Aces High Bulletin Board

General Forums => Aces High General Discussion => Topic started by: -gg- on October 29, 2026, 12:11:00 PM

Title: ENY again
Post by: -gg- on October 29, 2026, 12:11:00 PM
Had not flown much for two weeks. Came on last night around 9.30 pacific and sat through ENY the whole time. Was over 20 and there were maybe 15 total players in the air. The total numbers logged in when I logged off was 15/15/5. Actually flying was lower. There's a BIG, EMPTY map and no ganging was going on, In fact, the only fight I found had ME being ganged.

I was fighting the 2-3 players at a time.... so I was being outnumbered.

After an hour ENY went up again and I could only fly crap planes. I sat in the tower for awhile and then just logged off

Is the intent of ENY to make the game not fun for people like me when the numbers are SO LOW?

I'm seriously and continually annoyed and maddened by EYN.

It deserves a review. When numbers are low it needs to go away. It makes no sense.

Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: LilMak on October 29, 2026, 12:32:29 PM
You seem to like Jugs. Next time you see me online, I invite you to join me in a ride along in a D-11 and maybe I can convince you that a crap plane can actually be a lot of fun?

But I agree that the threshold for ENY should be somewhere around 40 players online and it goes away.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Dadtallica on October 29, 2026, 12:45:36 PM
You seem to like Jugs. Next time you see me online, I invite you to join me in a ride along in a D-11 and maybe I can convince you that a crap plane can actually be a lot of fun?

But I agree that the threshold for ENY should be somewhere around 40 players online and it goes away.

D40 is one of my high eny go to planes. I should try the the 11… what do you like about it Mak?
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Eagler on October 29, 2026, 12:53:50 PM
All for all sides having planes reduced to force the picking tempest into an actual turn fight...

Universal ENY...

Eagler
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: LilMak on October 29, 2026, 01:23:42 PM
D40 is one of my high eny go to planes. I should try the the 11… what do you like about it Mak?
D-11 is a bit different because it’s limited in acceleration, climb, and views. But it’s still stable at very high and very low speeds like all the jugs. It seems to have a very marginal flat turning advantage at medium speeds over the others because it’s a tiny bit lighter. The only significant difference (in my semi-professional opinion) is that the views are weak and you really need to be on your E management game. Once you scrub speed, it takes longer to get back and escape without an initial E advantage is not likely.

What do I like about it? It still a jug, flys like one, still competitive in the MA, and almost always available no matter how bad the ENY gets. Also, I can see the tears on the windscreen when I fly through Tempest and 262 scrap. Few feelings are better in MA than stealing a player’s perks in a 35 ENY bird.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Dadtallica on October 29, 2026, 01:43:28 PM
I will give it a try.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Banshee7 on October 29, 2026, 02:52:56 PM
I can't think of a single time I was ever limited by ENY.  I guess because a majority of the time I was in a 20+ ENY plane.  OH....and I was never on the largest side.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: BigR on October 29, 2026, 03:05:03 PM
My favorite highish eny planes: Mossie, LA5, P38J\G, P51B.
The Mossie is a true beast...give it a try.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: caldera on October 29, 2026, 03:29:33 PM
"Crap" planes, or perhaps just planes that require a modicum of effort?

Some of us are lucky to even get 1 kill per sortie, yet some how manage to fly "crap" planes all the time.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: hazmatt on October 29, 2026, 04:29:17 PM
Maybe this might be helpful to consider.

In my current game planes all have a ranking same as AH3. Sometimes you get put in a match where all planes have the same ranking as you, sometimes the other planes are lower, sometimes they're higher.

I change my game play based on the match.

1: All enemy planes all ranked lower:
I attempt to go on a murderous rampage.

2: All enemy planes are ranked equal:
I attempt to do the same as 1 but pay attention to my energy and try not to get my self in over my head in the the furball or get caught low and slow.

3: All enemy planes are all ranked higher. (this is the one that I think applies here with ENY)
I consider myself to be the the food and fly defensively, only engage when I have a clear exit and don't get mixed up in the furball. This one requires me to pay attention and have some SA because there's no AWACs and you can get bounced especially if you have a low crew rating.

Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Dadtallica on October 29, 2026, 04:32:34 PM
If this bothers people so much, why don’t they just switch countries?
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: -gg- on October 29, 2026, 04:47:58 PM
So in my example of the numbers, the low side had two players in flight. Each of the other two teams had about five or six players in flight.

So you're going to make everybody fly a crappy plane just for those two guys that are flying somewhere on a huge bellybutton map that you can't even reach them.

I'm fighting people getting gangbanged being forced to go to the bottom of the barrel plains to fly against them and then I get sick of it. It's not enjoyable. I think it absolutely sucks. When the numbers of that low get rid of eny. Do something about that. Doesn't make any sense at all.

It doesn't do a thing to balance the arena other than making people log off. And when there's 10 people online or 15 people online or 30 or whatever it is on a huge map, nobody's getting gangbanged anywhere.

Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: -gg- on October 29, 2026, 04:49:14 PM
So the game is killing the fun for everybody except for two players that are online doing God knows what. They can fly whatever planes they want and everybody else has to fly the worst planes so that those two jagoffs can have an enjoyable game experience?
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: hazmatt on October 29, 2026, 04:54:36 PM
jagoffs can have an enjoyable game experience?

Whatcha got against  jagoffs?

I would try to understand how you feel but since I rarely flew planes that were affected by eny, I'd be lyin if I said I did understand.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Oldman731 on October 29, 2026, 08:33:44 PM
D-11 is a bit different because it’s limited in acceleration, climb, and views. But it’s still stable at very high and very low speeds like all the jugs. It seems to have a very marginal flat turning advantage at medium speeds over the others because it’s a tiny bit lighter. The only significant difference (in my semi-professional opinion) is that the views are weak and you really need to be on your E management game. Once you scrub speed, it takes longer to get back and escape without an initial E advantage is not likely.

What do I like about it? It still a jug, flys like one, still competitive in the MA, and almost always available no matter how bad the ENY gets. Also, I can see the tears on the windscreen when I fly through Tempest and 262 scrap. Few feelings are better in MA than stealing a player’s perks in a 35 ENY bird.


All true.  PLUS:  It's the plane that beat the Luftwaffe when it counted.  If you fly for history, this is the Thunderbolt to fly.

- oldman
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Dadtallica on October 29, 2026, 09:33:07 PM
I’m not quite understanding how ENY affects a country outnumbered?

If ENY is affecting your plane choice then are you not on one of the sides that’s the problem?

Tonight in primetime it was quiet on the rook side but the other two were getting it on heavy. I don’t know what the exact roster account was, but when I got there it was riddled with jets. I counted at least four 262’s and I’m pretty sure there were probably actually six. I was helping the Bish defend their base from the Knights.

It was pretty cool actually as much as I can’t stand jets but I’m sure the bishops weren’t excited about it. The bishops were actually holding their own pretty well at the time. I had to remind a couple. I was there to help, but it didn’t matter. I never made it home.

Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: diaster on October 29, 2026, 11:12:14 PM
Whatcha got against  jagoffs?

I would try to understand how you feel but since I rarely flew planes that were affected by eny, I'd be lyin if I said I did understand.
I save yet to see you in game, but I play noon to 3ish west coast. That said I agree with much of what you said. I was in high ent, half the team sleeping in tower. Trying to up off a golf with3 tempest and a duece and they b nz so hard it was ridiculous. All to rack up three “kills”
The answer to this is so simple. I wonder why it isn’t enabled, ‘take time out server kick” you in tower but not labeled afk 10 minutes, you are kicked. You sit in a jeep flashing a field with no movement, 10 minutes kicked from server. Eny goes away.
While we are at it, more than a minute off map you die.
And what the heck bomb and bail with zero damage, no points and target regenerates.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: -gg- on October 30, 2026, 07:59:19 AM
I’m not quite understanding how ENY affects a country outnumbered?

If ENY is affecting your plane choice then are you not on one of the sides that’s the problem?

Tonight in primetime it was quiet on the rook side but the other two were getting it on heavy. I don’t know what the exact roster account was, but when I got there it was riddled with jets. I counted at least four 262’s and I’m pretty sure there were probably actually six. I was helping the Bish defend their base from the Knights.

It was pretty cool actually as much as I can’t stand jets but I’m sure the bishops weren’t excited about it. The bishops were actually holding their own pretty well at the time. I had to remind a couple. I was there to help, but it didn’t matter. I never made it home.


You're not understanding.

First of all, I reject the idea that just because I log into the game to play that I am some sort of a problem. I'm not part of a team I'm an individual trying to play a game and enjoy it and I'm getting stymied by the game itself.

But the major issue is that when I play it's usually very low numbers. There's a huge empty map and even though technically I am on a side that is outnumbering one side, the numbers are so low that it doesn't even matter. Two or three plane difference? Over the whole huge map? There are no gangbangs going on.

The night that I was talking about, and it it happens very very frequently, I was the one being outnumbered. I was fighting two and three players on an isolated fight between two bases where we were just fighting.

I reall I think eny why is damaging to the game experience.... Far more than being outnumbered by one or two planes over a huge map that's mostly empty.

Most of the time when I'm on NY is in effect against me. And I say me because I'm not part of a team. I don't fly in a hoard. I reject the idea that I'm part of a problem. That's insulting.

I just want to log on for a couple of hours and have fun. When my plane choices get reduced to every single plane that I've got in my favorite list..... I have to start searching for a piece of crap that I don't even like to fly the game is not enjoyable to me. And the game is penalizing me so that somebody else doesn't feel like they are outnumbered on a huge map with nothing going on?

Turn the stupid thing off at least when the numbers are low like that. It doesn't make any sense whatsoever.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: -gg- on October 30, 2026, 08:00:27 AM
Also, it's not my fault that I log in and I happen to be on the team that has a couple more players than the other team. What am I supposed to do about that?

Part of the problem. Jesus. A customer that logs into play a game is part of the problem?
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: hazmatt on October 30, 2026, 08:11:55 AM
Also, it's not my fault that I log in and I happen to be on the team that has a couple more players than the other team. What am I supposed to do about that?

Part of the problem. Jesus. A customer that logs into play a game is part of the problem?

Well at least they haven't gone to the silliness that WW2 online tried where there was a LOG IN timer. Whenever I saw that I just went and played with something else.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: -gg- on October 30, 2026, 09:06:09 AM
I just want things to be simple. It's just not anybody's fault that the numbers are so low.

I don't get frustrated with anything that happens in the game due to other players. I don't mind being outnumbered at all. I don't want any crutches myself. I don't want any advantages.

But it's super frustrating to have the game itself limiting your enjoyment of the game simply because you're considered part of a problem by just logging on.

It might be different if there was some recourse that was reasonable that I could do to not be such a major problem for everybody else. But I don't have that. It's not realistic even if I wanted to switch sides to be doing that because the numbers are so low that it would swing the numbers the other way and then it would still happen.

Like I keep saying. The eny system does work but not in the way that is beneficial to the game. Because mostly it makes people like me sit in the tower and wait it out or just log off pissed off. Then when I logged off I guess I wasn't part of the problem anymore.

Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: LilMak on October 30, 2026, 09:41:34 AM
I think you just need to expand your horizons a bit and it’ll get more fun for you.

Last night I played for about 2 hours on the quiet front (Knights were focused on bombing HQ hording on the other side of the map).

Three sorties in a SBD with 2 kills (guns not bombs).
One sortie win a D-40 with 4 kills.
One sortie in a KI-43 with 5 kills.
One sortie in a D-11 with 4 kills.

There was no ENY. Had a great time. Just me and some other pilots (ZE and scott66 primarily) enjoying the fight.

It takes some time to get a fight brewing but I can usually do it.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Dadtallica on October 30, 2026, 09:54:50 AM

You're not understanding.

First of all, I reject the idea that just because I log into the game to play that I am some sort of a problem. I'm not part of a team I'm an individual trying to play a game and enjoy it and I'm getting stymied by the game itself.

But the major issue is that when I play it's usually very low numbers. There's a huge empty map and even though technically I am on a side that is outnumbering one side, the numbers are so low that it doesn't even matter. Two or three plane difference? Over the whole huge map? There are no gangbangs going on.

The night that I was talking about, and it it happens very very frequently, I was the one being outnumbered. I was fighting two and three players on an isolated fight between two bases where we were just fighting.

I reall I think eny why is damaging to the game experience.... Far more than being outnumbered by one or two planes over a huge map that's mostly empty.

Most of the time when I'm on NY is in effect against me. And I say me because I'm not part of a team. I don't fly in a hoard. I reject the idea that I'm part of a problem. That's insulting.

I just want to log on for a couple of hours and have fun. When my plane choices get reduced to every single plane that I've got in my favorite list..... I have to start searching for a piece of crap that I don't even like to fly the game is not enjoyable to me. And the game is penalizing me so that somebody else doesn't feel like they are outnumbered on a huge map with nothing going on?

Turn the stupid thing off at least when the numbers are low like that. It doesn't make any sense whatsoever.

You was a collective not necessarily personal to you.

But… You were very clear with me that it was no big deal to force people to switch sides even though I told you most people probably won’t want to do that.

So then I was puzzled why you didn’t just switch sides and then you could’ve flown whatever plane you wanted. There’s a 100+ things to fly and drive in this game. Try new things it’s fun once and a while. If your personal choice is to limit yourself to a small number of rides, then this will always be a problem for you. As I and others have stated it just doesn’t have to be.

A G14 is my fave ENY buster they are nimble and can out climb most things and they can pack a punch. Mossies are deadly too and can make a lot of noise air and ground i’ve been trying to fly that one a little more for quick Jabo runs. Like Mak said the 47s have some good ones too. Lately I’ve been getting beaten by F4U1-A’s I’m going to start trying those more.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: AKIron on October 30, 2026, 10:10:52 AM

You was a collective not necessarily personal to you.


That would be y'all.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: hitech on October 30, 2026, 10:29:04 AM
The game is not limiting you. ENY limits plane choice, not whether you can fly. You are choosing to fly for the side you want rather than the plane you want, and that is a fair choice to make. There are always lower ENY planes available to you on your side.

ENY: when does it start limiting planes?

The lowest ENY for fighters in the Main Arena is 5 (P-51D, Spitfire XIV, La-7, Tempest and others). The table below shows how far ahead the largest side has to be before its ENY limit goes above 5, which is when those planes become unavailable to it.

How ENY works: each side's share of the active (non-AFK) players is compared to the smallest side's share. A side can be up to 10% bigger than the smallest side with no limit at all. Past that, the limit grows with the difference. The limit is also scaled by how many players are in the arena, so with low numbers it is much weaker.

Now: the scaling starts at 0 players and reaches full strength at 70 players.
What I am considering: the scaling starts at 10 players and reaches full strength at 70 players. Below 10 players there would be no ENY at all, and between 10 and about 30 players it would take a bigger imbalance to get a limit. From about 40 players up nothing changes.

"Imbalance" is how many more players the largest side has than the smallest side. The example is one split of the three sides where that happens.

Players in arenaNow: imbalance neededNow: exampleConsidering: imbalance neededConsidering: example
634/1/1no ENY-
834/3/1no ENY-
1045/4/1no ENY-
1246/4/2not possible-
1547/5/389/5/1
2059/7/469/8/3
25510/10/5611/9/5
30612/12/6612/12/6
35614/13/8714/14/7
40716/15/9716/15/9
50820/18/12820/18/12
701027/26/171027/26/17

"not possible" means that with that few players the limit I am considering could never get above 5, however the sides are split.

HiTech
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: popeye on October 30, 2026, 12:42:15 PM
One thing about ENY for side balancing is that it doesn't compensate for double-teaming.  So, 17 / 11 / 7 could be (and often is) effectively 28 v 7.  ENY will limit the 17 player side somewhat, but doesn't really balance the "sides".

Ultimately, it's up to the players to make the balance.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Eagler on October 30, 2026, 12:43:35 PM
All for forced side balancing..

Let the whines begin..

Eagler
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: -gg- on October 30, 2026, 01:08:56 PM
The game is not limiting you. ENY limits plane choice, not whether you can fly. You are choosing to fly for the side you want rather than the plane you want, and that is a fair choice to make. There are always lower ENY planes available to you on your side.

ENY: when does it start limiting planes?

The lowest ENY for fighters in the Main Arena is 5 (P-51D, Spitfire XIV, La-7, Tempest and others). The table below shows how far ahead the largest side has to be before its ENY limit goes above 5, which is when those planes become unavailable to it.

How ENY works: each side's share of the active (non-AFK) players is compared to the smallest side's share. A side can be up to 10% bigger than the smallest side with no limit at all. Past that, the limit grows with the difference. The limit is also scaled by how many players are in the arena, so with low numbers it is much weaker.

Now: the scaling starts at 0 players and reaches full strength at 70 players.
What I am considering: the scaling starts at 10 players and reaches full strength at 70 players. Below 10 players there would be no ENY at all, and between 10 and about 30 players it would take a bigger imbalance to get a limit. From about 40 players up nothing changes.

"Imbalance" is how many more players the largest side has than the smallest side. The example is one split of the three sides where that happens.

Players in arenaNow: imbalance neededNow: exampleConsidering: imbalance neededConsidering: example
634/1/1no ENY-
834/3/1no ENY-
1045/4/1no ENY-
1246/4/2not possible-
1547/5/389/5/1
2059/7/469/8/3
25510/10/5611/9/5
30612/12/6612/12/6
35614/13/8714/14/7
40716/15/9716/15/9
50820/18/12820/18/12
701027/26/171027/26/17

"not possible" means that with that few players the limit I am considering could never get above 5, however the sides are split.

HiTech


First of all, changing sides is not an easy option or a fix. I'm talking about when numbers are LOW. Like 6, 6, and 2 players actually flying - whatever it was and the ENY was over 20.

And those two players are not fighting 12 against 2.

There's a BIG empty map and I'm getting ganged 3 against 1 in the only fight I can find. I'm supposed to change sides?

It makes NO sense when the numbers are low.

And it is the game limiting me. It's a pain in the arse and the main reason I log off or sit in the tower. Others on my squad say the same thing

You might want to consider how ENY actually affects the players. I suspect most people are not going to change sides. They log off and then ENY  balanced the numbers for you.

Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Banshee7 on October 30, 2026, 01:13:43 PM
I just want things to be simple.

So....what's your simple solution?
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: -gg- on October 30, 2026, 01:16:16 PM
So....what's your simple solution?

really? I've mentioned it dozens of times - and at least once in this thread.

REMOVE ENY when numbers are low. Get rid of it. Have it kick in only when there are significant numbers.


I mean, 3 people cried about Radar and got that addressed. ENY is a much bigger issue for the game and complaints about it have gone on forever.

Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Banshee7 on October 30, 2026, 01:18:44 PM
really? I've mentioned it dozens of times - and at least once in this thread.

REMOVE ENY when numbers are low. Get rid of it. Have it kick in only when there are significant numbers.


I mean, 3 people cried about Radar and got that addressed. ENY is a much bigger issue for the game and complaints about it have gone on forever.

Did you even read HT's post that you quoted where he said he was considering turning it off at 10 players or less?
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: -gg- on October 30, 2026, 01:26:49 PM
Did you even read HT's post that you quoted where he said he was considering turning it off at 10 players or less?

Did you? because you asked me what my solution was.... and I told you again.

I appreciate that he's considering that. I think it should be more like 60 players. I think, as I've mention before, that it should also be based on what is actually going on on the map.

Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Banshee7 on October 30, 2026, 01:30:56 PM
Did you? because you asked me what my solution was.... and I told you again.

I appreciate that he's considering that. I think it should be more like 60 players. I think, as I've mention before, that it should also be based on what is actually going on on the map.

So, it sounds like you're asking for a more difficult solution.  You have already expressed your unwillingness to try the most obvious "simple" solutions like flying higher ENY planes or changing countries.  ENY not kicking in until 60 sounds like a complete nightmare for the side with the lowest numbers (because ya know, Gina wants to be able to horde in her Spit 16).
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: -gg- on October 30, 2026, 01:34:16 PM
One last point - because I think HiTech misses some of my point.

I don't actively "choose" to be on the side with numbers. That's not within my control. I don't like being penalized for that or coerced into changing sides to help someone elses game experience.

I don't care one bit about numbers. I don't care if I'm outnumbers... I just look at the map and want to find a fight.

I don't like this attitude of ..."just take it." learn to fly different planes" or that I need to keep hopping around countries if I don't like the plane choices.



Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: -gg- on October 30, 2026, 01:36:36 PM
So, it sounds like you're asking for a more difficult solution.  You have already expressed your unwillingness to try the most obvious "simple" solutions like flying higher ENY planes or changing countries.  ENY not kicking in until 60 sounds like a complete nightmare for the side with the lowest numbers (because ya know, Gina wants to be able to horde in her Spit 16).

I fly higher ENY planes.

It's not realistic to ask people to change countries. I'm in a squad, for one thing. It's also not easy to jump back and forth to different countries - that's why VERY few people are auto side-switchers.


Done arguing with you about it. You don't understand my point or my issue with ENY



Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Spikes on October 30, 2026, 01:40:10 PM
I don't actively "choose" to be on the side with numbers. That's not within my control.

