Aces High Bulletin Board
General Forums => Aces High General Discussion => Topic started by: LilMak on September 11, 2026, 06:56:16 AM
-
I’m at my home base with local radar tower destroyed. Enemy has moved in and the darbar is thick. GV dar shows but still a good drive away from the flag. Town is prepped and field is in jeopardy. Zero friendly aircraft in the local area. Runway runs East/West. Town is NW of base. Fire up my trusty Jug and take off to the East in with the intent to get speed and maybe a bit of altitude before turning back towards town. Perhaps I’ll get a lucky suicidal run on troops or M3? Maybe hold the line until some help arrives? I get about 1500 AGL east and well clear of my field guns. Turn north and run into a lone Spit well above me. Work him down and equalize the energy state a bit. Nose up to get a shot off. Take the spit’s wing tip. Start to level out with the intention of letting him go and turn back towards town. Get popped by a Dora. Back in the tower.
You might be saying that my sortie was stupid and that the likely outcome was almost certain death. You’d be correct. I was almost certainly going to die. My issue with my death here was the speed and disadvantage I received that there is no way to counter…AWACS.
Here’s some more information…
We had a friendly tank in town. This invisible tank served as a radar picket for me to see five fighters over town (no goons or bombers present). While it didn’t change my mission profile, it does seem to me that a GV that can’t be found (even by a storch) shouldn’t be able to show me this information. You might be thinking “hey you benefited from AWACS there” and that is partially true. However, a negative effect of that radar tank is to discourage smarter or more score related pilots on my team from even attempting defense because of the apparent hopelessness of the situation. So I’m on my own while my countrymen are clubbing baby seals on the other front or making a sandwich instead.
When I departed I was effectively invisible to the horde over town until I made my turn to the north and encountered the spit. At which time I was more than half a sector away. The spit was still on his perch with his tail towards me (Most likely RTB or texting his girlfriend). He “sees” me and turns around to engage. I needed to work him down because I wasn’t going to get away from him as low as I was. Shortly after getting in icon range of the Spit I noticed the entire town gaggle had turned directly at my position. Not approximately. Not in my general vicinity. All five noses pointed to my exact location. In between a couple missed passes by the spit, I noticed the town had mostly cleared of my radar picket tank. I could no longer see them on my radar but I knew the gaggle was headed my way. To be clear, I was on their “radar” over my own base but I couldn’t see them on my “radar”. Fight progresses and I got my lucky shot on the spit, dipped my nose down to get some speed, and the Dora was laying rounds into me. Wing snaps off and I look back to see... not one, not two, not three, but all five of those planes who were over town a bit ago were on my six.
This would’ve been rare before AWACS. Normally I would’ve had time to reset before I got bounced. Maybe taken the Dora with me before I went down. Or at least put up a good fight. Or made it to town to strafe a grunt before I succumbed to the inevitable. How do I know that? Experience. I’ve been virtual flying since the 90s.
Issues of note:
1- The GV who was showing the town swarmed but can’t even be found is a horrible game imbalance. Players (other than the rare idiots like me) tend to avoid Leroy Jenkins actions. Especially if they can see them before they happen. No one was going to come to the aid of that base because they can see how bad it was in real time. Defense is discouraged by…AWACS.
2- That Spit quite likely would’ve never seen me on his low six if it wasn’t for…AWACS. Not only that but I wouldn’t have known he was initially facing away if it wasn’t for…AWACS. Also, even though those five fighters over town didn’t “see” me, they saw me on the clipboard as soon as the Spit did.
3- Pretend that spit was AFK and headed towards me. Those five fighters over town still instantly know where I am, my direction of flight and whether I’m maneuvering as long as the guy asleep at the wheel is within icon range because of…AWACS. Now imagine that Spit is a tank off my base sleeping under a tree. Same effect only and, even worse, I can’t see him.
4- For the sake of argument we’ll say all five fighters over town were in the Spit’s squad and he had the capability to tell them to come run a train on this low D-40 he was struggling with (not likely but possible). They vector to my exact location and are able to jump me in unison. No need to fan out, no need to look out the window, just follow…AWACS.
5- As a defender I’m alone, low, and outnumbered. Five of the fighters have me on radar as they transition from the town to my fight with the Spit. Five can jump me being guided by radar but I only have eyes on one because of…AWACS.
I’m gonna keep going…
6- Pilots are avoiding combat they think they may not win because of…AWACS
7- Goons are virtually useless because of…AWACS
8- Planes selection is vanilla because you can’t escape…AWACS
9- Few are brave enough to be the tip of the spear in evenly matched groups because of…AWACS.
10- Clouds are nearly pointless because of….AWACS
11- Altitude is much more important because of…AWACS.
12- The chances of a player flying over you and not seeing you is zero because of….AWACS. Even if he doesn’t see you everyone else on his team will because of…AWACS.
13- Bombers are both singled out and can avoid confrontation because of…AWACS.
14- Friendlies don’t help when they can see all 5 enemies trailing because of…AWACS.
15- Limping a damaged plane back home is less likely because of…AWACS.
16- Running home with empty guns yields a much higher likelihood you’ll get cut off because of…AWACS.
17- Picking and avoiding any consequences is infinitely easier because of…AWACS.
18- SA has been relegated to the clipboard because of…AWACS.
19- Cockpit vision? Might as well give everyone F3 because of…AWACS.
20- Fighting or even strategically slowing down a horde is completely thrown off balance because of…AWACS.
Now. You can stick your head in the sand and say that the gang bangs have nothing to do with the ridiculous AWACS radar and a general degradation of the MA but, no matter what you say, it absolutely does. It’s absolute HORSE CRAP. Take it away. Find another way to seek out the enemy. Maybe try the window instead of the clipboard. It’s the second worst decision I’ve ever seen HT make.
