Aces High Bulletin Board

General Forums => Aces High General Discussion => Topic started by: Mol on October 30, 2026, 03:45:13 PM

Title: Radar Feedback
Post by: Mol on October 30, 2026, 03:45:13 PM
Here is my perspective on the Radar changes.

From recent experience the radar now reduces your situational awareness rather than improve it for the following reasons.

Now, when chasing an enemy at your 12 you look at radar and it can appear to be on your 6. That's given me a couple of "Holy Moly" moments. 

When you check radar at a base an enemy can appear to be distant and leaving but as you roll, its actually vulching.

With a 20 second delay, aircraft flying at 220 to 320 mph can be from 1.2 to 1.8 miles away from where they seem to be on Radar.   

If you check the radar and it tells you you're at risk when you aren't and its safe to roll when it isn't, that's not helping improve your SA that's just making it worse. That's not the fog of war, its misleading. It doesn't feel like a fix, it feels broken. I can't imagine how confusing it would be to new players.

I understand the desire for settings that reflect the methods of observation available at the time and for realism, but that's why I enjoy scenarios. In the MA I just want to get to where the other players are for the fastest most densely packed fun I can find. I suspect that is exactly what new players want too. I think the previous radar was a good compromise between realism and fun, with scenarios for those who want a more rigorously realistic experience.       

Can we have the Radar back the way it was please?

MoL
Title: Re: Radar Feedback
Post by: popeye on October 30, 2026, 03:52:33 PM
Not sure it would be confusing to new players.  Might confuse veteran players for while, if they are used to using the clipboard for SA.  New players wouldn't have to break that habit.
Title: Re: Radar Feedback
Post by: Dadtallica on October 30, 2026, 04:02:44 PM
+1 it was better at 5
Title: Re: Radar Feedback
Post by: ~ZoSo~ on October 30, 2026, 04:05:44 PM
Might as well delete the enemy icons and just have a darbar. The “radar” is confusing and deceptive the way it is now rendering it useless IMHO.
Title: Re: Radar Feedback
Post by: LilMak on October 30, 2026, 04:16:42 PM
Inside active rings. 5 is fine. Outside active rings. 20 or more until something less intrusive is developed.
Title: Re: Radar Feedback
Post by: Lazerr on October 30, 2026, 04:26:27 PM
Bummer, you guys need to look around a little and its bothersome.
Title: Re: Radar Feedback
Post by: CAV on October 30, 2026, 09:45:30 PM

the Ez fix is not the looks the map.
Title: Re: Radar Feedback
Post by: ~ZoSo~ on October 31, 2026, 04:54:58 AM
It’s a game.
Title: Re: Radar Feedback
Post by: Eagler on October 31, 2026, 07:17:35 AM
It’s a game.

Yeah..it is a game..where's my f3 view for my 109..... :banana: :banana: :banana:

Close the clipboard when you are near a fight and look outside the cockpit..

It's a game but it's a ww2 aircraft game where in flight instant radar never existed..

I find it a refreshing change myself..even as the change has caught me not checking my six as often as I should..

Thanks HT  :aok

Eagler
Title: Re: Radar Feedback
Post by: 1Cane on October 31, 2026, 12:10:08 PM
Might as well delete the enemy icons and just have a darbar. The “radar” is confusing and deceptive the way it is now rendering it useless IMHO.
Recently saw buffs near our fields dove down From .14,000 to 6000 and found out they weren't low looked again on radar and it showed them far behind me. Looked straight up and by golly there they were. The way things are now it's worse than having no radar if it's constantly telling you wrong information  ! I can't possibly see how this helps the new player by giving him false information and expecting him to take advantage of it. Yeah they didn't have head ups displays or radars during World War two. So let's get rid of all radar and Dars and wander around blindly wondering where they're at just like World War two. I have to say once again the vocal minority has managed to screw over the majority. Since they're the only ones complaining about a column that doesn't exist. One last word if it's not broken don't fix it'!You are right it's a game let us play please
Title: Re: Radar Feedback
Post by: 1Cane on October 31, 2026, 12:46:33 PM
Lets go to 8hour missions and stretch the base 2 to 400 miles apart. It will add more realism
Even better how about allowing us to put it to a vote. As it stands this is just pure crap
Title: Re: Radar Feedback
Post by: The Fugitive on October 31, 2026, 12:49:02 PM
Recently saw buffs near our fields dove down From .14,000 to 6000 and found out they weren't low looked again on radar and it showed them far behind me. Looked straight up and by golly there they were. The way things are now it's worse than having no radar if it's constantly telling you wrong information  ! I can't possibly see how this helps the new player by giving him false information and expecting him to take advantage of it. Yeah they didn't have head ups displays or radars during World War two. So let's get rid of all radar and Dars and wander around blindly wondering where they're at just like World War two. I have to say once again the vocal minority has managed to screw over the majority. Since they're the only ones complaining about a column that doesn't exist. One last word if it's not broken don't fix it'!You are right it's a game let us play please

