Originally posted by Kieran
I totally 100% understand what Mr.Fish (and you) are saying, really, I do.
What I cannot make clear is the concept knowing what will happen is not the same as making something happen.
God said "This will come to pass". From our perspective we can look at it like "God is going to make this happen". Not true. God has seen what will happen and is telling us.
if you create a toy and know
absolutely that if you turn it on it will walk out of your workshop and destroy a grocery store then do you have no liability?
what if you magically infuse it with the freewill to either destroy or spare the grocery store, even though you still know absolutely ahead of time which it will pick.
further, what if, before you enable it to leave you give it your opinion on the way that freewill would be used, knowing all the while he was still going to go out and destroy or spare the store?
do you think you'd have any liability? what if shop owner came back to you with a smoldering awning in one hand and a picture of your toy in the other- would you tell him, "well i gave him choice, it's his fault. of course i knew he'd destroy your awning before i turned him on and set him out the door but he made the choice. i gave him the freewill thing so he'd pick the right choice"
god designed
this world? i get stuck on why a god would enjoy all this drama- why the best use of their power and eternal nature would be to create a little rock where people have the duty to figure out how to live right when you already know how the game will turn out. you'd think they'd be a bit more sophisticated than that.