to me it's a good idea if somebody is actually AFK and not doing anything in an airplane or sitting in the tower that it shouldn't penalize the team that they are on for higher numbers. Isn't that the way it's supposed to work?

I'm not trying to be difficult with your example of Shane I just don't understand.

Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: JimmyD3 on September 04, 2026, 10:00:50 PM
Shane how many players you think are going to come up with this "gaming the game" technique. First off, it hasn't been a week since the change, I say give it at least 2 tours to  see how it functions. The time setting is in the arena tables so it is adjustable. It may in fact need to be adjusted some  :aokwhere down the line, but for now I say, lets wait and see.
Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: -gg- on September 04, 2026, 10:23:08 PM
The other thing about e n y and numbers and all that is that I don't think the numbers in the game should be micromanaged. There's going to be times when you are outnumbered and there's going to be times that you're outnumbering somebody else. Even in a local fight. There might be a squad that logs on for squad night and suddenly they're swarming a base or two. So what? That happens in real life that happens in war that happens in games.

I would rather let that ride. Let the game be the game. You know there are strategies to deal with that. Come in high and start attacking one of their other bases to split them up or whatever. It's actually fun for me to try counter things like that. I would rather be having to deal with being outnumbered then having to deal with being penalized for being on the side that's outnumbered, or being rewarded if on the other end of it.


But going back to the low numbers. Just don't mess with it. Those numbers are so low in your examples that nobody should be worried about which side has more by a few players. Doesn't even make any sense to worry about that.

Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: Shane on September 04, 2026, 10:41:37 PM
Shane how many players you think are going to come up with this "gaming the game" technique.

You really said this because you really believe it?  Like with Gina, perhaps check in some weekday mornings around 8-10am cst? 

I could be considered AFK merely by upping and alting from a rear base towards some action.

Here's the easiest way to game it:

While the ftrs/gvs go "AFK" for... 5 mins... 3-4 boxes of nice buffs, say b-24's up from 2 sectors away for the same or even differing targets (b24's wf easy)  by the time they're close in, they've been "AFK" and suppressing ENY for the fighters and gv's that launch when those buffs are closer to target(s.) 

Yay, fighters not under ENY, buffs not under ENY.  Of course, once both waves are in air and active, eny kicks in, but only for those late to the party. 

The mission editor could even facilitate this since you can create two separate missions with differing launch times.  Join mission and wait with no input, "AFK" until launch.

See how easy that was? Especially when it's say, 14 v 4 v 3 where those 14 concentrate on one of the two smaller sides, 14 v 4 or 14 v 3 basically.  3-4 "AFK" on that 14 side can lower the eny enough, fast enough to give them much nicer rides vs those small siders.

I think 30 minutes is a good timer compromise, because that means you're really AFK, not just grabbing a beer or checking your email while in tower or on climbout.
Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: The Fugitive on September 04, 2026, 10:59:46 PM
You really said this because you really believe it?  Like with Gina, perhaps check in some weekday mornings around 8-10am cst? 

I could be considered AFK merely by upping and alting from a rear base towards some action.

Here's the easiest way to game it:

While the ftrs/gvs go "AFK" for... 5 mins... 3-4 boxes of nice buffs, say b-24's up from 2 sectors away for the same or even differing targets (b24's wf easy)  by the time they're close in, they've been "AFK" and suppressing ENY for the fighters and gv's that launch when those buffs are closer to target(s.) 

Yay, fighters not under ENY, buffs not under ENY.  Of course, once both waves are in air and active, eny kicks in, but only for those late to the party. 

The mission editor could even facilitate this since you can create two separate missions with differing launch times.  Join mission and wait with no input, "AFK" until launch.

See how easy that was? Especially when it's say, 14 v 4 v 3 where those 14 concentrate on one of the two smaller sides, 14 v 4 or 14 v 3 basically.  3-4 "AFK" on that 14 side can lower the eny enough, fast enough to give them much nicer rides vs those small siders.

I think 30 minutes is a good timer compromise, because that means you're really AFK, not just grabbing a beer or checking your email while in tower or on climbout.

Your assuming thats how it works. What if AFK only pertains to tower sitters. Then most of your complaint falls apart. If afk is only those AFK, then your complaint has no bearing. There is no "manipulation", it is just what it is and your being paranoid.

1. lets wait to see what/if Hitech tells us how the "afk" timer is setup.
2. give it some time to play out in the arena. What happens in the mornings eastern times may not be a norm that we can follow.
3. Im thinking this afk thing might be a fix to "prime times" vs ALL the time. Again, time will tell.
Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: haggerty on September 04, 2026, 11:09:10 PM
But they're not logging off, they're just maybe doing some trivial thing like me sitting here responding while sitting in the tower. It is effecting ENY.  Let me go un-AFK to grab current data. While I (and maybe others) was AFK that ENY may have crept up to 10 for bish, as an example.

