Author Topic: Scoring A-20 havoc in fighter mode  (Read 3367 times)

Offline Karnak

  • Radioactive Member
  • *******
  • Posts: 23047
Scoring A-20 havoc in fighter mode
« Reply #45 on: December 14, 2007, 04:15:17 PM »
"Engage" does not mean "Luftberry".

The Mossie, Bf110G-2 and P-38X, flown competently, will engage and destroy an A-20G and never have to use one sector extensions.

As to the zoom of the A-20G, I view that as a bug.  It weighs a little bit more and has much greater drag.  Bombers, which the A-20 is, have disproportionate surface area and drag compared to fighters.
Petals floating by,
      Drift through my woman's hand,
             As she remembers me-

Offline B@tfinkV

  • Platinum Member
  • ******
  • Posts: 5751
Scoring A-20 havoc in fighter mode
« Reply #46 on: December 14, 2007, 05:36:05 PM »
tonight i saw a very well flown mosquito with altitude beaten by a very well flown A-20 in a drawn out fight. suggesting that X-plane will always beat Y-plane is absurd.
 400 yrds on my tail, right where i want you... [/size]

Offline Karnak

  • Radioactive Member
  • *******
  • Posts: 23047
Scoring A-20 havoc in fighter mode
« Reply #47 on: December 14, 2007, 06:11:52 PM »
The Mosquito lost, therefor it mustn't have been that well flown.

Sorry, but the difference in speed, climb and firepower means the Mosquito will win the gross majority of fights between equal pilots.  It only gets more lopsided if the Mosquito has the altitude.


EDIT:

All this thread makes me think is that the modeling of the A-20G is overly optimistic.
Petals floating by,
      Drift through my woman's hand,
             As she remembers me-

Offline humble

  • Platinum Member
  • ******
  • Posts: 6434
Scoring A-20 havoc in fighter mode
« Reply #48 on: December 14, 2007, 07:20:09 PM »
The Mossie was roughly 200 mph faster and 1000 ft higher at ~4.5k seperation. After I reversed I got speed up a bit and the "merge" differential was roughly 105 mph and 1600 ft alt. The mossie was able to easily take the high ground and force a series of tightening yoyos. The fight converted to a flat semi rolling scissor on the deck. The mossie closed to well under 400 but was unable to secure a guns solution and unable to match the A-20 in a climbing scissor. The A-20 easily topped out the mossie in the vertical and closed out the fight.

The primary misconception is that the A-20 is a "lumbering" plane and easy to hit and inferior in the vertical. The A-20 is outstanding in midspeed evasives and energy recovery, combined with exceptionally smooth mid range handling it can convert from E to angles and back to E fighting as well or better then any plane in the game...

Someone came looking for an A-20...found one...and walked home.

Nuff said...

I still have not lost a 1 on 1 to either a mossie or 110 (regardless of initial disadvantage) in the A-20. Could the mossie b&Zed me to death....sure. The moment he actually converted to a "dog fight" he died. In fact it took exactly 3 revolutions for me to move the mossie from 400 on my 6 to toast.

Now that doesnt mean that I'd win the next one or everyone vs a quality stick. What is does show is that any claim that the A-20 is incapable of beating a "well flown" mossie {or any other plane} is wrong.

I dont think the mossie was poorly flown at all, in fact it was a very well executed positive E attack. The mossie driver simply didnt give the A-20 enough credit.

The A-20 modeling is probably just fine, the moves I but on the mossie were just BFM manipulating the lift vector vs the mossie. He got out of sync and out of plane and I was inside his "nose cone". Once that happened the A-20 just dominated the mossie even though I lost views on him for a bit...