Here’s some settings I think will balance this out.
1. Turn off AWACS and never turn it back on again in flight unless some night fighters appear in game. Then maybe for those aircraft alone. Maybe a PT boat since it has a radar mast?
2. Harden radar towers to 500lbs of ord minimum.
3. Maybe AWACS or something similar in the tower to point players in the right direction like increasing the radar range of the local ring way beyond the ring while you’re not in flight.
4. Darbar refresh rates to as near as instant as possible.
If that’s not enough, because it’s too hard to look out the window without a crutch, consider breaking up darbar into quarters of grids.
But this thing where local hordes get a radar advantage needs to end.
-
Just keeping super dar out of the cockpit would be a great start...
I think HT thinks removal of easy dar will chase away more players than it makes happy..
I can't argue that..
Eagler
-
Just keeping super dar out of the cockpit would be a great start...
I think HT thinks removal of easy dar will chase away more players than it makes happy..
I can't argue that..
Eagler
Current radar settings ran off a ton of players and boogered the sweet balance of the game. If I’m being honest, I don’t care if changing it runs a few more players off because the game will be better for it and last longer as a result. Defense is being severely discouraged (from the air) by this one setting. The constant gang bang is becoming a real problem and AWACS feeds that. Players are talking the path of least resistance and that is absolutely based on what they see on the clipboard. Most of the tweaks and additions have gone to balancing out defense over the years. Town resupply, 88s, lowering NOE altitudes have been adjusted over the rears to slow (not stop) hordes. AWACS has killed the incentive to even try to fight the current (much smaller) groups. Not all will understand or agree with what I’m trying to say. But consider me the canary in the coal mine. If I cared about score or anything like that, I would’ve never upped from that base in my example. My story is to point out that I was the only one even making an attempt to join combat at a base being attacked. It’s getting increasingly frustrating for me to continue because, nearly every time I try, I get swatted before I can extract fun from the fight.
-
I’m at my home base with local radar tower destroyed. Enemy has moved in and the darbar is thick. GV dar shows but still a good drive away from the flag. Town is prepped and field is in jeopardy. Zero friendly aircraft in the local area. Runway runs East/West. Town is NW of base. Fire up my trusty Jug and take off to the East in with the intent to get speed and maybe a bit of altitude before turning back towards town. Perhaps I’ll get a lucky suicidal run on troops or M3? Maybe hold the line until some help arrives? I get about 1500 AGL east and well clear of my field guns. Turn north and run into a lone Spit well above me. Work him down and equalize the energy state a bit. Nose up to get a shot off. Take the spit’s wing tip. Start to level out with the intention of letting him go and turn back towards town. Get popped by a Dora. Back in the tower.
You might be saying that my sortie was stupid and that the likely outcome was almost certain death. You’d be correct. I was almost certainly going to die. My issue with my death here was the speed and disadvantage I received that there is no way to counter…AWACS.
Here’s some more information…
We had a friendly tank in town. This invisible tank served as a radar picket for me to see five fighters over town (no goons or bombers present). While it didn’t change my mission profile, it does seem to me that a GV that can’t be found (even by a storch) shouldn’t be able to show me this information. You might be thinking “hey you benefited from AWACS there” and that is partially true. However, a negative effect of that radar tank is to discourage smarter or more score related pilots on my team from even attempting defense because of the apparent hopelessness of the situation. So I’m on my own while my countrymen are clubbing baby seals on the other front or making a sandwich instead.
When I departed I was effectively invisible to the horde over town until I made my turn to the north and encountered the spit. At which time I was more than half a sector away. The spit was still on his perch with his tail towards me (Most likely RTB or texting his girlfriend). He “sees” me and turns around to engage. I needed to work him down because I wasn’t going to get away from him as low as I was. Shortly after getting in icon range of the Spit I noticed the entire town gaggle had turned directly at my position. Not approximately. Not in my general vicinity. All five noses pointed to my exact location. In between a couple missed passes by the spit, I noticed the town had mostly cleared of my radar picket tank. I could no longer see them on my radar but I knew the gaggle was headed my way. To be clear, I was on their “radar” over my own base but I couldn’t see them on my “radar”. Fight progresses and I got my lucky shot on the spit, dipped my nose down to get some speed, and the Dora was laying rounds into me. Wing snaps off and I look back to see... not one, not two, not three, but all five of those planes who were over town a bit ago were on my six.
This would’ve been rare before AWACS. Normally I would’ve had time to reset before I got bounced. Maybe taken the Dora with me before I went down. Or at least put up a good fight. Or made it to town to strafe a grunt before I succumbed to the inevitable. How do I know that? Experience. I’ve been virtual flying since the 90s.
Issues of note:
1- The GV who was showing the town swarmed but can’t even be found is a horrible game imbalance. Players (other than the rare idiots like me) tend to avoid Leroy Jenkins actions. Especially if they can see them before they happen. No one was going to come to the aid of that base because they can see how bad it was in real time. Defense is discouraged by…AWACS.
2- That Spit quite likely would’ve never seen me on his low six if it wasn’t for…AWACS. Not only that but I wouldn’t have known he was initially facing away if it wasn’t for…AWACS. Also, even though those five fighters over town didn’t “see” me, they saw me on the clipboard as soon as the Spit did.
3- Pretend that spit was AFK and headed towards me. Those five fighters over town still instantly know where I am, my direction of flight and whether I’m maneuvering as long as the guy asleep at the wheel is within icon range because of…AWACS. Now imagine that Spit is a tank off my base sleeping under a tree. Same effect only and, even worse, I can’t see him.
4- For the sake of argument we’ll say all five fighters over town were in the Spit’s squad and he had the capability to tell them to come run a train on this low D-40 he was struggling with (not likely but possible). They vector to my exact location and are able to jump me in unison. No need to fan out, no need to look out the window, just follow…AWACS.