(https://i.postimg.cc/8PzRv4ng/enyone.jpg) (https://postimg.cc/G96TwFCX)


Take mornings for example. I used you relating Jokers switching sides to lessen eny for reset (no perks for them; took it for the team!) Now there's no need to do that, just go AFK and come back to a win obtained under less eny.  Nice reward for gaming a "fairness" mechanism.

I think increasing the timer 30 min to an hr is less susceptible to manipulation while still performing its intended function.

Jokers no longer switching sides is a benefit, their being AFK is less impact on bish ENY than if they moved to another team.  What difference does it make if someone goes afk for 5 minutes or logs off for 5 minutes?  Either way its the same ENY reduction.
Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: Animl-AW on September 04, 2026, 11:15:32 PM
HiTech on another thread:
"The low-population example may justify reviewing whether the existing thresholds are calibrated correctly,... "
Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: -gg- on September 04, 2026, 11:17:40 PM
Your assuming thats how it works. What if AFK only pertains to tower sitters. Then most of your complaint falls apart. If afk is only those AFK, then your complaint has no bearing. There is no "manipulation", it is just what it is and your being paranoid.

1. lets wait to see what/if Hitech tells us how the "afk" timer is setup.
2. give it some time to play out in the arena. What happens in the mornings eastern times may not be a norm that we can follow.
3. Im thinking this afk thing might be a fix to "prime times" vs ALL the time. Again, time will tell.

That is how it works. If you're in a plane or vehicle and you're not actively controlling it for 5 minutes then you go afk.
Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: Animl-AW on September 04, 2026, 11:19:20 PM
That is how it works. If you're in a plane or vehicle and you're not actively controlling it for 5 minutes then you go afk.

Personally I have not seen it defined if it's just while AFK in tower or also includes while in AC or GV.
Maybe I missed it.

Edit: I assume/hope it's just while in tower.
Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: -gg- on September 04, 2026, 11:35:45 PM
Dale said that that's how it works.
Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: waystin2 on September 05, 2026, 07:38:17 AM
Less players makes for wilder ENY swings.  Not an AFK problem.
Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: Shane on September 05, 2026, 08:14:04 AM
Your assuming thats how it works. What if AFK only pertains to tower sitters. Then most of your complaint falls apart. If afk is only those AFK, then your complaint has no bearing. There is no "manipulation", it is just what it is and your being paranoid.

1. lets wait to see what/if Hitech tells us how the "afk" timer is setup.
2. give it some time to play out in the arena. What happens in the mornings eastern times may not be a norm that we can follow.
3. Im thinking this afk thing might be a fix to "prime times" vs ALL the time. Again, time will tell.

Well, you can doubt Kenai if you want, I generally take him at his word.    And unironically, you have a post directly below the one I just linked to where you even acknowledge it as being your own suggestion.    :headscratch: :rolleyes:  :aok   

https://bbs.hitechcreations.com/smf/index.php/topic,412969.msg5477128.html#msg5477128

Eny is less of an issue during primetime because there are simply more players at play.  Things can still get done (even with eny/double teaming) 30 v 25 v 37 compared to 17 v 8 v 9 where removing eny makes it more challenging under conditions.

ENY is actually less of an issue than the constant double teaming creating feast/famine fronts that the side switchers and the double teamed-ees complain about, and eny will not resolve this ethos issue - yanno, can't hard code sportsmanship.

For example, right now, look at that base count.  Those 4 knits are also pecking at rooks while bish basically go full on vs rooks. Because its weekend, there are a few more players on early.  Eny is meaningless here except that it forces bish into lesser rides which isn't really stopping much, just sometimes slows it down a bit until more players log on.  Let's not forget GV eny's are kind of... off.   

I've stopped upping a plane in these times and just hop from gun to gun getting kills (and denying kills on me) with minimal effort (and I'm getting better in 88's lol.)

(https://i.postimg.cc/wjNZjQCQ/dblteamweebz.jpg) (https://postimg.cc/4YJB8VNY)

Compare this morning screenshot above with one from 10pm cst last night below, same map.  What can be inferred when comparing?

(https://i.postimg.cc/T18QSzPS/lastniteweebz.jpg) (https://postimg.cc/vgzWxSfL) 

Let's see what this morning looks like in about 2 hrs (10:30 cst)




Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: The Fugitive on September 05, 2026, 08:38:02 AM
Well, you can doubt Kenai if you want, I generally take him at his word.    And unironically, you have a post directly below the one I just linked to where you even acknowledge it as being your own suggestion.    :headscratch: :rolleyes:  :aok   

https://bbs.hitechcreations.com/smf/index.php/topic,412969.msg5477128.html#msg5477128

Eny is less of an issue during primetime because there are simply more players at play.  Things can still get done (even with eny/double teaming) 30 v 25 v 37 compared to 17 v 8 v 9 where removing eny makes it more challenging under conditions.