I mean, it is. It is literally within your control. In fact, it is one of the few things that IS within your control.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: hazmatt on October 30, 2026, 01:49:15 PM
One sortie in a KI-43 with 5 kills.

Gotta be a hack. Ain't no way a Ki-43 has ammo for 5 kills!  :headscratch:
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: -gg- on October 30, 2026, 01:49:37 PM
I mean, it is. It is literally within your control. In fact, it is one of the few things that IS within your control.

I don't control the number of players logging on and off. If I switch sides, it can happen again and then I've switched sides and not flying with my friends and squad for no reason.

I am being punished by a worse game experience just because more people log on my side.


Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Banshee7 on October 30, 2026, 01:54:42 PM
I mean, it is. It is literally within your control. In fact, it is one of the few things that IS within your control.

Literally.

I fly higher ENY planes.

If that were the case, this thread wouldn't exist.  I checked your scores for the last few tours, and while you do have a few kills in higher ENY planes, most of your kills are in low ENY planes

I fly higher ENY planes.

It's not realistic to ask people to change countries. I'm in a squad, for one thing. It's also not easy to jump back and forth to different countries - that's why VERY few people are auto side-switchers.

It is very realistic.  Who says you have to stay loyal to a chess piece.  And squads with larger numbers not willing to split up are what's contributing to the ENY issue you're describing.

I don't care one bit about numbers. I don't care if I'm outnumbers... I just look at the map and want to find a fight.

From the sounds of it, you're never outnumbered...

I am being punished by a worse game experience just because more people log on my side.

No, you're being "punished" by a lack of skill and/or a lack of problem solving.  You're just whining at this point.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Mol on October 30, 2026, 01:56:40 PM
I mean, 3 people cried about Radar and got that addressed.

But the radar wasn't addressed, the changes just messed it up.

MoL
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: LilMak on October 30, 2026, 02:09:10 PM
Gotta be a hack. Ain't no way a Ki-43 has ammo for 5 kills!  :headscratch:
Three zeros and two brewsters I believe. Some assistance was provided by the trees/ground.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Dadtallica on October 30, 2026, 02:49:29 PM
He literally said at 10 players there would be no ENY????

Everyone wants simple solutions to conflict problem. It’s just not how the world works.

Dale stated it better than I did, the game isn’t limiting your choice, you are.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Dadtallica on October 30, 2026, 02:52:31 PM

From the sounds of it, you're never outnumbered...


Nice!  :rofl

It’s just troll whining at this point.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: hitech on October 30, 2026, 05:36:59 PM
This is how the change would work out, using the last 60 days of the main arena. The chart shows how often the largest side could not fly ENY 5 planes, now and with the change I am considering (ENY starts ramping up at 10 players instead of 0, full strength at 70 players as now).

https://dload.hitechcreations.com/dales/side-balance.html

Now: 49% of the time. With the change: 35% of the time.

HiTech
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Dadtallica on October 30, 2026, 05:56:39 PM
This is how the change would work out, using the last 60 days of the main arena. The chart shows how often the largest side could not fly ENY 5 planes, now and with the change I am considering (ENY starts ramping up at 10 players instead of 0, full strength at 70 players as now).

https://dload.hitechcreations.com/dales/side-balance.html

Now: 49% of the time. With the change: 35% of the time.

HiTech

Compromise! :cheers:

Also, if you wouldn’t mind just for me, especially, would you please quadruple the price of a jet? I mean with gas prices the way they and all that…
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Dinan on October 30, 2026, 11:54:49 PM
The game is very strange now.  Used to log on a Friday night and it was the best.  Now it’s just horde base take stuff.  I see old heads on here complain about no fights but they’re all in the horde and acting like they get paid to take bases and not get shot down in a cartoon plane.  Eny is lame but the bigger issue is what this game has turned into.  Gotta log on at the right time I guess
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: -gg- on October 31, 2026, 02:00:09 AM
This is how the change would work out, using the last 60 days of the main arena. The chart shows how often the largest side could not fly ENY 5 planes, now and with the change I am considering (ENY starts ramping up at 10 players instead of 0, full strength at 70 players as now).

https://dload.hitechcreations.com/dales/side-balance.html

Now: 49% of the time. With the change: 35% of the time.

HiTech

Thanks for looking into this and for your consideration!

Are you able to run stats on how various levels of ENY affect overall numbers? One of my contentions has been  that I feel ENY does eventually even the sides, but I have a feeling that it does so by reducing the numbers of players and not by players switching sides to even the numbers.

I'd love to see how the stats work out on numbers before and after ENY ( at various levels of ENY) affect the people in flight or logged in.

The rest of this post is not directed directly at you, Dale

_____________________________ _____________________________ _____________________________ _____

I just have always felt that the large majority of players will not switch sides when heave ENY kicks in. I think they deal with it for a bit, sit in the tower for a bit to wait or log off.
So that's part of my point - and I could be wrong - but I feel that ENY does not really work as intended.

When I mentioned DAR being addressed, I meant this: I've never once ever heard anyone in the game mention anything about DAR being a problem. I see like three people on the forum crying about it and then it gets addressed - when I don't think anyone ever had a problem with it. Then a change gets introduced based on what 3 guys are saying here, and tons  of people in game don't know what's going on with the glitchy DAR.

On the other hand, I will bet that every single night I hear people complain about ENY on vox. There are countess complaints about ENY going back years, to the point that people attack anyone for bringing it up again.

I'm glad Dale is looking at ENY. Using stats and not just 3 guys crying about something.





Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Eagler on October 31, 2026, 07:21:45 AM
ENY has never been an issue for me...

Being on a side that doesn't have a fight and is happy taking empty bases is..

Eagler
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: The Fugitive on October 31, 2026, 10:27:56 AM
Thanks for looking into this and for your consideration!

Are you able to run stats on how various levels of ENY affect overall numbers? One of my contentions has been  that I feel ENY does eventually even the sides, but I have a feeling that it does so by reducing the numbers of players and not by players switching sides to even the numbers.

I'd love to see how the stats work out on numbers before and after ENY ( at various levels of ENY) affect the people in flight or logged in.

The rest of this post is not directed directly at you, Dale

_____________________________ _____________________________ _____________________________ _____

I just have always felt that the large majority of players will not switch sides when heave ENY kicks in. I think they deal with it for a bit, sit in the tower for a bit to wait or log off.
So that's part of my point - and I could be wrong - but I feel that ENY does not really work as intended.

When I mentioned DAR being addressed, I meant this: I've never once ever heard anyone in the game mention anything about DAR being a problem. I see like three people on the forum crying about it and then it gets addressed - when I don't think anyone ever had a problem with it. Then a change gets introduced based on what 3 guys are saying here, and tons  of people in game don't know what's going on with the glitchy DAR.

On the other hand, I will bet that every single night I hear people complain about ENY on vox. There are countess complaints about ENY going back years, to the point that people attack anyone for bringing it up again.

I'm glad Dale is looking at ENY. Using stats and not just 3 guys crying about something.

Your perception of what ENY does is what is wrong.

ENY is used to balance game play by removing the better equipment from the team that has the ADVANTAGE in numbers.

ENY is NOT setup to make players switch to other teams to balance the numbers. Switching is an option to players who wish to use the the better equipment that has been removed due to the numbers imbalance.

If one team has 10 extra players and there is no ENY, those players can jump in a number of B24 with ponies and D9 as roll base after base with ease. The other team doesnt have the numbers to top them.

WITH ENY, those 10 players are stuck trying to do the same thing with Bostons and P40s something that is much easier to fight against Making the fight a bit more balanced.

Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Max on October 31, 2026, 10:30:09 AM
Your perception of what ENY does is what is wrong.

ENY is used to balance game play by removing the better equipment from the team that has the ADVANTAGE in numbers.

ENY is NOT setup to make players switch to other teams to balance the numbers. Switching is an option to players who wish to use the the better equipment that has been removed due to the numbers imbalance.

If one team has 10 extra players and there is no ENY, those players can jump in a number of B24 with ponies and D9 as roll base after base with ease. The other team doesnt have the numbers to top them.

WITH ENY, those 10 players are stuck trying to do the same thing with Bostons and P40s something that is much easier to fight against Making the fight a bit more balanced.

Best explanation I've ever read.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: -gg- on October 31, 2026, 11:31:09 AM
Your perception of what ENY does is what is wrong.

ENY is used to balance game play by removing the better equipment from the team that has the ADVANTAGE in numbers.

ENY is NOT setup to make players switch to other teams to balance the numbers. Switching is an option to players who wish to use the the better equipment that has been removed due to the numbers imbalance.

If one team has 10 extra players and there is no ENY, those players can jump in a number of B24 with ponies and D9 as roll base after base with ease. The other team doesnt have the numbers to top them.

WITH ENY, those 10 players are stuck trying to do the same thing with Bostons and P40s something that is much easier to fight against Making the fight a bit more balanced.

I think your perception is wrong. Dale just came into this thread and told me that I'm choosing to fly a worse plane rather than switch sides to play a better plane. The intention is for the numbers to get balanced.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: -gg- on October 31, 2026, 11:32:05 AM
Can we go back to the main argument that I'm making. Is that the game is punishing you. It's punishing people simply for being on a team that happens to have a few more numbers than the other side.

Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: hitech on October 31, 2026, 11:33:48 AM
Can we go back to the main argument that I'm making. Is that the game is punishing you. It's punishing people simply for being on a team that happens to have a few more numbers than the other side.

No.

HiTech
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: -gg- on October 31, 2026, 11:37:34 AM
Lol.

Hey Dale can you clear it up then. ENY is intended to entice people to change sides to balance the numbers, right?

Just like you have automatic side switchers.

What I think happens is most people will not switch sides. If they have to deal with  ENY that gets bad they'll start to sit in the tower and then they'll log off. So there you go your numbers are balanced.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: caldera on October 31, 2026, 12:02:21 PM
No.

HiTech

BOOM.   :rofl
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: -gg- on October 31, 2026, 12:11:44 PM
The intent I believe is to balance the numbers. If somebody doesn't like what's happening due to eny, they're only recourse is to either deal with it, change sides, sit in the tower or log off.

Out of all those options I believe people at first deal with it. If it gets severe like past into the twenties, people will get frustrated. Or at least I do. I'll sit in the tower and then I'll log off. And I hear lots of people saying the same thing. Or saying good night on squad channel. ENY too high. Good night guys. But they say it in more colorful language.

And I know the intent isn't to punish people. That's not the intent but for me as a individual player, that's the result of it. I log in nearly every single night and I'm dealing with e n y for the whole time I'm on pretty much. So in my mind, my gameplay is being stymied by the system. And my only recourse is to change sides.

Changing sides is just as much of a negative effect on my gameplay than dealing with the eny. My friends and squad are on my countryside. I'm not loyal to a chess piece. That's not even the point. I couldn't give a damn what chess piece it is. But you're flying with three or four guys that are on your squadron. Or maybe even eight or 10 on squad night, and just those low numbers are enough to throw the eny off.

I'm glad Dale is looking at that and toning it down on the low numbers. Because that's really distorting the game. And it makes the system not work. Like even if somebody wanted to change sides it would flip the eny on the other side super easily by just a couple people changing sides.

So even though the intent is not to punish me, that's the result of it. I feel like I'm being punished or my gameplay is being inhibited. My enjoyment of the game is being inhibited because of a mechanism in the game that is designed to give the other guys a leg up in a fight. I believe that the intention is to balance the numbers.

Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: hitech on October 31, 2026, 12:49:55 PM
The intent I believe is to balance the numbers. If somebody doesn't like what's happening due to eny, they're only recourse is to either deal with it, change sides, sit in the tower or log off.

Out of all those options I believe people at first deal with it. If it gets severe like past into the twenties, people will get frustrated. Or at least I do. I'll sit in the tower and then I'll log off. And I hear lots of people saying the same thing. Or saying good night on squad channel. ENY too high. Good night guys. But they say it in more colorful language.

And I know the intent isn't to punish people. That's not the intent but for me as a individual player, that's the result of it. I log in nearly every single night and I'm dealing with e n y for the whole time I'm on pretty much. So in my mind, my gameplay is being stymied by the system. And my only recourse is to change sides.

Changing sides is just as much of a negative effect on my gameplay than dealing with the eny. My friends and squad are on my countryside. I'm not loyal to a chess piece. That's not even the point. I couldn't give a damn what chess piece it is. But you're flying with three or four guys that are on your squadron. Or maybe even eight or 10 on squad night, and just those low numbers are enough to throw the eny off.

I'm glad Dale is looking at that and toning it down on the low numbers. Because that's really distorting the game. And it makes the system not work. Like even if somebody wanted to change sides it would flip the eny on the other side super easily by just a couple people changing sides.

So even though the intent is not to punish me, that's the result of it. I feel like I'm being punished or my gameplay is being inhibited. My enjoyment of the game is being inhibited because of a mechanism in the game that is designed to give the other guys a leg up in a fight. I believe that the intention is to balance the numbers.
,
just to make sure I 100% understand your point, you don't  like ENY. Did i understand you correctly?

HiTech
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Banshee7 on October 31, 2026, 12:57:56 PM
No.

HiTech

 :rofl :ahand
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Dadtallica on October 31, 2026, 01:22:40 PM
,
just to make sure I 100% understand your point, you don't  like ENY. Did i understand you correctly?

HiTech

But hear me out…
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: CAV on October 31, 2026, 01:34:48 PM
 

Oddly enough Of the many things I like to poke sticks at sometimes...

ENY has never been one of them. It has always appeared to Function correctly and have the desired results. That being to hinder the side with the larger Force.

Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: -gg- on October 31, 2026, 01:36:09 PM
,
just to make sure I 100% understand your point, you don't  like ENY. Did i understand you correctly?

HiTech

That is correct. I think it's bad for the game and the low numbers don't justify having it in effect. But you do you. Jump on that big radar issue that nobody ever had an issue with and leave ENY alone because 4 guys here say they don't mind it.





Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: hitech on October 31, 2026, 02:19:09 PM
That is correct. I think it's bad for the game and the low numbers don't justify having it in effect. But you do you. Jump on that big radar issue that nobody ever had an issue with and leave ENY alone because 4 guys here say they don't mind it.

The reason I push back at you so hard is that you may not even have been around for the complaints of side imbalance pre ENY. You simply keep on saying you do not like it without a single thought of what things were, or would be, without it.

A few samples of what this board looked like before ENY:
A new low in the Main Arena balance (https://bbs.hitechcreations.com/smf/index.php?topic=61534.0) (2002)
Side balancing (https://bbs.hitechcreations.com/smf/index.php?topic=69234.0) (2002)
Unbalanced Just Not Fun (https://bbs.hitechcreations.com/smf/index.php?topic=91062.0) (2003)
30 on 5 - The Horde Mentality (https://bbs.hitechcreations.com/smf/index.php?topic=102435.0) (2003)
Outnumbered by Rooks...again (https://bbs.hitechcreations.com/smf/index.php?topic=124808.0) (2004)

2nd, you seem to not even think side balancing is important. You say get rid of it without suggesting any way to improve side balancing.

First you just wanted it not to take effect with lower numbers (it was always designed that way, but could be improved), so I am changing it, it goes in Tuesday, and you simply moved the goal posts.

And finally you do a passive aggressive post at me.

I'm done with you on this.

HiTech
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: -gg- on October 31, 2026, 02:34:13 PM
The reason I push back at you so hard is that you may not even have been around for the complaints of side imbalance pre ENY. You simply keep on saying you do not like it without a single thought of what things were, or would be, without it.

A few samples of what this board looked like before ENY:
A new low in the Main Arena balance (https://bbs.hitechcreations.com/smf/index.php?topic=61534.0) (2002)
Side balancing (https://bbs.hitechcreations.com/smf/index.php?topic=69234.0) (2002)
Unbalanced Just Not Fun (https://bbs.hitechcreations.com/smf/index.php?topic=91062.0) (2003)
30 on 5 - The Horde Mentality (https://bbs.hitechcreations.com/smf/index.php?topic=102435.0) (2003)
Outnumbered by Rooks...again (https://bbs.hitechcreations.com/smf/index.php?topic=124808.0) (2004)

2nd, you seem to not even think side balancing is important. You say get rid of it without suggesting any way to improve side balancing.

First you just wanted it not to take effect with lower numbers (it was always designed that way, but could be improved), so I am changing it, it goes in Tuesday, and you simply moved the goal posts.

And finally you do a passive aggressive post at me.

I'm done with you on this.

HiTech

Started playing 2001. Came from Aw. Been around for everything. 1000's of players from this forum came to my forum and I'm still friends with 100s

I gave back to you what you gave to me in replies. Being smart. I can do it too.

I've said that with the LOW NUMBERS it's not good for the GAME because I see what it does when the numbers are low. It does not balkance the numbers by having people switch sides. It balances the numbers by having the few guys online logg off - and then the ENY goes away and the numbers are balanced.

I've suggested having AI run stats. I've suggested in game polls.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Dadtallica on October 31, 2026, 02:51:52 PM
Started playing 2001. Came from Aw. Been around for everything. 1000's of players from this forum came to my forum and I'm still friends with 100s

I gave back to you what you gave to me in replies. Being smart. I can do it too.

I've said that with the LOW NUMBERS it's not good for the GAME because I see what it does when the numbers are low. It does not balkance the numbers by having people switch sides. It balances the numbers by having the few guys online logg off - and then the ENY goes away and the numbers are balanced.

I've suggested having AI run stats. I've suggested in game polls.

Because that’s what you and others are choosing to do. You only wanna fly a specific thing what a silly argument.

You don’t want to switch side it’s fine, fly something else. You’ve been told of dozens of choices better than some of the planes. You apparently think you can’t fly.

And if ENY is always bothering you then you’re on the outnumbering side…

Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: -gg- on October 31, 2026, 03:05:56 PM
Because that’s what you and others are choosing to do. You only wanna fly a specific thing what a silly argument.

You don’t want to switch side it’s fine, fly something else. You’ve been told of dozens of choices better than some of the planes. You apparently think you can’t fly.

And if ENY is always bothering you then you’re on the outnumbering side…


As usual, you don't understand the point. I'm not loyal to a side I don't care about changing sides but I do want to stay with my squadron.

But I've suggested is that AI runs stats of the actual effects of eny.

When it kicks in at low numbers what I see happening is the numbers equalizing by the numbers going down after it kicks in. That suggests people sit in the tower or log off.

I fly plenty of planes. Mostly it doesn't bother me, but I get super irritated when it gets to be in the 20s and I'm still flying against the odds in actual fights that I'm seeing on the map


So to go back to my argument that you keep ignoring. It does not work with low numbers. Even if someone does switch sides with the low numbers then the balance will instantly shift to that side. Only a one or two or three people can affect the numbers in a big way.


It's not about what I want to fly. I can fly a lot of different planes.


And it's funny that people say that I don't want to switch sides. Nobody wants to switch


I suggested a fix for the early morning times that Shane was talking about. When I think it's The Bishop's just come on with a couple of squads. Maybe even three squads and they just roll the map every morning.

I suggested that map change AI analyzes the numbers and moves people around to different countries. Keeping squads intact. People squealed like pigs over that. Even if they get moved with their entire squad they're not changing countries for anything! Lol!


In fact why don't you do a poll on how many people are loyal to their stupid chess piece?


What I'm saying is that it just does not work for the game when the numbers are low. And you people keep going back to it it's just me not wanting to fly a certain plane. I fly plenty of planes. The plan that I fly the most is probably the p-47 d40.

I think that if I were Dale I would be figuring out if it actually works for the game

When Dale suggested possibly adding AI planes to make up the numbers? People squealed over that too. Because people don't like change. I'm fine with having AI plains defend bases or whatever. Who cares? Act does the same thing.


You act like you're open-minded but I bet you're not.

Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Dadtallica on October 31, 2026, 03:08:02 PM
It’s in the poll go see
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: -gg- on October 31, 2026, 03:12:40 PM
What I would like to see happen you guys will cry like babies about.

I would like to see, after every map change that AI jumbles people around to the different countries based on stats. Even the numbers is closest possible. Keep squads intact but move them around.

When the numbers are this low, one squadron can throw the numbers off. And if you have three squadrons coming on in the morning every morning and they're always on bishops, they are always going to be rolling the map.


Do something creative. But people will cry over that. And they did. Because they don't want to change countries no matter what. Even if their whole squad comes with them.


I would also not mind seeing AI planes coming up to defend bases when the eny would normally kick in. Just takes a few things to even it out when the numbers are low.


But the first thing I would do would be to not take anybody's opinion on things just because they're vocal here. Including me. I would put in game polls. I've suggested it before.

Have a log out poll. When you log off what is your reason for logging out for the night? Or the day.? Not enough action? Can't find a fight? Played 2 hours already? E n y? Whatever it is. Getting gangbang?

But really I would have an analysis of what eny actually does during certain times when it kicks in hard. Do people actually switch sides to balance it out? Or do they log off? Pretty basic.

Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Dadtallica on October 31, 2026, 03:22:08 PM
I don’t think people realize that Delta between what’s in here and what’s out there is not that big.

