Not making the argument here that picking is wrong. Trying to make the case for "clearing" (shooting the guy off one's Six) as opposed to "picking" (shooting the guy off one's Twelve). And that team can survive a furball much better than a lone wolf. And not by running but by fighting to success through effective tactics.
I understand you completely and I'm not making the argument that picking is right. Fighter pilots in WW2 and probably still in this generation learned that all that wingman stuff went out the window many times. They told that once a squad engaged, the fight often ended up spread over hundreds of miles. They frequently got separated from wingman. And here we are trying to prove it didn't have to be that way.
I think with a little organized discipline...
This is my point, too many are trying to organize what has always been better than 50% chaos and it always will be absent some weird controls.
Vinkman is correct with is idea of winging.. it yields the best results most of the time.. #1 engages, #2 engages the next badguy to come jump in #1's fight.. cause that is how it goes down 85% of the time.. the 2nd badguy will totally ignore #2 goodguy to try to pick #1 goodguy... Not saying its right or wrong.. Generally speaking from my observations and people I prefer to wing with.. If I can, I will usually call cover rather than pile in.. Unless it is someone I want to send to the tower or a spit/scavenger type a/c.. Always exceptions.. 8)
Not sure what you mean, best results for who? If you are one of the 1,2,3 and 4 and you can sit there and leisurely bounce all incoming bandits, I'm sure that will work quite well.
I've tended to forget one thing in this issue, my priorities. When I come into this scenario and I see 3 bandits below me and 1 friendly fighting 1 more lower, I'm engaging the three high ones first.
If I'm lower and the 1v1 is coalt, I'll be damned if I'm going to climb to the three bad guys. I'm going after that 1v1.
Why? Because the friendly would just as soon take my kill and if it's you he's fighting, I'm doing him a favor.
I don't want to ask for a fight, I frequently die while typing. And I'm not always in the mood to fly around in circles waiting my turn. Sometimes I do, sometimes I wont.
Those three bad guys up above will soon provide me with the fight I desire without a single word needed.
I like the MA just the way it is, no quarter asked, none given.