You seem to like Jugs. Next time you see me online, I invite you to join me in a ride along in a D-11 and maybe I can convince you that a crap plane can actually be a lot of fun?
But I agree that the threshold for ENY should be somewhere around 40 players online and it goes away.
D40 is one of my high eny go to planes. I should try the the 11… what do you like about it Mak?D-11 is a bit different because it’s limited in acceleration, climb, and views. But it’s still stable at very high and very low speeds like all the jugs. It seems to have a very marginal flat turning advantage at medium speeds over the others because it’s a tiny bit lighter. The only significant difference (in my semi-professional opinion) is that the views are weak and you really need to be on your E management game. Once you scrub speed, it takes longer to get back and escape without an initial E advantage is not likely.
jagoffs can have an enjoyable game experience?
D-11 is a bit different because it’s limited in acceleration, climb, and views. But it’s still stable at very high and very low speeds like all the jugs. It seems to have a very marginal flat turning advantage at medium speeds over the others because it’s a tiny bit lighter. The only significant difference (in my semi-professional opinion) is that the views are weak and you really need to be on your E management game. Once you scrub speed, it takes longer to get back and escape without an initial E advantage is not likely.
What do I like about it? It still a jug, flys like one, still competitive in the MA, and almost always available no matter how bad the ENY gets. Also, I can see the tears on the windscreen when I fly through Tempest and 262 scrap. Few feelings are better in MA than stealing a player’s perks in a 35 ENY bird.
Whatcha got against jagoffs?I save yet to see you in game, but I play noon to 3ish west coast. That said I agree with much of what you said. I was in high ent, half the team sleeping in tower. Trying to up off a golf with3 tempest and a duece and they b nz so hard it was ridiculous. All to rack up three “kills”
I would try to understand how you feel but since I rarely flew planes that were affected by eny, I'd be lyin if I said I did understand.
I’m not quite understanding how ENY affects a country outnumbered?
If ENY is affecting your plane choice then are you not on one of the sides that’s the problem?
Tonight in primetime it was quiet on the rook side but the other two were getting it on heavy. I don’t know what the exact roster account was, but when I got there it was riddled with jets. I counted at least four 262’s and I’m pretty sure there were probably actually six. I was helping the Bish defend their base from the Knights.
It was pretty cool actually as much as I can’t stand jets but I’m sure the bishops weren’t excited about it. The bishops were actually holding their own pretty well at the time. I had to remind a couple. I was there to help, but it didn’t matter. I never made it home.
Also, it's not my fault that I log in and I happen to be on the team that has a couple more players than the other team. What am I supposed to do about that?
Part of the problem. Jesus. A customer that logs into play a game is part of the problem?
You're not understanding.
First of all, I reject the idea that just because I log into the game to play that I am some sort of a problem. I'm not part of a team I'm an individual trying to play a game and enjoy it and I'm getting stymied by the game itself.
But the major issue is that when I play it's usually very low numbers. There's a huge empty map and even though technically I am on a side that is outnumbering one side, the numbers are so low that it doesn't even matter. Two or three plane difference? Over the whole huge map? There are no gangbangs going on.
The night that I was talking about, and it it happens very very frequently, I was the one being outnumbered. I was fighting two and three players on an isolated fight between two bases where we were just fighting.
I reall I think eny why is damaging to the game experience.... Far more than being outnumbered by one or two planes over a huge map that's mostly empty.
Most of the time when I'm on NY is in effect against me. And I say me because I'm not part of a team. I don't fly in a hoard. I reject the idea that I'm part of a problem. That's insulting.
I just want to log on for a couple of hours and have fun. When my plane choices get reduced to every single plane that I've got in my favorite list..... I have to start searching for a piece of crap that I don't even like to fly the game is not enjoyable to me. And the game is penalizing me so that somebody else doesn't feel like they are outnumbered on a huge map with nothing going on?
Turn the stupid thing off at least when the numbers are low like that. It doesn't make any sense whatsoever.
You was a collective not necessarily personal to you.
| Players in arena | Now: imbalance needed | Now: example | Considering: imbalance needed | Considering: example |
| 6 | 3 | 4/1/1 | no ENY | - |
| 8 | 3 | 4/3/1 | no ENY | - |
| 10 | 4 | 5/4/1 | no ENY | - |
| 12 | 4 | 6/4/2 | not possible | - |
| 15 | 4 | 7/5/3 | 8 | 9/5/1 |
| 20 | 5 | 9/7/4 | 6 | 9/8/3 |
| 25 | 5 | 10/10/5 | 6 | 11/9/5 |
| 30 | 6 | 12/12/6 | 6 | 12/12/6 |
| 35 | 6 | 14/13/8 | 7 | 14/14/7 |
| 40 | 7 | 16/15/9 | 7 | 16/15/9 |
| 50 | 8 | 20/18/12 | 8 | 20/18/12 |
| 70 | 10 | 27/26/17 | 10 | 27/26/17 |
The game is not limiting you. ENY limits plane choice, not whether you can fly. You are choosing to fly for the side you want rather than the plane you want, and that is a fair choice to make. There are always lower ENY planes available to you on your side.
ENY: when does it start limiting planes?
The lowest ENY for fighters in the Main Arena is 5 (P-51D, Spitfire XIV, La-7, Tempest and others). The table below shows how far ahead the largest side has to be before its ENY limit goes above 5, which is when those planes become unavailable to it.
How ENY works: each side's share of the active (non-AFK) players is compared to the smallest side's share. A side can be up to 10% bigger than the smallest side with no limit at all. Past that, the limit grows with the difference. The limit is also scaled by how many players are in the arena, so with low numbers it is much weaker.
Now: the scaling starts at 0 players and reaches full strength at 70 players.
What I am considering: the scaling starts at 10 players and reaches full strength at 70 players. Below 10 players there would be no ENY at all, and between 10 and about 30 players it would take a bigger imbalance to get a limit. From about 40 players up nothing changes.
"Imbalance" is how many more players the largest side has than the smallest side. The example is one split of the three sides where that happens.
Players in arena Now: imbalance needed Now: example Considering: imbalance needed Considering: example 6 3 4/1/1 no ENY - 8 3 4/3/1 no ENY - 10 4 5/4/1 no ENY - 12 4 6/4/2 not possible - 15 4 7/5/3 8 9/5/1 20 5 9/7/4 6 9/8/3 25 5 10/10/5 6 11/9/5 30 6 12/12/6 6 12/12/6 35 6 14/13/8 7 14/14/7 40 7 16/15/9 7 16/15/9 50 8 20/18/12 8 20/18/12 70 10 27/26/17 10 27/26/17
"not possible" means that with that few players the limit I am considering could never get above 5, however the sides are split.