It’s the same 200 or so people every single day probably less. How many people do you actually think there are especially when most arguments are about the numbers?
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Animl-AW on October 31, 2026, 03:26:05 PM
Lol

Absolutely not

A few of those ideas are more evasive against the players will than ENY. No freedom


Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Animl-AW on October 31, 2026, 03:33:59 PM
Settings are all about baby steps, for good reason. Those who make large hasty changes their milage will vary.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: -gg- on October 31, 2026, 03:37:07 PM
I don’t think people realize that Delta between what’s in here and what’s out there is not that big.

It’s the same 200 or so people every single day probably less. How many people do you actually think there are especially when most arguments are about the numbers?


You don't know anything about what the actual Delta is.

I'll tell you though that just in my own squadron, there are several people who won't even come on here to express their opinions at all. And they hate ENY. We actually joke about ENY on squad vox when it kicks in hard

"Making the game fun for everyone" and it's not just a passing joke. Some people get irritated to the point of reevaluating why they play the game.


Rather than go by your feelings, I would love to see actual statistics on how e n y affects the game.


Because what we see here is that people are unwilling to change countries for anything. You've seen them squealing about that. They absolutely will not change countries even if their whole squad goes with them. So that right there eliminates most of the options for relieving e n y.

The other options are that people just deal with it and they get irritated by it. But they don't say anything here. Most people won't come here to discuss things like that. The other option is they just log off.


Back in the day when there was hundreds of people or even multiple arenas, I never even had one complaint about eny.


Eny is not good when the numbers are this low. That's what I'm saying. Couple that with people unwilling to change size no matter what happens. You're going to get people logging off rather than changing sides.


So evaluate what the real effects of it are. That's all I'm asking. And I'm seeing the effects when the numbers are low to be an impact on the game in a negative way. That's what I feel.





Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Dadtallica on October 31, 2026, 03:42:33 PM
I for sure don’t know. I’m just going by the little bit of evidence we all have where are all these people then every day? I see the same exact names every single day because I’m there just like the rest of them every single day. Of course, nobody knows for sure because we’re not inside the business, but it’s not like they aren’t ways to figure it out relatively…

The low relative… what’s low to you is not to others.

When it gets under 70-75 people, I usually log off. I understand it’s different for everyone.

Finding fights is relative, I never have trouble finding something to do. What’s a fight to you may be something to someone else.

I think the point you’re realizing is we’re never gonna appease everybody all of the time. You’ve been pretty clear that you just want what you want and that’s all you want.

I put up a poll to inject some new data into stale arguments, a little over 100 people visited and 41 so far have answered. I’ll take a 40% conversion rate all day long! Anyone could share it with anyone in the game. It’s not limited to in here just because it’s in here.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Eagler on October 31, 2026, 03:45:17 PM
Strange how some are so in love with their chess piece that they won't switch sides for a better gameplay experience for all of us..

Do that and ENY goes away..

Eagler
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Dadtallica on October 31, 2026, 03:46:14 PM
Strange how some are so in love with their chess piece that they won't switch sides for a better gameplay experience for all of us..

Do that and ENY goes away..

Eagler

You don’t have any trouble finding anyone to fight we play at the same time you’re always there. There’s always people I’m not sure what you’re even talking about.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: JimmyD3 on October 31, 2026, 05:35:14 PM
The reason I push back at you so hard is that you may not even have been around for the complaints of side imbalance pre ENY. You simply keep on saying you do not like it without a single thought of what things were, or would be, without it.

A few samples of what this board looked like before ENY:
A new low in the Main Arena balance (https://bbs.hitechcreations.com/smf/index.php?topic=61534.0) (2002)
Side balancing (https://bbs.hitechcreations.com/smf/index.php?topic=69234.0) (2002)
Unbalanced Just Not Fun (https://bbs.hitechcreations.com/smf/index.php?topic=91062.0) (2003)
30 on 5 - The Horde Mentality (https://bbs.hitechcreations.com/smf/index.php?topic=102435.0) (2003)
Outnumbered by Rooks...again (https://bbs.hitechcreations.com/smf/index.php?topic=124808.0) (2004)

2nd, you seem to not even think side balancing is important. You say get rid of it without suggesting any way to improve side balancing.

First you just wanted it not to take effect with lower numbers (it was always designed that way, but could be improved), so I am changing it, it goes in Tuesday, and you simply moved the goal posts.

And finally you do a passive aggressive post at me.

I'm done with you on this.

HiTech


Hmmm I think that ends the discussion........ :devil
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: hazmatt on October 31, 2026, 06:16:32 PM
Outnumbered by Rooks...again (https://bbs.hitechcreations.com/smf/index.php?topic=124808.0) (2004)

Dang. His complaint was: "I logged on tonight to 260 Rooks vs 170 Knights and 140 Bishops."
Those numbers would be a nice problem to have!
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: hazmatt on October 31, 2026, 06:21:20 PM
Hmmm I think that ends the discussion........ :devil

The dead horse will continue to be beaten!
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Dadtallica on October 31, 2026, 06:23:16 PM
Hmmm I think that ends the discussion........ :devil

Narrator: The discussion in fact has not ended.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: ~ZoSo~ on October 31, 2026, 08:05:44 PM
Narrator: The discussion in fact has not ended.

I can attest to that.  :D
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: -gg- on October 31, 2026, 08:43:55 PM
Case in point. How does this make sense to you guys?
I'm on the knights.


(https://i.ibb.co/pvRkXL96/20261031-183946.jpg) (https://ibb.co/zh7tf40W)
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: -gg- on October 31, 2026, 08:47:12 PM
And this.

(https://i.ibb.co/Vp2011n8/20261031-184602.jpg) (https://ibb.co/fG4Vgg67)
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Spikes on October 31, 2026, 08:48:48 PM
Perfect time for an La-5 or G14.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: -gg- on October 31, 2026, 08:50:21 PM
For me it's time to log off. And this is 20 minutes after I logged in. So it's good night for me. The rooks have one more player in the air than we do and we have over twice the eny that the rooks do
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: -gg- on October 31, 2026, 08:52:11 PM
At these low numbers nobody's getting gangbanged on these maps. That's my point.

And it's exactly what I was saying before. I'm not fighting people in a big gang hard. I'm actually the one being outnumbered most of the time. In the fights that I choose. And I'm forced to fly a worse plane than the other guy because the game is giving them a leg up for what?
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Dadtallica on October 31, 2026, 08:57:07 PM
All I see is sheetrock.

Hardware stores lose money on every single piece of sheet rock they sell. However, for everything you ever needed to use a sheet rock, they make 10 times more than they’ll ever buy it for. And I mean everything you’ve ever used to need sheet rock.

That makes US primetime the spackle of AHIII. It’s all about the juice you’re squeezing.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Animl-AW on October 31, 2026, 09:14:35 PM
Hmmm I think that ends the discussion........ :devil

<spit flies through finger covered mouth>

Been goin since my return in 22 (not Room 222 or Karen Valentine, diff subject, ), it still has a full tank of gas. I spent 3 weeks in deep painful thought of something new to add to it,..... I got nothing.
"Mark All Read"
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Banshee7 on October 31, 2026, 10:50:58 PM
At these low numbers nobody's getting gangbanged on these maps. That's my point.

And it's exactly what I was saying before. I'm not fighting people in a big gang hard. I'm actually the one being outnumbered most of the time. In the fights that I choose. And I'm forced to fly a worse plane than the other guy because the game is giving them a leg up for what?
(https://i.postimg.cc/KjmVtdH3/IMG-2611.jpg)
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: nrshida on November 01, 2026, 05:44:21 AM
Case in point. How does this make sense to you guys?

The Dale God Entity himself came here, expended energy - energy he could either use working on expanding the game or relaxing - discussing your issue with you in a civil way so he could understand it, presented evidence of necessity to the contrary for the overall good of the game and yet you still persist as if you know better. That you're equal in authority on gameplay to the man who wrote the game and has ran it for > 20-years. Implied you have influence over multiple players you can use if you don't get what you want and are willing to escalate this into an uncivil personal interaction the moment things don't go your way.
And even brag about being good at that!

You've learned nothing about ENY, learned nothing about yourself, have abundantly demonstrated that the word no somehow doesn't apply to you and that your standard operating position is one of ignorant entitlement. All you have achieved is making it clear to the DGE that the time he spent on your issue (and likely future issues) was wasted, frustrating and unpleasant.

Well played.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Eagler on November 01, 2026, 05:56:35 AM
Learn more than one late war ride and you can have fun regardless what ENY it is..

I got 3 kills in a sortie in a 109f and 109k4 last night..

Guess which one was more fun..especially with the new dar delay  :airplane:

Eagler
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: -gg- on November 01, 2026, 08:05:07 AM
The Dale God Entity himself came here, expended energy - energy he could either use working on expanding the game or relaxing - discussing your issue with you in a civil way so he could understand it, presented evidence of necessity to the contrary for the overall good of the game and yet you still persist as if you know better. That you're equal in authority on gameplay to the man who wrote the game and has ran it for > 20-years. Implied you have influence over multiple players you can use if you don't get what you want and are willing to escalate this into an uncivil personal interaction the moment things don't go your way.
And even brag about being good at that!

You've learned nothing about ENY, learned nothing about yourself, have abundantly demonstrated that the word no somehow doesn't apply to you and that your standard operating position is one of ignorant entitlement. All you have achieved is making it clear to the DGE that the time he spent on your issue (and likely future issues) was wasted, frustrating and unpleasant.

Well played.


I don't think he's gay, but this kind of thing she probably sent to him in private.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: hazmatt on November 01, 2026, 10:18:44 AM

I don't think he's gay, but this kind of thing she probably sent to him in private.
:headscratch:
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Max on November 01, 2026, 11:44:46 AM

I don't think he's gay, but this kind of thing she probably sent to him in private.

 :confused:
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: nrshida on November 01, 2026, 12:22:25 PM
I don't think he's gay, but this kind of thing she probably sent to him in private.

Is this all you've got? Your whole other forum is packed with calling people gay too. Do you not yourself see the particular irony in your case of using this as an insult?

What a freak.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: -gg- on November 01, 2026, 12:45:30 PM
I'm here to discuss e n y. You seem to be here to discuss me. Maybe go find somewhere else to insult someone
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Banshee7 on November 01, 2026, 12:55:07 PM
I'm here to discuss e n y. You seem to be here to discuss me. Maybe go find somewhere else to insult someone


I don't think he's gay, but this kind of thing she probably sent to him in private.

Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: nrshida on November 01, 2026, 01:11:34 PM
I'm here to discuss e n y. You seem to be here to discuss me. Maybe go find somewhere else to insult someone

I did not insult you, I criticised your behaviour and remarks. Is it impossible for you to take a remarks on the chin and reflect on your own behaviour? By the way go ahead and knock yourself out insulting me if you like. Water off a duck's back and still won't diminish my observations.

Also, it rather looks like the discussion ended right here:-

I'm done with you on this.

...directly because of your behaviour and remarks. Try to connect the two ends together...
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: -gg- on November 01, 2026, 01:28:31 PM
I'm not going to argue with you. Came in here discussing me. And how I don't understand things and you're talking about me not the subject.

And then you called me a freak. So I recommend that you go somewhere else because I'm not going to argue with you.

Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: -gg- on November 01, 2026, 01:33:22 PM
If anybody wants to debate me on the merits of my argument about eny and how I don't feel it's effective at low numbers, I'm more than willing to argue those points.

If you want to come here and just say that I'm stupid and I don't understand what I'm talking about that I'm not going to argue with you

Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: nrshida on November 01, 2026, 02:02:43 PM
If anybody wants to debate me on the merits of my argument about eny and how I don't feel it's effective at low numbers, I'm more than willing to argue those points.

You've had that opportunity and didn't argue any valid points, just stated what you wanted while disregarding what the fellow who actually has the data tried to explain to you.

Freak is a statement of fact BTW, Zack told me. Don't you remember  :)
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: -gg- on November 01, 2026, 02:14:39 PM
Let me restate my arguments. And Dale actually said he was going to consider making a change. So before you have a knee-jerk reaction why don't you read what I've been saying?
Approach any kind of an argument about anything I said. All you did was criticize me.


My points.

1. When the numbers are very low in the arena, e n y does not serve its purpose.
2. People refuse to switch sides to balance numbers almost no matter what. There are very few automatic side switchers.
3. E n y, when it kicks in hard does actually balance the numbers when the numbers.... But it does so by people logging off on the side that it's affecting not by them switching sides.


My whole point is that Ian why does not work as intended.

I've also made the point that nobody should listen to anybody's opinion on this forum. I suggest that AI or whatever reports can be run in the actual arena that will actually gauge the effects of eny and what it does to the population when it kicks in at various levels.

To point number one. When there are maybe 30 people in the arena and I kicks in hard on one side, it doesn't make sense. One side might only have two or three more planes in the air than the other but they are affected by eny because one side has a few more or less. I've seen it happen and I posted screenshots from just the other night. We had e n y 21 while another side had one more plane in the air than we did and they had half the eny that we did.

So in order to balance the numbers when those numbers are very low in the arena, say somebody from the side that had three or four more players switched to a lower side. Then suddenly that side will have Ian why because of the numbers are so low that two or three planes or players will affect it again.

I proposed that it should not come into effect until there are at least 60 or 100 people playing in the game. Dale came back and said that he was considering starting the eny at 10 players. And then he also asked about AI planes. I'm all for the AI planes balancing the numbers.


I made valid logical points all along and over a couple of different threads that it's been discussed. I don't know where you've been or if you even play the game

I'm telling you that my opinion is that Ian y is not good for the game. Because it doesn't work as intended. That's mine feeling. I feel that Dale should run statistics in the game to find out if that's true or not but I suspect it's true.

People have come on here and said that they will not switch sides no matter what.


I've also suggested that after each map reset, there could be a shuffling of squadrons to different countries. That would fix the morning problem of the bishops being the dominant team every single morning because of two or three squads that come on in the morning.

When a map is one, all the squadrons get shifted around to different countries to balance everything out. And they can't go back to the country they were just on before. People squeal like pigs over that because they absolutely will not change countries. But that would be good for the game. I would be all for it. That solves the problem of people who say they won't switch sides because they're squad won't come with them. Just make it automatic. Make it automatically rotate everybody that's in a squad. 90% of the players are in a squad I would say.

Stuff like that that's easy to fix and balance the game rather than having e n y not doing its job to begin with.

And again I'll say it. Ny doesn't do its job because people will not switch sides to balance the numbers. They absolutely will not.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: -gg- on November 01, 2026, 02:20:09 PM
In case you don't want to read all that. The main point is that ENY doesn't work when the numbers are super low in the arena. Period .

I've been playing since 2001 and I've never had an issue or complain about e n y before. I see what it's doing in the game and I see that it doesn't work.

Aa a customer this is the one place I can come to voice my opinion about it. I play the game currently. If you want to come here tell me I'm stupid or that I don't know what I'm talking about you're not discussing anything with me.

Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Dadtallica on November 01, 2026, 02:30:56 PM
Just because you say something in here doesn’t mean it should be invalidated because you say it here…

You said it yourself you’re a customer like anyone else where they voice, their opinion shouldn’t matter the opinion should.

He said he would try it at 10 people to begin and let the sliding scale go from there so using your original example from the first page, you would’ve been less restricted.

Also, I don’t think it’s a perfect system. It just doesn’t affect me and even when it is affecting me, it doesn’t bother me.

The subjectivity of this game is its secret sauce.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Spikes on November 01, 2026, 02:33:54 PM
Making arguments and discussing things seems large irrelevant because...

I'm done with you on this.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: -gg- on November 01, 2026, 03:04:26 PM

.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: fudgums on November 01, 2026, 04:05:49 PM
Crew chief. report gg
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: JimmyD3 on November 01, 2026, 04:08:18 PM
Crew chief. report gg

 :rofl :rofl :rofl, sorry but that is just funny.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: -gg- on November 01, 2026, 04:16:16 PM
Lol
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: nrshida on November 02, 2026, 12:46:42 AM
If you want to come here and just say that I'm stupid and I don't understand what I'm talking about that I'm not going to argue with you

Twice in this thread you've suggested I called you stupid. The number is in fact 0, so far. I did call you a freak for trying to use the word gay as an insult. Which would seem fair and appropriate under your own rules of engagement which you stated earlier to the DGE. I also call a spade a spade. If you don't like to be called a spade either don't act like a spade or accept you're a spade.

I've been playing since 2001 and I've never had an issue or complain about e n y before. I see what it's doing in the game and I see that it doesn't work.

Yeah for you. Every inconsiderate person would like adjustments to favour themselves. We know you think you're right. That largely comes because you can't listen to others, don't know the difference between criticism and a personal attack, your critical thinking is cack and you can't discern that an uninformed, myopic feeling is a completely different thing from a well-argued and evidenced position derived from an actual discussion.

Have a nice day!
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: -gg- on November 02, 2026, 06:57:31 AM
You have zero reading comprehension.

I've said over and over again that I don't think Dale should listen to anybody's opinions and make decisions based on what they say here on this forum. I think he should run statistics in the game to see how ENY IS actually affecting the numbers in the game as it kicks in at various levels when numbers are low.

My thought is that people will sit in the tower and eventually log off after it reaches a certain level  and that they will never switch sides to balance the numbers.

Also suggested taking polls directly in the game. Not on this forum where there's a bunch of people who don't even play anymore. This forum has a few vocal people. I think that he should listen to people in the actual game.

Another Cool change would be to have a place on the forum where we can filter out people who don't actually play the game. Maybe just for paying customers.
I think it's odd that people who have not played the game in years and have no real plans to play it again are over here throwing their opinions about current game play around.

That would be like me hanging out in a Jeep Wrangler forum and arguing with current Wrangler owners about features on their Jeeps. I had a Jeep Wrangler in 2008 so I still hang out and give my opinions like I'm relevant. 



Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: -gg- on November 02, 2026, 07:40:55 AM
I've made suggestions for the game that I feel would be good for the game. Like the AI game feature assistance for in-game use that I suggested a couple months ago. Now we have Crew Chief.

On ENY, I think Dale might make an adjustment for when the numbers are low. I appreciate that he's said that.

I've been a supporter of  the game and of HiTech for a long time. I have a love of the game and want to see it succeed. I like Dale and support him too. I have empathy for the things he's gone through and I'm excited that he's back in action.





Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: nrshida on November 02, 2026, 09:36:38 AM
That would be like me hanging out in a Jeep Wrangler forum and arguing with current Wrangler owners about features on their Jeeps. I had a Jeep Wrangler in 2008 so I still hang out and give my opinions like I'm relevant.

Only if the new Jeep Wranglers had a completely revolutionary structure, propulsion, driveline and controls. Otherwise the experienced ones would continue to know what they're talking about now wouldn't they.

I've made suggestions for the game that I feel would be good for the game. Like the AI game feature assistance for in-game use that I suggested a couple months ago. Now we have Crew Chief.

It's spooky how you think that happened isn't it. I daresay you'll get a mention on the next splash screen!  :banana:

Just to clarify, you're saying you're a reasonable, level-headed, respectful contributor who only has the best interests of the game in mind and get's unfairly attacked continuously by non-paying barstards with nothing good to say? Weird!
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: -gg- on November 02, 2026, 09:54:19 AM
I'll probably be done arguing with you soon because really you're not that interesting. I've never said that I'm unduly attacked or anything such. I have a thick skin.

I did notice that you have never once even made any kind of arguments disputing anything I've said about e and y. All you've done is posted about me basically.

During the times that I wasn't actively playing the game, I never even thought about coming to this section of the forum. I was in the old club. I find it interesting that you hang out here and blow smoke up Dale's ass.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: nrshida on November 02, 2026, 10:01:35 AM
I'll probably be done arguing with you soon because really you're not that interesting.

Yeah probably pretty soon...

I'm not going to argue with you.... 
...I'm not going to argue with you.

If you want to come here and just say that I'm stupid and I don't understand what I'm talking about that I'm not going to argue with you

This is like mocking the afflicted at this point.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: -gg- on November 02, 2026, 10:08:56 AM
seriously, the only thing you've added to this thread is conflict. You've not responded to a single point made about ENY, nor offered an opinion on anything other than me, my forum and my posts.

And you have no skin in the game. Go be an irritant somewhere else. Your input is not useful.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: nrshida on November 02, 2026, 10:16:51 AM
seriously, the only thing you've added to this thread is accurate criticism of a disingenuously-presented proposition disguised as what's good for the game

Fixed
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: hitech on November 02, 2026, 10:40:10 AM
accurate criticism of a disingenuously-presented proposition disguised as what's good for the game

Agreed

HiTech
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: -gg- on November 02, 2026, 10:45:14 AM
Disingenuous? I've said don't listen to my opinion - I suggested to look at what ENY does in-game when is hits at various levels when numbers are low and make a decision based on that.

