Just out of curiousity, Bodhi, do you feel confident that every single person being detained there is a fighter?
I have my doubts, considering that the US paid cash bounties for people described as insurrectionists when they were turned in. For some of the people there, the US was not involved in determining their initial status, and there may have been conflicts of interest that led to people being rounded up and turned in whether or not they were actually combatants.
The people detained by the US military are one thing, and I know and trust that the best effort would be made to only rope the bad guys, but the other folks... a doubt is reasonable and prudent.