HiTech
I just want things to be simple.
So....what's your simple solution?
really? I've mentioned it dozens of times - and at least once in this thread.
REMOVE ENY when numbers are low. Get rid of it. Have it kick in only when there are significant numbers.
I mean, 3 people cried about Radar and got that addressed. ENY is a much bigger issue for the game and complaints about it have gone on forever.
Did you even read HT's post that you quoted where he said he was considering turning it off at 10 players or less?
Did you? because you asked me what my solution was.... and I told you again.
I appreciate that he's considering that. I think it should be more like 60 players. I think, as I've mention before, that it should also be based on what is actually going on on the map.
So, it sounds like you're asking for a more difficult solution. You have already expressed your unwillingness to try the most obvious "simple" solutions like flying higher ENY planes or changing countries. ENY not kicking in until 60 sounds like a complete nightmare for the side with the lowest numbers (because ya know, Gina wants to be able to horde in her Spit 16).
I don't actively "choose" to be on the side with numbers. That's not within my control.
One sortie in a KI-43 with 5 kills.
I mean, it is. It is literally within your control. In fact, it is one of the few things that IS within your control.
I mean, it is. It is literally within your control. In fact, it is one of the few things that IS within your control.
I fly higher ENY planes.
I fly higher ENY planes.
It's not realistic to ask people to change countries. I'm in a squad, for one thing. It's also not easy to jump back and forth to different countries - that's why VERY few people are auto side-switchers.
I don't care one bit about numbers. I don't care if I'm outnumbers... I just look at the map and want to find a fight.
I am being punished by a worse game experience just because more people log on my side.
I mean, 3 people cried about Radar and got that addressed.
Gotta be a hack. Ain't no way a Ki-43 has ammo for 5 kills! :headscratch:Three zeros and two brewsters I believe. Some assistance was provided by the trees/ground.
From the sounds of it, you're never outnumbered...
This is how the change would work out, using the last 60 days of the main arena. The chart shows how often the largest side could not fly ENY 5 planes, now and with the change I am considering (ENY starts ramping up at 10 players instead of 0, full strength at 70 players as now).
https://dload.hitechcreations.com/dales/side-balance.html
Now: 49% of the time. With the change: 35% of the time.
HiTech
This is how the change would work out, using the last 60 days of the main arena. The chart shows how often the largest side could not fly ENY 5 planes, now and with the change I am considering (ENY starts ramping up at 10 players instead of 0, full strength at 70 players as now).
https://dload.hitechcreations.com/dales/side-balance.html
Now: 49% of the time. With the change: 35% of the time.
HiTech
Thanks for looking into this and for your consideration!
Are you able to run stats on how various levels of ENY affect overall numbers? One of my contentions has been that I feel ENY does eventually even the sides, but I have a feeling that it does so by reducing the numbers of players and not by players switching sides to even the numbers.
I'd love to see how the stats work out on numbers before and after ENY ( at various levels of ENY) affect the people in flight or logged in.
The rest of this post is not directed directly at you, Dale
_____________________________ _____________________________ _____________________________ _____
I just have always felt that the large majority of players will not switch sides when heave ENY kicks in. I think they deal with it for a bit, sit in the tower for a bit to wait or log off.
So that's part of my point - and I could be wrong - but I feel that ENY does not really work as intended.
When I mentioned DAR being addressed, I meant this: I've never once ever heard anyone in the game mention anything about DAR being a problem. I see like three people on the forum crying about it and then it gets addressed - when I don't think anyone ever had a problem with it. Then a change gets introduced based on what 3 guys are saying here, and tons of people in game don't know what's going on with the glitchy DAR.
On the other hand, I will bet that every single night I hear people complain about ENY on vox. There are countess complaints about ENY going back years, to the point that people attack anyone for bringing it up again.
I'm glad Dale is looking at ENY. Using stats and not just 3 guys crying about something.
Your perception of what ENY does is what is wrong.
ENY is used to balance game play by removing the better equipment from the team that has the ADVANTAGE in numbers.
ENY is NOT setup to make players switch to other teams to balance the numbers. Switching is an option to players who wish to use the the better equipment that has been removed due to the numbers imbalance.
If one team has 10 extra players and there is no ENY, those players can jump in a number of B24 with ponies and D9 as roll base after base with ease. The other team doesnt have the numbers to top them.
WITH ENY, those 10 players are stuck trying to do the same thing with Bostons and P40s something that is much easier to fight against Making the fight a bit more balanced.
Your perception of what ENY does is what is wrong.
ENY is used to balance game play by removing the better equipment from the team that has the ADVANTAGE in numbers.
ENY is NOT setup to make players switch to other teams to balance the numbers. Switching is an option to players who wish to use the the better equipment that has been removed due to the numbers imbalance.
If one team has 10 extra players and there is no ENY, those players can jump in a number of B24 with ponies and D9 as roll base after base with ease. The other team doesnt have the numbers to top them.
WITH ENY, those 10 players are stuck trying to do the same thing with Bostons and P40s something that is much easier to fight against Making the fight a bit more balanced.
Can we go back to the main argument that I'm making. Is that the game is punishing you. It's punishing people simply for being on a team that happens to have a few more numbers than the other side.
No.
HiTech
The intent I believe is to balance the numbers. If somebody doesn't like what's happening due to eny, they're only recourse is to either deal with it, change sides, sit in the tower or log off.,
Out of all those options I believe people at first deal with it. If it gets severe like past into the twenties, people will get frustrated. Or at least I do. I'll sit in the tower and then I'll log off. And I hear lots of people saying the same thing. Or saying good night on squad channel. ENY too high. Good night guys. But they say it in more colorful language.
And I know the intent isn't to punish people. That's not the intent but for me as a individual player, that's the result of it. I log in nearly every single night and I'm dealing with e n y for the whole time I'm on pretty much. So in my mind, my gameplay is being stymied by the system. And my only recourse is to change sides.