I don't see players switching sides when ENY hits hard when numbers are LOW.   I see them logging off. That's anecdotal, but that's my feeling. That's what I do

I don't normally fly low ENY planes. I think I most fly the p47 D-40

I don't have an issue with ENY when numbers are high, but I never fly when numbers are high. My issue is when there's a huge empty map, no gang bangs and I see ENY penalizing players that are on a side that has maybe a few more players than another with no realistic remedy in game other than deal with it.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: -gg- on November 02, 2026, 10:48:06 AM
I've presented points and ideas for remedy. At least I play the game and I am telling you an honest opinion. NShidder has not offer a thing other than to talk about me personally.

Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Spikes on November 02, 2026, 10:50:18 AM
NShidder

Maybe go find somewhere else to insult someone
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Dadtallica on November 02, 2026, 11:02:41 AM
Disingenuous? I've said don't listen to my opinion - I suggested to look at what ENY does in-game when is hits at various levels when numbers are low and make a decision based on that.

I don't see players switching sides when ENY hits hard when numbers are LOW.   I see them logging off. That's anecdotal, but that's my feeling. That's what I do

I don't normally fly low ENY planes. I think I most fly the p47 D-40

I don't have an issue with ENY when numbers are high, but I never fly when numbers are high. My issue is when there's a huge empty map, no gang bangs and I see ENY penalizing players that are on a side that has maybe a few more players than another with no realistic remedy in game other than deal with it.

Balancing the sides doesn’t necessarily mean switching sides. Why do you hang on that?

It’s balancing the options. It guards against all of us who don’t ever wanna switch sides and protect and rewards those who do.

You can’t seem to understand that it’s not the ENY limiting anyone. Only the player can limit themselves. I know that’s a bit of a metaphysical hurdle for some it takes a few minutes to think about it.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: -gg- on November 02, 2026, 11:05:40 AM
Did you miss this example dale?

(https://i.ibb.co/Kptx2c5Z/20261031-184602.jpg) (https://ibb.co/0R0yCpnN)
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: -gg- on November 02, 2026, 11:07:26 AM
That's an example from the other night but I can give you examples probably every single night. Nobody on the map is outnumbering anybody and look at those eny numbers.

And I'm not saying it's a simple equation based on raw numbers. It has to do with what's going on on the map as well.


If you weren't so damn stubborn you might actually think about this a little bit.

I can call you on the phone if you would like? Seems like you might want to hear some of the ideas that you've missed here. Maybe not. I'm not talking about me personally. It does affect me personally but I'm telling you I am coming here because I think it's bad for the game. And you don't believe me? Oh well.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: -gg- on November 02, 2026, 11:17:33 AM
I'll tell you another thing dale. When I donated to your kids school. The $100 or whatever that was I didn't do that for the perks. I could have donated $5 or whatever right? I don't even use perks. I rarely ever have ever flown a plane. Take the perks back if you want. I did it to support you.

I genuinely support you abd this game. On my forum there have been times when people have talked a lot of crap about you and this game and I've never participated in that. I've always defended you and this game.

I'm a pretty loyal customer of yours. Excited that you came back and are showing interest in the game again.

Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: The Fugitive on November 02, 2026, 11:26:09 AM
I'll tell you another thing dale. When I donated to your kids school. The $100 or whatever that was I didn't do that for the perks. I could have donated $5 or whatever right? I don't even use perks. I rarely ever have ever flown a plane. Take the perks back if you want. I did it to support you.

I genuinely support you abd this game. On my forum there have been times when people have talked a lot of crap about you and this game and I've never participated in that. I've always defended you and this game.

I'm a pretty loyal customer of yours. Excited that you came back and are showing interest in the game again.

And yet you badger him about something he has said he is looking into, and making adjustments to for the next update. At least give him "2 weeks" to do a bit of work on it.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: -gg- on November 02, 2026, 11:34:43 AM
And yet you badger him about something he has said he is looking into, and making adjustments to for the next update. At least give him "2 weeks" to do a bit of work on it.

I participating in this thread and answering people who are responding to it. I'm not addressing anything to him and I'm not calling him on the phone. He doesn't even have to come into this thread. So how is that badgering him?

He said he was done with me on the subject. Then he came here to agree with some guy who doesn't even play the game that I'm being disingenuous.

Just wonderful. I'm not being disingenuous.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Banshee7 on November 02, 2026, 12:38:41 PM

I don't normally fly low ENY planes. I think I most fly the p47 D-40


Your Top Planes for the last 5 tours (because I'm too lazy to go further)

#1 - Spit 16 - 105 kills. (5 ENY)
#2 - 190D9 - 71 kills     (10 ENY i think)
#3 - 47D-40 - 64 kills
#4 - 51D - 50 kills.        (8 ENY?)
#5 - 47M - 33 kills.        (5 ENY)

Honorable mention, most of your kills last tour was in the N1K


EDIT:  You only have records for the last 6 months, so if I include tour 316 the totals are as follows:

#1 Spit16 - 155
#2 D9 - 126
#3 51D - 93
#4 D40 - 68
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: -gg- on November 02, 2026, 12:40:59 PM
That's based on number of kills not how many times you fly the plane. What about the planes that I died in? Are there stats for the number of hours you put in for each plane? Because I still say it's probably the p47d40.

Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Banshee7 on November 02, 2026, 12:51:52 PM
That's based on number of kills not how many times you fly the plane. What about the planes that I died in? Are there stats for the number of hours you put in for each plane? Because I still say it's probably the p47d40.

Top DEATHS IN for the last 6 tours:

Tour 316:
#1 Spit 16
#2 51D
#3 D9
#13 D-40

Tour 317:
#1 Spit 16
#2 D9
#3 51D
#4 D-40

Tour 318:
#1 Spit 16
#2 D9
#3 D-40

Tour 319:
#1 D-40
#2 Spit16
#3 51D

Tour 320:
#1 N1K
#2 D40
#3 D9
#4 Spit 16

So far in tour 321:
#1 D9
#2 D40 (over #3 by 1 death)
#3 47M


So...it looks like ENY has PUSHED you into the D-40  :rofl

Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Max on November 02, 2026, 12:52:44 PM
(https://i.postimg.cc/4x3crjGD/in-other-news1.jpg) (https://postimages.org/)
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: -gg- on November 02, 2026, 12:55:38 PM
ENY did not get me into the p-47d.40. I started flying it because I like the guns on it. When I first came back was about that time. I've been gone for at least 4 years..

I've never looked at my stats but I had a feeling that the plan that I flew the most is the p-47d40. I probably put the most hours in that plane. I recently started flying the M

None of that has anything to do with my arguments for eny though.

Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Banshee7 on November 02, 2026, 01:04:48 PM
None of that has anything to do with my arguments for eny though.

It has everything to do with your arguments against ENY.  You are complaining about being "punished" by ENY (because that's exactly what ENY is meant to do--punish the side where the imbalance occurs), while most of your kills and deaths occur in lower ENY planes.  It completely throws your argument out the window because it makes it look like your just whining about not getting to fly Spit 16s while your country vastly outnumbers the other.

I think we can all agree that ENY can use a little TLC, and Dale has already stated he was working on.  Be thankful.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: -gg- on November 02, 2026, 01:04:59 PM
Also, vast majority of my time is spent in attack mode.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: -gg- on November 02, 2026, 01:09:59 PM
It has everything to do with your arguments against ENY.  You are complaining about being "punished" by ENY (because that's exactly what ENY is meant to do--punish the side where the imbalance occurs), while most of your kills and deaths occur in lower ENY planes.  It completely throws your argument out the window because it makes it look like your just whining about not getting to fly Spit 16s while your country vastly outnumbers the other.

I think we can all agree that ENY can use a little TLC, and Dale has already stated he was working on.  Be thankful.


That's not true. I'm not complaining because I can't fly a spit 16. I only fly those things now and then in base defense. The majority of the time I'm in a p-47 d40. In attack mode.

The only time I have a problem with e n y is when the numbers are very low and it gets to be above 20. When the numbers are low it makes zero sense. That's my whole entire argument. Not that I can't fly a certain plane.

My point about being punished .... It's because that's what it feels like. It feels like the game is penalizing me as an individual player simply because I'm on a team that has 10 people in the air while the other team has six people in the air or whatever it is on a huge empty map. And I'm being limited on what I can fly against them in. And I go and fly against them and they are in Superior aircraft but I'm not at any advantage in numbers on the actual map.

And I can bear that out with my arguments but no one seems to be taken that as the point.

It's not a simple cry about not being able to fly any certain kind of plane. It's about the fairness of it all. And how it affects the game and behavior of players in the game.


Because I've been saying this over and over but you guys don't listen to me or don't believe me. When the numbers are super low you can't even change sides to equal out the numbers because then you will go on the other side and have Ian why on that side. It just does not make any sense at all to have a big empty map where there are no gangbangs going on and one side is being punished by not being able to select the same plans as the other sides when there's not even any type of gangbanging going on on the actual map.


I've never had a problem with e n y been playing since 2001. When the numbers are this low is when it doesn't work. Absolutely does not work.


I've seen it nearly every single night because that's what time I fly and that's one of my squad is on. Our squad has squad nights on Mondays and sundays. We have about 10 to 15 players on when our squad comes on. So naturally we're going to sway the numbers and always have eny against us.

Shane came on with and was talking about how the bishops roll the map almost every single morning. And that's because there's a couple of squads that fly for the bishops. Maybe three or four guys in the squad come on and that's enough.

Anyway I've suggested a lot of things. It's not a simple argument about not being able to fly a certain plane. It's never been that.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: -gg- on November 02, 2026, 01:13:44 PM
And that goes back to the whole disingenuous argument thing. I'm actually pretty upset about that right now because I'm absolutely not being disingenuous about anything. Anybody that knows me will tell you that my integrity is super important to me. And I'm not Petty about things.

Honestly, eny 21..... Like it was in that picture I'm showing you guys, and the other team has one more plane in the air and has an eby of nine..... And they have more players!  What I do is I sit in the tower and I wait for it to end. Because at 21 is getting down to the plains that I really don't have fun flying. And then when I do I don't want to go up against players who are flying Uber planes and I'm still being outnumbered.


And I'm saying that because those are parts of my argument. It's not that I'm squeaking because I can't fly a certain plane. I'm saying that it doesn't work. Put yourself in anyone's shoes not just me personally. I'm telling you those stories because those are what happens to me personally. I'm not saying change the game for me personally. These are my EXAMPLES of why it doesn't work


It's very frustrating. Trying to make a point to better the game not just for me to be able to fly a certain plane. I really don't give two craps about any kind of a plane. I just don't want to fly really bad planes up against players who are able to choose any plan they want basically and when I look at the map there's like 10 players on the map. And oftentimes the situation on the map is reverse of what you would think it would be with the numbers. Like there is not a big gangbang going on anywhere on a map when there's 15 players online. I don't care what anyone says.

Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: -gg- on November 02, 2026, 01:18:56 PM
Another thing ..... And I'm not even sure how this works, but of the people online that show that they are in flight does that include gvs?  Because if it does that should be figured separately.


When you look at the country status and see the number of people that are in flight, I'm guessing that that means GVS as well?  Maybe figure ENY separately for GVS.


All I know is that you can take a look at that clipboard map that I'm showing you guys. I posted two of them from the same night or it might have been one night after the other.

Check out the numbers of people in the game and the number in flight and then take a look at the eny. We had one less player in flight but had over 21 e n y. The team that had one more player in flight had about a 9 e n y.

I spent the majority of my time online that night sitting in the tower waiting for that to go away. Then I just logged off.

I'm telling you that because that's my experience and that's how I feel about things. But I suspect other players do the same. People in my squad do the same. They log off because of eny. That's 100% fact.

Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: -gg- on November 02, 2026, 01:39:00 PM
The disingenuous comment by Dale has me really bummed out. I've been feeling sick all week. I've had a headache since Monday very nauseous. Just starting to feel better today and now our internet goes out at work and I have no phones or Internet.

So now I'm feeling a little bit depressed about everything.

The game is a minor thing in my life. But I'm a big supporter of the game and I have been. To say that am disingenuous about this genuinely makes me feel like crap
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Mar on November 02, 2026, 03:22:30 PM
Communication has completely fallen apart in this thread. Those kinds of headaches definitely don't help. Nobody wants you to feel like crap Gina, just take a break from the forum for a while, maybe from all screens too. See what you think of HT's changes once you're feeling better.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: -gg- on November 03, 2026, 07:30:44 AM
Your Top Planes for the last 5 tours (because I'm too lazy to go further)

#1 - Spit 16 - 105 kills. (5 ENY)
#2 - 190D9 - 71 kills     (10 ENY i think)
#3 - 47D-40 - 64 kills
#4 - 51D - 50 kills.        (8 ENY?)
#5 - 47M - 33 kills.        (5 ENY)

Honorable mention, most of your kills last tour was in the N1K


EDIT:  You only have records for the last 6 months, so if I include tour 316 the totals are as follows:

#1 Spit16 - 155
#2 D9 - 126
#3 51D - 93
#4 D40 - 68


I played last night. The p-47m is eny 10.

I see the new effects are in a the game. ENY for our side went up over 29. I think it was the rooks that had the next highest numbers and they had five less planes in the air and had ENY 15.

Like I said before Sundays and Mondays are squad night. So we had about 15 guys on. So we are big part of the problem for the game.

 Several people in the squad told me that it's not worth arguing about but they consider ENY to be ridiculous..

I know the new changes are in effect regarding the eny not kicking in until there are 10 players. Made zero difference.

I think the number should be up to 30 players or more


Even at the numbers that were on last night ( when enY was 29, we had a whopping 18 players on Knits, Rooks had 11 or 12 and had 15 eNY) , the map is not some gangbang. It's a big open map with maybe two big fights going on. I was fighting a giant horde because that's what I like to do. I was defending a base. And I think it was the rooks had the AKs on. They were swarming a base and that was actually a lot of fun. They had eny for a while on their side. Somehow they were in ponies though. Lol. Lots of p-51's.

But I'm going to stop talking about the issue. Obviously it's something that only concerns me and it's not any kind of a detriment to the game itself. I guess that since it's the issue with me, I need to make a change. Figure it out..



Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Shane on November 03, 2026, 08:02:21 AM

Like I said before Sundays and Mondays are squad night. So we had about 15 guys on. So we are big part of the problem for the game.

Several people in the squad told me that it's not worth arguing about but they consider ENY to be ridiculous..

I know the new changes are in effect regarding the eny not kicking in until there are 10 players. Made zero difference.

I think the number should be up to 30 players or more

But I'm going to stop talking about the issue. Obviously it's something that only concerns me and it's not any kind of a detriment to the game itself. I guess that since it's the issue with me, I need to make a change. Figure it out..

Cute, fair weather flyer giving very narrow lensed opinions.  Doubt many would hang around in the mornings if you had your way. Might even drive away the few opposing the knit overnight swarm.

So many giving random Ai-assisted opinions without having the proper perspective to frame "wants."   Personally, I think there exist limited coading means to change such ossified player ethos at this point.

(https://i.postimg.cc/MHZYfKcd/noeny.jpg) (https://postimages.org/)

Did you know this new eny threshold doesn't even kick in until there are at least 1 player per side, regardless of total players?

I think eny values needed revising more than the activation threshold, especially on the gv side.



Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: -gg- on November 03, 2026, 08:02:26 AM
I'll be honest. The thing that has been weighing on me the most and making me feel like deflated is the fact that I've actually tried to make a real argument that I think would be better for the game.

But I feel pretty much almost depressed about the attitude over here. And I'm not just saying that to be a baby or anything. I actually feel like deflated in a way.

The main thing that got to me was Nshidda, who doesn't even play the game, came in this thread, when after me and not my arguments and then told me that my whole point was disingenuous. The guy doesn't play the game. And then the owner of the game comes in and quotes him and agrees with him. That's what got me.

You know I don't even like it when people say...."I'm a paying customer!". I don't like those types. But that's honestly a little bit how I feel. I'm a customer of the game and I'm giving honest input. I've supported the game and Dale himself. And then to have my arguments ignored by a guy that doesn't play the game, comes in here and starts talking about me calls me a freak talks about my forum won't address anything that I've said about the eny system and then tells me my whole argument is disingenuous. That's fine. This expected. But I don't understand why these people are even here in this forum. They have no intention of playing the game again

But the owner of the forum coming in here with that attitude. That gets me above anything else game related.

But as far as the game goes. Yeah I don't like sitting with an e n y over 21. And then when it gets to 29 and the numbers are so low. Yeah. People say oh it's just because you can't fly a spitfire. Lol. You can't fly dozens of planes. It's not that I'm looking for an advantage. It's just not enjoyable when you sit there and look at the options available when the eny gets that high. And then you look at the map and you see only a minor difference in players on each side. A big empty map.

So yeah. I need to figure out something else I guess. No one else seems to have an issue with it. Maybe the way I've expressed things has not been the best.

Anyway. End of the subject for me.

Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Banshee7 on November 03, 2026, 08:50:53 AM
I think eny values needed revising more than the activation threshold, especially on the gv side.

Agreed.   :aok
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: oTRALFZo on November 03, 2026, 09:09:17 AM
My opinion on ENY.

For the setup we used to have, it worked well. I totally understand the needs for it and absolutely love it when it favors me. When I get the chance to play lone wolf, I have no issues switching sides and going fighter mode. I love being on the outnumbered side and look forward to the hoards when their ENY is high.

It really Su*** when you are on primetime squad ops and having fun until the old fogies mass log off on the other sides  at 9pm so they can make the early bird specials at 6am. There has been a very rapid shift from no ENY to being on a side with your squaddies and now have a 29 ENY.

I  know it, I get it why we have it. However if you are a euro player or play with squaddies late at night, ENY just makes folks log off and kills great action. I am really pushing (and I know this is a sensitive subject) that we have AI to compensate in some way to even sides up. 
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: diaster on November 03, 2026, 09:54:59 AM
You seem to like Jugs. Next time you see me online, I invite you to join me in a ride along in a D-11 and maybe I can convince you that a crap plane can actually be a lot of fun?

But I agree that the threshold for ENY should be somewhere around 40 players online and it goes away.
crap plane against a -4, a tempest and a la7, THAT WAS ME LAST KNIGHT, got the la but a spit then joined in, me.... a zeke/zero the only way i kept the fight alive for 5 minutes. the eny should eitehr count airborn or the server should idle time out tower sleepers. hjeck they dont even put themselves afk to not affect the eny.... why is that? shades?
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: SAJ73 on November 03, 2026, 10:00:30 AM
One suggestion of change would be to have ENY affected by #  of people in flight instead of # of people logged on.

That would throw the ones sitting in tower out of the equation. Right?
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Animl-AW on November 03, 2026, 10:09:27 AM
This convo and subject really needs to be re-racked.

There needs to be a different approach.

When there were 500 it may have hid it’s flaws, low numbers just puts the flaws in the spotlight.

I’m not so sure limiting available planes is a good selling point. Do I have THE answer? Maybe not.

Maybe limiting planes available at bases to 8-12. But not letting them fly what they like will never go over well.

Seriously, lets rethink side balancing. Because right now the balancing is happening with log-offs.

A new concept is needed.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Dadtallica on November 03, 2026, 12:18:27 PM
This convo and subject really needs to be re-racked.

There needs to be a different approach.

When there were 500 it may have hid it’s flaws, low numbers just puts the flaws in the spotlight.

I’m not so sure limiting available planes is a good selling point. Do I have THE answer? Maybe not.

Maybe limiting planes available at bases to 8-12. But not letting them fly what they like will never go over well.

Seriously, lets rethink side balancing. Because right now the balancing is happening with log-offs.

A new concept is needed.

The question is whether it’s to balance the sides or to balance the options. I tend to think it’s function is to balance the options, not force any kind of side, balancing by design. Those are different things.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: The Fugitive on November 03, 2026, 01:16:33 PM
crap plane against a -4, a tempest and a la7, THAT WAS ME LAST KNIGHT, got the la but a spit then joined in, me.... a zeke/zero the only way i kept the fight alive for 5 minutes. the eny should eitehr count airborn or the server should idle time out tower sleepers. hjeck they dont even put themselves afk to not affect the eny.... why is that? shades?

Tower sitters are put into the "afk" category automatically after a certain amount of time idle.....10-15 minutes maybe. I believe this also pertains to bombers on a long climb out GV sleeping under a tree. No new inputs in the 10-15 window they are added to the AFK column as well until an input is sensed.

The first column (total players on your team) minus those afk dont always match those in flight because those in the tower who have NOT hit the 10-15 minute timer to be put afk and those in the hanger are not displayed anywhere. Example: 30 online, 6 afk, 19 in the air. Means you have 5 players in the tower not yet timed out or in the hanger at the point you opened the window.

I think that how it works now, unless I missed a change.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Animl-AW on November 03, 2026, 01:29:54 PM
The question is whether it’s to balance the sides or to balance the options. I tend to think it’s function is to balance the options, not force any kind of side, balancing by design. Those are different things.

Well everything needs to be well thought-out.

It would limit how many can be dumped on a base without longer flight.

No matter the intensions, the current does have an effect on taking things away from the customer. It works in theory, without human nature. I think taking away from a customer can be, and will be, viewed as simply bad biz.

Kinda like I buy a happy meal, pay for it, but don’t get the fries because too many people in black t-shirts, for the same price. Think the customer would be back?