5- As a defender I’m alone, low, and outnumbered. Five of the fighters have me on radar as they transition from the town to my fight with the Spit. Five can jump me being guided by radar but I only have eyes on one because of…AWACS.
I’m gonna keep going…
6- Pilots are avoiding combat they think they may not win because of…AWACS
7- Goons are virtually useless because of…AWACS
8- Planes selection is vanilla because you can’t escape…AWACS
9- Few are brave enough to be the tip of the spear in evenly matched groups because of…AWACS.
10- Clouds are nearly pointless because of….AWACS
11- Altitude is much more important because of…AWACS.
12- The chances of a player flying over you and not seeing you is zero because of….AWACS. Even if he doesn’t see you everyone else on his team will because of…AWACS.
13- Bombers are both singled out and can avoid confrontation because of…AWACS.
14- Friendlies don’t help when they can see all 5 enemies trailing because of…AWACS.
15- Limping a damaged plane back home is less likely because of…AWACS.
16- Running home with empty guns yields a much higher likelihood you’ll get cut off because of…AWACS.
17- Picking and avoiding any consequences is infinitely easier because of…AWACS.
18- SA has been relegated to the clipboard because of…AWACS.
19- Cockpit vision? Might as well give everyone F3 because of…AWACS.
20- Fighting or even strategically slowing down a horde is completely thrown off balance because of…AWACS.
Now. You can stick your head in the sand and say that the gang bangs have nothing to do with the ridiculous AWACS radar and a general degradation of the MA but, no matter what you say, it absolutely does. It’s absolute HORSE CRAP. Take it away. Find another way to seek out the enemy. Maybe try the window instead of the clipboard. It’s the second worst decision I’ve ever seen HT make.
Here’s some settings I think will balance this out.
1. Turn off AWACS and never turn it back on again in flight unless some night fighters appear in game. Then maybe for those aircraft alone. Maybe a PT boat since it has a radar mast?
2. Harden radar towers to 500lbs of ord minimum.
3. Maybe AWACS or something similar in the tower to point players in the right direction like increasing the radar range of the local ring way beyond the ring while you’re not in flight.
4. Darbar refresh rates to as near as instant as possible.
If that’s not enough, because it’s too hard to look out the window without a crutch, consider breaking up darbar into quarters of grids.
But this thing where local hordes get a radar advantage needs to end.
I’m sensing you aren’t happy with AWACS.
-
AWACS is just one symptom in the game causing problems. It's a setting that swings both ways. It's a tool.
What you are complaining about is how the tool is being used. This derives from one single aspect.
Each player chooses how to play the game. You want the change to allow your way of playing.
I agree 100% of what you said. I'm an experienced player and understand completely. I believe in a fair game across the board.
Do you have a solution in getting all players from old farts to new scripts to agree and go along with turning AWACS off?
-
To add to the criteria : Planes have little chance of creating an altitude advantage, taking off from a field further back without AWACS detection is impossible.
-
It is common for a plane to avoid localized dar by flying very low. Lower than sector dar to make it wwork. Yak, I think s really skilled in this technique.
I see your point LilMak. I see Hitech's point. Sitting on the fence on this one.
-
To add to the criteria : Planes have little chance of creating an altitude advantage, taking off from a field further back without AWACS detection is impossible.
As long as there are no enemy within 6k of you, it's still as possible as it was before AWACS.
As to Mak's point, while I think he is belabouring it a bit, I agree with a good bit of what he's saying. I think the solution is to take it away in flight, leave it in tower. Get rid of the little planes, make it dots. I think it's an acceptable compromise to finding the fight and leaving some uncertainty.
Wiley.
-
AWACS is just one symptom in the game causing problems. It's a setting that swings both ways. It's a tool.
What you are complaining about is how the tool is being used. This derives from one single aspect.
Each player chooses how to play the game. You want the change to allow your way of playing.
I agree 100% of what you said. I'm an experienced player and understand completely. I believe in a fair game across the board.
Do you have a solution in getting all players from old farts to new scripts to agree and go along with turning AWACS off?
I would argue it does not swing both ways in that the team with more players in the air (or on the ground) has a massively decisive advantage in situational awareness. More planes is more radar coverage. It’s literally penalizing any player that is outnumbered. If you come into contact with one of them EVERY enemy can see you and you can only see the player in icon range. That advantage is exponential for every plane in the sky or vehicle on the ground. 1v1 the odds are even. 2v1 they collectively have 100% more combined SA. Then when you increase it to 3v1, 4v1 and so on it’s horribly lopsided.
Taking it away does nothing to how anyone plays other than not giving them information they shouldn’t have without looking out the cockpit. Yes it’s a tool. But it’s a tool that cannot be countered. There’s no radar tower to destroy. There’s no way for an outnumbered group to effectively even the playing field. Whoever is outnumbered within a sector or two is at an extreme disadvantage. If it’s 6 on 1 like my example 5 players are making decisions about my presence before I even know they exist. There’s no fog for them but I’m effectively blind. They’re climbing, vectoring, avoiding, setting up attacks, all while I’m preoccupied with one of their countrymen. I can’t see what they’re doing but they can see what I’m doing. Even if I break away before they get there and they still have me on radar the whole time until I can extend beyond the Spit’s icon range. If players absolutely NEED to see aircraft on radar to play the game. Then just make radar towers impervious to bombs or turn it on globally so everyone can see everyone all the time.
If the goal is to just make me a target dummy to get repeatedly pounded into the dirt to the point I just leave to join my country horde or log instead. It’s working. If players want targets to shoot at (me) I suggest we make some adjustments.
-
can we distil the story down to a few words?
-
can we distil the story down to a few words?