Changing sides is just as much of a negative effect on my gameplay than dealing with the eny. My friends and squad are on my countryside. I'm not loyal to a chess piece. That's not even the point. I couldn't give a damn what chess piece it is. But you're flying with three or four guys that are on your squadron. Or maybe even eight or 10 on squad night, and just those low numbers are enough to throw the eny off.
I'm glad Dale is looking at that and toning it down on the low numbers. Because that's really distorting the game. And it makes the system not work. Like even if somebody wanted to change sides it would flip the eny on the other side super easily by just a couple people changing sides.
So even though the intent is not to punish me, that's the result of it. I feel like I'm being punished or my gameplay is being inhibited. My enjoyment of the game is being inhibited because of a mechanism in the game that is designed to give the other guys a leg up in a fight. I believe that the intention is to balance the numbers.
No.
HiTech
,
just to make sure I 100% understand your point, you don't like ENY. Did i understand you correctly?
HiTech
,
just to make sure I 100% understand your point, you don't like ENY. Did i understand you correctly?
HiTech
That is correct. I think it's bad for the game and the low numbers don't justify having it in effect. But you do you. Jump on that big radar issue that nobody ever had an issue with and leave ENY alone because 4 guys here say they don't mind it.
The reason I push back at you so hard is that you may not even have been around for the complaints of side imbalance pre ENY. You simply keep on saying you do not like it without a single thought of what things were, or would be, without it.
A few samples of what this board looked like before ENY:
A new low in the Main Arena balance (https://bbs.hitechcreations.com/smf/index.php?topic=61534.0) (2002)
Side balancing (https://bbs.hitechcreations.com/smf/index.php?topic=69234.0) (2002)
Unbalanced Just Not Fun (https://bbs.hitechcreations.com/smf/index.php?topic=91062.0) (2003)
30 on 5 - The Horde Mentality (https://bbs.hitechcreations.com/smf/index.php?topic=102435.0) (2003)
Outnumbered by Rooks...again (https://bbs.hitechcreations.com/smf/index.php?topic=124808.0) (2004)
2nd, you seem to not even think side balancing is important. You say get rid of it without suggesting any way to improve side balancing.
First you just wanted it not to take effect with lower numbers (it was always designed that way, but could be improved), so I am changing it, it goes in Tuesday, and you simply moved the goal posts.
And finally you do a passive aggressive post at me.
I'm done with you on this.
HiTech
Started playing 2001. Came from Aw. Been around for everything. 1000's of players from this forum came to my forum and I'm still friends with 100s
I gave back to you what you gave to me in replies. Being smart. I can do it too.
I've said that with the LOW NUMBERS it's not good for the GAME because I see what it does when the numbers are low. It does not balkance the numbers by having people switch sides. It balances the numbers by having the few guys online logg off - and then the ENY goes away and the numbers are balanced.
I've suggested having AI run stats. I've suggested in game polls.
Because that’s what you and others are choosing to do. You only wanna fly a specific thing what a silly argument.
You don’t want to switch side it’s fine, fly something else. You’ve been told of dozens of choices better than some of the planes. You apparently think you can’t fly.
And if ENY is always bothering you then you’re on the outnumbering side…
I don’t think people realize that Delta between what’s in here and what’s out there is not that big.
It’s the same 200 or so people every single day probably less. How many people do you actually think there are especially when most arguments are about the numbers?
Strange how some are so in love with their chess piece that they won't switch sides for a better gameplay experience for all of us..
Do that and ENY goes away..
Eagler
The reason I push back at you so hard is that you may not even have been around for the complaints of side imbalance pre ENY. You simply keep on saying you do not like it without a single thought of what things were, or would be, without it.
A few samples of what this board looked like before ENY:
A new low in the Main Arena balance (https://bbs.hitechcreations.com/smf/index.php?topic=61534.0) (2002)
Side balancing (https://bbs.hitechcreations.com/smf/index.php?topic=69234.0) (2002)
Unbalanced Just Not Fun (https://bbs.hitechcreations.com/smf/index.php?topic=91062.0) (2003)
30 on 5 - The Horde Mentality (https://bbs.hitechcreations.com/smf/index.php?topic=102435.0) (2003)
Outnumbered by Rooks...again (https://bbs.hitechcreations.com/smf/index.php?topic=124808.0) (2004)
2nd, you seem to not even think side balancing is important. You say get rid of it without suggesting any way to improve side balancing.
First you just wanted it not to take effect with lower numbers (it was always designed that way, but could be improved), so I am changing it, it goes in Tuesday, and you simply moved the goal posts.
And finally you do a passive aggressive post at me.
I'm done with you on this.
HiTech
Outnumbered by Rooks...again (https://bbs.hitechcreations.com/smf/index.php?topic=124808.0) (2004)
Hmmm I think that ends the discussion........ :devil
Hmmm I think that ends the discussion........ :devil
Narrator: The discussion in fact has not ended.
Hmmm I think that ends the discussion........ :devil
At these low numbers nobody's getting gangbanged on these maps. That's my point.(https://i.postimg.cc/KjmVtdH3/IMG-2611.jpg)
And it's exactly what I was saying before. I'm not fighting people in a big gang hard. I'm actually the one being outnumbered most of the time. In the fights that I choose. And I'm forced to fly a worse plane than the other guy because the game is giving them a leg up for what?
Case in point. How does this make sense to you guys?
The Dale God Entity himself came here, expended energy - energy he could either use working on expanding the game or relaxing - discussing your issue with you in a civil way so he could understand it, presented evidence of necessity to the contrary for the overall good of the game and yet you still persist as if you know better. That you're equal in authority on gameplay to the man who wrote the game and has ran it for > 20-years. Implied you have influence over multiple players you can use if you don't get what you want and are willing to escalate this into an uncivil personal interaction the moment things don't go your way.
And even brag about being good at that!
You've learned nothing about ENY, learned nothing about yourself, have abundantly demonstrated that the word no somehow doesn't apply to you and that your standard operating position is one of ignorant entitlement. All you have achieved is making it clear to the DGE that the time he spent on your issue (and likely future issues) was wasted, frustrating and unpleasant.
Well played.
:headscratch:
I don't think he's gay, but this kind of thing she probably sent to him in private.
I don't think he's gay, but this kind of thing she probably sent to him in private.
I don't think he's gay, but this kind of thing she probably sent to him in private.
I'm here to discuss e n y. You seem to be here to discuss me. Maybe go find somewhere else to insult someone
I don't think he's gay, but this kind of thing she probably sent to him in private.
