Aces High Bulletin Board

General Forums => Aces High General Discussion => Topic started by: hitech on November 12, 2026, 01:13:22 PM

Title: Current radar settings
Post by: hitech on November 12, 2026, 01:13:22 PM
We now have the ability to configure "Seen" and radar settings.

Currently On radar is set to 5 sec update rate (what is was set to for years) and no fade and dots only.
Seen is set to 20 secs with fade and detail plane info.

Friendlies always show detail.

HiTech
Title: Re: Current radar settings
Post by: Animl-AW on November 12, 2026, 01:19:04 PM
We now have the ability to configure "Seen" and radar settings.

Currently On radar is set to 5 sec update rate (what is was set to for years) and no fade and dots only.
Seen is set to 20 secs with fade and detail plane info.

Friendlies always show detail.

HiTech

Very nice

Wtg on that config
Title: Re: Current radar settings
Post by: popeye on November 12, 2026, 01:37:14 PM
 :aok
Title: Re: Current radar settings
Post by: Busher on November 12, 2026, 04:36:38 PM
Excellent  :aok
Title: Re: Current radar settings
Post by: LilMak on November 12, 2026, 06:05:18 PM
I don’t think it’s working as intended. Definitely not working how you described it.
Title: Re: Current radar settings
Post by: Dadtallica on November 12, 2026, 07:03:22 PM
I wouldn’t mind seeing the dots a little smaller.
Title: Re: Current radar settings
Post by: hitech on November 12, 2026, 07:08:16 PM
I don’t think it’s working as intended. Definitely not working how you described it.

I have noticed what I intend to say and what you hear are not always the same thing so describe back to me how you think it is working or what I said it would be doing and what you see.

HiTech
Title: Re: Current radar settings
Post by: LilMak on November 12, 2026, 07:57:36 PM
Here is what I am planning to do with radar. This is the plan, not a finished feature, so details may change as we test it.

The map will show enemy contacts 2 different ways.

Radar contacts
A plane within range of your side's radar and above radar height shows on the map as it does today. Position updates will be faster, something like every 5 seconds. Between updates the contact fades to about 25%, so you can tell how old the position is.

Seen contacts
Being near an enemy will no longer put him on your side's map. Someone on your side has to actually see him. You have seen him if he is within vis range and really in your view, so he does not count if he is off screen, behind your canopy frame, behind terrain or in the sun, or if either of you is inside a cloud. As soon as anyone on your side sees him he shows on your side's map. He stays while anyone keeps seeing him and for a little while after. Seen contacts have their own update rate, 20 seconds by default.

What this means in play
Flying under radar no longer shows you just because an enemy is nearby. If nobody spots you, you stay off their map. Flying inside a cloud, the sun and blind spots now hide you from the whole enemy side, not just the one pilot. Keeping your eyes on a contact helps your team.

Plain dots
Each arena can choose, for each type of contact, to show full detail or just a plain dot. Full detail is plane type and heading, as now. A dot tells you something is there but not what it is or where it is going. So an arena could show radar contacts as dots and seen contacts in full detail.

Your own side does not change. Friendly planes still show with full detail.

GVs may also be able to show as seen contacts. That would be an arena setting.

HiTech
Is this the what is in effect?
Title: Re: Current radar settings
Post by: atlau on November 12, 2026, 08:41:29 PM
When you say blind spot does that include blind spots due to terrain/mountains blocking the radar?
Title: Re: Current radar settings
Post by: Dadtallica on November 12, 2026, 09:03:55 PM
I’m eating a little humble pie here… I kinda like the radar it’s grown on me a little bit and the new changes are helpful.

Smaller dots is all
Title: Re: Current radar settings
Post by: Eagler on November 13, 2026, 06:43:36 AM
Like the dots  :aok

As asked above does mountains block dar now?

Eagler
Title: Re: Current radar settings
Post by: hitech on November 13, 2026, 07:03:35 AM
Is this the what is in effect?

I believe so yes. but please do what I ask please tell me what you think that means and what you see.
because there's always a possibility of a bug or a misunderstanding.
HiTech
Title: Re: Current radar settings
Post by: LilMak on November 13, 2026, 08:24:50 AM
I believe so yes. but please do what I ask please tell me what you think that means and what you see.
because there's always a possibility of a bug or a misunderstanding.
HiTech
Just wanted to make sure my expectations are what they should be.

What I noticed specifically.

Within the radar rings. Enemy aircraft are being pinged in the 20 second radar interval whether the radar is up or down. When up. Dots show but icons as well and fade back into a dot. This seems to happen when there is a friendly aircraft in icon distance or not. I was on/near the runway with the radar down and bombers were being painted as they crossed the radar ring. There were no other aircraft on that side of the ring.

Also, I was within an enemy’s airspace and the enemy aircraft were showing up with the 20 second delay where no one was within visual range. Specifically I was with my team and all friendly aircraft were well south of the airfield. About 1/2 a radar rings distance north of that airfield I could see a lone contact pinging every 20 seconds traveling to the NW. The distance to the closest friend from that target was about one ring radius away (10ish miles). No one could’ve possibly been in icon range of that aircraft let alone “seen” them.

Later I was relatively close to an enemy base, not looking at the runway at all. And a friendly M3 alerted me to an airplane on the runway. Brought up the clipboard and I could see the radar icon while that plane was on the ground. The friendly M3 couldn’t “see” them as they were on the opposite side of the town from the field. When I looked, I saw the plane spawned but not moving on the runway over my left shoulder. To be clear. I never saw the aircraft until I looked over my shoulder (7 o’clock after rolling my wing) and my plane was facing in a direction where my field of view would’ve never inadvertently caught them. I was the only aircraft in the sky within 4 sectors.