You said it best, you dont dogfight an A-20 regardless of what your flying.
« Last Edit: December 14, 2007, 07:25:26 PM by humble »

"The beauty of the second amendment is that it will not be needed until they try to take it."-Pres. Thomas Jefferson

Offline B@tfinkV

  • Platinum Member
  • ******
  • Posts: 5751
Scoring A-20 havoc in fighter mode
« Reply #49 on: December 14, 2007, 07:41:50 PM »
i actualy agree with karnak that the mosquito is just able to outclass the A-20 in almost every aspect of dogfighting, and very comfotably outclass the A-20 in a few key areas of flight such as weapon package and top speed.

what i disagree strongly with is that the mossy cannot lose to the A-20 with equal pilots.  

every fight is different. or...more acurately....if every one of your is the same as the last then you really should be expanding your knoledge in other areas and other flying styles.

x-plane does not just beat y-plane every time on stats or 'equal pilots' alone. 10 fights in a row with resonably similar pilots and individual planes it is not easy to find a match up that will produce a 10-0 victory every single time unless one person is winning with an unfair advantage on merge.

sure the best flown spitfire MkV will probably beat the best flown A-20 10/10 fights in the Da environment, there is one matchup that defies my point, but there are not many.  And more importantly, the MA mindset of most players is very different to the planned and controlled DA merge.
 400 yrds on my tail, right where i want you... [/size]

Offline humble

  • Platinum Member
  • ******
  • Posts: 6434
Scoring A-20 havoc in fighter mode
« Reply #50 on: December 14, 2007, 07:56:50 PM »
The D-25 jug is "outclassed" but that doesnt stop you and RT and blukitty and a host of others from beating "better" planes flown by respected pilots. There is no question the A-20 is totally outclassed in almost every aspect however it does have certain characteristics it can exploit..no different then the jug.

I've spent a significant amount of time figuring out what it can do (and i'm still learning) instead of simply assuming it cant. Meanwhile I'm being told I'm not "qualified" to offer opinions on its relative merits.

Long before I ever started to fly the A-20 I made the comment that some people worry about the other plane but smart pilots worry about who's in the other plane. To me that still holds true in the A-20...I'm not particularly worried about what I run into....just who I run into:D

"The beauty of the second amendment is that it will not be needed until they try to take it."-Pres. Thomas Jefferson

Offline Karnak

  • Radioactive Member
  • *******
  • Posts: 23047
Scoring A-20 havoc in fighter mode
« Reply #51 on: December 14, 2007, 09:29:39 PM »
B@tfinkV,

Please stop putting words in my mouth.  I have not once said the Mosquito would never lose.  I said it would win the gross majority of the fights, not all of them.


I have never fought an A-20G with the Mosquito that I recall.  I have had a good number of Mosquito vs Bf110G-2 fights and Mosquito vs Mosquito fights.  I have never lost to a Bf110G-2 and very rarely to a Mosquito.  P-38s are very much harder.


As to the A-20G's performance.  I highly doubt it was as capable a fighter in reality as it is here.  I seem to recall an A-20G pilot telling me that it was not permitted to roll upside down for example.
Petals floating by,
      Drift through my woman's hand,
             As she remembers me-

Offline humble

  • Platinum Member
  • ******
  • Posts: 6434
Scoring A-20 havoc in fighter mode
« Reply #52 on: December 14, 2007, 09:48:16 PM »
That's my last post, this is going nowhere with you.. My impression and gut feeling is that you aren't good enough a stick to have taken planes like the mossie, 110, P38 and others far enough towards the limit of their envelope to realize how far beyond the A20's those envelopes are, resulting in the inaccurate comparisons you make between the A20 and pretty much everything else.

:D

"The beauty of the second amendment is that it will not be needed until they try to take it."-Pres. Thomas Jefferson

Offline moot

  • Plutonium Member
  • *******
  • Posts: 16333
      • http://www.dasmuppets.com
Scoring A-20 havoc in fighter mode
« Reply #53 on: December 14, 2007, 09:59:42 PM »
I dont have anything to prove humble... I let you fly your A20 to see what was up with you, because you've got such an incongruous thing going.  Cheerleading the A20 like it's some hidden treasure...
Like I said in game, next time I will just shoot you down like I could have.  You're really outta touch humble.  Me or AKAK or anyone else will prove it to you.  I'm surprised batfink hasn't shown you, maybe he's just along for the friendship bandwagon.
Hello ant
running very fast
I squish you

Offline humble

  • Platinum Member
  • ******
  • Posts: 6434
Scoring A-20 havoc in fighter mode
« Reply #54 on: December 14, 2007, 11:10:04 PM »
Your egos writing checks your stick cant cash:)

It's funny I've never once have belittled another player about relative ability and I dont have any delusions about my overall skill level or place on the pecking order. Meanwhile I'm sitting here listening to both of you pompous guys tell me just how mediocre and misquided I am.