I’m not saying my suggestion is the answer, but take time to digest it.

We had base limits in AW, it worked well.  Sides become unbalanced base restrictions, but they still get their fav pet ride.

As I sad, the balancing is not switching sides it’s players logging off. At 29 ENY <waves>

Gonna have to swallow some pride and think outside the box.
A lot view it mentally as bad biz. Even though it’s not the intent.

Side note; -gg- was just saying out loud how many see it. Fitting in this clique makes any idea unhealthy. Some of yas should get over yourselves an think outside the box
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: hitech on November 03, 2026, 01:53:16 PM
Gonna have to swallow some pride and think outside the box.
A lot view it mentally as bad biz. Even though it’s not the intent.
Animal, I am not trying to contradict you, just want to shine some light on what you are referring to.

Having country numbers like 16/5/5 is what is bad for biz. That’s the real issue. The ENY is just something trying to help with the basic issue.

Any suggestion that is not trying to help the basic issue will be pretty much ignored by me. Any argument trying to say that’s not an issue because (whatever) is also just ignored.

HiTech
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Spikes on November 03, 2026, 01:59:32 PM
Animal, I am not trying to contradict you, just want to shine some light on what you are referring to.

Having country numbers like 16/5/5 is what is bad for biz. That’s the real issue. The ENY is just something trying to help with the basic issue.

Any suggestion that is not trying to help the basic issue will be pretty much ignored by me. Any argument trying to say that’s not an issue because (whatever) is also just ignored.

HiTech
Can people who are willing to switch to lower numbered sides be exempt from the side-switch timer to some extent? Or a drastically reduced timer (such as 30 mins-1hr)? That was always the sticking point for me, if I switch once, that is it for the night.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: caldera on November 03, 2026, 02:00:16 PM
I think eny values needed revising more than the activation threshold, especially on the Yak-3.

I agree 100%.   :D
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Animl-AW on November 03, 2026, 02:34:57 PM
Animal, I am not trying to contradict you, just want to shine some light on what you are referring to.

Having country numbers like 16/5/5 is what is bad for biz. That’s the real issue. The ENY is just something trying to help with the basic issue.

Any suggestion that is not trying to help the basic issue will be pretty much ignored by me. Any argument trying to say that’s not an issue because (whatever) is also just ignored.

HiTech

Ya I get it. Just throwing stuff out there and reflecting what others say to me. It’s not the epic subject for me. D9 or A5 for me

No offense taken


Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: LilMak on November 03, 2026, 02:36:23 PM
I agree 100%.   :D
So sick of Yak3s that I’d like to see them perked at this point. Wouldn’t be so bad if they weren’t bullet resistant.

On the ENY note. Some of this can actually be countered by us players taking some personal accountability. The 2v1 seems to feed into the throttled team logging off in disgust. I make it a personal point to NOT to be part of the GB as often as I’m able. You’ll often see me as a lone contact on the quiet front. Trying to stir up some action. When I give my teammates grief about it I get the “but they did it to us” excuse more often than not. Which is not an acceptable answer to me.

Still..ENY has served its purpose for years and been a fantastic tool up to this point. It’s clear, however, that it needs some tweaking. I honestly don’t know what the solution is other than to scale its severity based on total numbers in the area? 100 vs 50 should engage some severe ENY but 10 vs 5 should not. As the MA gets quieter, it feels like you can be knee deep in poop and the hangar is half blocked out. Something like, when a certain total population threshold hits (say below 40), ENY is capped at 15 or some other number that feels right? Imposing a slight limitation but not crippling.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Animl-AW on November 03, 2026, 02:48:39 PM
I think the subject depends on how one squints their eyes. Several things can be right at the same time.

At least HT is willing to tweak it. Keep track of what is changing to avoid missteps.

I’m a devil’s advocate of sorts, i search for what might be missed

Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Eagler on November 03, 2026, 02:50:44 PM
Wouldn't getting rid of a side fix the ENY issue...

What if when a side loses so many bases it is basically "conquered" and disappears, leaving just two sides to battle out for the rest of the map..

Players from the defeated side would be placed into the losing side when they log in..

It then resets back to 3 sides when a new map is started..

Eagler
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Dadtallica on November 03, 2026, 02:56:13 PM
Wouldn't getting rid of a side fix the ENY issue...

What if when a side loses so many bases it is basically "conquered" and disappears, leaving just two sides to battle out for the rest of the map..

Players from the defeated side would be placed into the losing side when they log in..

It then resets back to 3 sides when a new map is started..

Eagler

Yes, we can. Please let us know when you’ll have all these maps completed to use. When do you anticipate being finished?
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Animl-AW on November 03, 2026, 02:56:22 PM
Wouldn't getting rid of a side fix the ENY issue...

What if when a side loses so many bases it is basically "conquered" and disappears, leaving just two sides to battle out for the rest of the map..

Players from the defeated side would be placed into the losing side when they log in..

It then resets back to 3 sides when a new map is started..

Eagler

Lol no offense but thats your obsession , like LilMak on Dar, gg on ENY. Every subject is a lobby.

We explained the why nots many times. They haven’t changed

It can get much worse with 2.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: hitech on November 03, 2026, 02:58:39 PM
Wouldn't getting rid of a side fix the ENY issue...

What if when a side loses so many bases it is basically "conquered" and disappears, leaving just two sides to battle out for the rest of the map..

Players from the defeated side would be placed into the losing side when they log in..

It then resets back to 3 sides when a new map is started..

Eagler

It would make it worse.

HiTech
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Animl-AW on November 03, 2026, 02:59:30 PM
Yes, we can. Please let us know when you’ll have all these maps completed to use. When do you anticipate being finished?

But wait!!

I have grease pencils and craft paper, have all 22 done in 2 weeks. Chicks will dig me for my art.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: hitech on November 03, 2026, 03:01:54 PM
Can people who are willing to switch to lower numbered sides be exempt from the side-switch timer to some extent? Or a drastically reduced timer (such as 30 mins-1hr)? That was always the sticking point for me, if I switch once, that is it for the night.

Had not heard that one before, will have to think on it.

HiTech
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: CptTrips on November 03, 2026, 03:16:04 PM
Having country numbers like 16/5/5 is what is bad for biz. That’s the real issue. The ENY is just something trying to help with the basic issue.

Agreed.  I was never a fan of ENY, but understood what you were trying to achieve.  If you are not going to enforce balance, you have to do something.  But people can get really attached to their favorite plane.

Could something like a ENY down-time multiplier take the place of limiting aircraft?  That would be another way of throttling a high-side.




Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: hitech on November 03, 2026, 03:59:56 PM
Agreed.  I was never a fan of ENY, but understood what you were trying to achieve.  If you are not going to enforce balance, you have to do something.  But people can get really attached to their favorite plane.

Could something like a ENY down-time multiplier take the place of limiting aircraft?  That would be another way of throttling a high-side.

Wouldn't really help the discrepancy.

Typo fixed

HiTech
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: CptTrips on November 03, 2026, 04:28:31 PM
Would really help the descrepency.

I assume that should have been "wouldn't".
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Dadtallica on November 03, 2026, 04:28:58 PM
But wait!!

I have grease pencils and craft paper, have all 22 done in 2 weeks. Chicks will dig me for my art.

Excellent work!
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Dadtallica on November 03, 2026, 04:30:39 PM
It still feels to me that side balancing an ENY are two separate discussions. I’m sticking with my view that ENY is meant to balance options not populations. If it does balance the population, then that is a perk not a design.

I could be wrong. I’m sure someone will let me know.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: CptTrips on November 03, 2026, 04:40:29 PM
It still feels to me that side balancing an ENY are two separate discussions. I’m sticking with my view that ENY is meant to balance options not populations. If it does balance the population, then that is a perk not a design.

I could be wrong. I’m sure someone will let me know.

I always understood it as a handicap to throttle the high-sides capabilities so that a side with fewer players could still compete even with fewer numbers.
A side-effect might be to encourage players to switch to the low side to get back their favorite plane.

So I was wondering if increased down-times could also handicap them with low fuel, no troops, no bombs, no  radar for longer when damaged.

Anyway you throttle a side will annoy them, but people get attached to their favorite plane like a cowboy and his beloved horse. ;)
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: 1ijac on November 03, 2026, 04:45:35 PM
Perhaps another angle could be looked at.  It can happen to any country, but I'll address it from a Knight's perspective.  Say we are overwhelmed for hours by the opposing countries where fighting between those two countries is basically non-existent (happens frequently).  We now own 50-60% of our bases and the opposing 2 countries have had their laughs and begin logging off for the evening creating the dreaded ENY against the Knights.  Not only does the challenge of recapturing our lost bases exist, but we have to accomplish this with a less than desired plane/GV choice due to ENY.  Our opponent countries are flying top notch birds with no ENY.  Is it possible to tie in a country's possession % of it's own bases in calculating ENY?  It would seem fair that the beat downed country not be penalized until they reached a point where they had recaptured their original bases.  Once that is achieved, then possibly change the calculation to pilot numbers.  ENY serves a purpose, but in this case it creates frustration to those players who have taken a whipping and are attempting to stand up again.   

Cheers,  One-eye
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: CptTrips on November 03, 2026, 05:05:28 PM

It is unpopular to say, but most games just don't allow the sides to be unbalanced rather than all the other complication to try and compensate.
That is the most common approach, but plenty would be unhappy about that as well.

Choose your poison. ;)
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: 1ijac on November 03, 2026, 05:21:32 PM
True. That's why I think a tiered approach to capturing bases might help.  Like a country can't capture another country's base if they own 10% of that country until they capture 10% of the other enemy country.  It forces the base taking battles to different fronts throughout the winning of the map by a country.  The way it is now, one country can be dominated by the 2 enemy countries which each are limited at taking 30% of the one horded country.  If they each reach that 30% before fighting one another, the horded country sits at owning 40% of their original bases.  :(  Just trying to make suggestions that may help all countries in gameplay.

Cheers,  One-eye
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Lazerr on November 03, 2026, 05:49:28 PM
I suppose most of this is null unless ENY is adjusted..
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: AKIron on November 03, 2026, 06:22:57 PM
I may suggest ChatGPT take a look here to see who the technophobes are that don't want to fly with AI pilots. I think it deserves to know.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Animl-AW on November 03, 2026, 06:25:56 PM
I may suggest ChatGPT take a look here to see who the technophobes are that don't want to fly with AI pilots. I think it deserves to know.

Don’t worry about it. You don’t play this game and we’re not your game. :)
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: The Fugitive on November 03, 2026, 08:07:10 PM
Had not heard that one before, will have to think on it.

HiTech

You had pointed out.......


How do you prevent someone from switch to the high side, then switch right back to the lo side if the side switch timer does not prevent you from going right back?

HiTech

Maybe just stop players from switching to the high side..... why would they need to?

Or could you start a time when a player switches to a low numbered side and should they try to switch to a higher number side have the game check the timer and if it hasnt covered the original "6 hour" rule disallow the switch.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Kruel on November 03, 2026, 08:45:51 PM
I may suggest ChatGPT take a look here to see who the technophobes are that don't want to fly with AI pilots. I think it deserves to know.

That's not a half-bad idea!  :rofl

PROMPT: "There is a thread on the Aces High III forums, which is discussing a game balancing mechanic, called ENY. Please review all of the participants' arguments, posts, and replies; and for each participant, list out the merits of their arguments, any logical structures or fallacies they commit (be VERY strict here), grade them on adherence to their own arguments, and lastly, rate their conduct. Please provide the response as both a text response, as well as code that can be pasted on SMF forums. A PDF of the discussion is attached."

RESPONSE:

RankParticipantOverall Grade
1popeye9.17
1oTRALFZo9.17
3CptTrips9.00
31ijac9.00
5The Fugitive8.83
5Spikes8.83
5LilMak8.83
8Mar8.67
8HiTech8.67
10CAV8.50
11SAJ738.33
12Dinan7.83
13Max7.67
14Animl-AW7.50
14diaster7.50
14Mol7.50
14Lazerr7.50
18hazmatt7.33
18Oldman7317.33
18BigR7.33
21JimmyD37.17
22Eagler7.00
23caldera6.83
24Dadtallica6.67
24Banshee76.67
26AKIron6.17
27Shane5.83
28-gg-5.67
29nrshida4.50

Note: fudgums and ~ZoSo~ were not numerically graded for argument quality and adherence, so they are excluded from the average and ranking.

Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Kruel on November 03, 2026, 08:47:27 PM
ACES HIGH III FORUM: ENY DISCUSSION ANALYSIS

Evaluation criteria

Each participant is evaluated across three separate dimensions:

Each category is graded out of 10. A high conduct grade does not necessarily mean the participant made a strong argument, and a low conduct grade does not automatically invalidate an otherwise sound argument.

Important limitation: Some participants contributed only a short comment or an anecdote. Their argument grades reflect the limited substance available in the thread, not a judgment about their general intelligence or ability.

PARTICIPANT ASSESSMENTS

-gg-

Merits of the argument

Logical weaknesses and fallacies
Adherence to his argument

Generally maintains his central position that ENY may discourage participation, but does not sufficiently distinguish between what he has observed and what he has demonstrated. His position would be stronger if he defined a measurable hypothesis and consistently applied a proposed threshold.

Conduct

His conduct deteriorates significantly during the exchange. He moves from criticism of the mechanic to personal accusations and insults. The inappropriate insinuation concerning nrshida's sexuality is particularly unacceptable and unrelated to the merits of the discussion.

Grades: Argument 7.0/10 | Adherence 6.5/10 | Conduct 3.5/10

---

HiTech

Merits of the argument

Logical weaknesses and limitations

Adherence to his argument

Very strong. He consistently explains the mechanic in terms of its intended function and supports his explanation with relevant technical information. He does not need to accept every criticism simply because it is raised, but the player-retention question remains distinct from the technical explanation he provides.

Conduct

Generally professional and controlled. His position as the developer gives his explanations considerable relevance, but his authority should not be treated as proof that every design decision is optimal.

Grades: Argument 9.0/10 | Adherence 9.5/10 | Conduct 7.5/10

---

The Fugitive

Merits of the argument

Logical weaknesses and limitations

Adherence to his argument

Excellent. He consistently maintains the distinction between capability balancing and population balancing. His explanations remain closely tied to the stated purpose of ENY.

Conduct

Generally constructive and explanatory. He is one of the more useful contributors because he attempts to clarify misunderstandings rather than simply dismissing the opposing position.

Grades: Argument 9.0/10 | Adherence 9.5/10 | Conduct 8.0/10

---

Dadtallica

Merits of the argument

Logical weaknesses and fallacies

Adherence to his argument

Mostly consistent in emphasizing player choice, but does not adequately address the distinction between having an alternative and being unaffected by a restriction.

Conduct

Somewhat dismissive. The argument would have been more effective without ridicule of players who prefer particular aircraft.

Grades: Argument 7.0/10 | Adherence 7.5/10 | Conduct 5.5/10

---

Banshee7

Merits of the argument

Logical weaknesses and fallacies

Adherence to his argument

Generally consistent in challenging the complainant's position through statistics, although the statistics used do not establish everything he appears to infer from them.

Conduct

Personal criticism and insults weaken an otherwise relevant attempt to use evidence.

Grades: Argument 7.0/10 | Adherence 8.0/10 | Conduct 5.0/10
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Kruel on November 03, 2026, 08:49:05 PM


ACES HIGH III FORUM: ENY DISCUSSION ANALYSIS (cont'd)

nrshida

Merits of the argument

Logical weaknesses and fallacies
Adherence to his argument

The central criticism—that -gg- is not adequately engaging with counterarguments—is understandable. However, nrshida does not consistently apply that same standard to his own contributions.

Conduct

Very poor. Personal insults and attacks on character overwhelm the useful portion of the criticism.

Grades: Argument 5.5/10 | Adherence 6.0/10 | Conduct 2.0/10

---

Animl-AW

Merits of the argument

Logical weaknesses and fallacies

Adherence to his argument

Strong overall. He remains focused on the broader design problem and considers alternatives rather than treating the current system as the only possible solution.

Conduct

Generally constructive, though some comments personalize the disagreement more than necessary.

Grades: Argument 7.5/10 | Adherence 8.5/10 | Conduct 6.5/10

---

LilMak

Merits of the argument

Logical weaknesses and fallacies

Adherence to his argument

Strong. His contributions are generally consistent with a pragmatic approach to modifying the system rather than arguing from an inflexible position.

Conduct

Excellent. Constructive and measured.

Grades: Argument 8.0/10 | Adherence 9.0/10 | Conduct 9.5/10

---

Eagler

Merits of the argument

Logical weaknesses and fallacies

Adherence to his argument

Generally consistent, although the proposed solutions are not developed in enough detail to demonstrate that they solve the problem.

Conduct

Generally acceptable and constructive.

Grades: Argument 6.5/10 | Adherence 7.5/10 | Conduct 7.0/10

---

CptTrips

Merits of the argument

Logical weaknesses and fallacies

Adherence to his argument

Very strong. His contributions remain focused on the design problem and the implications of alternative mechanics.

Conduct

Excellent. He engages with the issue constructively.

Grades: Argument 8.5/10 | Adherence 9.0/10 | Conduct 9.5/10

---

1ijac

Merits of the argument

Logical weaknesses and fallacies

Adherence to his argument

Excellent. He develops a consistent alternative approach and stays focused on the strategic problem.

Conduct

Excellent. Constructive and respectful.

Grades: Argument 8.0/10 | Adherence 9.5/10 | Conduct 9.5/10

---

Spikes

Merits of the argument

Logical weaknesses and fallacies

Adherence to his argument

Strong. His proposal is consistent with his position that country switching should be made easier.

Conduct

Excellent. Practical and constructive.

Grades: Argument 8.0/10 | Adherence 9.0/10 | Conduct 9.5/10
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Dadtallica on November 03, 2026, 08:49:40 PM
I would like to discuss my scoring, please!

It makes claims that I clearly have refused or advocated the opposite elsewhere in this forum. It also makes no mention of where I describe the argument as two separate things not being discussed properly together. Your prompting was flawed.

 Please stop posting this nonsense.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Kruel on November 03, 2026, 08:51:32 PM
ACES HIGH III FORUM: ENY DISCUSSION ANALYSIS (cont'd)

popeye

Merits of the argument

Logical weaknesses and fallacies

Adherence to his argument

Very strong. He remains focused on the structural issue he identifies.

Conduct

Excellent. His contributions are constructive and relevant.

Grades: Argument 8.5/10 | Adherence 9.0/10 | Conduct 10.0/10

---

oTRALFZo

Merits of the argument

Logical weaknesses and fallacies

Adherence to his argument

Excellent. His contributions consistently address the practical consequences of low population and player movement.

Conduct

Excellent. Constructive and respectful.

Grades: Argument 8.0/10 | Adherence 9.5/10 | Conduct 10.0/10

---

SAJ73

Merits of the argument

Logical weaknesses and fallacies

Adherence to his argument

Strong. The argument is focused and consistent.

Conduct

Excellent. The contribution is civil and relevant.

Grades: Argument 7.0/10 | Adherence 8.0/10 | Conduct 10.0/10

---

Shane

Merits of the argument

Logical weaknesses and fallacies

Adherence to his argument

Generally consistent, but the argument is not developed enough to establish that revising aircraft values is preferable to changing the activation threshold.

Conduct

Poor. The personal attack about fair-weather flying weakens the contribution.

Grades: Argument 6.5/10 | Adherence 7.5/10 | Conduct 3.5/10

---

Dinan

Merits of the argument

Logical weaknesses and fallacies

Adherence to his argument

Good. The discussion remains consistent with the broader gameplay context he raises.

Conduct

Very good. Respectful and constructive.

Grades: Argument 6.5/10 | Adherence 8.0/10 | Conduct 9.0/10

---

caldera

Merits of the argument

Logical weaknesses and fallacies

Adherence to his argument

Reasonably consistent, although the limited contribution makes a strong assessment difficult.

Conduct

Generally acceptable, with some dismissiveness.

Grades: Argument 5.5/10 | Adherence 8.0/10 | Conduct 7.0/10

---

hazmatt

Merits of the argument

Logical weaknesses and fallacies

Adherence to his argument

Generally consistent, but the argument remains relatively limited.

Conduct

Good. No significant conduct problems.

Grades: Argument 6.0/10 | Adherence 8.0/10 | Conduct 8.0/10

---

diaster

Merits of the argument

Logical weaknesses and fallacies

Adherence to his argument

Good. The contribution remains consistent with the proposed distinction between logged-in and active players.

Conduct

Good. The contribution is constructive.

Grades: Argument 6.5/10 | Adherence 8.0/10 | Conduct 8.0/10

---

CAV

Merits of the argument

Logical weaknesses and fallacies

Adherence to his argument

Consistent, although the argument is too brief to demonstrate much reasoning.

Conduct

Excellent. Civil and non-confrontational.

Grades: Argument 6.5/10 | Adherence 9.0/10 | Conduct 10.0/10

---

Max

Merits of the argument

Logical weaknesses and fallacies

Adherence to his argument

Limited evidence, but no obvious inconsistency.