Outside any radar ring, the radar seems to act as you described but I can’t be positive. Inside any ring (friendly or enemy) radar seems to pick up all contacts with icons regardless of whether it’s a friendly ring or an enemy ring.

I’m not positive but, based on the observed behavior of the icons and the distances they’re showing up, I would guess that radar rings themselves are painting all aircraft within them at twenty second intervals and they’re doing so whenever any aircraft (friend or foe) is within the ring. But it only seems to happen when you’re within the radar ring. This is just a guess. My other guess would be that the “radar bubble” around aircraft/GV are painting icons on the clipboard well beyond visual range and having nothing to do with anyone actually picking them up visually.
Title: Re: Current radar settings
Post by: hitech on November 13, 2026, 08:47:59 AM
Take some screen shots please, what you described is not what I have ever seen during my testing. And any 20 sec ping and fade is always a "seen" and not radar.

Also note, people in towers can also see.

HiTech
Title: Re: Current radar settings
Post by: LilMak on November 13, 2026, 09:07:21 AM
Take some screen shots please, what you described is not what I have ever seen during my testing. And any 20 sec ping and fade is always a "seen" and not radar.

Also note, people in towers can also see.

HiTech
Wilco. I’ll take some shots and maybe a video or two (if I can remember how to do it).
Title: Re: Current radar settings
Post by: Dadtallica on November 13, 2026, 09:18:28 AM
Brought up the clipboard and I could see the radar icon while that plane was on the ground.

So lame using the clipboard!!! :rofl :cheers:
Title: Re: Current radar settings
Post by: hitech on November 13, 2026, 10:48:45 AM
Wilco. I’ll take some shots and maybe a video or two (if I can remember how to do it).

Video will not help as much as a simple alt print screen, save with paint or the aces high screen shot key

HiTech
Title: Re: Current radar settings
Post by: popeye on November 13, 2026, 10:55:42 AM
It seems that "Seen Contacts" are shown at dot range, rather than icon range as before for the "proximity dar".  Is that right?
Title: Re: Current radar settings
Post by: LilMak on November 13, 2026, 10:56:58 AM
Video will not help as much as a simple alt print screen, save with paint or the aces high screen shot key

HiTech
Ok thanks. AH combo something I can ask crew chief?
Title: Re: Current radar settings
Post by: hitech on November 13, 2026, 10:58:59 AM
LilMak, CAV: I think what you are seeing is how "seen" works, so here are the rules.

A contact is "seen" when any friendly player sees it:
- That friendly can be in flight or in the tower, and that includes you. Sitting on the runway or in the tower, you are seeing for your whole country.
- Seen range is out to dot range, about 7.5 miles in the MA. That is a lot farther than icon range.
- It needs a clear line of sight: not through terrain or clouds, and not in the sun.
- AI planes do not see for anyone.

Radar towers have nothing to do with seen contacts, so dar down does not stop them. Dar down only stops the 5 second radar dots.

A seen contact updates every 20 seconds and stays up to about 35 seconds after the last sighting. That is why a plane that just landed can still show on the clipboard for a bit.

So with dar down at your base and you on the runway, bombers crossing the ring within about 7.5 miles of you are "seen" by you.

If you still see one that nobody within about 7.5 miles could have seen, an alt print screen of the clipboard plus where every friendly was would help me track it down.

HiTech
Title: Re: Current radar settings
Post by: hitech on November 13, 2026, 11:02:20 AM
LilMak: yes, ask Crew Chief to take a screenshot. It saves one and tells you which key is yours for it (Alt+S unless you changed it).

The pictures go in the scrshot folder inside your Aces High III folder.

HiTech
Title: Re: Current radar settings
Post by: LilMak on November 13, 2026, 12:28:33 PM
LilMak, CAV: I think what you are seeing is how "seen" works, so here are the rules.

A contact is "seen" when any friendly player sees it:
- That friendly can be in flight or in the tower, and that includes you. Sitting on the runway or in the tower, you are seeing for your whole country.
- Seen range is out to dot range, about 7.5 miles in the MA. That is a lot farther than icon range.
- It needs a clear line of sight: not through terrain or clouds, and not in the sun.
- AI planes do not see for anyone.

Radar towers have nothing to do with seen contacts, so dar down does not stop them. Dar down only stops the 5 second radar dots.

A seen contact updates every 20 seconds and stays up to about 35 seconds after the last sighting. That is why a plane that just landed can still show on the clipboard for a bit.

So with dar down at your base and you on the runway, bombers crossing the ring within about 7.5 miles of you are "seen" by you.

If you still see one that nobody within about 7.5 miles could have seen, an alt print screen of the clipboard plus where every friendly was would help me track it down.

HiTech
So players are “seeing” well beyond icon range?!??? That would explain a great deal of what I witnessed last night.

If so, that’s extremely disappointing and it should be drawn in from 7.5 miles to no more than icon range. Up until that point, there should be no ability to “see” and determine friend from enemy.

Assuming and equilateral triangle anywhere I look. I can look in 4 different directions in about a second covering almost 56 square miles.
Title: Re: Current radar settings
Post by: Randy1 on November 13, 2026, 03:16:35 PM
I think your new radar is innovative for air to air.

