This is the first time I've ever heard you say you are merely average. I also wouldn't call you getting 12 kills in a F4U this camp to 124 kills in the Spit XVI you being a diverse pilot
I have always said I am average, you are mistaking that with me saying I fly into above average situations.
As for my plane selections, I made that point, because you think that all I fly is a spit, when in fact I will fly just about everything. I do enjoy turn fightings faster pace then E-fighting so I will log more hours in a knife fighter. I think it still makes my point.
I don't know what planet you are living on but noobs don't E-Fight, they have no concept of E-Fighting, pure E-Fighting is a very subtle thing. You think some guy off the street can march into the MA up an E-Fighter and be able to judge relative E states of 10+ planes at a glance and apply that information to his tactics?
E-fighting is actually the starting place for many a noob. It was mine as well. E-Fighting means keeping up your speed, not over commiting as you put it, keeping good seperation. Because of this the engagements are at a slower pace and your SA doesn't have to be perfect either, because you have seperation, speed and most of the time alt.
As a turn fighter you are usually slower and in tight. you have to be quick becuase you don't have the seperation to slow things down. Add a few more bogys and things get even faster and harder.