ENY is actually less of an issue than the constant double teaming creating feast/famine fronts that the side switchers and the double teamed-ees complain about, and eny will not resolve this ethos issue - yanno, can't hard code sportsmanship.

Yes I suggested that the players in the tower get removed from ENY calculations after a set time. I gave the idea to Kenai, my squad CO, and he mentioned it to Dale. Dale liked it enough to try it.

Personally I dont have an issue with ENY, never have. I understand why its there and how it works (though I wish the planes could be reevaluated as some of then are not set right for ENY). My suggestion was for those that complain about the "tower sitters" messing with the ENY. Now they see a solution. After a set time, all AFK players are automatically removed from the ENY calculations. Will that stop the complaining about ENY? I doubt it. To complain is another ..... what do you call it  ethos?  :D  Players cant seem to get away from their hot rods.

As I said, ENY doesnt bother me. If one team has 10 to 1 players they should fly camels and spads against the guys flying jets for 10 perks!
Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: Shane on September 05, 2026, 08:44:45 AM
Yes I suggested that the players in the tower get removed from ENY calculations after a set time. I gave the idea to Kenai, my squad CO, and he mentioned it to Dale. Dale liked it enough to try it.

Right... so what tempted you to latch onto my ankle with:

"Your assuming thats how it works. What if AFK only pertains to tower sitters. Then most of your complaint falls apart. If afk is only those AFK, then your complaint has no bearing. There is no "manipulation", it is just what it is and your being paranoid."

Maybe step back? 
Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: The Fugitive on September 05, 2026, 09:00:20 AM
You really said this because you really believe it?  Like with Gina, perhaps check in some weekday mornings around 8-10am cst? 

I could be considered AFK merely by upping and alting from a rear base towards some action.

Here's the easiest way to game it:

While the ftrs/gvs go "AFK" for... 5 mins... 3-4 boxes of nice buffs, say b-24's up from 2 sectors away for the same or even differing targets (b24's wf easy)  by the time they're close in, they've been "AFK" and suppressing ENY for the fighters and gv's that launch when those buffs are closer to target(s.) 

Yay, fighters not under ENY, buffs not under ENY.  Of course, once both waves are in air and active, eny kicks in, but only for those late to the party. 

The mission editor could even facilitate this since you can create two separate missions with differing launch times.  Join mission and wait with no input, "AFK" until launch.

See how easy that was? Especially when it's say, 14 v 4 v 3 where those 14 concentrate on one of the two smaller sides, 14 v 4 or 14 v 3 basically.  3-4 "AFK" on that 14 side can lower the eny enough, fast enough to give them much nicer rides vs those small siders.

I think 30 minutes is a good timer compromise, because that means you're really AFK, not just grabbing a beer or checking your email while in tower or on climbout.

Lets add context.

So when I said....

""Your assuming thats how it works. What if AFK only pertains to tower sitters. Then most of your complaint falls apart. If afk is only those AFK, then your complaint has no bearing. There is no "manipulation", it is just what it is and your being paranoid.""

I was referring to the bolded above. I still havent heard any confirmation that an AFK player flying, or sitting in a tank under a tree is part of the timer used to remove players from the ENY calc. Personally that isnt how I would set it up, but its not my game.

Personally, If a player, or players want to sit in the tower to lower their teams ENY thats OK. To me they arent playing so they arent involved so they shouldnt count toward ENY. Its like they were off-line  (AKA booted after a timer runs down  :D )

This is where the paranoia comes in for you. You see it as manipulation, I see it as booting AFK players.
Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: Shane on September 05, 2026, 09:10:05 AM
Lets add context.

So when I said....

""Your assuming thats how it works. What if AFK only pertains to tower sitters. Then most of your complaint falls apart. If afk is only those AFK, then your complaint has no bearing. There is no "manipulation", it is just what it is and your being paranoid.""

I was referring to the bolded above. I still havent heard any confirmation that an AFK player flying, or sitting in a tank under a tree is part of the timer used to remove players from the ENY calc. Personally that isnt how I would set it up, but its not my game.

Personally, If a player, or players want to sit in the tower to lower their teams ENY thats OK. To me they arent playing so they arent involved so they shouldnt count toward ENY. Its like they were off-line  (AKA booted after a timer runs down  :D )

This is where the paranoia comes in for you. You see it as manipulation, I see it as booting AFK players.

YOU DO NOT NEED TO BE KEYBOARD ACTIVE IN AUTO CLIMB FROM A SECTOR BACK.
  :rolleyes: :rolleyes: :rolleyes: :rolleyes: :rolleyes: :rolleyes: :rolleyes: :rolleyes:

It takes between 3-10 mins to cross a sector depending on ride speed and rate of climb, if any.

Seriously, step off my ankle and just stay with the actual issue at hand.