AWACS bad!
-
can we distil the story down to a few words?
AWACS b-
AWACS bad!
Yes! ;)
Wiley.
Wiley.
-
AWACS bad!
:rofl
-
But this thing where local hordes get a radar advantage needs to end.
I and many others agree with you LilMak. This was one of the things that lowered my "fun" in the game before the final straw came.
The issue seems to be that HT has a select group that he takes game advice from. If you can figure out who one of these people are and get them to pitch it to him you might get some traction because at this point I fear we're beating a dead horse.
-
can we distil the story down to a few words?
Shortest I can do: AWACS is bad for the game.
-
The issue seems to be that HT has a select group that he takes game advice from.
And that group has always appeared to be furballers...
Not combat simulation players...
CAV
-
Shortest I can do: AWACS is bad for [me].
Fixed. :aok
I'm okay going back to dot dar, tho'
-
even just dot dar alone would help quite a bit. knowing exactly where they are headed is super overpowered.
and id like to see the radar share detection range limited to like 3k instead of everyone in a 12k circle.
seems like these would help some, and wouldn't necessarily create the pushback turning it off completely would.
-
I and many others agree with you LilMak. This was one of the things that lowered my "fun" in the game before the final straw came.
The issue seems to be that HT has a select group that he takes game advice from. If you can figure out who one of these people are and get them to pitch it to him you might get some traction because at this point I fear we're beating a dead horse.
I’m certain HT is aware. I just don’t think the full ramifications AWACS is completely understood. I wholeheartedly believe getting rid of it will help a lot of what ails us at the moment. I’m also pretty convinced it’s more of a setting issue than a code issue. Depending on how it is addressed. There is also evidence it could potentially bring a significant number of players back if it’s addressed.
To be clear. I don’t think it will stop hordes or picking or any of those things. Nor would a want it to (believe it or not). But it absolutely will make combating those things more palatable. I just want the pendulum to swing back towards the middle ground. I can live with fighter and bomber icons with direction of flight in radar rings. I don’t think there’s a need to regress back to “dot dar”.
AWACS really affects the 4th dimension (time) the most. And it’s truly hard to quantify that with spreadsheets and statistics. You get a kill, you have a moment to reassess. That fighter flying away from doesn’t see you low on their 6. Now you can head for town. The fight is complete and there is an extra 10-15 seconds for you to see what’s coming versus it being dumped in your lap. You can get to town because that fighter on a perch didn’t see you below their wing. You get a little separation after maneuvering in a cloud. You catch that bomber before he can turn away. You sneak out skimming treetops after you used the last of your ammunition on the guy who limped away. You kill two bombers in the middle of 15 fighters before they can overwhelm you.
Some simply don’t remember or have had a lot more success with the crutch and don’t want to give it up. I understand that.
-
I don’t think there’s a need to regress back to “dot dar”.
You've obviously thought about this more than i have. But i still think Dot Dar is better for gameplay. anything that will force players eyes out the window is a win. in a furball knowing where each enemy is pointed without looking is a pretty strong tool.
you can fly defensivly without looking back, that's too much info and has zero analogue with how it was used in ww2.
and it doesn't stop anyone from finding a fight, it just makes you pay more attention when you do.
at least with a dot when i get jumped by 5 guys there is some hope that they all didn't immediately end up on my six.
-
And that group has always appeared to be furballers...
Not combat simulation players...
And there has always been that tension between the furballers and war-winners (or, a/k/a, the combat simulation players). Other examples are the pickers, the gangers, and the vulchers, also the carrier-hiders and the comical people who used to land their goon near an enemy base and sit there until the ack was down.
The game has always needed both groups.
- oldman
-
The problem I felt it did fix in the beginning was the reporting an enemy group inbound to a field on country, and people not responding until they saw the dots on radar at the field, and it not giving them enough time to up and climb before the group was over the field. I saw that get better when other people could see the little airplanes on their map.
But, we shall see what HT makes of it at some point I'm sure.
Wiley.
-
Have to agree with the OP. It sucks to be the single con that is a magnet for others far from you, both friend and foe. Had a good 1v1 against a P-39D of all things and just as I had him pinned down, three friendlies cleared my twelve. No "do you need help?", just "BANSAI!" and ganged the f out of him.
I think the old dot dar was fine, but would like to see the radar towers require 3,000 lbs (or more) to kill. It's stupid that one fighter can zoom in at 500 mph and take it out with guns.
-
You've obviously thought about this more than i have. But i still think Dot Dar is better for gameplay. anything that will force players eyes out the window is a win. in a furball knowing where each enemy is pointed without looking is a pretty strong tool.
you can fly defensivly without looking back, that's too much info and has zero analogue with how it was used in ww2.
and it doesn't stop anyone from finding a fight, it just makes you pay more attention when you do.
at least with a dot when i get jumped by 5 guys there is some hope that they all didn't immediately end up on my six.
I’m with you on dot dar. I don’t care for the icons but I can live with them if AWACS goes away. I actually try to think about the workload on Dale (believe it or not) and I don’t think it’s necessary to go back into the code to enact most of what I asked for in the OP. Believe it or not I try to temper my expectations but this setting has been detrimental to game play. Instant darbar will help players seek out the enemy. Hardening the radar towers is long overdue. And plane icons within radar rings is livable. I’ll never be OK with AWACS but I would be grateful if it’s pulled in.
-
I wouldn't worry to much about the "Load on Dale", with ChatGPT/Codex I think he's having a ball. :aok
-
I agree with dot dar as a solution. It's just a matter of settings being utilized. That was my initial thought after the OP. I just wanted to see if others would publicly post as well.
-
Shrinking the distance is more help than reverting to dot dar IMO. AWACS just needs to die.
