1. What is not honourable in a HO?? Is there something more honourable than giving you the possibility to kill him as well?? If you dont want the HO, simply avoid it, nothing is more easy than that.
2. A smoking planes is absolut combat worthy, specialy a Jug, which can fly very long with a smoking engine.
3. Why you didnt bail??? Its absolut ok to save you live by bailing and it would be absolut not honourable, if he would kill you at the chute.
4. Its absolut not honourable to expect from others(cry for mercy) to let you go as long as your plane is combat worthy. A lost elevator or aleron is a bigger handycap than a just smoked engine.
If your engine was shut out by someone else, or if someone else shot off a wingtip, then imho its not honourable to shoot the other plane down(in most situation i let such guys go).
Or if a plane, damaged by me, is to low for bailing out and obvious wanna ditch, its hounorable to let him do it and dishonourable to shoot him down.
If it was a long "close edge fight" its hobourable to let the damaged enemy go home as price for the great fight.
But its not dishonourable to shoot down a damaged but fully combat worthy plane with a for mercy crying pilot in it, of course its also not very honourable, its simply a thing needed to be done, otherwise the chat will fill up with "mercy cry´s" only cause the graphic show a hole in the wing.
No all things that dont add to the honour are dishonourable!!
Greetings,
Knegel