Still, it puts GVs at a bit more disadvantage.   Not only can a plane find a GV looking for the GV's icon, and or using film, the GV has problems seeing the plane now.

Title: Re: Current radar settings
Post by: Eagler on November 13, 2026, 03:20:06 PM
My vision isn't AH vision..I am legally blind without corrective lenses  :old:

Maybe different distances for each player after submitting their last eye examination   :banana:

So if the plane is within range it is seen? Even if it hasn't been by the player..afk,   10k under or above etc..

Eagler
Title: Re: Current radar settings
Post by: CAV on November 13, 2026, 03:35:57 PM
Quote
Seen range is out to dot range, about 7.5 miles in the MA.


I'm reading this as...


At about 7.5 miles The game has rendered a flight of aircraft Out of Icon range. But I may not have personally detected it because of ground clutter or I'm just not looking in the right damn direction or spot.
Title: Re: Current radar settings
Post by: atlau on November 13, 2026, 04:56:36 PM
I think your new radar is innovative for air to air.

Still, it puts GVs at a bit more disadvantage.   Not only can a plane find a GV looking for the GV's icon, and or using film, the GV has problems seeing the plane now.

On a separate note I've noticed flakpanzees shooting me thru the trees. Is the foliage visibility different when on the ground vs the air?
Title: Re: Current radar settings
Post by: LilMak on November 13, 2026, 05:23:04 PM
My vision isn't AH vision..I am legally blind without corrective lenses  :old:

Maybe different distances for each player after submitting their last eye examination   :banana:

So if the plane is within range it is seen? Even if it hasn't been by the player..afk,   10k under or above etc..

Eagler
Sounds to me like everywhere you “look” the players plane/tank “sees” 7.5 miles if nothing is in the way. So, an AFK player facing forward paints a radar picture in a cone the size of their field of view (at least 90 degrees) 7.5 miles in front of them whether they’re in icon range or not. Basically we went from icon AWACS to double that distance. I believe the cons are measured in yards so 6k is about 3.5 miles. We’re “seeing” enemies at more than double that range now. 56 square miles of fading radar from every player in any equipment.

For a little bit context. If a GV on the beach looks up at the right time, they can paint a B-29 formation on radar at 39000ft.
Title: Re: Current radar settings
Post by: Wiley on November 13, 2026, 05:26:03 PM
I think dot distance is a bit long.  I think it should be icon range.

Wiley.
Title: Re: Current radar settings
Post by: Lazerr on November 13, 2026, 05:26:47 PM
Sounds to me like everywhere you “look” the players plane/tank “sees” 7.5 miles if nothing is in the way. So, an AFK player facing forward paints a radar picture in a cone the size of their field of view (at least 90 degrees) 7.5 miles in front of them whether they’re in icon range or not. Basically we went from icon AWACS to double that distance. I believe the cons are measured in yards so 6k is about 3.4 miles. We’re “seeing” enemies at almost double that range now. 56 square miles of fading radar from every player in any equipment.

For a little bit context. If a GV on the beach looks up at the right time, they can paint a B-29 formation on radar at 39000ft.

Not through the cockpit, clouds ect.
Title: Re: Current radar settings
Post by: hitech on November 13, 2026, 05:27:41 PM
AFP players cannot see
Title: Re: Current radar settings
Post by: Lazerr on November 13, 2026, 05:41:24 PM
AFP players cannot see

So really the ability of the sight is also highly related to the cockpit of the plane and vehicle?

  Also meaning if its pitched up in a climb, anything under the nose isn't seen?
Title: Re: Current radar settings
Post by: Wiley on November 13, 2026, 05:44:10 PM
*wheels in head turn*  *smoke starts to rise*

If it's doing LOS checks for every player in the game...

Could it do LOS radar?  Actual more realistic NOE?

Wiley.
Title: Re: Current radar settings
Post by: hitech on November 14, 2026, 08:52:59 AM
I must have locked by a miss click, my mistake.

HiTech
Title: Re: Current radar settings
Post by: Dadtallica on November 14, 2026, 09:31:38 AM
I must have locked by a miss click, my mistake.

HiTech

You did the right thing the first time!
Title: Re: Current radar settings
Post by: popeye on November 14, 2026, 10:44:32 AM
FWIW, it seems to me that the 7.5 mile range for "seen contacts" is too far.  We can scan through views while watching the clipboard and "see" the enemy without ever seeing the dot.  There was some discussion of requiring "reporting" the seen contact with a button press (or something).  Maybe that, or just reduce the "seen contact" range to icon range as it was before the recent changes.

( Some players can see dots way before I do.  Screen resolution?  Ancient eyes? )

In any case, I think the recent changes are definite improvements.   :aok
Title: Re: Current radar settings
Post by: Dadtallica on November 14, 2026, 12:25:27 PM
I’m still working on this humble pie I have… I sort of liked the new set up  :uhoh
Title: Re: Current radar settings
Post by: Eagler on November 14, 2026, 02:16:48 PM
So really the ability of the sight is also highly related to the cockpit of the plane and vehicle?

  Also meaning if its pitched up in a climb, anything under the nose isn't seen?

I think it's a super 360 degree vision with anything in that range being displayed on dar now..

I think that's too much unless all contacts are a gray color until they are inside icon range and can be positively identified as friend or foe..

Eagler
Title: Re: Current radar settings
Post by: popeye on November 14, 2026, 02:47:06 PM

I think that's too much unless all contacts are a gray color until they are inside icon range and can be positively identified as friend or foe..

