I'm going to chime in here, not because I want to, but because I can!
I was a trainer in AW for a short time before it's demise. If you want the whole story of how I became one, ask, but it's too long to post here.
What I experienced as a trainer (perhaps) answers the following:
Originally posted by BTW
Show me films of a player being taken from newbie to a threat. It doesn't exist.
And you will never see them. Here's how it works..
A trainer takes someone who (at ANY level--beginning to advanced) wants to learn to get better. Let's take a beginner, for example. Pilot 1 takes beginning ACM everyday for a few weeks from several different trainers, because the same trainer isn't available every time he comes in. Mr./Ms. 1 has been using this useful information in the MA and has become confident enough and (perhaps) is invited/joins a squad.
The squad makes 1 a better pilot because of winging and squad tactics. Several months/years later, "1" comes back to training because there is a desire to be as good as, or better, than the "perceived best".
"1" is already much better than before, and there is no recordable measure of progress because of the gap in training. Threre's not really a way around that. I suppose you could get films from training "1" (who keeps those?) and compare them to current films shot by "1". That's a tough task, though, considering how many folks go through training..
As for this:
Nobody is going to see you get better than them.
Not true. I saw trainees in AW who started at the basic ACM level I taught to go on to train with Drano, KGann, and others. I had a hard time fighting them.
It is actually one of the rewarding things about me being a trainer--seeing a former student come up and kick butt. I had to re-think some of my flying. Why? Because these students were using the same things I was because we were teaching them how we flew.
It's actually funny when you can identify a (former) student in the main arena by the way he/she flies!
Well, good luck! and when all else fails, have fun!
Wind
--------------
The Damned Air Group
(former) AW Trainer
(former) WWIIOL Head Trainer