Yes, there's no doubt that that list of guys are the best of the best at the dogfighting aspect of the game. And I'm sure anyone of them will tell you, each one could beat the other on any given day.
But the score monger is also a breed of it's own with a whole different set of game knowlege, skill and goals. Pacerr and Shawk are always at the top of that list. But the fact they choose to play all parts of the game,instead of just the fighter aspect of it, some would say they suck. I don't agree with that.
We all know the fighter role is the most difficult SINGLE aspect of the game to master. To be #1 OVERALL, one has to be good at ALL parts of the game, not just one catagory. To compare Pacerr to Grizz is comparing apples to oranges. They play 2 different games.Because of this, depending on who you ask, one is considered to suck while the other is great. That's not fair. They're both equally skilled AT WHAT THEY DO. If I were to depend on one guy to take a VH down in one jabo pass, I'd want a Shawk or Pacerr to do it. But if I wanted a fighter for sure dead, I'd call on a Delrium or Grizz.