Originally posted by X2Lee
Riggghttt, then youre point is that all these guys were so stupid that after thier "cult leader" was killed and mocked in front of them that they all would rather die than say he was dead.
They must have all been idiots.
I guess thats kinda your point too.
I would have said hes dead myself.
Unless I saw him alive after he was killed...
No my point is that martyrdom seems to me a lousy indication of the objective truth of a religion. Especially as most of them claim to be the one true religion, and they all have martyrs. Bit of a problem - using this daft "must have 12 martyrs" criteria, all these "one and only true religions" are telling the truth: they are all the only "one true religion".
Patriotism is a good analogy - people are willing to kill and be killed for any cause - it doesn't matter if the cause is just or not - it merely has to be
their country's cause. The number of people willing to die for a cause is no indication of how good the cause is. You seem to be saying that the willingness of several people to die for something they saw is all you need to prove that what they saw is true. I'm saying that your argument is a
non sequitur: most people "see" the sun go down in the evening, and before copernicus, most of christendom would have been prepared to die for what they "saw": the earth is the centre of the universe. The Xian church was certainly prepared to kill for it. Thousands could be killed or kill either way - it wouldn't make the statement "the earth is the centre of the universe" true.