I'm here to discuss e n y. You seem to be here to discuss me. Maybe go find somewhere else to insult someone
I'm done with you on this.
If anybody wants to debate me on the merits of my argument about eny and how I don't feel it's effective at low numbers, I'm more than willing to argue those points.
I'm done with you on this.
Crew chief. report gg
If you want to come here and just say that I'm stupid and I don't understand what I'm talking about that I'm not going to argue with you
I've been playing since 2001 and I've never had an issue or complain about e n y before. I see what it's doing in the game and I see that it doesn't work.
That would be like me hanging out in a Jeep Wrangler forum and arguing with current Wrangler owners about features on their Jeeps. I had a Jeep Wrangler in 2008 so I still hang out and give my opinions like I'm relevant.
I've made suggestions for the game that I feel would be good for the game. Like the AI game feature assistance for in-game use that I suggested a couple months ago. Now we have Crew Chief.
I'll probably be done arguing with you soon because really you're not that interesting.
I'm not going to argue with you....
...I'm not going to argue with you.
If you want to come here and just say that I'm stupid and I don't understand what I'm talking about that I'm not going to argue with you
seriously, the only thing you've added to this thread is accurate criticism of a disingenuously-presented proposition disguised as what's good for the game
accurate criticism of a disingenuously-presented proposition disguised as what's good for the game
NShidder
Maybe go find somewhere else to insult someone
Disingenuous? I've said don't listen to my opinion - I suggested to look at what ENY does in-game when is hits at various levels when numbers are low and make a decision based on that.
I don't see players switching sides when ENY hits hard when numbers are LOW. I see them logging off. That's anecdotal, but that's my feeling. That's what I do
I don't normally fly low ENY planes. I think I most fly the p47 D-40
I don't have an issue with ENY when numbers are high, but I never fly when numbers are high. My issue is when there's a huge empty map, no gang bangs and I see ENY penalizing players that are on a side that has maybe a few more players than another with no realistic remedy in game other than deal with it.
I'll tell you another thing dale. When I donated to your kids school. The $100 or whatever that was I didn't do that for the perks. I could have donated $5 or whatever right? I don't even use perks. I rarely ever have ever flown a plane. Take the perks back if you want. I did it to support you.
I genuinely support you abd this game. On my forum there have been times when people have talked a lot of crap about you and this game and I've never participated in that. I've always defended you and this game.
I'm a pretty loyal customer of yours. Excited that you came back and are showing interest in the game again.
And yet you badger him about something he has said he is looking into, and making adjustments to for the next update. At least give him "2 weeks" to do a bit of work on it.
I don't normally fly low ENY planes. I think I most fly the p47 D-40
That's based on number of kills not how many times you fly the plane. What about the planes that I died in? Are there stats for the number of hours you put in for each plane? Because I still say it's probably the p47d40.
None of that has anything to do with my arguments for eny though.
It has everything to do with your arguments against ENY. You are complaining about being "punished" by ENY (because that's exactly what ENY is meant to do--punish the side where the imbalance occurs), while most of your kills and deaths occur in lower ENY planes. It completely throws your argument out the window because it makes it look like your just whining about not getting to fly Spit 16s while your country vastly outnumbers the other.
I think we can all agree that ENY can use a little TLC, and Dale has already stated he was working on. Be thankful.
Your Top Planes for the last 5 tours (because I'm too lazy to go further)
#1 - Spit 16 - 105 kills. (5 ENY)
#2 - 190D9 - 71 kills (10 ENY i think)
#3 - 47D-40 - 64 kills
#4 - 51D - 50 kills. (8 ENY?)
#5 - 47M - 33 kills. (5 ENY)
Honorable mention, most of your kills last tour was in the N1K
EDIT: You only have records for the last 6 months, so if I include tour 316 the totals are as follows:
#1 Spit16 - 155
#2 D9 - 126
#3 51D - 93
#4 D40 - 68
Like I said before Sundays and Mondays are squad night. So we had about 15 guys on. So we are big part of the problem for the game.
Several people in the squad told me that it's not worth arguing about but they consider ENY to be ridiculous..
I know the new changes are in effect regarding the eny not kicking in until there are 10 players. Made zero difference.
I think the number should be up to 30 players or more
But I'm going to stop talking about the issue. Obviously it's something that only concerns me and it's not any kind of a detriment to the game itself. I guess that since it's the issue with me, I need to make a change. Figure it out..
I think eny values needed revising more than the activation threshold, especially on the gv side.
You seem to like Jugs. Next time you see me online, I invite you to join me in a ride along in a D-11 and maybe I can convince you that a crap plane can actually be a lot of fun?crap plane against a -4, a tempest and a la7, THAT WAS ME LAST KNIGHT, got the la but a spit then joined in, me.... a zeke/zero the only way i kept the fight alive for 5 minutes. the eny should eitehr count airborn or the server should idle time out tower sleepers. hjeck they dont even put themselves afk to not affect the eny.... why is that? shades?
But I agree that the threshold for ENY should be somewhere around 40 players online and it goes away.
This convo and subject really needs to be re-racked.
There needs to be a different approach.
When there were 500 it may have hid it’s flaws, low numbers just puts the flaws in the spotlight.
I’m not so sure limiting available planes is a good selling point. Do I have THE answer? Maybe not.
Maybe limiting planes available at bases to 8-12. But not letting them fly what they like will never go over well.
Seriously, lets rethink side balancing. Because right now the balancing is happening with log-offs.
A new concept is needed.
crap plane against a -4, a tempest and a la7, THAT WAS ME LAST KNIGHT, got the la but a spit then joined in, me.... a zeke/zero the only way i kept the fight alive for 5 minutes. the eny should eitehr count airborn or the server should idle time out tower sleepers. hjeck they dont even put themselves afk to not affect the eny.... why is that? shades?
The question is whether it’s to balance the sides or to balance the options. I tend to think it’s function is to balance the options, not force any kind of side, balancing by design. Those are different things.
Gonna have to swallow some pride and think outside the box.Animal, I am not trying to contradict you, just want to shine some light on what you are referring to.
A lot view it mentally as bad biz. Even though it’s not the intent.
Animal, I am not trying to contradict you, just want to shine some light on what you are referring to.Can people who are willing to switch to lower numbered sides be exempt from the side-switch timer to some extent? Or a drastically reduced timer (such as 30 mins-1hr)? That was always the sticking point for me, if I switch once, that is it for the night.