And if you want to accuse Kenai of passing along false info, have at it.   :aok :aok :aok :aok :aok

Then why not simply boot afk players with a 30 min timer on activity to segregate brief afk from actual afk?  And if you think players don't manipulate game mechanics, I'll gladly laugh directly in your face.  :rofl :rofl :rofl :rofl :rofl :rofl :rofl

Here's a simple question, why should AFK buffs on their way to strats be taken out of eny, because once they're at target their impact is immediate?
Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: The Fugitive on September 05, 2026, 09:55:49 AM
YOU DO NOT NEED TO BE KEYBOARD ACTIVE IN AUTO CLIMB FROM A SECTOR BACK.
  :rolleyes: :rolleyes: :rolleyes: :rolleyes: :rolleyes: :rolleyes: :rolleyes: :rolleyes:

It takes between 3-10 mins to cross a sector depending on ride speed and rate of climb, if any.

Seriously, step off my ankle and just stay with the actual issue at hand.

And if you want to accuse Kenai of passing along false info, have at it.   :aok :aok :aok :aok :aok

Then why not simply boot afk players with a 30 min timer on activity to segregate brief afk from actual afk?  And if you think players don't manipulate game mechanics, I'll gladly laugh directly in your face.  :rofl :rofl :rofl :rofl :rofl :rofl :rofl

Here's a simple question, why should AFK buffs on their way to strats be taken out of eny, because once they're at target their impact is immediate?

And as I said a bomber on climb out, or a tank sitting under a tree (cybro) should always be counted in the ENY calcs, even if they are not active, because they are in the game. I havent talked to Kenai for a few days as I have family in from Vegas so Im not playing. Did Hitech tell him ALL AFK players are subject to the timer, or is he just repeating what he has heard in the game?

Hitech doesnt want to boot players, its a negativity thing. Removing them from the ENY calcs does essentially the same thing with out the player get bent out of shape because he was booted.

As I said we havent heard what players are added to the AFK timer. I would hope it was only those sitting in the tower. There are some people saying all kinds of things. Untill I hear it from Hitech I'll go with "tower sitters".
Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: Shane on September 05, 2026, 10:01:49 AM
And as I said a bomber on climb out, or a tank sitting under a tree (cybro) should always be counted in the ENY calcs, even if they are not active, because they are in the game. I havent talked to Kenai for a few days as I have family in from Vegas so Im not playing. Did Hitech tell him ALL AFK players are subject to the timer, or is he just repeating what he has heard in the game?


As I said we havent heard what players are added to the AFK timer. I would hope it was only those sitting in the tower. There are some people saying all kinds of things. Untill I hear it from Hitech I'll go with "tower sitters".

You're really trying hard to achieve something here, but...

(https://i.postimg.cc/5ymJY8Kb/eyefnroll.jpg) (https://postimg.cc/N2LSZ2wz)

Slow your roll.

Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: The Fugitive on September 05, 2026, 10:46:54 AM
Sorry, dont remember seeing that, as I said its been a very busy couple of weeks.

Its too bad that it includes players playing. I would only make it for the tower sitters, but again, its not my game.
Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: Spikes on September 05, 2026, 10:52:59 AM
I think tower + if the game can somehow detect that the aircraft or GV is not moving/on the ground, to prevent just spawning and sitting on the runway.
Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: -gg- on September 05, 2026, 11:19:42 AM
Sorry, dont remember seeing that, as I said its been a very busy couple of weeks.

Its too bad that it includes players playing. I would only make it for the tower sitters, but again, its not my game.

 I think the point of it is that players who are AFK are not really playing the game. Like the people who go to bed sitting in  gv or whatever. Or climbing AFK in a bomber from 10 sectors away for an hour.  They aren't impacting the game play and should not count in the ENY calculations.

I'm trying to wrap my head around the idea that anyone would object to that. If you're AFK you cannot interact with anyone or affect anything. As soon as you touch your keys or controls, you're back.

Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: Animl-AW on September 05, 2026, 11:28:46 AM
I think tower + if the game can somehow detect that the aircraft or GV is not moving/on the ground, to prevent just spawning and sitting on the runway.

Problem is I found a loophole that can be easily exploited. Which I won’t post here I’d suggst keeping it to tower. I sent HT a pm.
Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: The Fugitive on September 05, 2026, 11:59:14 AM
I think the point of it is that players who are AFK are not really playing the game. Like the people who go to bed sitting in  gv or whatever. Or climbing AFK in a bomber from 10 sectors away for an hour.  They aren't impacting the game play and should not count in the ENY calculations.

I'm trying to wrap my head around the idea that anyone would object to that. If you're AFK you cannot interact with anyone or affect anything. As soon as you touch your keys or controls, you're back.

The only problem is like Shane said, that bomber isnt part of the game until it is Then its over a strat crushing the place. I hope the dar still shows them while "AFK" so they could still be intercepted, but if one of those bomber groups go up with 6 or 8 bomb formations and all just use auto pilot for an hour, how is that going to effect ENY? That could be a big jump depending on the numbers.