Eagler

If they are friend, they are displayed everywhere all the time.
Title: Re: Current radar settings
Post by: Eagler on November 14, 2026, 03:11:08 PM
If they are friend, they are displayed everywhere all the time.

Which isn't accurate imo...

Should be a 3rd color icon as unrecognized until it is..

And the super vision icons range should be corrected imo too..

We've got the big red and green bars..how much more is needed..

Eagler
Title: Re: Current radar settings
Post by: Dadtallica on November 14, 2026, 03:58:26 PM
FFS we don’t need more colors.

The updates were a nice improvement. Just leave it.
Title: Re: Current radar settings
Post by: LilMak on November 14, 2026, 05:11:17 PM
FWIW, it seems to me that the 7.5 mile range for "seen contacts" is too far.  We can scan through views while watching the clipboard and "see" the enemy without ever seeing the dot.  There was some discussion of requiring "reporting" the seen contact with a button press (or something).  Maybe that, or just reduce the "seen contact" range to icon range as it was before the recent changes.

( Some players can see dots way before I do.  Screen resolution?  Ancient eyes? )

In any case, I think the recent changes are definite improvements.   :aok
I believe that if we walk back the “seen contacts” to normal icon range (3.4miles), we’ll be in the goldy locks zone.
Title: Re: Current radar settings
Post by: Mol on November 14, 2026, 05:17:01 PM
If so, that’s extremely disappointing and it should be drawn in from 7.5 miles to no more than icon range. Up until that point, there should be no ability to “see” and determine friend from enemy.

You can determine enemy well beyond icon range, if you see a dot in the distance, you check the map, if there isn't a corresponding friendly, then you know it is an enemy.

I recently called a warning for enemy bombers, all I saw was 3 dots in formation, I checked radar, no friendly bombers.

That's what appears to be modelled with the current radar, dot range, not icon range.

MoL
Title: Re: Current radar settings
Post by: Mol on November 14, 2026, 05:21:40 PM
I believe that if we walk back the “seen contacts” to normal icon range (3.4miles), we’ll be in the goldy locks zone.

Icon range is too close, if you said dot range that would just being the same capability a human observer already has.

Even at dot range it is easy to tell which dots are friendly or enemy. If we can do it the AI observers should also.

Heck, I can even see a furbal as only dots in the distance, check the radar and be pretty sure which dots are friendly and which are enemy and which friendlies need help or not.

MoL
Title: Re: Current radar settings
Post by: LilMak on November 14, 2026, 05:35:42 PM
You can determine enemy well beyond icon range, if you see a dot in the distance, you check the map, if there isn't a corresponding friendly, then you know it is an enemy.

MoL
Yes you can. But that takes a bit of work and intelligence and shouldn’t be automatic. Icon range seems more like a  fair distance.

Literally found a parked goon last night because my clipboard “see” it before I could ever actually put eyes on it. Likely would’ve never found him otherwise. As it stands right now, I can “see” for my entire country 56 square miles while I text my wife. That seems a bit of a stretch.
Title: Re: Current radar settings
Post by: Mol on November 14, 2026, 06:27:53 PM
Yes you can. But that takes a bit of work and intelligence and shouldn’t be automatic. Icon range seems more like a  fair distance.

Literally found a parked goon last night because my clipboard “see” it before I could ever actually put eyes on it. Likely would’ve never found him otherwise. As it stands right now, I can “see” for my entire country 56 square miles while I text my wife. That seems a bit of a stretch.

I thought it was supposed to be modelling the Observers and Sentries normal at every military base.

Those guys had binoculars and were equipped with mechanical sighting instruments that could provide the position of the aircraft with map grid coordinates, height, time, and number of aircraft for each sighting. They were well trained and highly skilled, lives depended on them so they were alert! They never texted their wives :rofl

Icon range is intended to be the distance at which a visual observer could identify the aircraft type using the unaided Mk1 eyeball. In reality observers were able to spot and warn of approaching enemy well before dot range so that is already a compromise.

A base command remaining unaware of an attack until icon range would have about a three second warning or less before bombs were falling... They would have been issuing court marshals.

MoL
Title: Re: Current radar settings
Post by: thndregg on November 15, 2026, 08:19:15 AM
All I know is..  while I was spacing out while there was an enemy darbar in the sector with me deep into and high above Rookland, I was suddenly jolted out of my daydreaming by the sounds of 50 cal. working my B29's all over at 30+K. Looking out front, and not behind me, no pinpoint contact on the map.

Checked my six. There was Skishill in his jug, parked right on my a**, ventilating my lead plane from wingtip to wing tip.. POOF!  :D

I had it coming. He earned it. :airplane: Head on a swivel, people.. head on a swivel.

Good change back to something we had ages ago, HiTech..  :cool: I like it.
Title: Re: Current radar settings
Post by: LilMak on November 15, 2026, 11:17:33 AM
I thought it was supposed to be modelling the Observers and Sentries normal at every military base.

Those guys had binoculars and were equipped with mechanical sighting instruments that could provide the position of the aircraft with map grid coordinates, height, time, and number of aircraft for each sighting. They were well trained and highly skilled, lives depended on them so they were alert! They never texted their wives :rofl

Icon range is intended to be the distance at which a visual observer could identify the aircraft type using the unaided Mk1 eyeball. In reality observers were able to spot and warn of approaching enemy well before dot range so that is already a compromise.

