I don't think the Me163 could really "dogfight" in the traditional sense at all, so no.
Well, look at the criteria here.. The 163 is so good that it's the exception to even this absolute comparison. It outturns, out guns, out maneuvers and out thrusts everything. Otherwise, I'd say the 262. It decides the fights' outcome.
I think you guys need to constrain this comparison a little more, otherwise the late war optimized air superiority designs make any of the capable approaches like the Zero just benign. The same way the paradigm later shifted to pushing buttons to kill things before they're even visible to the naked eye.
Put Germany and the allies back in WWII, and make it a purely dogfighting war. No attrition by carpet bombing or ground warfare or anything. The Komet just wipes the floor with everything, given 1:1 odds, IMO. This comparison needs better criteria if you're going to rule out the 163.
And making Speed, Range, Firepower the criteria still doesn't rule out the 262 as an arguable alternative to the P51. I also think the Tempest and maybe F4U4 (I've never flown the latter above 25k) beat it on these criteria. The P47N flown that high up is probably also a contender. None of them compare with the 163, though.