You didnt "let me" do anything. You flew an aggressive positive E attack and I sucked you in and thumped your butt fair and square.

The bottom line is simple, you called me out over 200, hunted my A-20 (and found it) engaged me with alt & E and got beat even up. You couldnt hit me from 400...so much for just flipping the turtle:p

I've got no real issues with either one of you and I have zero clue why you both seem to feel the need to belittle me for an opinion based on experience. Both of you seem so sure that your past experience with the A-20 exceeds my current experience and that your significantly "superior" overall as pilots. Yet neither one of you has any real experience flying against me in anything let alone the A-20.

Had you beaten me (and you had every intention of doing just that) it wouldnt have mattered that you had alt & E on me to start. Given the options at hand I chose to make it a flying contest not a guns contest. I converted your semi vertical E attack which would have inevitably given you a good snapshot into a different type of fight. That involved giving you my 6 at a range that encouraged you not to resume attacks in the vertical and relying on your belief you "know everything" about the A-20 to suck you into a fight the mossie wouldnt win. I took you from a flat scissor to a semi rolling scissor to a vertical scissor and then went vertical on you in a modified double who's high AoA (duh) the "superior" mossie couldnt handle and sawed your wing off with a single burst.

You lost because I flew the snot out of the A-20 and beat you in a superior plane that had superior position by putting your better ride in a situation where it was forced to use its less then stellar aspects...

Basically smooth is fast and wobbly ended up dead. So regardless of what happens in the future (and I'm sure we'll meet again) the 1st time my A-20 met your Mossie you died.
« Last Edit: December 14, 2007, 11:27:34 PM by humble »

"The beauty of the second amendment is that it will not be needed until they try to take it."-Pres. Thomas Jefferson

Offline moot

  • Plutonium Member
  • *******
  • Posts: 16333
      • http://www.dasmuppets.com
Scoring A-20 havoc in fighter mode
« Reply #55 on: December 15, 2007, 03:28:00 AM »
I'll just kill you like the average pilot flying a big turtle plane you are, from now on... No offense but now I'm wasting my time trying to play it fair.  I could have done something else than equalize E with 75% fuel and extra ammo load in a mossie while you were already all set for flaps etc.

Writing checks my stick can't cash?  You just shot any chance of me trying to play along anymore...  If I'd played it straight you'd have "died the first time we met" and what would that have proven?  You're just after bragging rights the same way dweeby noobs pull out stats saying they shot you down once, nevermind it being when you werent looking...
If I can't hit you from 400 it's got nothing to do with whatever super duper properties the A20's supposed to have.

This was never about you humble, I said that many times before, that it was strictly about the A20 being far below fighters' worries 1:1, but you keep repeating that me or AKAK or anyone else is in fact insinuating you suck or that it's in a belittling tone.
Now though it's obvious you can't keep your ego out of it.
Quote
(and you had every intention of doing just that)
Wrong, and you being so damn sure of it just shows you've shut your blinders to anything but your agenda... Cheerleading the A20 no matter what, even if it means ignoring the facts.
In fact if batfink's around you as much as he seems to be he might echo what I'm saying, that I'll fly real lax in duels if I don't see any threat or if I'm curious about what someone can do.
« Last Edit: December 15, 2007, 03:35:23 AM by moot »
Hello ant
running very fast
I squish you

Offline B@tfinkV

  • Platinum Member
  • ******
  • Posts: 5751
Scoring A-20 havoc in fighter mode
« Reply #56 on: December 15, 2007, 07:08:14 AM »
karnak i appologise, i misunderstood your post.

Quote
Originally posted by moot
I'll just kill you like the average pilot flying a big turtle plane you are, from now on... No offense but now I'm wasting my time trying to play it fair.  .