A base command remaining unaware of an attack until icon range would have about a three second warning or less before bombs were falling... They would have been issuing court marshals.

MoL
All cool I guess. But what is being seen is driven by the pilot. Not guys on the ground with binoculars. Why would canopy frames, wings, clouds, all block “seen contacts”? There is zero possibility that a pilot could identify friendly from enemy at over seven miles. ZERO. Now the game clipboard might help with that because friendlies are painted on it 100% of the time at any distance. But that doesn’t excuse the same thing for enemy equipment.

At 7.5 miles every plane and GV if essentially a radar tower that is 3/4 the size of the actual radar circle for “seen contacts”. There appears to be no delay in how quickly a “seen contact” manifests. So I can literally run a 360 on my hat switch in less than a second and paint everything I can “see” on the clipboard for 20 seconds over 56 square miles from the dirt to 40000ft.

Mol. Essentially what you’re trying to sell me is that you can go outside, do a Wonder Woman spin, and plot exactly where every airplane in the sky is on a piece of paper from the surface to 40000ft. Not only that, but you can tell me which ones are Gulfstreams and which are 737 and which are Delta, American, or Southwest.

I know we’re playing a game and there are concessions. But this game is also supposed grounded somewhat in reality. I’m suspending my take on reality if we can drawn in “seen contacts” to 3.4 miles (icon range). Then I accept all the Wonder Woman spin plotting.

My reasoning is simple. For every additional mile you can “see”, the square miles your field of view covers is tripled.
Title: Re: Current radar settings
Post by: Dadtallica on November 15, 2026, 11:24:04 AM
Dude just quit already. Good grief!
Title: Re: Current radar settings
Post by: LilMak on November 15, 2026, 11:28:44 AM
Dude just quit already. Good grief!
No.
Title: Re: Current radar settings
Post by: hazmatt on November 15, 2026, 11:51:08 AM
Dude just quit already. Good grief!

There's a way to get the numbers up!

Curious if you treat new players the same...
Title: Re: Current radar settings
Post by: Dadtallica on November 15, 2026, 12:17:43 PM
There's a way to get the numbers up!

Curious if you treat new players the same...

lol easy troll… you do nothing here but talk about “the game you play” while I and others actively promote this one daily… for free!

With all the time you spend here there is absolutely no reason for not playing other than spite.

Mak isn’t new here and even if he was and spent 18 pages going on and on and on about a radar perfectly subjective to him then I would also tell the new guy to take down a step.

It’s getting to the point where it’s just over the top.

I won’t be responding to whatever silliness you come back with. Go play “your game” and have a nice day.
Title: Re: Current radar settings
Post by: Mol on November 15, 2026, 03:29:17 PM
All cool I guess. But what is being seen is driven by the pilot. Not guys on the ground with binoculars.

No, it is also being driven by guys on the ground in the tower, as stated here:

A contact is "seen" when any friendly player sees it:
- That friendly can be in flight or in the tower
- Seen range is out to dot range, about 7.5 miles in the MA.

So the real question is could someone in the tower see an aircraft at 7.5 miles.

Anyone on the ground looking for enemy aircraft would almost certainly be a lookout and thus using binoculars so the question is easy to answer using wartime sources.

The most useful source is the US Navy's Lookout Manual, published in 1943, which provides specific figures for the detection of aircraft both with the naked eye and using binoculars.

On page 33, the manual states:

Quote
A good lookout can sight planes at 6,000 yards with his naked eye, and at two or three times that range with binoculars.

Converting those distances into statute miles gives:

Naked eye: 3.4 miles

Binoculars: between 6.8 and 10.2 miles


This is particularly interesting because the 3.4 mile icon limit corresponds almost exactly to the US Navy's figure for naked-eye detection. However, the same wartime manual explicitly states that using binoculars extends the detection range to as much as three times that distance at 10.2 miles, significantly farther than the current dot setting.

If you take the average value using binoculars it is 8.5 miles so the existing 7.5 mile dot range is already conservative.

Naturally, detection distances would vary with visibility, atmospheric conditions, aircraft size, aspect, background and the observer's ability.

Nevertheless, the historical evidence establishes that trained wartime observers equipped with binoculars could sight aircraft considerably farther away than 7.5 miles and as far as 10.2 miles.

Then I accept all the Wonder Woman spin plotting.
My reasoning is simple. For every additional mile you can “see”, the square miles your field of view covers is tripled.

Sorry, it just looks to me as if your reference to square miles and wonder woman are both entirely irrelevant and don't even make any sense.

However, using wartime sources:

In view of the 10.2 mile value, the 7.5-mile detection range is therefore quite reasonable. In fact, it falls towards the lower end of the 6.8–10.2-mile range given in the 1943 US Navy manual.

This provides strong historical support for 7.5 miles as an already conservative range for a lookout in the tower.

Later evidence based on visibility trials suggests bombers could be seen with the naked eye as far away as 15 miles.

MoL
Title: Re: Current radar settings
Post by: LilMak on November 15, 2026, 04:19:03 PM
No, it is also being driven by guys on the ground in the tower, as stated here:

So the real question is could someone in the tower see an aircraft at 7.5 miles.
 :banana:
Anyone on the ground looking for enemy aircraft would almost certainly be a lookout and thus using binoculars so the question is easy to answer using wartime sources.

The most useful source is the US Navy's Lookout Manual, published in 1943, which provides specific figures for the detection of aircraft both with the naked eye and using binoculars.