I dont know, I always thought just the tower sitters should be in the timer. Why complicate things?
Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: -gg- on September 05, 2026, 12:04:49 PM
Yeah, and that's Shane's pint regarding the AFK thing open to being gamed purposely too, I guess. Like he's been saying - easy to game the AFK - just stay inactive 5 minutes while everybody grabs the good planes to get around the ENY.

I'm appreciative that HT is looking into the ENY issues and doing something though.
Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: Animl-AW on September 05, 2026, 12:13:05 PM
Because auto-climb needs to be considered a control.
It DOES affect ENY. I watched already.
Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: -gg- on September 05, 2026, 12:13:14 PM
.

 


Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: toasted on September 05, 2026, 12:13:23 PM
I think the point of it is that players who are AFK are not really playing the game. Like the people who go to bed sitting in  gv or whatever. Or climbing AFK in a bomber from 10 sectors away for an hour.  They aren't impacting the game play and should not count in the ENY calculations.

I'm trying to wrap my head around the idea that anyone would object to that. If you're AFK you cannot interact with anyone or affect anything. As soon as you touch your keys or controls, you're back.

i personally think anyone in game  should count toward eny.remove the tower sitters, but removing players because they were inactive? that seems odd and easily manipulated. not the rest of our fault you decided to go afk while climbing. that plane is active in the arena to be used at any time.
And we don't need to incentivize more gvs to just go park somewhere and go afk for hours. its annoying enough finding them as is.
way too easy to game the system even by accident if your counting people afk in flight.

i'd even go the other way and give anyone who had been afk more than 5 minutes a nice flashing dar beacon so the rest of us could remove them. parking a vehicle hidden and leaving it for the day should not be a valid tactic.
Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: Oldman731 on September 05, 2026, 01:06:58 PM
i'd even go the other way and give anyone who had been afk more than 5 minutes a nice flashing dar beacon so the rest of us could remove them.


I think I already have one of those.

- oldman
Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: Animl-AW on September 05, 2026, 01:12:37 PM
Refer back to I have not seen it defined if it includes in flight or gv.

No one answered that clearly the last 2 times I, so far the guesses go both ways. Without it nothing is definitive.


Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: 1stpar3 on September 09, 2026, 07:56:05 AM
How about just "PERK" everything on ENY Scale? I have over 30,000 points I will never cash in.  Why can I not use them when ENY is above 5.0, IF I want to fly my SpitXVI?   
Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: Dadtallica on September 09, 2026, 09:16:52 AM
I asked about this in the update thread and never really got around to it with anyone. I don’t understand if I’m in a plane auto climbing which I do often while I go do something else. I may be physically AFK but I have a skin in the game, pun very intended, and my flight should affect ENY.

Sometimes I get shot down before I come back so I know I was definitely there even though I really wasn’t.
Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: LilMak on September 09, 2026, 09:50:03 AM
How about just "PERK" everything on ENY Scale? I have over 30,000 points I will never cash in.  Why can I not use them when ENY is above 5.0, IF I want to fly my SpitXVI?
I honestly think this is an elegant solution. ENY activation shuts down the current perked planes and requires perks to fly the low ENY equipment. Probably still not going to make me spend my 60k perks but will definitely have an effect.
Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: The Fugitive on September 09, 2026, 10:28:58 AM
How about just "PERK" everything on ENY Scale? I have over 30,000 points I will never cash in.  Why can I not use them when ENY is above 5.0, IF I want to fly my SpitXVI?

I honestly think this is an elegant solution. ENY activation shuts down the current perked planes and requires perks to fly the low ENY equipment. Probably still not going to make me spend my 60k perks but will definitely have an effect.

As Par pointed out he, like many players have thousands of perks in the bank. The point of ENY is to handicap the team that has a numerical advantage. You take away that handicap if you allow players to tap into these huge banks.

On the other hand, if the perks reset each tour .....  :devil
Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: LilMak on September 09, 2026, 10:58:31 AM
As Par pointed out he, like many players have thousands of perks in the bank. The point of ENY is to handicap the team that has a numerical advantage. You take away that handicap if you allow players to tap into these huge banks.

On the other hand, if the perks reset each tour .....  :devil
Feel free to reset them. I’m fine with that. Should start with a minimum balance though for those who need them.
Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: Animl-AW on September 09, 2026, 11:01:57 AM
I asked about this in the update thread and never really got around to it with anyone. I don’t understand if I’m in a plane auto climbing which I do often while I go do something else. I may be physically AFK but I have a skin in the game, pun very intended, and my flight should affect ENY.

Sometimes I get shot down before I come back so I know I was definitely there even though I really wasn’t.