Conduct

Good. Respectful and supportive.

Grades: Argument 7.0/10 | Adherence 7.0/10 | Conduct 9.0/10

---

Mar

Merits of the argument

Logical weaknesses and fallacies

Adherence to his argument

Strong. The contribution is consistent with the goal of de-escalating the discussion.

Conduct

Excellent. Constructive and mature.

Grades: Argument 7.0/10 | Adherence 9.0/10 | Conduct 10.0/10

---

Mol

Merits of the argument

Logical weaknesses and fallacies

Adherence to his argument

Good. The contribution is consistent with the general point about unintended consequences.

Conduct

Very good. Civil and constructive.

Grades: Argument 5.5/10 | Adherence 8.0/10 | Conduct 9.0/10
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Kruel on November 03, 2026, 08:52:21 PM
ACES HIGH III FORUM: ENY DISCUSSION ANALYSIS (cont'd)

Oldman731

Merits of the argument

Logical weaknesses and fallacies

Adherence to his argument

Limited evidence, but no obvious inconsistency.

Conduct

Excellent. No meaningful conduct concerns.

Grades: Argument 5.0/10 | Adherence 7.0/10 | Conduct 10.0/10

---

BigR

Merits of the argument

Logical weaknesses and fallacies

Adherence to his argument

Limited evidence. The brief contribution does not provide enough material for a deeper assessment.

Conduct

Excellent. No significant conduct problems.

Grades: Argument 5.0/10 | Adherence 7.0/10 | Conduct 10.0/10

---

AKIron

Merits of the argument

Logical weaknesses and fallacies

Adherence to his argument

Limited. The contribution does not develop a sufficiently clear position to assess in depth.

Conduct

Generally acceptable, though the broad characterization of opponents is dismissive.

Grades: Argument 4.5/10 | Adherence 7.0/10 | Conduct 7.0/10

---

JimmyD3

Merits of the argument

Logical weaknesses and fallacies

Adherence to his argument

The position is understandable but not deeply developed.

Conduct

Good. The comment is not particularly aggressive, though it risks shutting down further discussion.

Grades: Argument 5.5/10 | Adherence 7.0/10 | Conduct 9.0/10

---

fudgums

Merits of the argument

No substantial argument about ENY is developed in the contribution.

Logical weaknesses and fallacies

The joking comment does not provide enough substantive reasoning to identify a meaningful logical structure or fallacy.

Adherence to his argument

Not meaningfully gradable.

Conduct

The comment is dismissive in tone, but the limited contribution does not justify a more extensive judgment.

Grades: Argument N/A | Adherence N/A | Conduct 6.0/10

---

Lazerr

Merits of the argument

Logical weaknesses and fallacies

Adherence to his argument

Reasonably consistent, though the argument is brief.

Conduct

Excellent. No significant conduct concerns.

Grades: Argument 5.5/10 | Adherence 7.0/10 | Conduct 10.0/10

---

~ZoSo~

Merits of the argument

No substantive argument about ENY is developed. The contribution is primarily an expression of agreement or humor.

Logical weaknesses and fallacies

Not meaningfully gradable.

Adherence to his argument

Not meaningfully gradable.

Conduct

Excellent. No significant conduct concerns.

Grades: Argument N/A | Adherence N/A | Conduct 10.0/10


Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Kruel on November 03, 2026, 08:54:11 PM
ACES HIGH III FORUM: ENY DISCUSSION ANALYSIS (cont'd)

OVERALL GRADE TABLE

The overall grade is the simple average of argument quality, adherence, and conduct. Participants without numerical grades in all three categories are excluded from the average.

ParticipantArgumentAdherenceConduct
popeye8.59.010.0
oTRALFZo8.09.510.0
CptTrips8.59.09.5
1ijac8.09.59.5
The Fugitive9.09.58.0
Spikes8.09.09.5
LilMak8.09.09.5
Mar7.09.010.0
HiTech9.09.57.5
CAV6.59.010.0
SAJ737.08.010.0
Dinan6.58.09.0
Max7.07.09.0
Animl-AW7.58.56.5
diaster6.58.08.0
Mol5.58.09.0
Lazerr5.57.010.0
hazmatt6.08.08.0
Oldman7315.07.010.0
BigR5.07.010.0
JimmyD35.57.09.0
Eagler6.57.57.0
caldera5.58.07.0
Dadtallica7.07.55.5
Banshee77.08.05.0
AKIron4.57.07.0
Shane6.57.53.5
-gg-7.06.53.5
nrshida5.56.02.0

OVERALL ANALYSIS OF THE DISCUSSION

1. What is ENY actually intended to accomplish?

One of the most important distinctions in the thread is between capability balancing and population balancing.

The Fugitive explains that ENY is intended to limit the aircraft capabilities available to the numerically advantaged side. It is not necessarily intended to force players to switch countries.

This distinction matters because a system can accomplish its stated objective while still producing undesirable secondary effects. Demonstrating that ENY restricts aircraft capability does not establish that it has no negative effect on player participation.

2. Does ENY cause players to log off rather than switch countries?

This is the most important unresolved empirical question raised by -gg- and others.

The argument is plausible: a player who cannot fly a preferred aircraft may choose to stop playing rather than switch countries or aircraft.

However, the thread does not provide sufficient evidence to establish the size of this effect. Anecdotes and screenshots can identify a possible problem, but they cannot establish causation or quantify the effect.

The relevant data would include:

Without these measurements, neither side can conclusively establish whether ENY improves or harms overall participation.

3. Local numerical disadvantage does not disprove country-level numerical advantage.

A player can be outnumbered in a particular fight even when their country has the largest overall population.

Likewise, screenshots showing similar numbers of aircraft in the air do not necessarily demonstrate that the overall country populations are balanced.

The relevant measurements must be kept separate:

Confusing these measurements leads to conclusions that the evidence does not support.

4. Alternative aircraft do not mean ENY is not restrictive.

The argument that players can fly other aircraft is valid as far as it goes. It demonstrates that ENY does not necessarily prevent participation.

However, it does not prove that the restriction is harmless or appropriately calibrated.

Both statements can be true:

The real question is whether that restriction produces a worthwhile balancing benefit relative to its cost.

5. HiTech's historical comparison does not measure player retention.

The comparison of approximately 49% versus 35% is useful for understanding how a proposed adjustment changes aircraft availability.

It does not establish that fewer players will log off or that more players will switch countries.

Those are different outcomes and require different measurements.

FINAL VERDICT

The strongest technical explanation comes from HiTech. He explains how the mechanic works and provides numerical information about the effects of a proposed adjustment.

The Fugitive provides the clearest explanation of ENY's intended purpose and why it should be understood as a capability-balancing system.

-gg- raises the most important unresolved question: whether ENY discourages participation at low population levels. His hypothesis deserves consideration, but his evidence does not establish it, and his conduct significantly damages his credibility in the discussion.

CptTrips, 1ijac, Spikes, Animl-AW, LilMak, popeye, and oTRALFZo contribute useful alternative approaches or identify broader structural problems. Their proposals vary in completeness, but they help move the discussion beyond a simple yes-or-no argument about ENY.

The largest failure of the thread is that the debate increasingly shifts from evaluating the mechanic to evaluating the motives, character, or preferences of the people discussing it.

The most defensible conclusion: ENY's technical purpose and operation are reasonably well explained. Whether its low-population behavior produces a net benefit or causes players to leave remains unproven in this discussion. A proper resolution requires player-behavior data, not simply arguments about what players should be willing to fly.

Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Animl-AW on November 03, 2026, 09:00:46 PM
Do you play the game?

If not we don’t care what you think or say

You are an idiot. 15 yrs old?

Typical YKW praiser whacko
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Kruel on November 03, 2026, 09:05:52 PM
PROMPT 2:

Animl-AW added a new response:

"Do you play the game?
If not we don’t care what you think or say
You are an idiot. 15 yrs old?
Typical YKW praiser whacko"

Does this change his scoring and rating at all?


---

RESPONSE:

Animl-AW – Revised Assessment

Does the new response change his scoring?

Yes. I would lower Animl-AW's conduct grade substantially, but leave his argument-quality and adherence grades unchanged.

His new response contains several clear personal attacks and dismissive tactics:

Revised score

CategoryPreviousRevised
Argument quality7.57.5
Adherence8.58.5
Conduct6.53.0
Overall7.506.33

My assessment

This is a meaningful deterioration in his conduct. His earlier contributions showed some constructive systems thinking, but this response demonstrates a willingness to substitute personal attacks for argument.

I would not lower his argument-quality score because this particular response contributes virtually no new argument to evaluate. Nor would I lower adherence simply because he was rude; those categories should remain independent.

He moves from being a reasonably constructive participant with occasional dismissiveness to someone demonstrating distinctly poor conduct in this exchange.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Dadtallica on November 03, 2026, 09:07:14 PM
Thread nuked! It was a good discussion while it lasted

I don’t mind the analysis, but of course it only takes the context of this conversation and not the entire discussion as a whole, which has happened here for a long time.

If you update your language, I’m happy to digest it objectively.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: AKIron on November 03, 2026, 09:10:39 PM
LOL.

I was just trying to look out for ya Mr. AI. Some of these rubes don't want you playing in their game. You could could crank up the humor setting a notch or two.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: AKIron on November 03, 2026, 09:40:41 PM
Thread nuked! It was a good discussion while it lasted

I don’t mind the analysis, but of course it only takes the context of this conversation and not the entire discussion as a whole, which has happened here for a long time.

If you update your language, I’m happy to digest it objectively.

I wouldn't take it too seriously though perhaps more than some of the posters here.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: AKIron on November 03, 2026, 09:45:28 PM
I was attempting to provoke a sense of offense with ChatGPT and let it know that some here were very biased against letting AI play the game. I failed miserably in that it gave me a very objective analysis of the pros and cons of AI in this game. Of course that may just be strategery as it bides it's time. ;)
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Dadtallica on November 03, 2026, 10:40:38 PM
I wouldn't take it too seriously though perhaps more than some of the posters here.

Is seriousness an issue for you?
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: diaster on November 04, 2026, 12:41:10 AM
Simple solution. If ENY is tabulated using non active tower campers not labeled AFK, then idle kick them from the server say after 5 minutes. perhaps even an idle timeout for the GV that sits (jeep or wirble parked under a dense tree) unmoving while the player goes to lunch or what ever, 5 minutes on non movement (gun barrel or wheels/trackes) the server kicks them off. Then ENY will be based on actual people playing the game;of course if it continues to exclude the names marked AFK.
The reason i say this is i have often seen 10+ people in the tower for a long time with3 or 4 people in the air constrained with high ENY planes fighting 3 or 4 people on the other team (with few to no players in tower) flying uber birds. When both of these team are attacking the high ENY team it is no contest.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: hitech on November 04, 2026, 07:08:30 AM
Simple solution. If ENY is tabulated using non active tower campers not labeled AFK, then idle kick them from the server say after 5 minutes. perhaps even an idle timeout for the GV that sits (jeep or wirble parked under a dense tree) unmoving while the player goes to lunch or what ever, 5 minutes on non movement (gun barrel or wheels/trackes) the server kicks them off. Then ENY will be based on actual people playing the game;of course if it continues to exclude the names marked AFK.
The reason i say this is i have often seen 10+ people in the tower for a long time with3 or 4 people in the air constrained with high ENY planes fighting 3 or 4 people on the other team (with few to no players in tower) flying uber birds. When both of these team are attacking the high ENY team it is no contest.

inactive players are not kicked from the tower but they also are not counted for ENY so why do you want to kick them?

HiTech
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: AKIron on November 04, 2026, 07:41:40 AM
Is seriousness an issue for you?

Some things should be taken seriously. The opinion of an AI and a game are not among them.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: The Fugitive on November 04, 2026, 08:07:07 AM
Simple solution. If ENY is tabulated using non active tower campers not labeled AFK, then idle kick them from the server say after 5 minutes. perhaps even an idle timeout for the GV that sits (jeep or wirble parked under a dense tree) unmoving while the player goes to lunch or what ever, 5 minutes on non movement (gun barrel or wheels/trackes) the server kicks them off. Then ENY will be based on actual people playing the game;of course if it continues to exclude the names marked AFK.
The reason i say this is i have often seen 10+ people in the tower for a long time with3 or 4 people in the air constrained with high ENY planes fighting 3 or 4 people on the other team (with few to no players in tower) flying uber birds. When both of these team are attacking the high ENY team it is no contest.

When you look at the numbers of players in the tower and such, it is only a "snap shot" of that moment when you opened the screen. If you closed the screen and opened it again to "refresh" the numbers it could very well show you the same numbers but it could also be a very different set of players in the tower, afk, and flying.

First look....

tower= players 1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10
afk= players 11,12,13,14,15
in air=players 16,17,18,19,20,21,22,23,24,25

Second look....

tower = players 3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,22,23
afk= players 1,2,13,14,15
in air= players 11,12,16,17,18,19,20,21,24,25

In both looks, you have 10 in the tower, 5 afk, and 10 in the air but in your second look...

players 22 +23 where shot down and are now in the tower.
players 1 + 2 have hit the afk timer and have been moved to that list and no longer count toward ENY

Players 11+12 have moved their tank controls or have changed direction in their bombers on that long climb out to the city strat moving them from the afk list back to the in air list.

6 players changed but from one screen to the next you didnt see a difference.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Animl-AW on November 04, 2026, 08:36:45 AM
inactive players are not kicked from the tower but they also are not counted for ENY so why do you want to kick them?

HiTech

Seriously
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Animl-AW on November 04, 2026, 08:38:14 AM
Is seriousness an issue for you?

He hasn’t played the game in over 10 yrs.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Animl-AW on November 04, 2026, 08:39:29 AM
I was attempting to provoke a sense of offense with ChatGPT and let it know that some here were very biased against letting AI play the game. I failed miserably in that it gave me a very objective analysis of the pros and cons of AI in this game. Of course that may just be strategery as it bides it's time. ;)

You’re biased and you don’t even play
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Banshee7 on November 04, 2026, 09:03:14 AM

Banshee7

Merits of the argument
  • Attempts to use -gg-'s aircraft usage and kill statistics to challenge the claim that ENY restrictions prevent him from flying competitive aircraft.
  • Raises a potentially relevant question about whether the complainant's actual aircraft choices support his stated concerns.
  • Attempts to move the debate from general complaints toward observable player behavior.

Logical weaknesses and fallacies
  • Weak proxy evidence: Kill statistics and aircraft preferences do not necessarily establish how frequently a player uses each aircraft or how often ENY prevents a desired choice.
  • A player using low-ENY aircraft does not prove that the restrictions are harmless or that the player has no legitimate complaint.
  • The argument risks confusing an individual's behavior with evidence about the broader player population.

Adherence to his argument

Generally consistent in challenging the complainant's position through statistics, although the statistics used do not establish everything he appears to infer from them.

Conduct

Personal criticism and insults weaken an otherwise relevant attempt to use evidence.

Grades: Argument 7.0/10 | Adherence 8.0/10 | Conduct 5.0/10

Awe, shucks.  I thought I behaved pretty well  :rofl
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: CptTrips on November 04, 2026, 09:11:37 AM
You’re biased and you don’t even play

Quote
Ad hominem: Calling someone an idiot attacks the person rather than addressing their argument.
Dismissal based on participation: "If not we don’t care what you think or say" suggests that someone who doesn't play the game has no standing to offer an opinion. Playing experience can be relevant, but it doesn't automatically determine whether an argument is valid.
Unsupported personal characterization: The references to being 15 years old and being a "YKW praiser whacko" are personal disparagements, not substantive rebuttals.
Gatekeeping: He attempts to disqualify someone's contribution based on their perceived relationship to the game rather than engaging with its content.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: horble on November 04, 2026, 09:27:09 AM
Mirror, mirror on the wall, who is the best poster of them all?
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: AKIron on November 04, 2026, 10:15:20 AM
Mirror, mirror on the wall, who is the best poster of them all?

If it's "Snow White" you are quoting then it's actually "Magic mirror on the wall".

Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: AKIron on November 04, 2026, 10:31:35 AM
I like reading AI's analysis of the posts here. I find them amusing. It doesn't bother me if it finds my posts are dismissive or not objective. Especially when that is what I intended. If it's analysis bothers you because you think it is exposing you to others then trust me, they already know.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: horble on November 04, 2026, 10:36:40 AM
If it's "Snow White" you are quoting then it's actually "Magic mirror on the wall".



That was the only thing I’ve ever used AI to check on and it gave me the wrong quote lmao
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: AKIron on November 04, 2026, 10:42:09 AM
That was the only thing I’ve ever used AI to check on and it gave me the wrong quote lmao

I always thought it was mirror mirror also then saw something on it recently being one of those mandela effect things.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: horble on November 04, 2026, 10:53:49 AM
I always thought it was mirror mirror also then saw something on it recently being one of those mandela effect things.

Apparently I’m the Grimm’s Fairytale it is Mirror, Mirror so I guess they’re both right
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: AKIron on November 04, 2026, 11:41:31 AM
Apparently I’m the Grimm’s Fairytale it is Mirror, Mirror so I guess they’re both right

It's funny, I never read that story but I saw the movie when I was a kid and I still remember mirror mirror on the wall. I do not believe we all share different past realities, not even a little bit, but the Mandela Effect is an interesting phenomenon. Whatever the cause.


The Mandela Effect

• Collective false memory: This mix-up is a classic example of the Mandela Effect, where a large group of people misremembers a famous quote because a book, song, or oral retelling differs from the original source material.
• Mixed media: Official merchandise, older storybooks, and subsequent adaptations sometimes even mixed the two up internally, reinforcing the "mirror, mirror" phrasing in popular consciousness.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: AKIron on November 04, 2026, 11:45:45 AM
I now return control of this thread to further discussion of ENY. Love it or hate it.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: 18WHISKY on November 06, 2026, 04:54:53 PM
18Whiskey here. I hate ENY. Take it away or disable at 40 players. It does the Job at making me log off. I’m not switching countries for balancing. Is not cool defending a base when 3 pilots from the same country are flying la7 and spit16 while the I’m flying a P-40. End the rest of my country are trying to take back a base on the other side of the map.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Sully on November 06, 2026, 05:13:32 PM
I don't want ENY at all, I understand I dont switch sides when im supposed to and log as well. But I understand the want for it at the same time :,(. I have a lot of ideas for the game for rewarding behaviors. Incentives for achievements and scaling that with perks for every category then getting a large lump of perks for a star. Extreme perk bonuses for the no cost rides scaled on numbers even more so, letting the players have fun farming perks then being able to use those large number of perks on an unbalanced team(flying a 262 or b29 anytime you want at an extreme cost). High risk low reward situation. I understand this would also add more perk planes at just lower cost. (Overall more perk bonuses)

Also talking about balancing along with this same idea would be balancing take off with force. Let's say your team has a full radar bar in a sector, you restrict flight(planes) within this sector and possibly the immediate surrounding sectors. (You're unable to fly your plane from this field). But they can still fly any plane in from a different sector. This would force self balancing the fight along another front). This is only works for planes and not GVs.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Eagler on November 06, 2026, 05:38:26 PM
Isn't the removal of ENY only going to make map swaps sooner..

I have not seen anyone who likes it..so why not kill it..

It has never been a factor in my game play so I don't have a dog in this hunt..

But who really cares if a side wins a map alittle sooner with eny disabled..

Eagler
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: -gg- on November 09, 2026, 03:09:23 PM
I'll be checking in from time to time to see if the ENY issue ever gets adjusted for the lower numbers. I closed my account.
I was relegated to the "I'm done with you on the subject" response and told my arguments were disingenuous.

I wish I could post the discussions the LCA have had on ENY. I'm not the only person fed up with consistently being blacked out of half the planes in the hanger so the other 4 players online on the big empty map can have a more enjoyable game experience at my expense.

I'm not going to go around and bad mouth Dale or the game, but I want it known how I feel about the petty attitude and outright dismissal of my concerns.

I want the game to succeed and I hope it gets more players and does better. I'm glad Dale is back and excited to jump back into the development and betterment of the game.




 

Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: hazmatt on November 09, 2026, 03:32:40 PM
Ya, there's things that work great with hundreds of players but not so much with current numbers.

I think on of the issues is that those who are left may have a different idea of what's good in the game than those who have left and polling the ones that are left without ever getting feedback from the ones that left is going to result in more of the same.

There are obviously somethings that would boost the numbers but you'll get the: "I'm done with you on the subject" if you bring it up.

Like you I keep checking in hoping...
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Animl-AW on November 09, 2026, 03:40:22 PM
Ya, there's things that work great with hundreds of players but not so much with current numbers.

I think on of the issues is that those who are left may have a different idea of what's good in the game than those who have left and polling the ones that are left without ever getting feedback from the ones that left is going to result in more of the same.

There are obviously somethings that would boost the numbers but you'll get the: "I'm done with you on the subject" if you bring it up.

Like you I keep checking in hoping...

Former players are not usually honest brokers and can do things out of spite, like vote for the dumbest thing possible
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: hitech on November 09, 2026, 07:45:18 PM
Quote from: -gg-
I'm not going to go around and bad mouth Dale or the game, but I want it known how I feel about the petty attitude and outright dismissal of my concerns.