On page 33, the manual states:

Converting those distances into statute miles gives:

Naked eye: 3.4 miles

Binoculars: between 6.8 and 10.2 miles


This is particularly interesting because the 3.4 mile icon limit corresponds almost exactly to the US Navy's figure for naked-eye detection. However, the same wartime manual explicitly states that using binoculars extends the detection range to as much as three times that distance at 10.2 miles, significantly farther than the current dot setting.

If you take the average value using binoculars it is 8.5 miles so the existing 7.5 mile dot range is already conservative.

Naturally, detection distances would vary with visibility, atmospheric conditions, aircraft size, aspect, background and the observer's ability.

Nevertheless, the historical evidence establishes that trained wartime observers equipped with binoculars could sight aircraft considerably farther away than 7.5 miles and as far as 10.2 miles.

Sorry, it just looks to me as if your reference to square miles and wonder woman are both entirely irrelevant and don't even make any sense.

However, using wartime sources:

In view of the 10.2 mile value, the 7.5-mile detection range is therefore quite reasonable. In fact, it falls towards the lower end of the 6.8–10.2-mile range given in the 1943 US Navy manual.

This provides strong historical support for 7.5 miles as an already conservative range for a lookout in the tower.

Later evidence based on visibility trials suggests bombers could be seen with the naked eye as far away as 15 miles.

MoL
I concede view from the ground in the tower. I do not concede view from the air.

So pilots in the tower can “see” 7.5 miles. In the sky they can “see” 3.4.

Or…hear me out…since already have a 10 mile radar ring, and pilots don’t fly with binoculars taped to their head, we set it at 3.4 for simplicity.
Title: Re: Current radar settings
Post by: popeye on November 15, 2026, 04:35:48 PM
I believe that the "seen distance" applies everywhere -- not just over friendly territory where there could be observers with binoculars.
Title: Re: Current radar settings
Post by: Eagler on November 15, 2026, 04:51:09 PM
Hitech will issue everyone a pair of super binoculars so that this change is then accurate   :banana:  :airplane:  :banana:

Eagler
Title: Re: Current radar settings
Post by: Mol on November 15, 2026, 06:33:34 PM
Or…hear me out…since already have a 10 mile radar ring, and pilots don’t fly with binoculars taped to their head, we set it at 3.4 for simplicity.

Nope, the problem isn't that simple at all.

When you think about translating human visual acuity onto a screen in pixels the problems faced by developers is much more difficult. The main problem is great distances and limited screen resolution at different viewing angles. That's why early sim's used to show enemy aircraft magnified to compensate. At typical viewing distances and fields of view, ordinary monitors cannot reproduce the full resolving power of human vision. So there isn't one clean answer, different developers have different solutions and make different compromises, there is no single correct spotting distance that solves it. The reality is that ordinary rendering makes distant aircraft disappear because their dimensions become smaller than individual pixels. The developers therefore introduced special rendering methods to compensate.

So I decided to take a look at what visual distance was being used in other Sim's to model what the eye can really see, for comparison.

DCS is considered to be realistic, and one particularly useful observation on their forums comes from 31 October 2024. A player named YoYo reported testing fighter versus fighter visibility in VR, finding an enemy fighter visible at 27 nautical miles in cloudless weather. That is: 31.1 miles.

In War thunder fighter to fighter visibility is reported up to 20km (12.4 miles) but some players reports show longer ranges are possible. For example in August 2025 a player verified enemy dot visibility against radar distance at 20 km (12.4 miles). Then in January 2026 there was a community report involving larger aircraft visible at 25 km (15.5 miles). Again in January 2026 a player reported a visual spotting test visibility up to 30 km (18.6 miles).

So the evidence shows that other developers have adopted considerably different solutions to the problem of representing human vision on a computer screen.

DCS has reported fighter spotting distances exceeding 30 miles, while War Thunder players have reported visual detection at 12 miles and sometimes considerably farther.

That doesn't prove those distances are realistic, nor does it prove that HTC's shorter ranges are more realistic. It does demonstrate that this is a difficult simulation problem for which developers have adopted different compromises. The reports suggest that HTC may already be using substantially shorter spotting distances than other simulators, potentially making long range visual detection more challenging.

That last sentence bears repeating... HTC are already using significantly lower spotting distances thus already providing a more challenging visual experience.

So simply declaring that pilots didn't carry binoculars and therefore visual detection should stop at 3.4 miles isn't a technical argument for that distance on a computer screen. There needs to be some evidence that it would better reproduce what a real pilot could see. In fact, the evidence shows that other developers have considered much greater spotting distances necessary or acceptable in their simulations.

MoL
Title: Re: Current radar settings
Post by: Dadtallica on November 15, 2026, 08:09:46 PM
It’s plenty real enough!
Title: Re: Current radar settings
Post by: popeye on November 16, 2026, 07:10:04 AM
<snip>

That doesn't prove those distances are realistic, nor does it prove that HTC's shorter ranges are more realistic. It does demonstrate that this is a difficult simulation problem for which developers have adopted different compromises. The reports suggest that HTC may already be using substantially shorter spotting distances than other simulators, potentially making long range visual detection more challenging.

<snip>

MoL

I haven't played other games.   Do they light up the "seen" enemy contact on a map that all other players can see?
Title: Re: Current radar settings
Post by: AKIron on November 16, 2026, 08:09:07 AM
In real life your eyes don't focus from in front of your face to infinity without you changing your focus. This effect cannot be reproduced on a flat screen. And of course VR is just two flat screens offset to produce the illusion of distance.

