I explained why perks + rps would be better for the game.... but no one explained to me why it would not work.
I think because when people log into the game they want to fly:
The plane they want
The time of day they want
On the map they want
And they want to do their activity. fighting, or gv or bombing.
If any of these things are out of wack is seems to cause them to log. (I know some stick it out, but I'm talking about the folks who won't)
If you had
limited time to play and it was a RPS AND you just wanted to fly some very specific plane, You'd be not flying most of the time. Because there is only one Melee arena.
If something is wrong with that arena, the option isn't to just switch arenas. There IS nothing else.
Well, there are other games...
RPS + Perks is based on denying some users what they want in favor of giving them something that is limited plus a reward that many don't care about.
I like seeing all of the ideas, even when I disagree with some of them or even most of them. There may be some really good ones just waiting to be floated. They may even be ones that I don't like.