Originally posted by moot
You know what Humble? I'll take you up on that.
Provided we get it with MK103s, your 38 won't get more than 49% victories against my 410
The gun package wont matter...nothing is gonna out laser the IL-2. The 410 doesnt have the armor or nimbleness of the IL-2 (wingloading 31 lbs/sqf) to really effectively work the reverses. It's not very easy to kill a 38 (even as badly as I fly it) in an A-20, 110 or mossie unless you have alt & E at the beginning. I dont see the 410 being a match for the mossie let alone the 38......but when we get it (now or later) look me up....be fun to find out how it does.
The leading Zerstörer pilot of the war was Tratt. He has 5 38 kills (along with 3 hurricanes){38 total}. In the context of a bomber intercept I can see the 410 being effective against the 38. No detail online I can see but he got 3 in 20 minutes on 2/11/44 so he was mixing it up with a bunch of em. This fits pretty well with the comments from one of the guys from the 20th FG (79thFS). No question the 38's were pushed to the limit trying to fly long range escort for the buff's.
"Angrily, we were told that the 79th. had lost half the squadron the day before, including the Deputy Grp. CO, Lt. Col. Montgomery; that he had been on the phone since the mission return, all night and all morning trying to answer the questions of everyone from 8th. AF Headquarters to the lowest Wing weenie; and that the 20th. had been "stood down" from combat indefinitely, for reorganization."
""We were deeply jolted by being told not to expect to survive this thing, but if we did survive the first three to five missions there might be a slight hope for us. We were also told that, if we felt we couldn't fly formation and/or were afraid to die.....just quit now. Leaving formation would not be tolerated, and Jackson would personally shoot us down if we went off chasing some German by ourselves. "
{link to full article below}
This is pretty typical of the flawed "close escort" tactics used at the time....however in a purely fighter on fighter encounter I think the 410 would have very little chance....
Tratt 79th SQ/20thFG "history"