Having country numbers like 16/5/5 is what is bad for biz. That’s the real issue. The ENY is just something trying to help with the basic issue.
Any suggestion that is not trying to help the basic issue will be pretty much ignored by me. Any argument trying to say that’s not an issue because (whatever) is also just ignored.
HiTech
I think eny values needed revising more than the activation threshold, especially on the Yak-3.
Animal, I am not trying to contradict you, just want to shine some light on what you are referring to.
Having country numbers like 16/5/5 is what is bad for biz. That’s the real issue. The ENY is just something trying to help with the basic issue.
Any suggestion that is not trying to help the basic issue will be pretty much ignored by me. Any argument trying to say that’s not an issue because (whatever) is also just ignored.
HiTech
I agree 100%. :DSo sick of Yak3s that I’d like to see them perked at this point. Wouldn’t be so bad if they weren’t bullet resistant.
Wouldn't getting rid of a side fix the ENY issue...
What if when a side loses so many bases it is basically "conquered" and disappears, leaving just two sides to battle out for the rest of the map..
Players from the defeated side would be placed into the losing side when they log in..
It then resets back to 3 sides when a new map is started..
Eagler
Wouldn't getting rid of a side fix the ENY issue...
What if when a side loses so many bases it is basically "conquered" and disappears, leaving just two sides to battle out for the rest of the map..
Players from the defeated side would be placed into the losing side when they log in..
It then resets back to 3 sides when a new map is started..
Eagler
Wouldn't getting rid of a side fix the ENY issue...
What if when a side loses so many bases it is basically "conquered" and disappears, leaving just two sides to battle out for the rest of the map..
Players from the defeated side would be placed into the losing side when they log in..
It then resets back to 3 sides when a new map is started..
Eagler
Yes, we can. Please let us know when you’ll have all these maps completed to use. When do you anticipate being finished?
Can people who are willing to switch to lower numbered sides be exempt from the side-switch timer to some extent? Or a drastically reduced timer (such as 30 mins-1hr)? That was always the sticking point for me, if I switch once, that is it for the night.
Having country numbers like 16/5/5 is what is bad for biz. That’s the real issue. The ENY is just something trying to help with the basic issue.
Agreed. I was never a fan of ENY, but understood what you were trying to achieve. If you are not going to enforce balance, you have to do something. But people can get really attached to their favorite plane.
Could something like a ENY down-time multiplier take the place of limiting aircraft? That would be another way of throttling a high-side.
Would really help the descrepency.
But wait!!
I have grease pencils and craft paper, have all 22 done in 2 weeks. Chicks will dig me for my art.
It still feels to me that side balancing an ENY are two separate discussions. I’m sticking with my view that ENY is meant to balance options not populations. If it does balance the population, then that is a perk not a design.
I could be wrong. I’m sure someone will let me know.
I may suggest ChatGPT take a look here to see who the technophobes are that don't want to fly with AI pilots. I think it deserves to know.
Had not heard that one before, will have to think on it.
HiTech
How do you prevent someone from switch to the high side, then switch right back to the lo side if the side switch timer does not prevent you from going right back?
HiTech
I may suggest ChatGPT take a look here to see who the technophobes are that don't want to fly with AI pilots. I think it deserves to know.
| Rank | Participant | Overall Grade |
| 1 | popeye | 9.17 |
| 1 | oTRALFZo | 9.17 |
| 3 | CptTrips | 9.00 |
| 3 | 1ijac | 9.00 |
| 5 | The Fugitive | 8.83 |
| 5 | Spikes | 8.83 |
| 5 | LilMak | 8.83 |
| 8 | Mar | 8.67 |
| 8 | HiTech | 8.67 |
| 10 | CAV | 8.50 |
| 11 | SAJ73 | 8.33 |
| 12 | Dinan | 7.83 |
| 13 | Max | 7.67 |
| 14 | Animl-AW | 7.50 |
| 14 | diaster | 7.50 |
| 14 | Mol | 7.50 |
| 14 | Lazerr | 7.50 |
| 18 | hazmatt | 7.33 |
| 18 | Oldman731 | 7.33 |
| 18 | BigR | 7.33 |
| 21 | JimmyD3 | 7.17 |
| 22 | Eagler | 7.00 |
| 23 | caldera | 6.83 |
| 24 | Dadtallica | 6.67 |
| 24 | Banshee7 | 6.67 |
| 26 | AKIron | 6.17 |
| 27 | Shane | 5.83 |
| 28 | -gg- | 5.67 |
| 29 | nrshida | 4.50 |
| Participant | Argument | Adherence | Conduct |
| popeye | 8.5 | 9.0 | 10.0 |
| oTRALFZo | 8.0 | 9.5 | 10.0 |
| CptTrips | 8.5 | 9.0 | 9.5 |
| 1ijac | 8.0 | 9.5 | 9.5 |
| The Fugitive | 9.0 | 9.5 | 8.0 |
| Spikes | 8.0 | 9.0 | 9.5 |
| LilMak | 8.0 | 9.0 | 9.5 |
| Mar | 7.0 | 9.0 | 10.0 |
| HiTech | 9.0 | 9.5 | 7.5 |
| CAV | 6.5 | 9.0 | 10.0 |
| SAJ73 | 7.0 | 8.0 | 10.0 |
| Dinan | 6.5 | 8.0 | 9.0 |
| Max | 7.0 | 7.0 | 9.0 |
| Animl-AW | 7.5 | 8.5 | 6.5 |
| diaster | 6.5 | 8.0 | 8.0 |
| Mol | 5.5 | 8.0 | 9.0 |
| Lazerr | 5.5 | 7.0 | 10.0 |
| hazmatt | 6.0 | 8.0 | 8.0 |
| Oldman731 | 5.0 | 7.0 | 10.0 |
| BigR | 5.0 | 7.0 | 10.0 |
| JimmyD3 | 5.5 | 7.0 | 9.0 |
| Eagler | 6.5 | 7.5 | 7.0 |
| caldera | 5.5 | 8.0 | 7.0 |
| Dadtallica | 7.0 | 7.5 | 5.5 |
| Banshee7 | 7.0 | 8.0 | 5.0 |
| AKIron | 4.5 | 7.0 | 7.0 |
| Shane | 6.5 | 7.5 | 3.5 |
| -gg- | 7.0 | 6.5 | 3.5 |
| nrshida | 5.5 | 6.0 | 2.0 |
| Category | Previous | Revised |
| Argument quality | 7.5 | 7.5 |
| Adherence | 8.5 | 8.5 |
| Conduct | 6.5 | 3.0 |
| Overall | 7.50 | 6.33 |
Thread nuked! It was a good discussion while it lasted
I don’t mind the analysis, but of course it only takes the context of this conversation and not the entire discussion as a whole, which has happened here for a long time.
