Like I said.... hogwash.
Urchin still on your squad forum? Why don't you talk to him about how he likes the game.
How about Nomak? I seem to recall a long post of his a few years ago saying, in essence, he'd accomplished all he could.
Not that I'm even close to being one of the best sticks, but I also end up playing for about three weeks, getting bored, and quitting for three months. It's been going on for some time.
Absolutely not hogwash.