My point being if there is a dot on your screen representing an aircraft at any range you will see it on a flat screen. In real life, maybe not.
Title: Re: Current radar settings
Post by: AKIron on November 16, 2026, 08:15:55 AM

AI Overview

No, you generally cannot see an aircraft clearly at long range if your eyes are not focused at that distance due to empty field myopia, where a lack of visual cues causes the eyes to automatically relax to a short resting focal length (usually 10 to 30 feet).

Scientific Mechanisms

• Empty Field Myopia: In a featureless or open sky with no objects, clouds, or textured gradients to lock onto, the eye's lens defaults to a relaxed state of about 10 to 30 feet (or roughly 1 meter in a dark focus state).
• Focal Mismatch: Because your eyes are focused close up, distant objects like a high-altitude or approaching aircraft will appear blurred, distorted, or completely invisible even if they sit directly in your line of sight.
• Foveal vs. Peripheral Vision: The central part of your eye (the fovea, covering about 1°) is required to see and recognize small, sharp objects like an aircraft at a distance. Your peripheral vision is great for catching motion, but an aircraft on a head-on or constant-bearing collision course shows almost no relative motion until it is dangerously close.
Title: Re: Current radar settings
Post by: AKIron on November 16, 2026, 08:19:36 AM
My second point being don't try to translate spotting an enemy in a simulation to real life without understanding there is a big difference.
Title: Re: Current radar settings
Post by: LilMak on November 16, 2026, 08:54:51 AM
Nope, the problem isn't that simple at all.

MoL
It is, in fact, that simple. Simply draw in how far an AH pilot can identify friend from foe in the MA to 6k. What it’s been from day one. I don’t care about what happens in DCS or Grand Theft Auto.

It’s one thing to see a dot on the horizon. It’s something completely different to positively identify that dot and plot it on the clipboard for everyone to see. Part of institution of these adjustments was to pull back how much real time information is given while balancing out the ability to find combat.

A couple nights ago I looked right, didn’t see anything, and then there was a bomber icon on my clipboard. The icon was about five or six miles out. I flew to it, didn’t see anything, and figured out it was a goon sitting on the ground. The problem with the “seen contacts” being extended so far is that the slant vertical visibility I have from my cockpit. It basically covers everything from the ground to infinity and there is no window where any NOE or high aircraft can sneak past me and, by clipboard extension, anyone else on my team. Had the “seen contacts” been drawn into 3.4 miles, I never would’ve been able to find that poor goon. Had I flown over it at a 3.4 mile range, there’s a chance that he might’ve been hidden by my cowling and/or wings. Now, if the goal is simply to paint everything on the clipboard at 20 second intervals, just do it. No need to make it a “seen contact.” As of right now, every piece of manned equipment has the ability to paint “seen contacts” on the clipboard at 3/4 the coverage of a radar ring. Given the typical distance between bases in the MA, it’s effectively providing zero avenues for approaching enemy airspace without being “seen” regardless of altitude.

If we’re not going to bring it in from 7.5 miles, then I think there needs to be delay added to how long I look at a patch of sky before it gets reported. So, if I just happen to look over my shoulder for a second, I don’t paint everything on the clipboard for 20 square miles. But that makes everything more complicated.

The simplest solution is just to draw “seen contacts” to icon range. It’s easy to understand and still provides the ability to find combat without overly hampering the strategy of non-fighter aircraft. Do that and I’m happy with the radar compromise and will let my arguments rest.
Title: Re: Current radar settings
Post by: atlau on November 16, 2026, 10:29:03 AM
I don't know if reducing SA has been beneficial. It seems to further favor high speed high alt fighters blowing thru. It would be interesting to compare kill and aircraft stats to previous tours.
Title: Re: Current radar settings
Post by: Animl-AW on November 16, 2026, 12:28:45 PM
This catering to one player is way out of hand

More is never enough. Solve this problem there will be a new one the next day

Enough already
Get over it
Title: Re: Current radar settings
Post by: Mol on November 16, 2026, 12:46:49 PM
If we’re not going to bring it in from 7.5 miles, then I think there needs to be delay added

Just checked the arena settings after todays update.

It looks as though the SeenPlaneRange is currently set at 5.1 miles with a 20 second delay.

Things change faster than I can keep up LOL

MoL
Title: Re: Current radar settings
Post by: Eagler on November 16, 2026, 12:55:39 PM
Just checked the arena settings after todays update.

It looks as though the SeenPlaneRange is currently set at 5.1 miles with a 20 second delay.

Things change faster than I can keep up LOL

MoL

Sounds like an interesting setting..

Eagler
Title: Re: Current radar settings
Post by: Lazerr on November 16, 2026, 05:50:39 PM
Sounds like an interesting setting..

Eagler

I think 5 is perfect for this, maybe even 4. 

If you set it to icon range, you basically have the same dar as before, minus having to be looking in that direction.

Haven't tried to kill a radar tower yet.. if its a still the same setting prior to these changes, its too soft.
Title: Re: Current radar settings
Post by: Badboy on November 16, 2026, 06:29:20 PM
I don't know if reducing SA has been beneficial. It seems to further favor high speed high alt fighters blowing thru. It would be interesting to compare kill and aircraft stats to previous tours.

A good point, it got me thinking.

There's another aspect to this discussion that I think deserves consideration, and that's the influence of gameplay on the visibility settings we prefer.