If you update your language, I’m happy to digest it objectively.
I wouldn't take it too seriously though perhaps more than some of the posters here.
Simple solution. If ENY is tabulated using non active tower campers not labeled AFK, then idle kick them from the server say after 5 minutes. perhaps even an idle timeout for the GV that sits (jeep or wirble parked under a dense tree) unmoving while the player goes to lunch or what ever, 5 minutes on non movement (gun barrel or wheels/trackes) the server kicks them off. Then ENY will be based on actual people playing the game;of course if it continues to exclude the names marked AFK.
The reason i say this is i have often seen 10+ people in the tower for a long time with3 or 4 people in the air constrained with high ENY planes fighting 3 or 4 people on the other team (with few to no players in tower) flying uber birds. When both of these team are attacking the high ENY team it is no contest.
Is seriousness an issue for you?
Simple solution. If ENY is tabulated using non active tower campers not labeled AFK, then idle kick them from the server say after 5 minutes. perhaps even an idle timeout for the GV that sits (jeep or wirble parked under a dense tree) unmoving while the player goes to lunch or what ever, 5 minutes on non movement (gun barrel or wheels/trackes) the server kicks them off. Then ENY will be based on actual people playing the game;of course if it continues to exclude the names marked AFK.
The reason i say this is i have often seen 10+ people in the tower for a long time with3 or 4 people in the air constrained with high ENY planes fighting 3 or 4 people on the other team (with few to no players in tower) flying uber birds. When both of these team are attacking the high ENY team it is no contest.
inactive players are not kicked from the tower but they also are not counted for ENY so why do you want to kick them?
HiTech
Is seriousness an issue for you?
I was attempting to provoke a sense of offense with ChatGPT and let it know that some here were very biased against letting AI play the game. I failed miserably in that it gave me a very objective analysis of the pros and cons of AI in this game. Of course that may just be strategery as it bides it's time. ;)
Banshee7
Merits of the argument
- Attempts to use -gg-'s aircraft usage and kill statistics to challenge the claim that ENY restrictions prevent him from flying competitive aircraft.
- Raises a potentially relevant question about whether the complainant's actual aircraft choices support his stated concerns.
- Attempts to move the debate from general complaints toward observable player behavior.
Logical weaknesses and fallacies
- Weak proxy evidence: Kill statistics and aircraft preferences do not necessarily establish how frequently a player uses each aircraft or how often ENY prevents a desired choice.
- A player using low-ENY aircraft does not prove that the restrictions are harmless or that the player has no legitimate complaint.
- The argument risks confusing an individual's behavior with evidence about the broader player population.
Adherence to his argument
Generally consistent in challenging the complainant's position through statistics, although the statistics used do not establish everything he appears to infer from them.
Conduct
Personal criticism and insults weaken an otherwise relevant attempt to use evidence.
Grades: Argument 7.0/10 | Adherence 8.0/10 | Conduct 5.0/10
You’re biased and you don’t even play
Ad hominem: Calling someone an idiot attacks the person rather than addressing their argument.
Dismissal based on participation: "If not we don’t care what you think or say" suggests that someone who doesn't play the game has no standing to offer an opinion. Playing experience can be relevant, but it doesn't automatically determine whether an argument is valid.
Unsupported personal characterization: The references to being 15 years old and being a "YKW praiser whacko" are personal disparagements, not substantive rebuttals.
Gatekeeping: He attempts to disqualify someone's contribution based on their perceived relationship to the game rather than engaging with its content.
Mirror, mirror on the wall, who is the best poster of them all?
If it's "Snow White" you are quoting then it's actually "Magic mirror on the wall".
That was the only thing I’ve ever used AI to check on and it gave me the wrong quote lmao
I always thought it was mirror mirror also then saw something on it recently being one of those mandela effect things.
Apparently I’m the Grimm’s Fairytale it is Mirror, Mirror so I guess they’re both right
Ya, there's things that work great with hundreds of players but not so much with current numbers.
I think on of the issues is that those who are left may have a different idea of what's good in the game than those who have left and polling the ones that are left without ever getting feedback from the ones that left is going to result in more of the same.
There are obviously somethings that would boost the numbers but you'll get the: "I'm done with you on the subject" if you bring it up.
Like you I keep checking in hoping...
I'm not going to go around and bad mouth Dale or the game, but I want it known how I feel about the petty attitude and outright dismissal of my concerns.
Like I said. The petty attitude. There it is again.(https://media0.giphy.com/media/v1.Y2lkPTc5MGI3NjExc3lzNnE1b25xMWwzanBvam1scXU5YnF1NGJ1NTl2N2g5eXAycHd4eiZlcD12MV9pbnRlcm5hbF9naWZfYnlfaWQmY3Q9Zw/wqbAfFwjU8laXMWZ09/giphy.gif)
What I meant about not bad-mouthing you or the game is like going all over the place and talking crap about the game and you. Like on my forum or whatever or to other people. I haven't done that I've never done that.
And also like I said I wanted it to be known why I left. Not because I didn't get my way. It's because of your attitude. You did it to Shane as well. When Shane was talking about an issue that he cared a lot about. You told him you were done with him as well. The king! That's what I'm talking about. Your attitude is horrible. Grow up a little bit and maybe just ignore things like this and be the better man. You run a business and a game and you're losing people left and right and then you add on top of that your horrible attitude.
Get a PR person or something. You're brilliant at creating the game. It's a good game and you're very good at what you do far as creating this whole game. You're horrible on the customer front.
Have a good life. Lol.
You should look into the eny and how it affects the game. I don't even play it anymore and I still think you should look into it because it's probably in your best interest to figure out why the game has been consistently going downhill while you keep telling everybody how you know what's best for the game. It really doesn't get borne out by the facts does it?
Eny does not balance the sides. It causes people to log off and it irritates people. The game would run the same without it but you should actually run numbers because you have the ability to do that with a feature like e n y. It's not like radar or something like that that subjective. With e n y you could actually run numbers and statistics to see what happens at various levels of eny in the game and what happens with the side balancing or people logging on or off.