Did you spot the Buffs below you before you dove? Im thinking not, you assumed they were low and dove. The radar is now telling you "There are bombers in the area" they are not pin pointing them for you any more. You still have to find them, and then adjust your approach.

Your blaming the radar for your poor SA.
Title: Re: Radar Feedback
Post by: Eagler on October 31, 2026, 01:07:22 PM
Old habits are hard to break...

Give it time and most will adjust..

Trying to clear SNO's six I got him killed by looking at dar and not rolling over to see they were alot closer than dar showed..

I think he forgave me.. :)

It's a nice change for some of us..

Eagler
Title: Re: Radar Feedback
Post by: AKIron on October 31, 2026, 01:13:26 PM
Roving AI recording and reporting sightings. "Red Leader One spotted 3 bandits at angels 10 heading 235 in sector 23 5 minutes ago".
Title: Re: Radar Feedback
Post by: SIK1 on October 31, 2026, 02:08:14 PM
If your SA depends on looking at the clipboard, then you don't really have any SA.

Look outside the cockpit, get into a habit of scanning around your plane, don't forget to look underneath it.

Personally, I like the changes, it's a step in the right direction. Maybe we should go to just dar bar. 

 :cheers:

Title: Re: Radar Feedback
Post by: SNO on October 31, 2026, 02:19:55 PM
Old habits are hard to break...

Give it time and most will adjust..

Trying to clear SNO's six I got him killed by looking at dar and not rolling over to see they were alot closer than dar showed..

I think he forgave me.. :)

It's a nice change for some of us..

Eagler

Forgiven for sure  :aok
Title: Re: Radar Feedback
Post by: mERv on October 31, 2026, 03:52:33 PM
I havent heard a single player praise the dar change. All are in agreement it was an awful implementation. In a game that demands situational awareness, where the default views are awful already, the clip board map is something players heavily rely on.

I dont understand why a detrimental change to game play would be implemented to the MA. You dont fix what is not broken.  :bhead

Title: Re: Radar Feedback
Post by: The Fugitive on October 31, 2026, 04:06:56 PM
I havent heard a single player praise the dar change. All are in agreement it was an awful implementation. In a game that demands situational awareness, where the default views are awful already, the clip board map is something players heavily rely on.

I dont understand why a detrimental change to game play would be implemented to the MA. You dont fix what is not broken.  :bhead

I love it! There, there is one whos happy with it !   :)

I think once Hitech gets the icons to do a fade as the positioning report gets older it will be even better. I like the old "Keep your head on a swivel" mantra
Title: Re: Radar Feedback
Post by: -gg- on October 31, 2026, 04:16:33 PM
I like the idea of the radar not being as accurate. I just think that the way it's displayed makes it confusing for people. Most of us by now know how it's working but maybe other people still don't realize what's going on with the radar. Because they see an individual plane that kind of burns the image in your head that that's like a location for an individual plane.


But I do love the idea that it's not up to date accurate. I think that it's cool to be relying on your own situationianal awareness. For instance when you go into the clouds, you can't just pull up the clipboard and see exactly where the guy is you're fighting. We have to keep eyes on him. I like that.

I know you guys were talking about having the fading color thing to represent how new the radar image was. I think that's a good idea. I think it might be cool that if initially the symbol shows up as the plane but then as it fades it just becomes a square so you can instantly look at it and see that's just like a representation of the general area..
Title: Re: Radar Feedback
Post by: Busher on October 31, 2026, 04:24:46 PM
I havent heard a single player praise the dar change. All are in agreement it was an awful implementation. In a game that demands situational awareness, where the default views are awful already, the clip board map is something players heavily rely on.