-
I like the AWACS, in fact it was a wishlist of mine that got implemented. The only changes I would make is no plane type icon from standard radar, only when spotted by a player in icon range. The AWACS is simulating what you would be reporting in real life, sure its in real time, but still the same data. In a game I don't want to be talking in a MIC to HQ to report everything i'm seeing, so a simulation of it is great.
Maybe could add a button that the player has to press to 'spot' the enemy, like marking it with the box, then its reported to everyone else's map.
-
I think it's lil late in the game for any huge changes.
Icon Dar has been around a long time now.
People tend to grow into things, even if it's not perfect.
What we read on bbs is not the last word of the masses, it's the words of a fraction of the masses who have been kinda lobbied.
I tend to like Dot Dar.
Icons are/were cool, but outside the realm of realism.
I think there needs to be something easier for new players and doesn't shake the vets up too much.
Consideration
Radar Ring Size
Early-Warning Radars
British Chain Home (CH): Large static coastal stations had a maximum detection range of up to 120 to 200 miles for high-flying bomber formations.
Surface and Tactical Sets: Standard ground and shipboard early warning sets (like the US SCR-270) typically tracked incoming aircraft out to about 100 miles.
Gun-Laying and Fire-Control Radars
Anti-Aircraft (e.g., SCR-584): Tactical mobile units used to direct anti-aircraft fire could detect medium-range aircraft up to 40 miles away with high precision.
Naval Fire Control: Shipborne systems like the US Mark 4 tracked bomber aircraft up to 22 miles (40,000 yards) and large enemy warships at 17 miles (30,000 yards).
Anti-Submarine / Surface Search
Airborne radar fitted to patrol aircraft could spot a surfaced U-boat at distances over 5 miles, while later centimetric sets could identify smaller targets like exposed periscopes.
-
I don't look at the radar as strictly representing actual radar. I view it as a display of tactical information that could have been coming over a radio. I view it as the game's way of representing what might have been transmitted over a radio by local pilots in the area. Yeah, it might be too accurate but I think it's pretty cool and I've never had a problem with it. I don't see how it really hurts anything. I thought it was a pretty cool idea myself. The local radar that shows up when a friendly is in an area where you wouldn't normally have radar. That's what I'm talking about. I don't view that as radar.
I don't view it as literal AWACS.
I would way much rather have ENY adjusted for low numbers.
-
I like the AWACS, in fact it was a wishlist of mine that got implemented. The only changes I would make is no plane type icon from standard radar, only when spotted by a player in icon range. The AWACS is simulating what you would be reporting in real life, sure its in real time, but still the same data. In a game I don't want to be talking in a MIC to HQ to report everything i'm seeing, so a simulation of it is great.
Maybe could add a button that the player has to press to 'spot' the enemy, like marking it with the box, then its reported to everyone else's map.
Requiring someone to actually see the enemy plane would improve the simulation of reporting a contact to HQ. Add a delay before the contact shows up on the map for the "report" to be relayed from HQ to friendlies, and make the reported contact stationary on the map at the reported location with a short persistence before requiring a new sighting and "report".
-
I like the AWACS, in fact it was a wishlist of mine that got implemented. The only changes I would make is no plane type icon from standard radar, only when spotted by a player in icon range. The AWACS is simulating what you would be reporting in real life, sure its in real time, but still the same data. In a game I don't want to be talking in a MIC to HQ to report everything i'm seeing, so a simulation of it is great.
Maybe could add a button that the player has to press to 'spot' the enemy, like marking it with the box, then its reported to everyone else's map.
Thats the problem tho, the radar we have now is simulated modern radar and communications, NOT WWII information.
Even "popeye's (Kong) solution would be a bit too modern, tho it would be cool to see stationary dot flashing on the map for a few minutes waiting for updated info to move. Once a squadron left on its mission and flew out of radio range...not a lot of satellites back then... communication was only plane to plane. Even if those guys chatted... which most didnt due to enemy "listening" on the radio frequencies..... none of that information made it back to base until the debrief AFTER the mission.
Thats why I think LilMaks solution works best for what the game should be simulating. Its a good compromise between WWII tech and game play. In the tower you get ALL the info as if everyone is radioing positions and sightings of everything they see (what we have now). In the plane, your more on your own, only what you can see yourself, an 8K sphere of view. The only way that info is relayed to your wingman/friendlies is if you key up the mic and send it. No dar info, just eyes on. Sure there is the opportunity for someone to sit in the tower and "direct traffic" as it were, but wheres the fun in that.
I think there is way too much information the way it is now. That may be good in really low numbers conditions... dont know as I dont play in those time... but like LilMak said whos going to up against 5-6 guys attacking a base? There is now way to to sneak up on the first guy or two...they see you coming a few miles away on dar. You lose any type of "surprise" advantage and end up with all guys vectoring strait to you before you can even get your speed up
I hope Hitech takes a look at it.
-
Start small..
Change the directional plane icons to dots..all the same size..bombers and fighters..
Then start with a 10 second delay on all cons outside of icon range..
Eagler
-
Start small..
Yep.
Start by removing a plane or tank’s ability to be a moving radar tower.
Then update darbar so it’s virtually instant.
Harden radar towers.
All arena settings and no code required.
Then, if that totally flops because using your eyes and keying the mic is too hard, consider coding so darbar is more precise (shows up in different quadrants of grids). Maybe make it so radar from in the tower has triple the range?
Or just go the lazy route and turn on radar for everyone all the time. Don’t forget to give airplanes ground radar too. We can’t have the GVs using trees to hide. After all, the planes can’t use clouds to hide. Since we’ve established that the clipboard is the place to look, please add gunsights to the clipboard as well. Wouldn’t want someone to have to look out the window.
-
Clipboard auto closes after 5 seconds of opening with a 1 minute delay between openings..
