Originally posted by AKFokerFoder+
Explain,?
I am not sure how you equate Zekes against F4U's and F6F's as "balanced"
Nor some of the other matchups I see.
The big factor in the MA is that each side has exactly the same planeset. This is not historical of course, but it is balanced.
The big factor in the CT is that it is more historical, which negates the idea of "balanced."
Should have waited to post until I saw this.
We ran a PAC setup a couple of weeks ago that had A6M5s and Tonys against FM2s, F4Us, Hellcats, P-40Es and P-38Gs. Within about 24 hours most of the Japanese players were in A6M5s, and were doing quite well against the Allies. I suggest that this is principally because, in the CT, people really want to fight. I imagine you could maximize your points or rank or whatever by flying a 38 or a Corsair in a strictly b&z mode, and eventually you'd land some kills and advance your statistics. When you actually decide you're going to stick around and fight, though, the zekes do just fine.
The notion that the MA is balanced because each side has the same plane set is, of course, correct in a very general sense. In practice, you still have planes of very different characteristics fighting each other. Certainly you can have a greater variety of match-ups (P-51s v. Corsairs), but most of those match-ups will be unbalanced one way or the other. I also agree with you that, historically, there were very few times when the Allied v. Axis plane sets were equally balanced. In the CT we try to achieve as good a balance as we can while remaining true to history, and sometimes this works out poorly (F4Fs v A6M2s, for example, or...er...any Spitfire v. a Frank, makes for a very difficult day for the Allied player). Most times, though, you can find a ride on either side that works well.
Slash is right, you shouldn't fly in the CT if you don't think it's fun. I suspect most people really want to fly a particular plane most of the time, and you can't do that in the CT. But I do believe that it's true that you can find good, mutually-agreeable dogfights more easily in the CT than you can in the MA, where so many people seem to want to just run away from you.
- oldman