I dont understand why a detrimental change to game play would be implemented to the MA. You dont fix what is not broken.  :bhead

I agree.. exactly on point.. What the H*** was this supposed to accomplish?
Is it possible it was done to "go easier" on the game's server?
Title: Re: Radar Feedback
Post by: thndregg on October 31, 2026, 04:39:33 PM
I remember dot dar.

I remember having to use more situational awareness back then, and I got good at it.

I detested the nearly-"tell all" dar that it became, but I got used to it.

I have no issue with the current dar as it is forcing me to get back into the old SA practice I was in the habit of doing 20 years ago.

If I did it then, I can do it again.
Title: Re: Radar Feedback
Post by: ~ZoSo~ on October 31, 2026, 06:10:35 PM
Yeah..it is a game..where's my f3 view for my 109..... :banana: :banana: :banana:

Close the clipboard when you are near a fight and look outside the cockpit..

It's a game but it's a ww2 aircraft game where in flight instant radar never existed..

I find it a refreshing change myself..even as the change has caught me not checking my six as often as I should..

Thanks HT  :aok

Eagler

Why have an F3 key for any plane? Why have icons? Why have darbars? Spawn point locations? I could go on.  :aok

Like I said. “It’s a game”.   :aok

Oh! And I love you too HT!!!
Title: Re: Radar Feedback
Post by: GOODBYE on October 31, 2026, 06:21:18 PM
I remember dot dar.

I remember having to use more situational awareness back then, and I got good at it.

I detested the nearly-"tell all" dar that it became, but I got used to it.

I have no issue with the current dar as it is forcing me to get back into the old SA practice I was in the habit of doing 20 years ago.

If I did it then, I can do it again.

Love this, it’s wild that people forgot you actually had to look for enemy planes when you left your radar bubble…. I love the new radar. Brings back the thrill of actually having to use my views and look for planes than relying on my clipboard tracking system
Title: Re: Radar Feedback
Post by: popeye on October 31, 2026, 07:13:52 PM
HiTech said something about implementing a system that required a player to see and "report" a contact to make it appear on the clipboard (outside the field radar rings), and then have that contact fade away.  Sounds promising, I'm interested to see what he comes up with.
Title: Re: Radar Feedback
Post by: ~ZoSo~ on October 31, 2026, 08:03:20 PM
Love this, it’s wild that people forgot you actually had to look for enemy planes when you left your radar bubble…. I love the new radar. Brings back the thrill of actually having to use my views and look for planes than relying on my clipboard tracking system

I actually prefer the old dot system. I was surprised to see what the Dar system had become after a 16 year hiatus. That being said, the delay setting as it is now is like playing wack a mole. HT is working on it. And that is what matters.  :salute
Title: Re: Radar Feedback
Post by: DmonSlyr on October 31, 2026, 08:47:40 PM
The dar should go back to how it use to be back in AH2, with one easy change, make the radar harder to destroy. Make it 5k pounds.

The way I see it now, 2 things are happening.

Fighters getting ganged. Regardless of the timing, it still shows players near and around you no matter where you are on the map, whether inside the rings or not. Outside the rings should be no man's land where there is no radar. The conga line of players coming to gang makes it extremely difficult for players. There almost better off not being seen on radar. They should only show up inside the dar rings when the radar is up. A tank should not give away a players location

Bombers getting jumped way too early being spotted before they get to a field ruining their time spent. 90% of bombers arnt master gunners. This causes more players to get into Tu2s, or B26s which are extremely hard to shoot down and catch, they should be perked.

IMO ganging is the absolute worst due to this full on awacs dar and kill messages. Kills messages for whole arena should be removed. I hate that it shows everyone in the furball who is there when they shoot someone down. There is no anonymity. Players can choose not to roll if they know a good stick is in the area. They can immediately change their tactics and tell all their buddies to come gang. I feel like its simply not fair from a SA point of view because now the whole furball knows where im at and what im flying. 

While it would seem that open radar makes it easier for noobs, it really only males it harder for them. As soon as I see a kill message and I know whose in the fight and I can adjust my style accordingly which is not good for them and puts them at a major disadvantage.

 :aok
Title: Re: Radar Feedback
Post by: Lazerr on October 31, 2026, 09:16:51 PM
 :rofl
Title: Re: Radar Feedback
Post by: Banshee7 on October 31, 2026, 11:02:22 PM
:rofl


This is not a laughing matter….






