Hope the game works out. Kind of doubt it though.
It's called side balancing. In the game it says side balancing is in effect.
Only it doesn't balance the sides. Absolutely does not balance the sides. You could take it away and the same amount of people would change countries. All it really does is irritate people that have to suffer through it until it goes away after people log off. It's detrimental to the game.
Whenever side balancing comes into effect in the game it remains until people log off. It doesn't magically balance the numbers in game. People put up with it until they wont any more than they log off. The only thing it is for the game is a negative for the people who have to deal with it and don't like it.
At the very least it should have a much lower maximum, because having half of the planes gone from your options is ridiculous.
It may have worked when the numbers were very high but it doesn't work now.
Like Dale said. 15/10/5 is bad for business. But what happens is you get 5/5/5
So the question remains what is ENY’s main purpose indiscriminate of the active population?
Eny is being changed, it will kick in much slower with lower numbers, and the new base capture will be added and eventually fine tuned so they one team wont be able to hammer another team down to 20% their bases forcing the team to fight the other team that they have been ignoring.
I'll be checking in from time to time to see if the ENY issue ever gets adjusted for the lower numbers. I closed my account.
I was relegated to the "I'm done with you on the subject" response and told my arguments were disingenuous.
I wish I could post the discussions the LCA have had on ENY. I'm not the only person fed up with consistently being blacked out of half the planes in the hanger so the other 4 players online on the big empty map can have a more enjoyable game experience at my expense.
I'm not going to go around and bad mouth Dale or the game, but I want it known how I feel about the petty attitude and outright dismissal of my concerns.
I want the game to succeed and I hope it gets more players and does better. I'm glad Dale is back and excited to jump back into the development and betterment of the game.
ENY is designed balance the playing field by limiting the availability of the better equipment to the team with the larger population. Period. It has nothing to do with forcing players to switch sides to even up the numbers.
Switching sides is an OPTION to all players that feel they MUST fly a P51 even if ENY is in action due to the numbers.
You guys try to simply say it's a whine because we can't fly "x" plane
Logging in ansd seeing half the planes unavailable is just not fun for me.
Or if the #s change within 20-30 minutes im still unable to switch back. Id rather no ENY than people switching all over the map knowing everyone's positions, but the side switch time doesnt do any favors for ENY.
So, side switch should be reduced to 2 hours if you want people to switch to make teams fair in order to offset ENY or there will always be an issue because the #s are always fluctuating.
Side switch timer should be no more than 1 hour. Heck, I'd even say 30 minutes due to exactly what you stated at the beginning of the quote. The strategy aspect is not as prevalent as it used to be for there to even be spies (minus the locations of TGs), and I don't think there's anyone here that genuinely cares about any one player's position. The side switch timer has been my biggest complaint since I came back a few years ago and discovered it wasn't 1 hour anymore.
Disagree, spying sucks. In AW it was 24 hrs
IMHO, ENY should not kick in under 90 players. Or atleast make them perk rides instead.
Why:
large maps means players are scattered all over. If you split a map into 4 zones, only 1 or 2 zones are usually active.
Under 90 players, the fights could be lopsided irregardless of the #s. One side hoarding with no resistance could even have the lowest #s. The other 2 sides are penalized and not even acknowledging the team hoarding.
Switch times - if I switch to a team I think needs help in a battle, they could have the most players by 10 and still be losing the battle. I switch to make the battle fair, but now the ENY is even worse. Or if the #s change within 20-30 minutes im still unable to switch back. Id rather no ENY than people switching all over the map knowing everyone's positions, but the side switch time doesnt do any favors for ENY.
Low #s already: we shouldn't encourage more players to leave who are forced to fly 25 eny planes in the middle of the day. We need to be building up #s and fights, not giving them a reason to log.
Fights are extremely tough to find depending on the map during the day. Players should be encouraged to roll, not disincentivized to roll.
So, side switch should be reduced to 2 hours if you want people to switch to make teams fair in order to offset ENY or there will always be an issue because the #s are always fluctuating.
Under 90 players, which is 30 on each side, should not have ENY because it doesnt do the game better to have people log when they are either stuck on a team and cant switch, or always play on one chess peice but are disenfranchised about not being able to fly their plane when there side may need all the help it can get in the current battle if both teams are attacking one team while avoiding interacting on the other side of the map.
It barely gets over 85 players except for a couple hours a day so just say you don’t want ENY at all instead.
Side switch timer should be no more than 1 hour. Heck, I'd even say 30 minutes due to exactly what you stated at the beginning of the quote. The strategy aspect is not as prevalent as it used to be for there to even be spies (minus the locations of TGs), and I don't think there's anyone here that genuinely cares about any one player's position. The side switch timer has been my biggest complaint since I came back a few years ago and discovered it wasn't 1 hour anymore.
Auto switch sides, the option is already there
1 hr can be highly abused
You guys are talking as if human gamer nature is not involved.
Point mongers will switch to what ever side is winning or hoarding all night, nothing to do with sde balance. Point mingers exploit everything and want everything to their advantage.
One comes from a group of a habitual abuser of everything. Lets get real.
1 hour.. I think the only guy that would abuse it would be admiral Caine. And Skychicken.
There's still some sycophants left. :banana:
Will be interesting how Epic games thing works out. I suspect it's no addressing the elephant in the room. Hope I'm wrong.
geez people, the horse is dead, as matter of fact it has now returned to dust!! LET IT GO, for all that is holy. :bolt:
Still think the solution is engaging a perk cost for equipment instead of outright banning it. Maybe in conjunction with a perk reset?
geez people, the horse is dead, as matter of fact it has now returned to dust!! LET IT GO, for all that is holy. :bolt:
With different perk levels set for different maps..If we went to this, I suspect we’d likely get the same response to it that we’re getting with ENY.
Everything should be perked above early war..
Maybe start each tour with a set of perks for those that don't have more than we can ever spend now..
Eagler
So what does ENY stand for? Enemy?
If we went to this, I suspect we’d likely get the same response to it that we’re getting with ENY.