Aces High is a unique combination of air combat simulation and strategic warfare. Players can pursue very different objectives, and those objectives sometimes create conflicting preferences about how the game should work.

For example, fighter pilots generally want to find enemy aircraft and engage them. For them, good visibility and information about enemy activity help create opportunities for combat.

On the other hand, players flying bombers, ground attack aircraft or operating vehicles may have very different priorities. They can achieve high scores and rankings by destroying ground targets, factories, radar installations and other strategic objectives. For many of those missions, the ideal outcome is to reach the target undetected, destroy it or capture it without ever encountering an enemy player.

In real warfare that's obviously desirable. Accomplishing your objectives without suffering losses is a success. But whether that's equally desirable in a multiplayer combat game is another question.

I've recently seen the MA with around 20 players online, all apparently pursuing their own objectives with almost no combat occurring between them. Everyone may be achieving something, contributing to the war effort, but with very little or no direct interaction between the players.

That raises an important question about what makes Aces High enjoyable and keeps players coming back.

The strategic element is valuable, but I would argue that it works best when it creates opportunities for combat. Bombing raids provide opportunities for interception, ground attacks generate defensive responses, and battles for territory bring opposing forces together. In my view, the strategic game and the combat simulation should complement each other.

The difficulty arises when the most effective way of achieving objectives is also to avoid contact with other players. The scoring and ranking systems can reward activities that produce little or no direct combat. That's not necessarily wrong, but it can create incentives that conflict with the interests of players who primarily come online to fight.

I suspect this conflict of interests influences our preferences about visibility. Players who want to find combat are likely to favour better detection, while those who want to complete missions without interception may prefer greater opportunities for concealment. Neither preference is inherently bad or even unreasonable, and I'm not suggesting that anyone advocating shorter detection ranges necessarily has that motive.

There's also the question of realism. Concealment, surprise and reconnaissance are all important aspects of warfare. Aircraft operating at low altitude against a terrain background should sometimes be difficult to detect, and terrain masking should provide real opportunities for avoiding observation.

But equally, military forces employ observers, reconnaissance and communications specifically to locate and report enemy activity. More observers generally provide better coverage, and pilots can communicate sightings directly through voice or text, irrespective of what appears on the clipboard. Restricting automatic reports doesn't eliminate those advantages.

Ultimately, I think we're dealing with a gameplay balance problem rather than simply a question of visual acuity.

Particularly with the relatively small player population we have today, finding opponents and generating encounters is important. If we make enemy activity more difficult to locate, we risk creating even more situations where players are online with fewer opportunities to encounter one another.

In real warfare, most military personnel spent only a small proportion of their time actually fighting. Reproducing that level of inactivity might be historically realistic, but it wouldn't necessarily make for enjoyable gameplay. There's an important distinction between making combat itself realistic and reproducing the historically low frequency of combat.

I believe that more opportunities for meaningful player interaction generally make Aces High more enjoyable, encouraging existing players to stay and new players to subscribe. More players then create more opportunities for interaction, producing a virtuous cycle that benefits everyone.

Unfortunately, the reverse is also possible. Fewer encounters can make the game less enjoyable, causing players to leave, which further reduces opportunities for interaction. That becomes a vicious cycle of declining player numbers and activity.

Of course, stealth and strategic operations are important parts of the game, and combat shouldn't be unavoidable. But we need to be careful that changes intended to improve realism or protect particular styles of play don't inadvertently reduce the interaction that makes multiplayer gaming attractive.

The objective should be realistic combat, not necessarily a realistic scarcity of combat.

For me, the priority should be a system that preserves realistic opportunities for concealment while encouraging encounters, interceptions, defensive responses and combat.

After all, the central attraction of a multiplayer air combat game is surely the opportunity to engage other human players. If we make it increasingly easy for everyone to avoid one another, we risk undermining the very thing that makes multiplayer combat different from flying offline.

We all have strong views about what's realistic and what we'd personally prefer, but are those preferences necessarily what's best for the game as a whole?

Badboy
Title: Re: Current radar settings
Post by: hitech on November 16, 2026, 08:44:08 PM
bad boys right up which is rather good condensed to my words. Aceshigh is a game that's meant to be fun and fair ,war is meant to be neither.

HiTech
Title: Re: Current radar settings
Post by: hazmatt on November 16, 2026, 08:52:28 PM
I haven't played other games.   Do they light up the "seen" enemy contact on a map that all other players can see?

Depends on game. Some don't have icons at all. Some you have to mark on the map. Some do light up an enemy contact for the team but not in the way that AH3 does. Even on the ones that do light up for the team it is still possible to terrain mask and to come up from below or behind somebody or to close in at such a high speed that you're on top of them before you are detected.
Title: Re: Current radar settings
Post by: Rubicon on November 16, 2026, 08:57:09 PM
I have enjoyed the changes and look forward to seeing what the latest iteration brings.

I play only for fighter combat.  I have no idea how bombing works and even my jabo bombing skills are incredibly bad, I am here to shoot at other planes.  My poor colour vision means the ground game is unplayable for me, I simply cannot distinguish between a tank and a bush  :)

I have enjoyed the less complete information given by the clipboard.  I have been bounced a few times and bounced a few.  It adds more excitement IMO.
Title: Re: Current radar settings
Post by: Dadtallica on November 16, 2026, 09:34:37 PM
Also liking the new changes after much complaining lol.

Casting my vote for smaller dots…