:D









Title: Re: Radar Feedback
Post by: Molsman on October 31, 2026, 11:10:21 PM
No matter what the Dar says I still die equally
Title: Re: Radar Feedback
Post by: Eagler on November 01, 2026, 06:04:22 AM
Gotta give it a go Violator..

It's a much better experience with the 20 second delay imo..

Best fun last night than in a while..

Thanks again HT  :cheers:

Eagler
Title: Re: Radar Feedback
Post by: -gg- on November 01, 2026, 08:16:45 AM
I like the change.
Title: Re: Radar Feedback
Post by: The Fugitive on November 01, 2026, 01:58:24 PM
I agree.. exactly on point.. What the H*** was this supposed to accomplish?
Is it possible it was done to "go easier" on the game's server?

You mean the same servers that use to have 700-800 players on prime time nightly?   :rolleyes:  I think they can handle much more than the 100+ we get these days. I hope with these updates we can get the numbers back up to test those servers.

As for the radar, I really like it. Im more into the game as I play now as you cant count on pin point radar contacts to be your SA, you have to look outside your plane.

A couple changes I'd like to see.....

Id like to see the "fading contact" on the radar come to fruition. Have the contact fade the contact over the next 10 seconds, and 10 seconds later the updated and delayed contact reappears on the map.

I would like to see the radar circle be worth something again. As it is you have the 20 second delay for a contact whether dar is up or not. Return the 5 second delay to contacts inside the radar circle. When the dar goes down you lose that advantage of quicker updates. Id like to see the what it takes to drop dar be beefed up a bit like the ammo bunkers. That way the dar as a target becomes more important (quicker updates) but it takes more than a single guns pass to take it out (extra chances to take out the dar popper)
Title: Re: Radar Feedback
Post by: 1Cane on November 01, 2026, 04:22:09 PM
Not one of the pilots advocating this has a fighter score  ranked below 50. I'm not saying that I'm better than them I'm not. But the method that they choose to use does not produce better results. If you want more realism go to DCS and learn the 15 step procedure to start up a Mustang you would need to go to ground school for 6 to 8 weeks to to learn how to start and fly on these aircraft. I'm pretty sure in the p47 you had to be above a certain altitude to engage the advanced engine controls or you burn out your mains. You want more realism let's delete dar, Zoom toggle, bullet counter, cross country radio, auto takeoff, all the little tools that we use to make this game enjoyable. How can you be a purist when you're willing to accept these other little gifts.
 to quote Josey Wales" don't piss down my leg and tell me it's raining"
Title: Re: Radar Feedback
Post by: Rubicon on November 01, 2026, 04:38:26 PM
Not one of the pilots advocating this has a fighter score  ranked below 50. I'm not saying that I'm better than them I'm not. But the method that they choose to use does not produce better results. If you want more realism go to DCS and learn the 15 step procedure to start up a Mustang you would need to go to ground school for 6 to 8 weeks to to learn how to start and fly on these aircraft. I'm pretty sure in the p47 you had to be above a certain altitude to engage the advanced engine controls or you burn out your mains. You want more realism let's delete dar, Zoom toggle, bullet counter, cross country radio, auto takeoff, all the little tools that we use to make this game enjoyable. How can you be a purist when you're willing to accept these other little gifts.
 to quote Josey Wales" don't piss down my leg and tell me it's raining"

There are plenty of good fighter pilots advocating for this change.  Score does not neccessarily mean a person is good, it is often about whether you can tick certain boxes to get points.

On the point of realism V gameplay.  This is exactly what the conversation is about.  Not one person is advotaing for the removal of radar or the introduction of more complex flight management etc.  What is being discussed is how can things change for the better.  And, before you yell that this is not better, please consider other points of view.  You may not like it but others do.  Put forward an opinion not just a rant.

Regards,
Title: Re: Radar Feedback
Post by: -gg- on November 01, 2026, 05:07:52 PM
Lol. One guy was whining about the radar early this morning. I mentioned that I liked the new changes and he said that I wasn't under 100 rank. Hahaha. Rank.

Title: Re: Radar Feedback
Post by: -gg- on November 01, 2026, 05:10:19 PM
To be fair, nobody really asked for the radar changes did they? I mean that wasn't some big thing that everyone was dying to have changed that I'm aware of. I've never once heard anybody complain about the way it was in the game.

I do like the changes. I think it's better. But some people hate any kind of change. 





