It is not wether it is OK.
I dont see it as wrong. Maybe not PC, but I dont care about that.
I make racially stereotypical jokes all the times about blacks, whites, jews, irish, italians, germans, etc. But there is a line between a funny racial stereotype, and flat out racism (hate).
Maniac did not cross that line. To me, it is just about offensive about making a joke about a loud American, or a charmingly gay Englishman, or a smart japanese, or the many chinese, or the mexicans in their bodegas, or the snobby french, what have you.
To you, it is only offensive because you are confrontational and you CHOOSE to perceive it as offensive just so you can have a hostile arguement with Maniac (who was only trying to lighten up this thread)
Hortlund, I think you need to take your own advice. Listen to some classical, open a bottle of wine or scotch, and just chill for a while.
With the attitude you are displaying, I dont see how you can be enjoying reading and talking about this. Maybe you enjoy flat out arguing with other people, I dont know. I hope you either dont get married, or find someone who loves it just as much as you do.