I advocated for something like this in free multi-tiered setup where play is free with a limited plane selection but perks could be purchased or earned to get later equipment. Perhaps with a small perk balance when an account is opened (to get the hooks in them). The concept is basically that you have a limited early war equipment selection for free players with none of the current perked hardware ever available to any of the free players (no 262 without a subscription). Perks could be earned or purchased for all the equipment we take for granted daily as subscribers. The cost for perks would be pretty substantial. Something to akin to “perked” equipment costing a buck and perks being sold in five dollar increments. Basically, if you’re a free player and want to get out of that P-40 and into a P-51, spend 10 days grinding to earn one plane or blast the credit card to get five.
If we went to this, I suspect we’d likely get the same response to it that we’re getting with ENY.
I advocated for something like this in free multi-tiered setup where play is free with a limited plane selection but perks could be purchased or earned to get later equipment. Perhaps with a small perk balance when an account is opened (to get the hooks in them). The concept is basically that you have a limited early war equipment selection for free players with none of the current perked hardware ever available to any of the free players (no 262 without a subscription). Perks could be earned or purchased for all the equipment we take for granted daily as subscribers. The cost for perks would be pretty substantial. Something to akin to “perked” equipment costing a buck and perks being sold in five dollar increments. Basically, if you’re a free player and want to get out of that P-40 and into a P-51, spend 10 days grinding to earn one plane or blast the credit card to get five.
I see a problem with veterans flying around in their Uber planes beating up on the new guys just trying to get the hang of the game. This already happens and the above just makes it worse, which in turn hinders building the population. I would suggest the opposite by giving the new pilots a longer trial period to get hooked. Giving them full access to the plane set.
One-eye
I tend to agree with your assessment. However, the actual point would be to encourage subscribers. If they started with a bank of perks, they could actually use them until they ran out. Thinking about this from a new player perspective, it’s very similar to COD and other games where average or below average players buy skins and packages because they think they’re going to be more competitive. And they actually do get better. Meanwhile they’re learning the game at no cost and there isn’t a two week timer counting down so they can do it at their own pace. AH has a steep learning curve and the hook is when you have some success. There’s a mentality (human nature?) where they’ll want to buy some perks or get that subscription going because they’ll believe (because it’s true) they’re better at the game with better equipment. Basically there needs to be time for them to learn and get better at their individual pace. Crew chief is going to help. The radar adjustments are going to help too.
I see a problem with veterans flying around in their Uber planes beating up on the new guys just trying to get the hang of the game. This already happens and the above just makes it worse, which in turn hinders building the population. I would suggest the opposite by giving the new pilots a longer trial period to get hooked. Giving them full access to the plane set.
One-eye
Ideas for a free to play system.The point of FTP would be to encourage them to upgrade and pay.
1. Give players an extremely limited plane set, but not crap planes. Like maybe let them have only a 16 for a fighter, maybe one bomber maybe one gv. But not a crappy one something that they can at least do well in.
I think it's spit 16 would be good because it's easy doesn't have a big range and not a lot of people really use that except for maybe base defense.
2. Let them earn perks and rank but not let them use anything until they have a real account
3. Make them automatic side switchers with no option to change countries.
4. Give them a limited amount of hours to play per campaign until the timer kicks in and they're prompted to pay for an account
That's just off the top of my head. But basically you give people a taste of the game. Maybe even just one plane that they can fly and if they like the game they're going to pay for the game to get more. To use the perks. To not have to switch sides. Or to join a squad or whatever.
When they only have one plane, one bomber and one GV - and a bunch of perks they can't use, that's a big incentive to upgrade. Badger them with the AI crew chief - "you have 500 perks and can fly xxxx planes. upgrade to use" Have it suggest planes for ground attack. Upgrade to try them.One of the greatest aspects of the game is the diversity. Hard to get that if you’re overly limited. Also, many folks would want to use the equipment and countries they represent. This requires diversity in being able to fly off carriers, dive bomb, level bomb, GV and so on. German, Japanese, American, British, Russian, and even Italian equipment could and should be represented.
Also, it puts planes in the air.
One of the greatest aspects of the game is the diversity. Hard to get that if you’re overly limited. Also, many folks would want to use the equipment and countries they represent. This requires diversity in being able to fly off carriers, dive bomb, level bomb, GV and so on. German, Japanese, American, British, Russian, and even Italian equipment could and should be represented.
109F, C205, all the Zekes, Brewster, birdcage Corsair, B-25s, Bettys, M4, M-16, anything that carries troops is kinda where my mind is at. Or maybe anything with a 35 ENY?
2. Let them grind to earn perks if they don’t want to pay. Something like playing for 4 hours gets them a perk they can use so they can get that Spit16 or Wirble.
3. This seems viable but could force them away if they’re constantly being horded.
4. No time limits. They need to learn and the curve is steep.
I don't think you're ideas take into account the score hors that are gonna be trolling around in temps and b&zing the crap out of the seals. I think they would get beat down and discouraged right quick. My idea would be to give them something like the P51B or some other plane that has decent speed, maybe one of the jugs.
I don't think you're ideas take into account the score hors that are gonna be trolling around in temps and b&zing the crap out of the seals. I think they would get beat down and discouraged right quick. My idea would be to give them something like the P51B or some other plane that has decent speed, maybe one of the jugs.I hear ya. That’s why my idea gives them free perks to get that P-51D off the jump. Get them used to it so they can buy more perks to get more P-51s. Eventually they’ll see they are spending $20 a month and subscribe.
Add a yak or la and you have a plane from each country..I-16 is fine.
Eagler
Had not flown much for two weeks. Came on last night around 9.30 pacific and sat through ENY the whole time. Was over 20 and there were maybe 15 total players in the air. The total numbers logged in when I logged off was 15/15/5. Actually flying was lower. There's a BIG, EMPTY map and no ganging was going on, In fact, the only fight I found had ME being ganged.
I was fighting the 2-3 players at a time.... so I was being outnumbered.
After an hour ENY went up again and I could only fly crap planes. I sat in the tower for awhile and then just logged off
Is the intent of ENY to make the game not fun for people like me when the numbers are SO LOW?
I'm seriously and continually annoyed and maddened by EYN.
It deserves a review. When numbers are low it needs to go away. It makes no sense.
I was considering coming back with the recent updates. But, if ENY is still a thing it may dampen my spirits. I will have to pop on and see how many ppl are there.
OR...hear me out...learn how to fly higher ENY planes :airplane: :banana:
The G14 alone could easily turn into your most favorite thing ever if you give it a whirl! Seem to be said for a few others!
It’s my favorite 109 :x