Got dragged to see it today, and actually really enjoyed it. Of course, I spent the whole movie watching and trying to pick out all the characters out before they were actually introduced, and reliving what I'd liked about TOS when I was a kid (Characters and Story, not Tech and Eyecandy), not picking it apart from a Trekkie POV- my date was doing that for me (shes a HUGE Trekkie). I actually LoLed at a few parts that reminded me of the original ("Are you out of your Vulcan mind?") and wowed at some of the visuals. Was surprised at how much I actually enjoyed it.
But the one thing that bugged me most- why, in the movies, are the Romulans ALWAYS total whack jobs? They were the best villains in TOS and TNG, and great allies in DS9, and now they've been Stackpoled!
I have always wondered this as well... And also, we never see a Romulan ship or have any really major Romulan elements at all from the TMP era(I don't consider Ambassador Nanclus from ST:VI or the Romulan ambassador chick from ST:V that major). The script for ST:III was originally written with Romulans in mind.. The ship and crew of the Bird of Prey were supposed to be Romulan.. That's as close as it got..
If you really like Romulans, you should get a hold of the book The Romulan Way. eBay or something will probably be like $1.00 or less.. I got mine at Half-Price books from 50cents..
Anyhow, it gives a detailed history of the Romulans from the time that they left Vulcan all the way up to Star Trek II.. I was totally awed reading this stuff as they are my favorite race
in the Trek Universe (GEEK ALERT GEEK ALERT!!!) The Rihannsu (what the Romulans supposedly really call themselves which means The Delcared: as in Declared to leave Vulcan) series of books (I think there's like 5 now) also offer quite a bit if insight in the Romulan element as a whole..