Don’t know if it is included or not
But auto-climb/level should either be included in controls OR flight cannot be AFK
Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: Dadtallica on September 09, 2026, 11:32:51 AM
Don’t know if it is included or not
But auto-climb/level should either be included in controls OR flight cannot be AFK

The switch I read was “away from Joystick” so I assume that means anyone on auto pilot and not touching it
Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: Animl-AW on September 09, 2026, 12:17:58 PM
The switch I read was “away from Joystick” so I assume that means anyone on auto pilot and not touching it

I won’t even mention the loophole in that.
It’s not been clarified and may not be.
Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: Dadtallica on September 09, 2026, 10:14:15 PM
I won’t even mention the loophole in that.
It’s not been clarified and may not be.

What about the ground pounders? Who find a nice hiding spot and leave for an entire eight hour shift? They’re definitely a way but they’re still involved.

Dale?
Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: 1stpar3 on September 10, 2026, 05:34:41 AM
As Par pointed out he, like many players have thousands of perks in the bank. The point of ENY is to handicap the team that has a numerical advantage. You take away that handicap if you allow players to tap into these huge banks.

On the other hand, if the perks reset each tour .....  :devil
Resetting every tour?  Absolutely fine with me!  As long as we can spend earned perks during ENY issues.  You know me Fugi.  I love my 3 bomb SpitXVI...but I am fine with lesser rides.  :devil  Some times I just want to be in my comfort zone. Resetting would probably keep JG11 from jumping our missions in 262s like they do?  :rofl 
Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: Animl-AW on September 10, 2026, 11:19:34 AM
What about the ground pounders? Who find a nice hiding spot and leave for an entire eight hour shift? They’re definitely a way but they’re still involved.

Dale?

Well, this can get complicated. Because now we might have to get into timeout log-off if your controls see nothing for a time period (shrug)

It’s hard to suggest without more details in the equation, which HT may not expose.

For me, this started out towards tower sitters.
When “controls” are mentioned it gives the impression it also includes in flight.

Something seems misunderstood?

Maybe simple ignorant questions, but without clarification I/we are just guessing our way through it. Which is not very productive.

I think good questions are;

1) Does this new ENY include “controls” while in flight?

2) If so, are auto-climb/level included as “controls”?

I’m stuck on this misunderstanding.
Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: Shane on September 10, 2026, 12:11:02 PM
When “controls” are mentioned it gives the impression it also includes in flight.
Something seems misunderstood?
Maybe simple ignorant questions, but without clarification I/we are just guessing our way through it. Which is not very productive.
I think good questions are;

1) Does this new ENY include “controls” while in flight?
2) If so, are auto-climb/level included as “controls”?
I’m stuck on this misunderstanding.



https://bbs.hitechcreations.com/smf/index.php/topic,412969.msg5477128.html#msg5477128

"I [Kenai77/JimmyD3] called Hitech about the AFK/ENY function. Any player inactive on the keyboard or joystick for more than 5 minutes, is classified as AFK. They then drop out of the ENY calculation. When ever they become active again in the above conditions, they are then included in the calculation.

Seems fairly clear to me, unless Kenai77 misunderstood -which is quite possible, actually.  :neener:

I still think raising the timer threshold, and qualifying it by not in flight, eliminates this from becoming manipulatable while preserving ENY removal for those "tower sitters."

Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: nrshida on September 10, 2026, 12:27:25 PM
I still think raising the timer threshold, and qualifying it by not in flight, eliminates this from becoming manipulatable while preserving ENY removal for those "tower sitters."

Astutely-observed  :aok
Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: Animl-AW on September 10, 2026, 09:24:17 PM



https://bbs.hitechcreations.com/smf/index.php/topic,412969.msg5477128.html#msg5477128

"Any player inactive on the keyboard or joystick for more than 5 minutes, is classified as AFK.

Yes i know this part.... it does not say whether it just means tower and flight. SO I am safe to assume it's anywhere, including flight.

Because I'm tired of dancing around the bushes on this,... I can take 10 sets of buffs up, get them all pointed in the right direction, and no one touches controls through the entire climb-out. the other side gets hit with ENY and cannot up 163s to go after them in time.

If it includes while in flight, I watched 5 sets of buffs and 4 escorts do exactly that, the first night. Even thought they (Bish) had 29 in flight and us (nits) 18 and rooks 14. Nits got ENY, and no 163s. Unfortunately I didn't see the AFK count.

 If that's how it works that is a massive loophole.

This is why I say include auto-climb/level as controls. if those are set you are doing something.

Sheeeeesh.
Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: JimmyD3 on September 10, 2026, 10:37:55 PM
I would think "In Flight" would prevent any "AFK" condition. But I don't know that. I'll put that on my list to ask Hlitech.
Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: Dadtallica on September 11, 2026, 12:46:04 AM
Some clarification would be cool.
Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: Animl-AW on September 11, 2026, 05:53:24 AM
I would think "In Flight" would prevent any "AFK" condition. But I don't know that. I'll put that on my list to ask Hlitech.

I sent him a pm or text the next day. Haven’t heard back, soo…. ya know………
Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: hitech on September 11, 2026, 10:09:08 AM
It just a host setting. 5 min may be too short but 30 would be way too long.