Eagler
-
1937: British researchers successfully tested the first rudimentary airborne radar system aboard a Handley Page Hayford bomber.
May 1940: The first operational air-intercept radar (AI Mark III) entered service on fighter planes to locate enemy aircraft in the dark.
July 1940 – 1941: The improved AI Mark IV became the world's first widely produced airborne radar, heavily used on aircraft like the Bristol Beaufighter to counter German night raids.
But not all sides had it, so to implement it on all is the game part of the sim. MA is the game side, Scenarios/Events are the sim side of AH
-
Clipboard auto closes after 5 seconds of opening with a 1 minute delay between openings..
Eagler
Meh!
I think that would be an annoyance and not solve much.
-
Clipboard auto closes after 5 seconds of opening with a 1 minute delay between openings..
Eagler
Lol. Can you imagine? That would be crazy. Lol!
-
1937: British researchers successfully tested the first rudimentary airborne radar system aboard a Handley Page Hayford bomber.
May 1940: The first operational air-intercept radar (AI Mark III) entered service on fighter planes to locate enemy aircraft in the dark.
July 1940 – 1941: The improved AI Mark IV became the world's first widely produced airborne radar, heavily used on aircraft like the Bristol Beaufighter to counter German night raids.
But not all sides had it, so to implement it on all is the game part of the sim. MA is the game side, Scenarios/Events are the sim side of AH
I covered radar equipped aircraft in the OP. Still, they didn’t broadcast positions to other friendly aircraft like AWACS. I’m willing to concede those aircraft and those aircraft only having AWACS. Every other GV or aircraft…no.
-
Lol. Can you imagine? That would be crazy. Lol!
Not feasible. You have to have the clipboard for navigation in game. Mostly because the terrain is too generic to navigate via compass and dead reckoning.
-
Ok clipboard stays up but icons only display for 5 seconds every 60 seconds..
That way it actually becomes a hindrance as most eyes would be darting back and forth trying not to miss the next flash..
Eagler
-
Ok clipboard stays up but icons only display for 5 seconds every 60 seconds..
That way it actually becomes a hindrance as most eyes would be darting back and forth trying not to miss the next flash..
Eagler
Maybe? Or icons only update every 60 seconds? But that would require code.
-
Meh, again.
Comes down to does the majority like Icon Dar or not.
Doesn’t really natter how many creative ideas are born in lobbying against it by a few.
It still comes down to majority vs what HT thinks new players need as a crutch.
Anyone who says we no longer get new players;
1) Bzzzt!! Wrong
2) I personally stop listening to defeatist
I prefer dot dar, but I’m not seeing any big rally to remove icon dar.
I think it comes down to dot or icon.
Any change can have an unforeseen backlash. We have no buffer for mistakes.
And trying settings just to flip back is not wise, its frowned upon.
Personally, I think reverting to dot MAY draw players back. But there is no proof it would. What people say and what they do is not always the same.
“I left because of Icon dar”
“Would you return if it was reverted?”
No answer, or maybe, doesn’t count, so I call BS.
Dar is not a deal breaker for me. But, I’d rather have dot dar like used in most events.
-
Maybe? Or icons only update every 60 seconds? But that would require code.
It's already a setting. It can put a delay on updates to dot locations.
Wiley.
-
Maybe? Or icons only update every 60 seconds? But that would require code.
It's an adjustable setting, actually.
-
When the radar system was updated to its current version, I asked for it to be changed back, but since most of the feedback was positive, I gave up.
I’m still not satisfied with the current radar system.
https://bbs.hitechcreations.com/smf/index.php/topic,394591
-
I’m still not satisfied with the current radar system.
I agree with you Blade-san :salute
NonDots and AWACS are not good for gameplay. :old:
-
When the radar system was updated to its current version, I asked for it to be changed back, but since most of the feedback was positive, I gave up.
I’m still not satisfied with the current radar system.
https://bbs.hitechcreations.com/smf/index.php/topic,394591
There were many who thought it was a good idea at the time and have since reversed their opinions. AWACS is just not good for the overall health of the game. Players may not see it because it’s been a boon for their style of play. I get that. The problem is it comes at the expense of the game as a whole. If you think of it from a predator/prey analogy, the predators love it until they kill off the prey. Then they starve slowly but surely. AWACS has that effect on the offense/defense balance of the game. It’s thrown that balance in favor of the offense and hamstrung defense.
-
There were many who thought it was a good idea at the time and have since reversed their opinions. AWACS is just not good for the overall health of the game. Players may not see it because it’s been a boon for their style of play. I get that. The problem is it comes at the expense of the game as a whole. If you think of it from a predator/prey analogy, the predators love it until they kill off the prey. Then they starve slowly but surely. AWACS has that effect on the offense/defense balance of the game. It’s thrown that balance in favor of the offense and hamstrung defense.
I'm just laughing that the new plane type on clipboard map arrived too late for Skyyr to take advantage of. :noid :rofl
-
He should at least change the directional icons to dots..
That seems like a good compromise to start with..
It's not like we are asking for FSO settings.... :joystick:
Eagler
-
It's not like we are asking for FSO settings.... :joystick:
I think FSO settings in main would be awesome! Would be some real Hartman stuff going on.
-
He should at least change the directional icons to dots..
That seems like a good compromise to start with..
It's not like we are asking for FSO settings.... :joystick:
Eagler
Agreed
-
He should at least change the directional icons to dots..
That seems like a good compromise to start with..
It's not like we are asking for FSO settings.... :joystick:
Eagler
Helpful but it doesn’t address the real problem which is using the clipboard for r real time location information.
-
I think FSO settings in main would be awesome! Would be some real Hartman stuff going on.
Yes, No and Maybe
Yes
It puts things in perspective and closer to realism.