'playing it fair' was and should be part of the test between the two aircraft. If you have to avoid 'playing it fair' to beat humble then you are not proving anything aside from 'initial advantage will win most fights'
 you claim further down this post not to make this anything personal with humble yet your first quoted line here is most derogatory.
 I have flown humble's wing or fought head to head with him in the DA for the last 2.5 maybe even 3 years. not only has his vast stack of experience (which goes light years beyond mine) helped me to improve my overall game, but his even larger stack of friendship has benifited me and countless others on a personal level.
 he is not ego centered in any way, and thus you consider him an 'average pilot' because he doesnt promote himself in many aspects of this game.

whereas most people will lose and look for excuses as to why they lost, humble will always consider the other pilots skill, and what his enemy 'did right' long before he will look for excuses as to why he lost or what he 'did wrong'.

as to the A20 i think the debate has finished and opinions been made quite clear from all sides. but there seems to be more to it here than just performance. thing is, i dont see many other people using 95% A-20 clips to help explain fighter tactics to the new guys....

i do really hope that the many objections aimed at humble are not through jealousy that he was taking 'the spotlight' for the voice of the A-20 in the training forum.
« Last Edit: December 15, 2007, 07:37:46 AM by B@tfinkV »
 400 yrds on my tail, right where i want you... [/size]

Offline humble

  • Platinum Member
  • ******
  • Posts: 6434
Scoring A-20 havoc in fighter mode
« Reply #57 on: December 15, 2007, 10:44:34 AM »
Quote
Originally posted by moot
I'll just kill you like the average pilot flying a big turtle plane you are, from now on... No offense but now I'm wasting my time trying to play it fair.  I could have done something else than equalize E with 75% fuel and extra ammo load in a mossie while you were already all set for flaps etc.

Writing checks my stick can't cash?  You just shot any chance of me trying to play along anymore...  If I'd played it straight you'd have "died the first time we met" and what would that have proven?  You're just after bragging rights the same way dweeby noobs pull out stats saying they shot you down once, nevermind it being when you werent looking...
If I can't hit you from 400 it's got nothing to do with whatever super duper properties the A20's supposed to have.

This was never about you humble, I said that many times before, that it was strictly about the A20 being far below fighters' worries 1:1, but you keep repeating that me or AKAK or anyone else is in fact insinuating you suck or that it's in a belittling tone.
Now though it's obvious you can't keep your ego out of it.
 Wrong, and you being so damn sure of it just shows you've shut your blinders to anything but your agenda... Cheerleading the A20 no matter what, even if it means ignoring the facts.
In fact if batfink's around you as much as he seems to be he might echo what I'm saying, that I'll fly real lax in duels if I don't see any threat or if I'm curious about what someone can do.


somebody got owned

Here's the clip.

Please show me where you got "fair".You came in with alt & E went vertical immediately right into a classic positive E attack and drove me to the deck. There was nothing fair or even in your attack. You had every intent on doing just what you said you would....end of story.

This isn't personal, but you to sure seem to need to make it that. I actually have zero agenda with the A-20, I simply enjoy flying it to a suprising degree.

I've never said I could beat anybody (including you) in the A-20 vs any plane. What I've said is that I  feel like I can beat any plane/pilot in the A-20 just like I would in any other plane. When I lose a fight I look to the 85% of the encounter that was under my control not to the other guys ride. I also said that so far I have not lost a single 1 on 1 fight to either a Mossie or 110 (still true). A week ago I could have said the same thing about the pony (skat took care of that)...

Did you not come up on 200 asking "where the a-20 is"? Point blank you were looking for me. You didnt ask if it was me. You didnt look to set up a fair fight. You came in looking to stomp on me...fine.

I dont ever talk smack to anybody, and I didnt here. I simply said what I've said all along. That the A-20 is suprisngly capable in the air to air role and can but up a good fight vs all comers if it has some alt to play with. Bat told you how tough it seems to be for guys to draw a bead on the A-20 (if its flown well). Of course that cant have anything to do with me, has to be the other guy having a bad day. Every comment in this thread has been directed at me. My lack of ability, my lack of experience, my noobishness. Meanwhile I've tried to be reasonable, fair and on topic.