Title: Re: Radar Feedback
Post by: 1Cane on November 01, 2026, 05:43:26 PM
There are plenty of good fighter pilots advocating for this change.  Score does not neccessarily mean a person is good, it is often about whether you can tick certain boxes to get points

 Making a kill certainly effects your score Doesn't it  :banana:


On the point of realism V gameplay.  This is exactly what the conversation is about.  Not one person is advotaing for the removal of radar or the introduction of more complex flight management etc.  What is being discussed is how can things change for the better.  And, before you yell that this is not better, please consider other points of view.  You may not like it but others do.  Put forward an opinion not just a rant.


So changing the radar's abilities certainly changes the game. I understand they have a different view that they want the game to change to their ideas ideas not mine. I can't think of a clearer way than to point out all the changes they want to make yet exclude deleting Zoom toggle, icons, cross country radios and all the other tools that are friendly to to players. I think this approach is very selfish so once again I'll quote Josey Wales don't piss down my leg and tell me it's raining :x
This is stepping backwards not forwards!

Regards,
There are plenty of good fighter pilots advocating for this change.  Score does not neccessarily mean a person is good, it is often about whether you can tick certain boxes to get points.

On the point of realism V gameplay.  This is exactly what the conversation is about.  Not one person is advotaing for the removal of radar or the introduction of more complex flight management etc.  What is being discussed is how can things change for the better.  And, before you yell that this is not better, please consider other points of view.  You may not like it but others do.  Put forward an opinion not just a rant.

Regards,
Title: Re: Radar Feedback
Post by: Animl-AW on November 01, 2026, 05:50:46 PM
Fighter ranking means zero, it’s not a most important player ranking,
No such thing

However non-players should not be counted

I am king cod, I have spoken
Title: Re: Radar Feedback
Post by: Dadtallica on November 01, 2026, 05:58:38 PM
To be fair, nobody really asked for the radar changes did they? I mean that wasn't some big thing that everyone was dying to have changed that I'm aware of. I've never once heard anybody complain about the way it was in the game.

I do like the changes. I think it's better. But some people hate any kind of change.

Feels like it was more a response to the overall radar discussion that is endless. Search the word AWACS in here and it will take you several decades to read it all!
Title: Re: Radar Feedback
Post by: toddbobe on November 01, 2026, 07:43:51 PM
Now the radar gives wrong information, is it behind you or in front of you?

Yes the map gives us SA, but its a game. If we had 800 players on a server fights would be easy to find, now they are not as easy as we would like. I fear this would be another thing to scare off new players. we dont need that!!!
Title: Re: Radar Feedback
Post by: JimmyD3 on November 01, 2026, 08:02:45 PM
To be fair, nobody really asked for the radar changes did they? I mean that wasn't some big thing that everyone was dying to have changed that I'm aware of. I've never once heard anybody complain about the way it was in the game.

I do like the changes. I think it's better. But some people hate any kind of change.

There was a vocal few. It was all about the "AWACS" feeling and this was part of it.
Title: Re: Radar Feedback
Post by: GOODBYE on November 01, 2026, 10:51:37 PM
The radar is super easy…. You look at where the little plane nose is pointing and you fly to where they should be going. No different than when you lead your shots. I’ve been able to spot these guys a lot faster now before they’re even in icon range, except for pony’s… those things are extremely hard to see
Title: Re: Radar Feedback
Post by: Dadtallica on November 01, 2026, 10:55:54 PM
I very much gotten used to it still would prefer the way it was, but it’s small potatoes.

Can we all please focus?
Title: Re: Radar Feedback
Post by: Eagler on November 02, 2026, 06:20:10 AM
I like the fact you can sneak up on someone who flies with their nose stuck in the clipboard..

It's much more enjoyable for many of us but wouldn't surprise me if the whine chorus becomes so loud that it isn't switched back..

Eagler
Title: Re: Radar Feedback
Post by: LilMak on November 02, 2026, 10:31:02 AM
To be fair, nobody really asked for the radar changes did they? I mean that wasn't some big thing that everyone was dying to have changed that I'm aware of. I've never once heard anybody complain about the way it was in the game.

I do like the changes. I think it's better. But some people hate any kind of change.
You’re right. Not many (recently) asked for a change. The change happened years ago. One day the MA had only radar within the radar rings. The next day we had every GV and airplane as its own individual radar tower with little to no delay and kill messages added for every death. This change wasn’t asked for. It just showed up. Presumably to make the MA appear more active and help people find the action.