No
That is a good draw for events and reason to step out of the sandbox. It’s kinda like a trade mark. Not as inclusive to newer players.
Maybe
Something similar reserving the extent for events.
Eagler compromise may be just that. Baby steps. Nothing crazy.
Many are conditioned to the current. It’s now subconscious. A big shakeup is not advised. Older don’t like abrupt change.
-
Helpful but it doesn’t address the real problem which is using the clipboard for r real time location information.
Baby steps
No one has come to a conclusive point that HT will change anything, yet.
I’d go to Las Vegas and bet large sums HT will not buy into drastic changes.
-
Baby steps
No one has come to a conclusive point that HT will change anything, yet.
I’d go to Las Vegas and bet large sums HT will not buy into drastic changes.
HT implemented drastic changes. I’m pretty sure he can do the same in reverse.
-
HT implemented drastic changes. I’m pretty sure he can do the same in reverse.
I think you’ll lose that bet.
I don’t mind being wrong.
You may get there in time. Not all at once, if ever.
-
Never go into court with a case you can’t win for sure.
Only bring forward what you know you can win.
Ask for too much at once you may end up with nothing.
Eagler has something HT may find a compromise in. That has possibilities of winnable.
You can take something now and lobby for more later. You’ve been at this for years. I don’t think you’ll stop.
-
I think you’ll lose that bet.
I don’t mind being wrong.
You may get there in time. Not all at once, if ever.
AWACS, icon radar, player killed player in the text buffer all came out at about the same time. I’m only asking for AWACS to go away in flight. Keep it in the tower. Make it useful if there’s a plane that had a radar option selectable in the hangar (JU88, Black Widow, Mossi and such). AKA. Baby steps.
-
AWACS, icon radar, player killed player in the text buffer all came out at about the same time. I’m only asking for AWACS to go away in flight. Keep it in the tower. Make it useful if there’s a plane that had a radar option selectable in the hangar (JU88, Black Widow, Mossi and such). AKA. Baby steps.
I understand your point. I do not disagree.
I personally go on what is inclusive to new players, not lose numbers and what may be winnable right now.
IMO, asking for a complete overhaul in one flick of the switch is a high bar to meet.
Yes, it kicked up dust when this was implemented, but I also assume a lesson of cation may have been learned. Don’t expect the same in reverse.
Again, I just don’t see the masses begging for something that deep.
Do you want some change or no change?
Hey, never say never.
-
I understand your point. I do not disagree.
I personally go on what is inclusive to new players, not lose numbers and what may be winnable right now.
IMO, asking for a complete overhaul in one flick of the switch is a high bar to meet.
Yes, it kicked up dust when this was implemented, but I also assume a lesson of cation may have been learned. Don’t expect the same in reverse.
Again, I just don’t see the masses begging for something that deep.
Hey, never say never.
Game was fine for over a decade without it. Noobs, vets, everyone knew/learned how darbar and radar rings worked. There was no magical influx of new players that came as a result but there was a rather significant exodus because of it. Making it easier for masters of the game to find and ruthlessly pound on noobs (and vets) isn’t helping retention.
-
Game was fine for over a decade without it. Noobs, vets, everyone knew/learned how darbar and radar rings worked. There was no magical influx of new players that came as a result but there was a rather significant exodus because of it. Making it easier for masters of the game to find and ruthlessly pound on noobs (and vets) isn’t helping retention.
I don’t need further explanation. I already understand, and frankly, my word means nothing.
We all know what you’d like. Don’t over-talk it. Next step.
You and the part of the community that backs your concept should come to terms on what you’ll accept.
Ever sell a house?
In compromise almost no one is totally happy.
What are the 2 top changes you would accept as a minimum?
Sell that
-
I don’t need further explanation. I already understand, and frankly, my word means nothing.
We all know what you’d like. Don’t over-talk it. Next step.
You and the part of the community that backs your concept should come to terms on what you’ll accept.
Ever sell a house?
In compromise almost no one is totally happy.
What are the 2 top changes you would accept as a minimum?
Sell that
I am compromising. I just don’t think you understand that I am.
Before the radar change there were dots in radar rings that didn’t show type or direction of flight. Tower went down and “dot dar” was gone.
Darbar led you to where the enemy was with a significant delay. HQ went down and darbar went away.
What was implemented was…
1- Every plane and GV is its own radar tower. With type and direction of flight.
2- Tower provides aircraft type and direction of flight inside radar ring.
3- Darbar is basically unchanged.
My compromise is leave type and direction of flight inside radar rings.
Update darbar to nearly instant is it’s easier to find enemies in flight (even segmenting darbars within grid squares essentially quartering their size).
Fortify radar towers so they can’t be gunned down in a single pass.
Most Importantly, even if everything else is ignored, eliminate GVs and planes as individual radar towers. If it has to stay, It should only be visible from the tower. Not in flight.
-
Or continue in the direction we are going...
Display plane model, speed and altitude of enemy plane when mouse cursor is held over it.. :banana:
Eagler
-
I've never seen a combat game where the community spends as much effort as possible avoiding direct combat.
If I had it my way, everything would be displayed 24/7 where you couldn't run or hide. I'd shrink the maps and put enemy airbases next to every airbase, so no matter where you went, you couldn't avoid the enemy (except maybe rear bomber bases). Combat games should promote combat. :old:
-
Or continue in the direction we are going...
Display plane model, speed and altitude of enemy plane when mouse cursor is held over it.. :banana:
Eagler
Yeah. I want speed and direction for every tank I fly over too. What the heck…I want to see every player on the map.
I've never seen a combat game where the community spends as much effort as possible avoiding direct combat.