However at this point I simply dont see the benifit of being nice here. You didnt give me a "fair fight". You came to kill me and had every opportunity to do so and got owned. Bat and I are good friends and we spend a fair amount of time in the DA. I think he's a better stick then I am but we go back and forth most of the time. When I'm fooling around with Bat I'm well aware that regardless of the plane he's in its Bat flying it...if he could open the window on a goon he'd kill me with the .45 if I gave him an opening. So I try and treat everybody I run into with the respect I give Bat in a fight...including you.

End when it was over I wasnt demeaning at all over 200 and didnt make any comment other then saluting you for a fun fight that could have gone either way. What you didnt understand is that Bat and I readily give each other our 6. Bat knows that when he's 600 behind me he's in the most danger (and the same if I'm on him). We both feel the defender has the advantage and spend alot of time beating each other up. 70% of our fights are exactly what you saw...on the deck between the trees under 150 in the vertical...except bat and I would have gone at least another 5 minutes there (and that is not ment as a belittling comment). We both can fight just about everything in the vertical indefinately at 150 or less.

I am far from the best stick here, but I'm way above "average" or a noob. When I put stats out they are what they are. I was flying the A-20 low, slow on the deck in a heavily red enviornment. Most of my losses came in heavy traffic to Lynx, bipolar and other good pilots who can kill me regardless of what i'm in.

My question to you is simple. For a guy with a good reputation who normally seems to act with some class....why didnt you? Whats wrong with simply saying I flew the A-20 better then you thought it could be flown and you wont make the same mistake again...end of story.

Like I said it was a good fight and next time will be next time. So we reach a point where I guess you have 2 choices. If I'm an average pilot at best and the A-20 is a pitiful plane (as a fighter) and your such a good stick and an expert in both the mossie and the A-20....well why did you lose?

Or maybe, just maybe I'm a better then average stick who's spent a fair amount of time actually fighting the A-20 "as a fighter" {yes I know it isn't} and has learned that its got alot of subtle strengths that can be applied in a fight. Now if you leave it up to me I'd say you got educated. But if you want to stay nasty then I'll leave it as you got owned...this time.
.
« Last Edit: December 15, 2007, 10:49:32 AM by humble »

"The beauty of the second amendment is that it will not be needed until they try to take it."-Pres. Thomas Jefferson

Offline E25280

  • Gold Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 3475
      • http://125thspartanforums.com
Scoring A-20 havoc in fighter mode
« Reply #58 on: December 15, 2007, 11:20:51 AM »
While this pissing match is entertaining, the original question . . .
Quote
Originally posted by B@tfinkV
the mosquito has a fighter mode, wuld it be possible to have the same option for the A20?
[/b]
. . . was answered quite correctly here . . .
Quote
Originally posted by Ack-Ack
Correct...the only variants of the Havoc that were considered "fighters" were the P-70 and P-70A (night fighters).  Both saw service with the USAAC in in the PTO only and their service time was brief.  Both were equipped with the British AI Mk IV and the P-70 was equipped with 4 20mm (60 rounds each) in the nose.  The P-70A had machine guns mounted in the nose.

Contrary to what some may believe, the A-20 was primarily used as a bomber that was capable of both high and low altitude bombing missions.  Yes, it could defend itself if needed like the A-26 but it still doesn't change the fact that it was first and foremost a bomber and was used almost exclusively in that role (with the exception of some specialized variants like the above mentiond P-70 series).
. . . and that's about the end of it.

Now, bring night to AH, and add the P-70 as a "fighter," and everyone would be happy, yes?
Brauno in a past life, followed by LTARget
SWtarget in current incarnation
Captain and Communications Officer~125th Spartans

"Proudly drawing fire so that my brothers may pass unharmed."

Offline BaldEagl

  • Plutonium Member
  • *******
  • Posts: 10791
Scoring A-20 havoc in fighter mode
« Reply #59 on: December 15, 2007, 12:01:34 PM »
You guys are still going at it?  Give it up.

BTW, the A-20 is not a fighter and shouldn't be scored as such.
I edit a lot of my posts.  Get used to it.