Shreck, if the Sherman is so superior, why does the Tiger kill the Sherman more than vice versa, and why is the Tiger 60% more effective than the Sherman against the Panzer, and 250% more effective against the T34? This is based on every single tank on tank inter-model kill over the last completed five months.
Seriously, anecdotes are a dime a dozen. The Sherman is demonstrably not superior against other tanks than the Tiger, on average.