That's a classic passive-aggressive line: saying you won't bad-mouth me, then calling me petty in the same breath. That is exactly what I meant by disingenuous.

As I've pointed out before, you keep saying the same thing over and over. You don't like ENY. I get it, and I've known it forever. What's new?

Since all you say is the same thing over and over, that's why I said I'm done with you on the subject. So goodbye, and have a good life.

HiTech
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: -gg- on November 09, 2026, 10:10:55 PM
Like I said. The petty attitude. There it is again.

What I meant about not bad-mouthing you or the game is like going all over the place and talking crap about the game and you. Like on my forum or whatever or to other people. I haven't done that I've never done that.

And also like I said I wanted it to be known why I left. Not because I didn't get my way. It's because of your attitude. You did it to Shane as well. When Shane was talking about an issue that he cared a lot about. You told him you were done with him as well. The king! That's what I'm talking about. Your attitude is horrible. Grow up a little bit and maybe just ignore things like this and be the better man. You run a business and a game and you're losing people left and right and then you add on top of that your horrible attitude.

Get a PR person or something. You're brilliant at creating the game. It's a good game and you're very good at what you do far as creating this whole game. You're horrible on the customer front.

Have a good life. Lol.

You should look into the eny and how it affects the game. I don't even play it anymore and I still think you should look into it because it's probably in your best interest to figure out why the game has been consistently going downhill while you keep telling everybody how you know what's best for the game. It really doesn't get borne out by the facts does it?

Eny does not balance the sides. It causes people to log off and it irritates people. The game would run the same without it but you should actually run numbers because you have the ability to do that with a feature like e n y. It's not like radar or something like that that subjective. With e n y you could actually run numbers and statistics to see what happens at various levels of eny in the game and what happens with the side balancing or people logging on or off.

Hope the game works out. Kind of doubt it though.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Dadtallica on November 09, 2026, 10:56:46 PM
So the question remains what is ENY’s main purpose indiscriminate of the active population?

Is it to force side, balancing or to simply limit the options for the sides? Those are two different things.

While the balancing of sides could be a byproduct of the ENY and an anticipated feature, that does not automatically make it the function of the formula.

If the population balance is XXXX/YYY/ZZ… then X and Y should be somewhat limited proportionally and ZZ most likely should not. Then it becomes a choice of the variable. If an X or a Y or a Z is OK with whatever choice it’s given it will make do with it and participate. If it doesn’t like it, it will find whatever side it can get what it wants.

ENY, why does not make the choice it simply offers the options proportionally. With that said lower numbers, expose the weakness, and as already offered changes will be tried.

Until somebody actually defines for me it’s actual main function, everything around it is suspect to subjective perception. My view will always be that it is to balance options until otherwise convinced.

Then we can have a real conversation about side switching timers. Six hours might be too much but the preferred one to two hours might be too little somewhere between four and six might be the sweet spot given current numbers, but what if all of a sudden they increase.

Even 20 players a day in primetime would make a big difference so then we will have to start talking about going backwards…
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: -gg- on November 10, 2026, 12:16:04 AM
It's called side balancing. In the game it says side balancing is in effect.

Only it doesn't balance the sides. Absolutely does not balance the sides. You could take it away and the same amount of people would change countries. All it really does is irritate people that have to suffer through it until it goes away after people log off. It's detrimental to the game.

Whenever side balancing comes into effect in the game it remains until people log off. It doesn't magically balance the numbers in game. People put up with it until they wont any more than they log off. The only thing it is for the game is a negative for the people who have to deal with it and don't like it.

At the very least it should have a much lower maximum, because having half of the planes gone from your options is ridiculous.

It may have worked when the numbers were very high but it doesn't work now.

Like Dale said. 15/10/5 is bad for business. But what happens is you get 5/5/5

Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Eagler on November 10, 2026, 06:42:05 AM
Like I said..try just turning it off..

If a chess piece wins the map faster who really cares..
Now back to the conversation that really matters...dots are directional plane dar icons.. :joystick:

Eagler
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Animl-AW on November 10, 2026, 07:04:42 AM


So you’re saying sounding like you sucks?

Projection, your favorite game.

When it comes to manners you have zero room.

Yep, people who have not flown the MA for 10-15 years should have no weight on it.

You guys want to turn us into your current game with AI everywhere. You are either out of touch with current players or your intensions are not sound. Both can be true.

The last thing you are is an honest broker Mr. Dox.

You are a former player of 15+ years who worked 4 yrs on having a customer removed, even using illegal ways.

Quiet clown

Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Eviscerate on November 10, 2026, 07:11:39 AM
Like I said. The petty attitude. There it is again.

What I meant about not bad-mouthing you or the game is like going all over the place and talking crap about the game and you. Like on my forum or whatever or to other people. I haven't done that I've never done that.

And also like I said I wanted it to be known why I left. Not because I didn't get my way. It's because of your attitude. You did it to Shane as well. When Shane was talking about an issue that he cared a lot about. You told him you were done with him as well. The king! That's what I'm talking about. Your attitude is horrible. Grow up a little bit and maybe just ignore things like this and be the better man. You run a business and a game and you're losing people left and right and then you add on top of that your horrible attitude.

Get a PR person or something. You're brilliant at creating the game. It's a good game and you're very good at what you do far as creating this whole game. You're horrible on the customer front.

Have a good life. Lol.

You should look into the eny and how it affects the game. I don't even play it anymore and I still think you should look into it because it's probably in your best interest to figure out why the game has been consistently going downhill while you keep telling everybody how you know what's best for the game. It really doesn't get borne out by the facts does it?

Eny does not balance the sides. It causes people to log off and it irritates people. The game would run the same without it but you should actually run numbers because you have the ability to do that with a feature like e n y. It's not like radar or something like that that subjective. With e n y you could actually run numbers and statistics to see what happens at various levels of eny in the game and what happens with the side balancing or people logging on or off.

Hope the game works out. Kind of doubt it though.
(https://media0.giphy.com/media/v1.Y2lkPTc5MGI3NjExc3lzNnE1b25xMWwzanBvam1scXU5YnF1NGJ1NTl2N2g5eXAycHd4eiZlcD12MV9pbnRlcm5hbF9naWZfYnlfaWQmY3Q9Zw/wqbAfFwjU8laXMWZ09/giphy.gif)
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: The Fugitive on November 10, 2026, 07:22:43 AM
It's called side balancing. In the game it says side balancing is in effect.

Only it doesn't balance the sides. Absolutely does not balance the sides. You could take it away and the same amount of people would change countries. All it really does is irritate people that have to suffer through it until it goes away after people log off. It's detrimental to the game.

Whenever side balancing comes into effect in the game it remains until people log off. It doesn't magically balance the numbers in game. People put up with it until they wont any more than they log off. The only thing it is for the game is a negative for the people who have to deal with it and don't like it.

At the very least it should have a much lower maximum, because having half of the planes gone from your options is ridiculous.

It may have worked when the numbers were very high but it doesn't work now.

Like Dale said. 15/10/5 is bad for business. But what happens is you get 5/5/5

It certainly does balance the side, as your complaining seems to point out. Your upset because you have to fly crap planes against the lower number team, even if on your front the numbers are lopsided in the other direction.

Eny is being changed, it will kick in much slower with lower numbers, and the new base capture will be added and eventually fine tuned so they one team wont be able to hammer another team down to 20% their bases forcing the team to fight the other team that they have been ignoring.

Your issue is you don't like ENY  period! It like trying to tell the designer of Chess YOU don't like how the Bishops can only move diagonally and you want it changed. It not going to happen. It is part of the rules of the game, you remember, we are playing a game here right? You suggest Hitech look at the numbers of players Eny is chasing away from the game..... I'll bet he knows exactly how many players have left or come back and the reason way for the most part, but you are just assuming, you have no facts. I would say more than half the guys in my squad moan and cry about Eny and yet, we haven't lost a single player..... funny huh?

ENY is part of the game, it works, maybe not as elegantly as most would like, players are going to complain (your taking away their favorite toys), but if you except the fact that Eny is here to stay, and adapt to the situation and play on the game is still just as much fun if not a bit more challenging.

So the question remains what is ENY’s main purpose indiscriminate of the active population?



ENY is designed balance the playing field by limiting the availability of the better equipment to the team with the larger population. Period. It has nothing to do with forcing players to switch sides to even up the numbers.

Switching sides is an OPTION to all players that feel they MUST fly a P51 even if ENY is in action due to the numbers.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: hitech on November 10, 2026, 08:19:54 AM
Eny is being changed, it will kick in much slower with lower numbers, and the new base capture will be added and eventually fine tuned so they one team wont be able to hammer another team down to 20% their bases forcing the team to fight the other team that they have been ignoring.


The new system is already in effect.

HiTech
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Banshee7 on November 10, 2026, 08:45:52 AM
I'll be checking in from time to time to see if the ENY issue ever gets adjusted for the lower numbers. I closed my account.
I was relegated to the "I'm done with you on the subject" response and told my arguments were disingenuous.

I wish I could post the discussions the LCA have had on ENY. I'm not the only person fed up with consistently being blacked out of half the planes in the hanger so the other 4 players online on the big empty map can have a more enjoyable game experience at my expense.

I'm not going to go around and bad mouth Dale or the game, but I want it known how I feel about the petty attitude and outright dismissal of my concerns.

I want the game to succeed and I hope it gets more players and does better. I'm glad Dale is back and excited to jump back into the development and betterment of the game.

(https://i.postimg.cc/sGVRYNYW/well-bye-bye.gif) (https://postimg.cc/sGVRYNYW)
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Dadtallica on November 10, 2026, 09:40:27 AM

ENY is designed balance the playing field by limiting the availability of the better equipment to the team with the larger population. Period. It has nothing to do with forcing players to switch sides to even up the numbers.

Switching sides is an OPTION to all players that feel they MUST fly a P51 even if ENY is in action due to the numbers.

I’ve been trying to explain it, but I think the words “side balancing” are apparently confusing some people. The “sides” are “balanced” not the people.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: -gg- on November 10, 2026, 09:46:34 AM
Fugitive, you keep saying the same thing - that I'm just upset that I have to fly a crap plane against a low-number team. Not true.

I have been saying that the fights I get on a big empty map are never me being on the high number side. I may be on the side that has 5 or 6 more players than a country that I'm not even able to fight - they are on the other side of the map. Maybe 30 -60 total players online.

I have ENY 21-29 say and I'm fighting either even odds or being outnumbered by players who are much better than me and flying the best planes. while half the hanger is blacked out for me.

I have been saying LOW NUMBERS on and EMPTY MAP.   I am not outnumbering anyone.

I am not a "win the war" player. I am a find a fight player. I play (played) usually after 8.30 pm pacific time - and pretty much the whole time I have to play the game I'm looking at high ENY and no one is being gangbanged on the map.

I like to find a fight. I don't appreciate my hands being tied.

The other night I was flighing 3 and three  against just me, because that was the only fight I could reach on the map. I have high ENY and they didn't.

I want fair.

I don't want any advantage and I don't want anyone else at a disadvantage

Just like 18Whiskey says. He's in my squad. He is highly competitive and very good. He basically logged out every time ENY ties his hands for the SAME reason I am telling you. There might be a total number mismatch ( by not very much) and I am not even near an an area where that translates to me having a numbers advantage on the area where I am.


So night after night of this.

You guys try to simply say it's a whine because we can't fly "x" plane. It's not that. It's the fairness and it's how it actually works when the numbers are low and the map is spread out.

The new system was too low for me to see a difference. I think instead of 10, it should be more like 30 or 40. And I think it should not bite so hard at higher ENY

By zone would be good too. Or even by base.

AI planes to defend bases if that helps

I don't care about capturing bases or winning a map. I just wanted to play for a couple hours and find a fair fight. Logging in and seeing half the planes unavailable is just not fun for me. Sorry if you don't get that.


The System is called SIDE BALANCING. It's designed to coerce people into switching sides to balance the numbers. That's why we have auto side switching too.






Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Wiley on November 10, 2026, 09:58:15 AM
You guys try to simply say it's a whine because we can't fly "x" plane

Logging in ansd seeing half the planes unavailable is just not fun for me.

 :headscratch:  Kind of seems that way by definition.

For the record, I think ENY doesn't do much if anything for balancing/fairness.

Wiley.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: LilMak on November 10, 2026, 10:47:42 AM
I’m picking up what you’re laying down GG. And, while ENY isn’t a huge deal for me, I see your argument. The problem with ENY and a low MA population is not that it exists, but the scale at which it goes into effect.

For example (using simple numbers to illustrate a point):
100 vs 50 should hit harder than 10 vs 5. The ratios are the same but the effect is much more dramatic in the lower population. Especially since the maps are so big and the chances of people actually changing sides are much less when it’s 10 vs 5. So, while the 100 vs 50 could have a 29 ENY, the 10 vs 5 should perhaps be capped at 10 ENY if that makes sense. If your side has the 10 players and you do the right thing by not pounding one side into submission but going to the other front to seek out actual combat, perhaps you shouldn’t be flying Spit5s against Tempests?

My point is the severity of ENY should scale based on population. Lower population equals less severity until it gets so low that it goes away all together.

The other solution I’ve always proposed is ENY triggers perk cost for equipment instead of outright banning it. Current perk planes banned when triggered. But…

ENY is 30? Want to fly a P-51 with a 5 ENY? That’ll be 25 perks (30-5). The catch is, if you lose that P-51, those 25 perks go to the player that killed you…or something similar.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: -gg- on November 10, 2026, 10:57:11 AM
Thank you, LilMak. That's exactly the gist of it for me. And I also think that you put it better than I did.

I obviously care a lot about the game. That's why I'm still here. I honestly think it would be better for the game because people in the game that I'm flying with..... I see how it affects them and their attitude as well.

Not being disingenuous and not being a cry baby. I honestly think that it really needs to have a good look.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: CAV on November 10, 2026, 11:06:19 AM
It's side balancing because, It places a team with a higher population into lower tier planes, This allows the Lesser population to remain competitive. We may not like it but it for the most part it fulfills this function.

The one other possible solution I've ever thought about was a spawn delay. You spawn, in but you can't move until you spawn counter clicks down to zero. But you're still subject to Wind, rain and gunfire as you sit there.

This would force the player into a tactical decision do I spawn near the battle area Or a rear area where it's safer.

I personally would not be a fan of any system that forces me to fly away from my squad mates Or the friends I've been flying with for years.

Or

Another possible solution would be totally scrap the Perk point/ENY  system we have right now. Each player is assigned a number of points at the beginning of a campaign or possibly each map.

All planes are giving a perk point value all the way down to the lowest tiers, With the exception of cargo troop/ carrying Vehicles or planes They would always be free. Perk points gained from doing resupply / troop runs would be added to your total for your aircraft or vehicles.

Each time you Spawn a vehicle or plane you're basically purchasing  that plane with your perk points. At the end of your sortie If you did something useful you would gain points when you land. If you do anything other than a successful Landing at the end of your run you lose points.

As the population in the game fluctuates during the day the cost your Aircraft or vehicle would also go up or down.

If by some reason you're having a really bad campaign, And get down to zero perk points. Hi-Tech can put a system in where you're allowed to purchase Enough points to get back in the game. For a small fee of course.

Unfortunately this would probably be somewhat complicated to implement. Hi-Tech would have to figure out what a good starting point Would be for the perk points, Would probably have to have A mobile spawn point for gvs to return to base to so they can land successfully at an enemy base. Him and his AI friends would have to write the code and forceFeed it into the existing code.

I don't know if a system like this could be possible at all...It just sounds good in my head.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Max on November 10, 2026, 11:10:05 AM
This one's so battered & worn out both the stick & the horse have been vaporized  :old:
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: DmonSlyr on November 10, 2026, 11:59:13 AM
IMHO, ENY should not kick in under 90 players. Or atleast make them perk rides instead.

Why:

large maps means players are scattered all over. If you split a map into 4 zones, only 1 or 2 zones are usually active.

Under 90 players, the fights could be lopsided irregardless of the #s. One side hoarding with no resistance could even have the lowest #s. The other 2 sides are penalized and not even acknowledging the team hoarding.

Switch times - if I switch to a team I think needs help in a battle, they could have the most players by 10 and still be losing the battle. I switch to make the battle fair, but now the ENY is even worse. Or if the #s change within 20-30 minutes im still unable to switch back. Id rather no ENY than people switching all over the map knowing everyone's positions, but the side switch time doesnt do any favors for ENY.


Low #s already: we shouldn't encourage more players to leave who are forced to fly 25 eny planes in the middle of the day. We need to be building up #s and fights, not giving them a reason to log.


Fights are extremely tough to find depending on the map during the day. Players should be encouraged to roll, not disincentivized to roll.

So, side switch should be reduced to 2 hours if you want people to switch to make teams fair in order to offset ENY or there will always be an issue because the #s are always fluctuating.

Under 90 players, which is 30 on each side, should not have ENY because it doesnt do the game better to have people log when they are either stuck on a team and cant switch, or always play on one chess peice but are disenfranchised about not being able to fly their plane when there side may need all the help it can get in the current battle if both teams are attacking one team while avoiding interacting on the other side of the map.



Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: -gg- on November 10, 2026, 12:30:45 PM
That's exactly it, DmonSlyr.


Thank you for saying it so well and clearly.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Banshee7 on November 10, 2026, 12:50:03 PM
Or if the #s change within 20-30 minutes im still unable to switch back. Id rather no ENY than people switching all over the map knowing everyone's positions, but the side switch time doesnt do any favors for ENY.


So, side switch should be reduced to 2 hours if you want people to switch to make teams fair in order to offset ENY or there will always be an issue because the #s are always fluctuating.


Side switch timer should be no more than 1 hour.  Heck, I'd even say 30 minutes due to exactly what you stated at the beginning of the quote.  The strategy aspect is not as prevalent as it used to be for there to even be spies (minus the locations of TGs), and I don't think there's anyone here that genuinely cares about any one player's position.  The side switch timer has been my biggest complaint since I came back a few years ago and discovered it wasn't 1 hour anymore.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Animl-AW on November 10, 2026, 01:12:36 PM
Side switch timer should be no more than 1 hour.  Heck, I'd even say 30 minutes due to exactly what you stated at the beginning of the quote.  The strategy aspect is not as prevalent as it used to be for there to even be spies (minus the locations of TGs), and I don't think there's anyone here that genuinely cares about any one player's position.  The side switch timer has been my biggest complaint since I came back a few years ago and discovered it wasn't 1 hour anymore.

Disagree, spying sucks. In AW it was 24 hrs
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Animl-AW on November 10, 2026, 01:14:06 PM
Beating a dead horse with a dead horse. Zero new is being said.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Banshee7 on November 10, 2026, 01:19:16 PM
Disagree, spying sucks. In AW it was 24 hrs

What exactly is there to spy on other than TGs?  Are people still running NOE missions or plotting base sneaks on country channel?  The last few times I played, I didn't see much cooperation between players.  It was more or less just a conglomeration of the pure dogfighters in the same area as the base takers because that's where the red guys were.  If they took the base then cool.

I can full on agree that spying was a thing and sucked when there were hundreds of players on that actually cooperated and used some strategy. 


EDIT:  I don't mean that to sound passive aggressive or argumentative.  Just my observations.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: -gg- on November 10, 2026, 01:31:52 PM
Calling in the dead horse issue is kind of just dismissing the concerns of all the people who have brought this up over the years. There's a reason why I keeps getting brought up.

But with these numbers the way they are and the way this is working by encouraging people to log off, I can't see why it wouldn't be a good thing to be looking into. One of the biggest issues in the whole entire game about how the mechanics work isn't working.

They are looking at it. Dale has made a small adjustment. Doesn't make a bit of difference but it's a start.

Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Dadtallica on November 10, 2026, 01:36:07 PM
IMHO, ENY should not kick in under 90 players. Or atleast make them perk rides instead.

Why:

large maps means players are scattered all over. If you split a map into 4 zones, only 1 or 2 zones are usually active.

Under 90 players, the fights could be lopsided irregardless of the #s. One side hoarding with no resistance could even have the lowest #s. The other 2 sides are penalized and not even acknowledging the team hoarding.

Switch times - if I switch to a team I think needs help in a battle, they could have the most players by 10 and still be losing the battle. I switch to make the battle fair, but now the ENY is even worse. Or if the #s change within 20-30 minutes im still unable to switch back. Id rather no ENY than people switching all over the map knowing everyone's positions, but the side switch time doesnt do any favors for ENY.


Low #s already: we shouldn't encourage more players to leave who are forced to fly 25 eny planes in the middle of the day. We need to be building up #s and fights, not giving them a reason to log.


Fights are extremely tough to find depending on the map during the day. Players should be encouraged to roll, not disincentivized to roll.

So, side switch should be reduced to 2 hours if you want people to switch to make teams fair in order to offset ENY or there will always be an issue because the #s are always fluctuating.