It basically worked. Too well.

Initially the response was mixed with most of the complaints about individual players being hunted because their name was being broadcast whenever they scored or died. The name in lights thing was a symptom of the the real problem in my opinion. Which is/was the ability of localized groups to either flat out gang/hunt individual players while outright avoiding danger unless all the conditions were 100% favorable. It fed things like the C-47 becoming virtually useless. Bombers being singled out before they could even get close to targets unless they had copious amounts of altitude. Flanking large groups was nearly impossible. Plane selection pushed to faster and faster aircraft just to be competitive (both bombers and fighters). Altitude became much more important. Radar rings being less strategic. Pilots taking off from a quiet field were being broadcast on radar by an enemy GVs sleeping under trees. Lone pilots being converged on before they could even close to gun range on the lone enemy they see. Entire groups hovering on opposite sides of imaginary battle lines to avoid being the first one into a fight. All of that is still happening. Just slower.

There was pushback. Swaths if people complained. Many quit citing the radar settings as the final straw.

Some of us dealt with it (me) but refused to let it go. I’ve railed against proximity radar for years. To the point that I’m a basically joke because of it. Partly because it sucked much of the fun out of the game for me but mostly because I believe it was bad for business. I recognized that pilots like me are much more rare than we used to be. We were being run off and ignored providing fewer targets for the hordes and career pickers. We are type who didn’t care if we won the war. We generally didn’t care if we won or lost a good fight. As long as that fight could be had without radar pointing us out for the 2-6 other folks who never would’ve been a part of it if they weren’t spoon fed our position on the clipboard. Am I going to be picked with a 20 second delay? Yes. Am I going to be ganged? Yes. But I’m also going to have more fun providing a target for you which results in me being there for you to shoot down at a much higher frequency. Provided, of course, that you look out the cockpit every few seconds to actually see me.

So…yeah. Changes and compromises were asked for, but most of those asking gave up years ago or simply quit. But it’s been years in the past.

I personally can’t thank HT enough for the change. I was skeptical that the delay would do much of anything. The last couple weeks have been infinitely better. The fights are lasting longer without one side getting beat down. The first couple days there was a bunch of people who were clearly staring at the clipboard and getting surprised. That’s tapering off as they learn. I believe we can refine the radar without simply reverting to the uneven standard we had before the delay. Until then, keep it as it stands.
Title: Re: Radar Feedback
Post by: -gg- on November 02, 2026, 10:41:01 AM
That's a good explanation. I do remember the way radar used to work and then when it was updated to the AWACS version, lol.

I think it was a good call to change the radar to what it is now. I really like it.

Title: Re: Radar Feedback
Post by: Animl-AW on November 02, 2026, 11:12:58 AM
You’re not a joke.

Anyone who sticks their neck out upfront for a change, even with best intensions, is also opening themselves to clubbing by the vocals. Ask me how I know.

What I see is the convo is vastly over-talked.
Several here think recycling creative ways to say the same thing over and over gives it more weight. Which can be true, but sometimes it can also become an irritant and repelling can take over.

You don’t have to defend the change. It comes down to it either works with the masses or it doesn’t.

I think in ENY and Dar changes, no matter if they go over well or not, it shows HTs willingness to work directly with the players and give their ideas and input a consideration. I can’t think of another game where dev works directly with the players.

Just a few months ago we got nothing. Now everyone wants their wishlist implemented yesterday.

I still maintain; “do you want it done fast or right” they aren’t always both.

Personally, I think a lil different approach may evolve. I don’t think it’s the magic solution. But it’s a move in the right direction to do anything at all.

Main point, stick your neck out and someone will chop it off,…you’ll find who your friends aren’t right quick. It goes with the territory.
Title: Re: Radar Feedback
Post by: -gg- on November 02, 2026, 12:16:32 PM
Well said, Animal. There's a reason why those people in our squad won't come here to express their opinions on anything. You've got people here who don't even play the game who will just ride you.

People have opinions on e n y within our squadron and they won't come here to express them even though they get super pissed off in the game about it. I've asked them to come here and they just won't because they're not going to get jumped on over here. Their words
Title: Re: Radar Feedback
Post by: Mol on November 02, 2026, 06:00:02 PM
I read a lot of different perspectives on the radar and I now accept my original post was heavily influenced by my initial difficulty getting used to the new settings and a failure to appreciate the bigger picture.