If I had it my way, everything would be displayed 24/7 where you couldn't run or hide. I'd shrink the maps and put enemy airbases next to every airbase, so no matter where you went, you couldn't avoid the enemy (except maybe rear bomber bases). Combat games should promote combat. :old:
The irony is icons displayed on screen is precisely how people are avoiding combat or at least combat where they might be at a disadvantage.
-
Yeah. I want speed and direction for every tank I fly over too. What the heck…I want to see every player on the map.
The irony is icons displayed on screen is precisely how people are avoiding combat or at least combat where they might be at a disadvantage.
I disagree, it's inconsistent data + incentivized behavior that allows avoiding combat. If you display players' locations 24/7, then you can't really avoid combat, you can only make yourself harder to fight.
With the current system, you can avoid combat entirely and therefore create an advantage by going where you can't be detected. It works in reverse too, where if you encounter another player, all of their friends can see you, but you can't see their friendlies. So the optimal behavior, currently, is to hide your entire team while a lone scout finds the enemy. The current player behavior aligns with this, and that makes sense if you look at it from a logical perspective.
Turn on 24/7 radar for everyone everywhere and there's no longer an advantage in this behavior.
-
I am compromising. I just don’t think you understand that I am.
Before the radar change there were dots in radar rings that didn’t show type or direction of flight. Tower went down and “dot dar” was gone.
Darbar led you to where the enemy was with a significant delay. HQ went down and darbar went away.
What was implemented was…
1- Every plane and GV is its own radar tower. With type and direction of flight.
2- Tower provides aircraft type and direction of flight inside radar ring.
3- Darbar is basically unchanged.
My compromise is leave type and direction of flight inside radar rings.
Update darbar to nearly instant is it’s easier to find enemies in flight (even segmenting darbars within grid squares essentially quartering their size).
Fortify radar towers so they can’t be gunned down in a single pass.
Most Importantly, even if everything else is ignored, eliminate GVs and planes as individual radar towers. If it has to stay, It should only be visible from the tower. Not in flight.
Sounds kinda fair to me.
However, hardening dar would not be realistic. Compared to RL, all I’d have to do is hit the antenna itself at the top. That’s an easy shot with 10-20 rounds. The fact it takes 130-150 20mm rounds to drop the whole thing instead can be considered already hardened.
In past times there were enough players to up and head off a hoard from getting there in the first place. I don’t think that’s a big ticket item, myself.
-
BTW
GVs and planes can radio what they see. Kinda keeps the players attention/involved. That would seem realistic.
-
I disagree, it's inconsistent data + incentivized behavior that allows avoiding combat. If you display players' locations 24/7, then you can't really avoid combat, you can only make yourself harder to fight.
With the current system, you can avoid combat entirely and therefore create an advantage by going where you can't be detected. It works in reverse too, where if you encounter another player, all of their friends can see you, but you can't see their friendlies. So the optimal behavior, currently, is to hide your entire team while a lone scout finds the enemy. The current player behavior aligns with this, and that makes sense if you look at it from a logical perspective.
Turn on 24/7 radar for everyone everywhere and there's no longer an advantage in this behavior.
I agree. That’s my point. Either even it back up so localized numbers don’t have the advantage or give the advantage to everyone all the time. What’s happening now is players are gaming the radar advantage (intentional or not) which cuts down on the action. My assumption is players enjoy some of the tactical advantages of the fog of war. After all, it’s hard to flank a position if everything is painted on the map. The actual result of everything being on radar all the time would likely be aircraft all flying 20k+.
-
Being continuously jumped 7 on 1 the hard way -e is not combat, it's paying to be a target drone. Score / death never really meant anything significant to me, but denying players any proportionally realistic form of reward makes them promptly stop playing, and so they should.
-
How many people who were raving about AWACS & LINK16 back then are still around today?
I wish HT hadn’t let themselves be swayed by players offering those short-sighted opinions and had stuck to their original concept.
At the very least, it’s a fact that my motivation dropped significantly because of AWACS & LINK16.
-
Let's start somewhere...
Join the chant... :old:
"Dots, dots, dots...." :banana: :banana: :banana:
Eagler
-
Let's start somewhere...
Join the chant... :old:
"Dots, dots, dots...." :banana: :banana: :banana:
Eagler
I don’t think simply reverting to dots solves the core issue which is tactical and strategic advantage of the local group with the most numbers.
I don’t know what a good chant would be.
-
It isn't the end all but would show HT is listening and willing to try a change of some sort...
Right now I don't get that feeling....
Eagler
-
It isn't the end all but would show HT is listening and willing to try a change of some sort...
Right now I don't get that feeling....
Eagler
I’m pretty sure the dot thing is a code revision. AWACS is probably a setting.
Overall. AWACS needs to go with darbar beefed up so folks can more easily find each other.
-
Too bad different dar settings can't be set by map...
Go from what is there now to FSO settings on the next map...and back again..
Variety is the spice of life.. :old:
Eagler
-
Too bad different dar settings can't be set by map...
Go from what is there now to FSO settings on the next map...and back again..
Variety is the spice of life.. :old:
Eagler
I’d love some crazy stuff like that but the MA doesn’t have the mission centric structure of FSO so you’d spend most of the time looking around and not finding anything.
-
What was wrong with the old dot dar system? :headscratch:
-
What was wrong with the old dot dar system? :headscratch:
Nothing was wrong with it.
HT just changed it one day. Presumably to make the MA seem busier? Basically ruining half the magic that made the game so well balanced. There were a lot of questionable decisions (a hud in a WWII cockpit?!?! And entire night sky you could navigate by?!?!). But the AWACS is/was far and away the second worst decision I’ve ever seen him make.
-
Last night I was trying to make the clipboard smaller in the cockpit and realized I had it as about as small as it can go...
I was surprised how big you can actually expand it to be...it can almost blot out the entire screen in the quest 2..you could almost play without looking at anything else..
Eagler