HiTech
Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: Shane on September 11, 2026, 10:14:44 AM
It just a host setting. 5 min may be too short but 30 would be way too long.

HiTech

It needs to be set at a time where it's not tactically impactful; 15mins is still a bit borderline, imo. 

I also hope it can be flagged for not in-flight players only?
Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: ~ZoSo~ on September 20, 2026, 01:54:02 AM
Wouldn't it be cool if ENY just was gone forever?  I usually see one country getting ganged by the other two countries anyway. So the Bish lose the war, so what? We get a new map and move on. Just this evening, one country had 13 in flight, another 12 and finally the other with 10. And we have ENY while the team with 13 in flight is getting ganged by the other two countries. Insipid. I think if it were put to vote, it would be gone. And that's my worthless 2 cents.    :furious :old:  :salute :bolt:
Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: Dinan on September 21, 2026, 08:30:01 PM
It needs to be set at a time where it's not tactically impactful; 15mins is still a bit borderline, imo. 

I also hope it can be flagged for not in-flight players only?

imo.. If the game was somehow just tailored for you,  there would be only you on, just sitting in the tower as usual. 

Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: -gg- on September 22, 2026, 12:10:27 PM
Another long night last night... squad night for LCA Raiders

ENY held steady at over 26 and we were NOT outnumbering anyone on the map. We could not capture a base and were not able to defend our bases.

But the point is that some of of were IRATE on vox over the unfairness of ENY. One guy logged on, saw ENY and just logged right back off.

I don't care what anyone says .... this this needs to be addressed. The theme on vox was that we are paying customers and we pay for OUR time and enjoyment of the game, not someone elses game enjoyment at OUR expense and players.

It pisses players off, makes them log off and is not fair

Fix it. Get rid of it

Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: -gg- on September 22, 2026, 12:13:57 PM
The joke on our squad vox was " but ENY makes the game fun for everybody!"

It's BS to have ENY to begin with, but to be stuck at over 26 for hours. No fun. Not fair.

Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: The Fugitive on September 22, 2026, 12:15:37 PM
Another long night last night... squad night for LCA Raiders

ENY held steady at over 26 and we were NOT outnumbering anyone on the map. We could not capture a base and were not able to defend our bases.

But the point is that some of of were IRATE on vox over the unfairness of ENY. One guy logged on, saw ENY and just logged right back off.

I don't care what anyone says .... this this needs to be addressed. The theme on vox was that we are paying customers and we pay for OUR time and enjoyment of the game, not someone elses game enjoyment at OUR expense and players.

It pisses players off, makes them log off and is not fair

Fix it. Get rid of it

Both of these statements cant be true.

What were the population numbers?
Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: Dadtallica on September 22, 2026, 01:38:58 PM
I got my butt handed to me twice last night by a P-51B… ENY isn’t a problem.

Some of you need to go touch grass.
Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: Animl-AW on September 22, 2026, 01:41:49 PM
Everyone has their whine. You ain’t any different
Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: GOODBYE on September 22, 2026, 01:42:53 PM
ENY literally only goes up when you outnumber the lowest country lmao
Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: Animl-AW on September 22, 2026, 01:44:42 PM
I wonder if there is a convo on bbs that didn’t have a whine and a troll in it.
Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: -gg- on September 22, 2026, 02:10:42 PM
ENY literally only goes up when you outnumber the lowest country lmao

That does not translate to what is going on on the actual area of the map that we were on..


We were split up actually not as one mob. So you have a bunch of bases on a map right? In a big area right? Just because overall the team that you're on has more numbers than the other side doesn't mean that in a local area where the fight is going on that the numbers are all going to be in that local area. Do you not understand this?

Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: -gg- on September 22, 2026, 02:12:16 PM
Also, the numbers are very small. There's not a lot of people on and you're getting slammed with this disadvantage when the other side maybe only has a couple less people overall over the entire map. Or maybe the other team is working with the other side that's low numbers. It doesn't translate into what's going on in the fight that you're in on the map.


And when you're paying $15 a month to play a game and enjoy the game and you can't fly a large portion of the plans that everybody else on the same map is flying against you and shooting you down constantly, do you think that's fair? Do you think that's fun for the game and for the players paying to play it? I don't.

And I don't care how much or how often anybody says this is a wine. It's a legitimate concern. The game is not fun when that toejam kicks in.
Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: -gg- on September 22, 2026, 02:17:39 PM
One last point. I said it before. But I am paying the same as anyone else to play the game. If I'm outnumber I don't care. I'm not purposely trying to be on a side that has more numbers. But I want to be able to take any plane that any other person is taking in the game that's paying to play the same game.

So people say yeah you're trying to balance the numbers and make it fair for the other side that's got four less players than our side? So I'm screwed out of an hour's worth of enjoyment so that they can have enjoyment in the game?

Why don't you just let the numbers be the natural cause for any gameplay issues and not an artificial penalty for some somebody just because they happen to be on the side that has four more guys than another side has.

