How about instead of flaming each other one whether there should be rules or not (as we have done at least a dozen times that I can remember) we do this:
I, {yourname}, pledge to follow these rules/guidelines.
or
I, {yourname}, do not agree to these rules/guidelines.
If you think they are stupid, really no need to reply, just do your own thing and have a merry time. If you want to abide, let it be known. In the end, the AvA is so small, we all know who does what. If you spend enough time in the AvA you can often tell who your opponent is simply by the way he merges.
Anyhow, just a suggestion on how to save a thread from the looming flame induced lock.
So...
I, Republic, pledge to follow these rules/guidelines.