You're kidding right?
How can ONE squad feel its right to dictate what that fleet does or doesn't do???
Unbelievable. Its waaaaaaaaaaay beyond rude and childish.
One Squad??? LOL, you really think that that one squad has absolute control over the carriers? I've seen (and you know you have too) every country use this tactic. I''ll up your rude and childish, with idiocy, hypocrisy and dishonesty. Furthermore, I'll counter it with the treachery of players that reveal the location of carriers to the enemy.
The denial of assets to the enemy is a valid tactic, especially when the port that controls these CV's is in enemy hands. The control of CV's does not in any significant way diminish the ability to find a "good fight" for those whose only interest in the game is to find one. On the other hand, for those whose objectives include "winning the war", their control is a significant advantage.
A CV is a tremendous offensive asset, but it's use will typically lead to its sinking. The use of a CV whose port is controlled by the enemy to attempt the capture of a base, that will most likely result in it's sinking, and therefore being returned to the enemy is strategically foolish. Not only have you at best traded bases, you have given your enemy a resource with which to capture more of your bases.