It feels wrong the way this works. Penalized. You know if I'm on a side that's outnumbered I don't feel penalized by the game I just feel like that's the unfortunate circumstance at the moment and it will change. I don't like it being the game punishing me and trying to manipulate me.
Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: ~ZoSo~ on September 22, 2026, 03:46:06 PM
I got my butt handed to me twice last night by a P-51B… ENY isn’t a problem.

Some of you need to go touch grass.

ENY is a problem.

Example.

Knights have 13 players in the air.

Bishops have 12 players in the air.

Rooks have 10 players in the air.

The Bishops and the Rooks are not fighting each other as usual.

I can go into more detail if you like. ?

Your skill level is irrelevant.

Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: caldera on September 22, 2026, 04:05:11 PM
(https://i.postimg.cc/qBQ48gS8/whiny.jpg) (https://postimg.cc/3WyshrKR)
Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: -gg- on September 22, 2026, 05:26:18 PM
I don't care what anybody says about the "whines" having all been heard before. I'm playing a game and I'm a customer of the game and I have a legitimate gripe about it and so do a lot of people that I fly with

I'll give you an example just from last night. We had 26.7 en y or something like that for hours. At one point there was 14 of Us online from our squad and we never once could get more than four or five of us together at one time. Some were going off on their own fighting the bishops others are fighting the rooks. At no time was I ever in any kind of a fight on the map where we were outnumbering the people we were fighting.


So you also have an example of maybe the side that I was on had more numbers or almost equal numbers to say the bishops but then maybe the rooks had a lot less players. But we're not even fighting the rooks.

Yeah, so maybe the bishops had some e and y as well but I don't give one toejam about what anyone else is having to deal with because it's only affecting me as a player. The eny is affecting what planes we could take and what I can take. And there was a lot of planes off the table last night for a long time.

It was pissing a lot of us off. It pisses me off and it happens every night.

It's not fair and I can voice my concern as a customer. And I don't know where else to do it. So I'll just do it here whenever it happens I'll just come here and I'll squeak and squeak and squeak and squeak about it.


It's a problem. Especially when the numbers are so low it's a big problem. I hope it gets dealt with because it's sickening to deal with this



Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: -gg- on September 22, 2026, 05:27:37 PM
And just in case you don't get it. I'm a player I'm not a team. When I log in I'm playing as a player. An individual player who's being punished just because the side that I happen to be on has more numbers by a few players than anyone else. That's not my problem. And it's not my fault either.
Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: -gg- on September 22, 2026, 05:30:42 PM
It's funny that people say it's a whine. It's actually a mechanism of the game affecting me not anything other than being punished for what others cried about. A vocal minority who cry about numbers.


I'll tell you what. I would love to have imbalance numbers and be on the imbalance side and not have this eny roadkill.

The numbers on a given team on any given night or just basically an ebb and flow and a random kind of thing. That's to be expected it's nobody's fault that the numbers are the way they are. It's not my fault for sure. If I log in all I want to do is have fun for an hour or two. I don't want to be screwed out of that time by being extremely limited on what I can do in the game simply because the numbers are slightly in balanced


It's extremely offensive to me to be getting a leg up to somebody else at my expense for something that is in no way my fault or under my control.


When I log in I have no co what makes that other person's game experience more valuable than mine? Because they have five players on their team and I have eight? Screw that.

Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: Shane on September 22, 2026, 06:28:11 PM
I'll tell you what. I would love to have imbalance numbers and be on the imbalance side and not have this eny roadkill.

Are you (all?) so tied into your skwad/country that you cannot consider using the several other options available?
Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: The Fugitive on September 22, 2026, 06:31:09 PM
Lets put it this way....... You play a certain type of music. You enjoy it, its fun. Unfortunately for you not many others like what you play. To them its too loud, maybe too fast, what ever. Sure you can play it to your hearts content, but your not going to make any money on it. Venues wont hire you because you dont draw in the crowds and the crowds are where they make their money.

Aces High, is here to make money. Removing ENY would create more and more lopsided population. Over time those being on the low numbered side all the time end up quitting.

Another thing, Aces High IS a TEAM game, whether you play it that way of not. I doubt very much that Hitech would model the game to align with one, or a few players. He is going to make it work for the larger group..... more money.

Now, could ENY be work on? Yup, but is it worth the time and effort at this point. Im sure the ENY numbers could be reworked, and I would love to see an "Area ENY" that way when you have more players than the other teams but are fighting both teams on two fronts. ENY shouldnt kick in so much in those cases.
Title: Re: AFK ENY - unintended consequences: fix = timer change
Post by: GOODBYE on September 22, 2026, 06:35:25 PM
Sometimes when we have eny and I see the perk bonus above 2 I switch countries… then I get the benefit of no eny AND I get perk bonus :)

My squad is chill with it and thankfully so, otherwise I wouldn’t be in that squad :rock