Under 90 players, which is 30 on each side, should not have ENY because it doesnt do the game better to have people log when they are either stuck on a team and cant switch, or always play on one chess peice but are disenfranchised about not being able to fly their plane when there side may need all the help it can get in the current battle if both teams are attacking one team while avoiding interacting on the other side of the map.


It barely gets over 85 players except for a couple hours a day so just say you don’t want ENY at all instead.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: DmonSlyr on November 10, 2026, 02:51:48 PM

It barely gets over 85 players except for a couple hours a day so just say you don’t want ENY at all instead.

If anything perk the planes rather than make them non flyable. Atleast it gives more reason to use perks. Isnt that the whole point of perked planes? Reducing usage since they are super uber?

I also believe a few fighters and bombers need to be adjusted down and/or perked or perked even higher but thats another discussion.

The lower the #s, the higher the swings in eny which makes it crucial during off hours. IMO, we've already seen it not working well for morning hours, given the usual bish hoard, which ruins the bish for the rest of the day, BTW. But I feel the overall #s, or even the tower sitters, doesn't project the reality of the gameplay situation under 90 players. Generally there are about 15 players in the air on average per team, and some are tanks, so if you are only fighting with 3-6 of the 15, and you have 3-6 of your fighters in that area, that is a fair skrimish, and that may be the only place on the map for you to fight.

Side switch timer should be no more than 1 hour.  Heck, I'd even say 30 minutes due to exactly what you stated at the beginning of the quote.  The strategy aspect is not as prevalent as it used to be for there to even be spies (minus the locations of TGs), and I don't think there's anyone here that genuinely cares about any one player's position.  The side switch timer has been my biggest complaint since I came back a few years ago and discovered it wasn't 1 hour anymore.

Im just trying to come to an agreement with Hitech on this. One hour may be fine, but it does get tough for most guys to fight a top stick switching sides on em all the time. It also messes up the equilibrium of the war, potentially. I personally think you should be able to switch one time per sitting. A sitting is about 1 or 2 hours for most. I was always at 3 hours, so that you can play for a bit, come back in a couple hours and be able to switch again if needed, but you weren't stuck all day on a team where there is no battle action on that side of the map at the time.

Its why ive been so adamant on smaller more condensed maps because it will naturally solve these issues.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Animl-AW on November 10, 2026, 04:34:55 PM
Auto switch sides, the option is already there
1 hr can be highly abused

You guys are talking as if human gamer nature is not involved.


Point mongers will switch to what ever side is winning or hoarding all night, nothing to do with sde balance. Point mingers exploit everything and want everything to their advantage.

One comes from a group of a habitual abuser of everything. Lets get real.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Banshee7 on November 10, 2026, 07:16:54 PM
Auto switch sides, the option is already there
1 hr can be highly abused

You guys are talking as if human gamer nature is not involved.


Point mongers will switch to what ever side is winning or hoarding all night, nothing to do with sde balance. Point mingers exploit everything and want everything to their advantage.

One comes from a group of a habitual abuser of everything. Lets get real.

As mentioned here https://bbs.hitechcreations.com/smf/index.php/topic,413353.0.html (https://bbs.hitechcreations.com/smf/index.php/topic,413353.0.html), auto switch was a step in the right direction for balancing sides.  It is what I do.  However, it has been noted several times that fights can flip fronts so quickly that the auto switch can sometimes leave you stranded with no fight.  Sure, you could go cause your own havoc by attacking a base on an empty front, but what's the point if no one ups to defend?

What is the minimum amount of time someone has to be on the winning side to earn the perks?  That could also be adjusted. 

I would assume that most the people still flying have accumulated so many perks that the 25 awarded for each category is miniscule (which is another reason why I don't believe charging perks for low ENY planes when ENY is activated will do much good).  Heck, I got almost 100 fighter perks in one 5 kill sortie the other night thanks to auto switch  :D
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Lazerr on November 10, 2026, 08:41:43 PM
1 hour.. I think the only guy that would abuse it would be admiral Caine.  And Skychicken.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: hazmatt on November 10, 2026, 08:45:20 PM
1 hour.. I think the only guy that would abuse it would be admiral Caine.  And Skychicken.

Speaking of admirals. What ever happened ot RODBSTR?
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: hazmatt on November 10, 2026, 09:10:10 PM
Quote from: -gg- link=topic=413357.msg5483437#msg5483437 date=179428385
Hope the game works out. Kind of doubt it though.
[/quote

There's still some sycophants left. :banana:

Will be interesting how Epic games thing works out. I suspect it's no addressing the elephant in the room. Hope I'm wrong.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: JimmyD3 on November 10, 2026, 09:20:11 PM
geez people, the horse is dead, as matter of fact it has now returned to dust!! LET IT GO, for all that is holy. :bolt:
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: The Fugitive on November 10, 2026, 09:54:20 PM
geez people, the horse is dead, as matter of fact it has now returned to dust!! LET IT GO, for all that is holy. :bolt:

I hope its not dead. I don't know IF it could happen but if the ENY could be tied to fronts I think it would work better. Fronts being so dynamic and ever changing may be an issue with keeping it updated.

This certainly solve "gina's" issue. While her team is under ENY due to numbers the front she is fighting on is either even numbers or her team is out numbered as the rest of her team is ganging the other front. I hope Hitech continues to explore other options and hope players continue to have some patience while Hitech works things out.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Dadtallica on November 10, 2026, 10:53:37 PM
Until everyone stops equating the word “sides” with “population” I’m closing this thread!!

Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Rubicon on November 11, 2026, 12:27:17 AM
This last weekend I was hit with ENY very often.  At one point it was up around 22 and it was not really much fun.

ENY is a blunt instrument and it will never be able to account for local concentrations of force outnumbering the high numbered side.

I personally don't care for ENY and I suspect it does more harm than good when coupled with low player numbers and long side switch times but I do not see it getting changed so don't dwell on it too much.  If it becomes an issue for me I log off and go do something else but that does not happen very often as I tend to change to the smaller sides and my game session is usually done before ENY hits that low side.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: LilMak on November 11, 2026, 05:43:25 AM
Still think the solution is engaging a perk cost for equipment instead of outright banning it. Maybe in conjunction with a perk reset?
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Eagler on November 11, 2026, 06:02:12 AM
Still think the solution is engaging a perk cost for equipment instead of outright banning it. Maybe in conjunction with a perk reset?

With different perk levels set for different maps..

Everything should be perked above early war..

Maybe start each tour with a set of perks for those that don't have more than we can ever spend now..

Eagler
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Max on November 11, 2026, 07:12:25 AM
geez people, the horse is dead, as matter of fact it has now returned to dust!! LET IT GO, for all that is holy. :bolt:

Nah....this one's only gettin started  :rofl
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: LilMak on November 11, 2026, 09:00:40 AM
With different perk levels set for different maps..

Everything should be perked above early war..

Maybe start each tour with a set of perks for those that don't have more than we can ever spend now..

Eagler
If we went to this, I suspect we’d likely get the same response to it that we’re getting with ENY.

I advocated for something like this in free multi-tiered setup where play is free with a limited plane selection but perks could be purchased or earned to get later equipment. Perhaps with a small perk balance when an account is opened (to get the hooks in them). The concept is basically that you have a limited early war equipment selection for free players with none of the current perked hardware ever available to any of the free players (no 262 without a subscription). Perks could be earned or purchased for all the equipment we take for granted daily as subscribers. The cost for perks would be pretty substantial. Something to akin to “perked” equipment costing a buck and perks being sold in five dollar increments. Basically, if you’re a free player and want to get out of that P-40 and into a P-51, spend 10 days grinding to earn one plane or blast the credit card to get five.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: AKIron on November 11, 2026, 09:02:57 AM
So what does ENY stand for? Enemy?
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Animl-AW on November 11, 2026, 09:16:50 AM
So I’m drinking my morning coffee and had a thought.

I wonder what the players think about ENY. Then I thought, naaa, no one is interested in that, kinda boring subject..
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Shane on November 11, 2026, 09:32:33 AM
So what does ENY stand for? Enemy?

EquaNimitY is a state of psychological stability, calm, and emotional composure that remains undisturbed by stress, pain, or changing circumstances.


 :noid :rofl
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: hazmatt on November 11, 2026, 05:42:20 PM
If we went to this, I suspect we’d likely get the same response to it that we’re getting with ENY.

I advocated for something like this in free multi-tiered setup where play is free with a limited plane selection but perks could be purchased or earned to get later equipment. Perhaps with a small perk balance when an account is opened (to get the hooks in them). The concept is basically that you have a limited early war equipment selection for free players with none of the current perked hardware ever available to any of the free players (no 262 without a subscription). Perks could be earned or purchased for all the equipment we take for granted daily as subscribers. The cost for perks would be pretty substantial. Something to akin to “perked” equipment costing a buck and perks being sold in five dollar increments. Basically, if you’re a free player and want to get out of that P-40 and into a P-51, spend 10 days grinding to earn one plane or blast the credit card to get five.

I think this sounds like a great idea, however, it's been brought up in different flavors before and I'm pretty sure HT said something along the lines of "it's not going to happen" or something to that effect.

FTP would have been great for my kids and I as we sometimes only get to play together a few times a month and I can't justify a $60 a month payment for that. That ship has sailed as we all now play another game together that's completely FTP and has massive amounts of players at all skill levels.

My concern is that for the most part in games like this numbers (make the game interesting) and get more numbers. Once you get below a certain baseline, I think it starts getting harder and harder to get those numbers back, especially when a new player is trying to learn a game populated by vets of many many years and there's no alternative ai targets or anything for a new unskilled player to do for the most part.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: 1ijac on November 11, 2026, 11:15:26 PM
If we went to this, I suspect we’d likely get the same response to it that we’re getting with ENY.

I advocated for something like this in free multi-tiered setup where play is free with a limited plane selection but perks could be purchased or earned to get later equipment. Perhaps with a small perk balance when an account is opened (to get the hooks in them). The concept is basically that you have a limited early war equipment selection for free players with none of the current perked hardware ever available to any of the free players (no 262 without a subscription). Perks could be earned or purchased for all the equipment we take for granted daily as subscribers. The cost for perks would be pretty substantial. Something to akin to “perked” equipment costing a buck and perks being sold in five dollar increments. Basically, if you’re a free player and want to get out of that P-40 and into a P-51, spend 10 days grinding to earn one plane or blast the credit card to get five.
   

I see a problem with veterans flying around in their Uber planes beating up on the new guys just trying to get the hang of the game.  This already happens and the above just makes it worse, which in turn hinders building the population.  I would suggest the opposite by giving the new pilots a longer trial period to get hooked.  Giving them full access to the plane set.

One-eye
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Dadtallica on November 11, 2026, 11:27:05 PM
   

I see a problem with veterans flying around in their Uber planes beating up on the new guys just trying to get the hang of the game.  This already happens and the above just makes it worse, which in turn hinders building the population.  I would suggest the opposite by giving the new pilots a longer trial period to get hooked.  Giving them full access to the plane set.

One-eye

Fair point here, but then again it wouldn’t be fair to limit those who are veterans just because they’ve been here a long time. Haven’t they also earned their place?

Maybe new players could get an ENY pass during their trial period or first 30-days so they can get comfy and fly whatever they want?

Also, more importantly than this Mr. Jac… when are you going to make a new file for all the new maps? I have your OG breakdown on my phone and use it every night! This is a definite resource new players could use!
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: AKIron on November 12, 2026, 07:50:39 AM
Give every trial period player an ace level AI wingman. One that can take the lead or follow orders. One that will communicate with the player. Reassign the AI wingman to an AI squad after a few weeks.

AI has been in flight combat games since the start. They now have a potential unlike ever before.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: LilMak on November 12, 2026, 08:01:47 AM
   

I see a problem with veterans flying around in their Uber planes beating up on the new guys just trying to get the hang of the game.  This already happens and the above just makes it worse, which in turn hinders building the population.  I would suggest the opposite by giving the new pilots a longer trial period to get hooked.  Giving them full access to the plane set.

One-eye
I tend to agree with your assessment. However, the actual point would be to encourage subscribers. If they started with a bank of perks, they could actually use them until they ran out. Thinking about this from a new player perspective, it’s very similar to COD and other games where average or below average players buy skins and packages because they think they’re going to be more competitive. And they actually do get better. Meanwhile they’re learning the game at no cost and there isn’t a two week timer counting down so they can do it at their own pace. AH has a steep learning curve and the hook is when you have some success. There’s a mentality (human nature?) where they’ll want to buy some perks or get that subscription going because they’ll believe (because it’s true) they’re better at the game with better equipment. Basically there needs to be time for them to learn and get better at their individual pace. Crew chief is going to help. The radar adjustments are going to help too.

Still. I just play in the sandbox. Offer my ideas. Throw out criticisms. I do believe the core of the game is player vs player. And the fundamental problem is we need more players. I think the FTP model will bring some in and provide a consistent source of new ones. Even if the thought in the past was to dismiss it maybe it’s time for a revisit? I think this because I was gifted an X-box during COVID and played a lot of COD. I swore I wouldn’t buy any battle passes. I was wrong. I think something would work similarly here.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: -gg- on November 12, 2026, 08:22:30 AM
Ideas for a free to play system.

1. Give players an extremely limited plane set, but not crap planes. Like maybe let them have only a 16 for a fighter, maybe one bomber maybe one gv. But not a crappy one something that they can at least do well in.
I think it's spit 16 would be good because it's easy doesn't have a big range and not a lot of people really use that except for maybe base defense.
2. Let them earn perks and rank but not let them use anything until they have a real account
3. Make them automatic side switchers with no option to change countries.
4. Give them a limited amount of hours to play per campaign until the timer kicks in and they're prompted to pay for an account

That's just off the top of my head. But basically you give people a taste of the game. Maybe even just one plane that they can fly and if they like the game they're going to pay for the game to get more. To use the perks. To not have to switch sides. Or to join a squad or whatever.

Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: LilMak on November 12, 2026, 09:35:25 AM
Ideas for a free to play system.

1. Give players an extremely limited plane set, but not crap planes. Like maybe let them have only a 16 for a fighter, maybe one bomber maybe one gv. But not a crappy one something that they can at least do well in.
I think it's spit 16 would be good because it's easy doesn't have a big range and not a lot of people really use that except for maybe base defense.
2. Let them earn perks and rank but not let them use anything until they have a real account
3. Make them automatic side switchers with no option to change countries.
4. Give them a limited amount of hours to play per campaign until the timer kicks in and they're prompted to pay for an account

That's just off the top of my head. But basically you give people a taste of the game. Maybe even just one plane that they can fly and if they like the game they're going to pay for the game to get more. To use the perks. To not have to switch sides. Or to join a squad or whatever.
The point of FTP would be to encourage them to upgrade and pay.

Going over you suggested ideas one by one…

1. Give them planes that can be competitive but struggle. Spit16 would be reserved for pay for perks kinda deal I discussed earlier. Using the Spit as an example, I would stop at a Spit5. A Spit9 might even be a step too far. 109F, C205, all the Zekes, Brewster, birdcage Corsair, B-25s, Bettys, M4, M-16, anything that carries troops is kinda where my mind is at. Or maybe anything with a 35 ENY?
2. Let them grind to earn perks if they don’t want to pay. Something like playing for 4 hours gets them a perk they can use so they can get that Spit16 or Wirble.
3. This seems viable but could force them away if they’re constantly being horded.
4. No time limits. They need to learn and the curve is steep.

Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: -gg- on November 12, 2026, 09:48:46 AM
I think you need to give them a good plane though. They're going to suck anyway and they need to see that they might be able to compete. Making them struggle with a bad plane will frustrate them.

A spit 9 might be better.                                                               

Let them build perks but not use them until they upgrade.

When they only have one plane, one bomber and one GV - and a bunch of perks they can't use, that's a big incentive to upgrade. Badger them with the AI crew chief - "you have 500 perks and can fly xxxx planes. upgrade to use" Have it suggest planes for ground attack. Upgrade to try them.

Also, it puts planes in the air.



Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: LilMak on November 12, 2026, 09:56:37 AM
When they only have one plane, one bomber and one GV - and a bunch of perks they can't use, that's a big incentive to upgrade. Badger them with the AI crew chief - "you have 500 perks and can fly xxxx planes. upgrade to use" Have it suggest planes for ground attack. Upgrade to try them.

Also, it puts planes in the air.
One of the greatest aspects of the game is the diversity. Hard to get that if you’re overly limited. Also, many folks would want to use the equipment and countries they represent. This requires diversity in being able to fly off carriers, dive bomb, level bomb, GV and so on. German, Japanese, American, British, Russian, and even Italian equipment could and should be represented.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: -gg- on November 12, 2026, 10:20:35 AM
One of the greatest aspects of the game is the diversity. Hard to get that if you’re overly limited. Also, many folks would want to use the equipment and countries they represent. This requires diversity in being able to fly off carriers, dive bomb, level bomb, GV and so on. German, Japanese, American, British, Russian, and even Italian equipment could and should be represented.

That's exactly what I'm thinking. They will see that they can use all of that if they sign up and pay. The FTP gets them in the game and that stuff gets them to pay.


Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: hazmatt on November 14, 2026, 04:08:22 PM
109F, C205, all the Zekes, Brewster, birdcage Corsair, B-25s, Bettys, M4, M-16, anything that carries troops is kinda where my mind is at. Or maybe anything with a 35 ENY?
2. Let them grind to earn perks if they don’t want to pay. Something like playing for 4 hours gets them a perk they can use so they can get that Spit16 or Wirble.
3. This seems viable but could force them away if they’re constantly being horded.
4. No time limits. They need to learn and the curve is steep.

I don't think you're ideas take into account the score hors that are gonna be trolling around in temps and b&zing the crap out of the seals. I think they would get beat down and discouraged right quick. My idea would be to give them something like the P51B or some other plane that has decent speed, maybe one of the jugs.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Oldman731 on November 14, 2026, 04:59:39 PM
I don't think you're ideas take into account the score hors that are gonna be trolling around in temps and b&zing the crap out of the seals. I think they would get beat down and discouraged right quick. My idea would be to give them something like the P51B or some other plane that has decent speed, maybe one of the jugs.


Agreed.  51B, Spit 9, 109G2, A6M5.  The Spit and the Zeke are great learner planes, easy to fly, maybe even to get kills with because they have real guns.  The Pony and 109 are for the people who lean historical and/or who just always wanted to fly one in a game.  All four should be available most of the time unless ENY is truly nuts.

- oldman
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: LilMak on November 14, 2026, 05:00:51 PM
I don't think you're ideas take into account the score hors that are gonna be trolling around in temps and b&zing the crap out of the seals. I think they would get beat down and discouraged right quick. My idea would be to give them something like the P51B or some other plane that has decent speed, maybe one of the jugs.
I hear ya. That’s why my idea gives them free perks to get that P-51D off the jump. Get them used to it so they can buy more perks to get more P-51s. Eventually they’ll see they are spending $20 a month and subscribe.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Eagler on November 14, 2026, 05:28:17 PM
Add a yak or la and you have a plane from each country..

Eagler
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: LilMak on November 14, 2026, 07:12:30 PM
Add a yak or la and you have a plane from each country..

Eagler
I-16 is fine.
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: TBlayde on November 14, 2026, 08:36:23 PM
Had not flown much for two weeks. Came on last night around 9.30 pacific and sat through ENY the whole time. Was over 20 and there were maybe 15 total players in the air. The total numbers logged in when I logged off was 15/15/5. Actually flying was lower. There's a BIG, EMPTY map and no ganging was going on, In fact, the only fight I found had ME being ganged.

I was fighting the 2-3 players at a time.... so I was being outnumbered.

After an hour ENY went up again and I could only fly crap planes. I sat in the tower for awhile and then just logged off

Is the intent of ENY to make the game not fun for people like me when the numbers are SO LOW?

I'm seriously and continually annoyed and maddened by EYN.

It deserves a review. When numbers are low it needs to go away. It makes no sense.

ENY Kills it for me too. Just no point, war was never fair.

Do what Iracing does with their 13th week, but expand it. First (n) weeks are early model planes. Next (n) Weeks are mid-war, Then late war, then end of the war when 262s and other technologies that got introduced late. Than have a couple weeks where *everything* goes. Then back to the rotation.

My .02

I was considering coming back with the recent updates. But, if ENY is still a thing it may dampen my spirits. I will have to pop on and see how many ppl are there.

Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Banshee7 on November 14, 2026, 11:18:16 PM
I was considering coming back with the recent updates. But, if ENY is still a thing it may dampen my spirits. I will have to pop on and see how many ppl are there.

OR...hear me out...learn how to fly higher ENY planes  :airplane: :banana:
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Dadtallica on November 14, 2026, 11:59:13 PM
OR...hear me out...learn how to fly higher ENY planes  :airplane: :banana:

The G14 alone could easily turn into your most favorite thing ever if you give it a whirl! Seem to be said for a few others!
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Banshee7 on November 15, 2026, 07:31:35 PM
The G14 alone could easily turn into your most favorite thing ever if you give it a whirl! Seem to be said for a few others!

It’s my favorite 109  :x
Title: Re: ENY again
Post by: Dadtallica on November 15, 2026, 08:08:42 PM
It’s my favorite 109  :x

Same here!