Can we have the Radar back the way it was please?

MoL

I've changed my mind, I no longer want it back the way it was, but I also don't want it the way it is now, for the following reasons:

That is the balance I am trying to find: enough on the map that a new player can find a fight, but not so much that a veteran can't get a fair one.

But I am trying to think of another way to have players be able to simply report the players they see, possibly by key press and anything in view gets sent. This then could also include vehicles.

Also no mater what we go with I will have the icons fade with update rate.

HiTech

That all sounds a lot better.

Two things seem certain, the thinking around this topic goes much deeper than I thought, and there are good things coming.

My oppologies for the initial post. Reading it back it sounds like a whine was recorded  :rofl

MoL
Title: Re: Radar Feedback
Post by: DmonSlyr on November 02, 2026, 06:42:01 PM
You’re right. Not many (recently) asked for a change. The change happened years ago. One day the MA had only radar within the radar rings. The next day we had every GV and airplane as its own individual radar tower with little to no delay and kill messages added for every death. This change wasn’t asked for. It just showed up. Presumably to make the MA appear more active and help people find the action.

It basically worked. Too well.

Initially the response was mixed with most of the complaints about individual players being hunted because their name was being broadcast whenever they scored or died. The name in lights thing was a symptom of the the real problem in my opinion. Which is/was the ability of localized groups to either flat out gang/hunt individual players while outright avoiding danger unless all the conditions were 100% favorable. It fed things like the C-47 becoming virtually useless. Bombers being singled out before they could even get close to targets unless they had copious amounts of altitude. Flanking large groups was nearly impossible. Plane selection pushed to faster and faster aircraft just to be competitive (both bombers and fighters). Altitude became much more important. Radar rings being less strategic. Pilots taking off from a quiet field were being broadcast on radar by an enemy GVs sleeping under trees. Lone pilots being converged on before they could even close to gun range on the lone enemy they see. Entire groups hovering on opposite sides of imaginary battle lines to avoid being the first one into a fight. All of that is still happening. Just slower.

There was pushback. Swaths if people complained. Many quit citing the radar settings as the final straw.

Some of us dealt with it (me) but refused to let it go. I’ve railed against proximity radar for years. To the point that I’m a basically joke because of it. Partly because it sucked much of the fun out of the game for me but mostly because I believe it was bad for business. I recognized that pilots like me are much more rare than we used to be. We were being run off and ignored providing fewer targets for the hordes and career pickers. We are type who didn’t care if we won the war. We generally didn’t care if we won or lost a good fight. As long as that fight could be had without radar pointing us out for the 2-6 other folks who never would’ve been a part of it if they weren’t spoon fed our position on the clipboard. Am I going to be picked with a 20 second delay? Yes. Am I going to be ganged? Yes. But I’m also going to have more fun providing a target for you which results in me being there for you to shoot down at a much higher frequency. Provided, of course, that you look out the cockpit every few seconds to actually see me.

So…yeah. Changes and compromises were asked for, but most of those asking gave up years ago or simply quit. But it’s been years in the past.

I personally can’t thank HT enough for the change. I was skeptical that the delay would do much of anything. The last couple weeks have been infinitely better. The fights are lasting longer without one side getting beat down. The first couple days there was a bunch of people who were clearly staring at the clipboard and getting surprised. That’s tapering off as they learn. I believe we can refine the radar without simply reverting to the uneven standard we had before the delay. Until then, keep it as it stands.

Likmak and I are on the same page here  :cheers:

Regarding the balance issue hitech pointed to. I believe maybe making the dar bars look bigger with 3 or more planes would spark more defenders. Many players live off the dar bars. One of my biggest issues is a huge map with tiny 1 notch dars scattered all over the place. This makes rolling pointless.

One team being ganged by both sides at night is also a huge problem. 114 players on and not a single fight on the other side of the map while bish are being hoarded by both teams. This vastly limits # growth in fights. My idea to fix that is adding zones in specific areas of the map the provide more points/perks if you attack them, and they would also benefit the war effort and give people a path to action if there is no clear battle on that side.
Title: Re: Radar Feedback
Post by: mERv on November 03, 2026, 11:34:37 PM
The new radar system is dog cheeet  :bhead

-1
Title: Re: Radar Feedback
Post by: diaster on November 04, 2026, 12:06:13 AM
I havent heard a single player praise the dar change. All are in agreement it was an awful implementation. In a game that demands situational awareness, where the default views are awful already, the clip board map is something players heavily rely on.

I dont understand why a detrimental change to game play would be implemented to the MA. You dont fix what is not broken.  :bhead
Ok i will praise it then. It is more realistic, i see a plane on far, i plot an intercept to be where i think it will be. I have to actually look for it, once i arrrive. i have then managed an effective attack cause he was ruling on my last position. Minimums a radar sweep is appropriate and adds realism. One adjustment i would make. When you are within icon range the position should update constantly. That mimics verbal update comms as to location etc. also friendly positions updated in real time as that also mimics verbal comms. I say this because not all people talk, for reasons I am unsure, SkyHawk/OOPK and Pica to name two. Maybe it gives away age (when you build a rep as a united pilot, act like a child on 200 etc)or lack of English mastery, who knows. But live updates on friends would be appropriate
Title: Re: Radar Feedback
Post by: Eagler on November 04, 2026, 06:11:39 AM
HT has stated it's not radar but a display of gathered intelligence displayed in a logical usable manner..

All for the new settings including the new icon fade..

Thanks HT  :aok

Eagler
Title: Re: Radar Feedback
Post by: 1Cane on November 08, 2026, 12:11:00 PM
The new radar system is dog cheeet  :bhead

-1



 Please Quit fixing something that's not broken!
Title: Re: Radar Feedback
Post by: Flayed1 on November 08, 2026, 01:03:12 PM
 The new radar system is good and, in my personal opinion doesn't go far enough. But I won't argue for more drastic change other than I would love to go back to dot dar.   There you have another long time player who is praising the new dar settings!  ;)
Title: Re: Radar Feedback
Post by: atlau on November 08, 2026, 03:01:08 PM
My 2 cents with the current radar system is instead of fading to 0, have the icons fade to 25% where you can still see the last position rather than nothing at all...
Title: Re: Radar Feedback
Post by: Blade on November 08, 2026, 04:49:12 PM
So, in the end, it doesn't change the fact that all piston-engine fighters are equipped with omnidirectional radar and data links.
It feels way too casual to be able to pinpoint the enemy's location just by looking at a clipboard map—without having to switch your field of view back and forth, roll the aircraft, or make occasional turns to search for the enemy.
Title: Re: Radar Feedback
Post by: JimmyD3 on November 08, 2026, 05:40:57 PM
So, in the end, it doesn't change the fact that all piston-engine fighters are equipped with omnidirectional radar and data links.
It feels way too casual to be able to pinpoint the enemy's location just by looking at a clipboard map—without having to switch your field of view back and forth, roll the aircraft, or make occasional turns to search for the enemy.

In the Radar ring, the only difference from what we had in AH2 is Plane/bomber symbols vs the dot. No big deal.
Title: Re: Radar Feedback
Post by: Eagler on November 08, 2026, 05:55:50 PM
My 2 cents with the current radar system is instead of fading to 0, have the icons fade to 25% where you can still see the last position rather than nothing at all...

The 2 second no icon is the best part of the change imo..

Eagler
Title: Re: Radar Feedback
Post by: Busher on November 08, 2026, 06:34:41 PM
The new radar system is dog cheeet  :bhead

-1

While I doubt HT cares whether we like it or not, I do suspect it will lead to some departures.... no idea how many,  if any.

I participate mostly in winter months when weather leaves F'all else to do but play computer games. Not a lot of fun right now.
Title: Re: Radar Feedback
Post by: Dadtallica on November 08, 2026, 06:46:54 PM
My 2 cents with the current radar system is instead of fading to 0, have the icons fade to 25% where you can still see the last position rather than nothing at all...

HT said this was happening in the next update.
Title: Re: Radar Feedback
Post by: Oldman731 on November 08, 2026, 09:07:48 PM
While I doubt HT cares whether we like it or not, I do suspect it will lead to some departures.... no idea how many,  if any.

I participate mostly in winter months when weather leaves F'all else to do but play computer games. Not a lot of fun right now.


One thing that those of us who have been here awhile - like you, Busher! - is that we adapt.  I was fine with the way radar was.  I'll be fine with the way radar is or becomes.  Heck, I was one of the people who argued for no-icons. 

The players are stronger than the radar settings.

- oldman